![]() |
Favorite Lawson Style
You have to appreciate Jim Lawson's stuff. I know the man's work is a little bit...polarizing, but it really is an interesting discussion. He's drawn the Turtles more than anyone else over the years, and I can't think of many other artists whose styles have changed so drastically. Yes, you can find similarities between eras and track his transitions, but he's really used three distinct styles over the years.
1) The style used in the intial Tales volume and Return to New York. Stocky Turtles and characters, the most "realistic" of his styles, but probably the least well drawn. To my knowledge, he never inked any of his own issues in this style. 2) The style used in City at War and Volume 2. Much more surreal and stylized. There's something that feels very '90s about it, and in a good way. It's fantastically wonky, and my personal favorite. It can still carry the action well, but captures the bizarness of TMNT. Looks great with the colors in Volume 2. 3) The style used in Tales Vol 2 and Volume 4. Extremely angular, a distinct style of shading, completely stylized. While not my favorite, it really does suite certain aspects of TMNT. I remember a few years back when fans were bashing this style for being lazy, but you'd have to be nuts to think so. His work in this style is some of his most insanely detailed, and it's still hard to replicate. My only gripes are that it doesn't convey action well and his humans do have a tendency to get a little "samey." Talbot's inks seriously rock over this style though. Discuss. |
Good question. I was just thinking about this in a drawing I'm doing (which I just posted in "Fan Works").
My favorite of Lawson's styles is from Volume I Tales of the TMNT. Combination of the drawing and the shading. Great stuff. "Return To New York" is a close second. I never could get into his art on the City at War stuff, or the current stuff. Too blocky. I saw an Italian TMNT comic not too long ago and it really got me wishing they would get a really good superhero artist to try drawing a Turtles comic. |
Quote:
I'm cool with over-the-top, style-over-substance, ultra muscular art like Volume 3, and I'm cool with the revolving door of surreal independant artsists like Lawson. Either extreme works for me. But generic, Jim Lee superhero style? No thanks, not in TMNT. |
I think I'd have to say early early Lawson...like Vol 1. Lawson. Then again, I was never a huge fan of his style any way.
|
Well, his early work was good, I especially liked his work in Archie's comic adaptation of the the first movie. But Volume 4, ummmmm not so much. His work reminds me of those " wiggle vision " cartoons like Dr. Katz and Home Movies, and makes my head hurt now.
|
You might also want to mention the styles he used in the Archie comics and the old newspaper strips.
Personally, my favorite Lawson art would be a combination of his early Volume 4 turtles, monsters, buildings, etc. with his late Volume 4 humans. I mean, just look at the turtles, Utroms, and Fugitoid in these pictures: http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/m...me04/04/04.htm Beautiful! Inks and tones have a huge effect on his art too. He can draw the same pencils with two different ink and tone styles applied with drastically different results. Some of his styles are arguably my favorite of any of the TMNT artists, though Dan Berger draws some great TMNT too. |
I actually think that his best work so far is in the Smash Up game. I was really really impressed with how those animated cut-scenes looked!
|
Hands down this issue
http://www.ninjaturtles.com/comics/m...ales/04/04.htm He just did a stellar job. Smash Up looks awesome too. |
I very love Jim's current style, especially with his own ink and with Peter Laird's inking (Paleo issues). That's rock!
But my favorite, of course, his b/w style in City at War. |
Really? No other takers on the Volume 2 art?
I forgot to even mention his Adventures work. It's certainly...special. I'd seriously like to ask him what was up with that. Was he just not used to the cartoon asthetic? Less pay? Less time? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
wow really nice art, I wish talbot would do that to the comics it really adds to lawsons art!
And seeing some of those next mutation images are awesome. As well as that technodrome background. |
Quote:
But the later ones he did were more his style, I think he did an issue of "Terracide" Quote:
|
I'd go with the earlier, gritty underground comic-looking style of like early Tales vol. 1. Second would be Smash-Up art. But yeah... while most of his modern art is passable, sometimes they just stretch him too thin with work and his art suffers because of it.
Quote:
|
Quote:
I really like Vol. 2 and City at War, and think his Vol. 4 Turtles look very good. I agree his Vol. 4 art is incredibly detailed, but it is almost surreal at times and doesn't really tickle my fancy (except the Turtles--I love the way he draws them almost always). His art always expresses emotion really well, even the pupil-less Turtles. Return to New York is incredible art, but since the layouts by Eastman and Laird were so tight, it hardly looks like Lawson's style at all--more Eastman's and Laird's. |
We really need to seperate early and late V4 in this favorites argument.
|
Quote:
|
I really love Lawson's earlier era of TMNT art he did. Early Lawson did kick ass muscle bound turtles. To me his art has slowly deteriated through the years. A first sign was TMNT Vol.1 #28. Then when City at War came along it got worser. I remember when CAW was coming along, my brothers friend was also into TMNT and he and I thought "alright Jim Lawson drawing it"! Then when TMNT 48-49 came out we were like what the hell? The Vol.2 series and TMNT/Flaming Carrot mini continued this look. The people looked bad and the turtles look liked rubber bands. Now Vol.4 and Tales issues today his art still is a far cry from the earlier stuff.
I can't see how anyone can hate his art in Return to NY. Sure the layouts were by others but he drew out the darn thing in the final pencil finishes. Look at his Tales of TMNT Vol.1 covers he did by himself. They were awesome. What about that old pin up of the turtles against a dinosaur? That was awesome. Nope its early Jim Lawson art is my fave as he was right under Kevin and Peter for my fave TMNT artists. |
I never see anyone mention his artwork in the TMNT Magazine from the '90's. That was where he apparently began practicing his stylized version of the Turtles as the artwork is very angular, almost moreso than the current version.
Lawson grows on ya, especially when you realize he genuinely nice and cares very much about his work and that his style is just that - his artistic style that separates him from others. There surely is no mistaking a Lawson work! :D |
I have to say my favorite thing Lawson has done over all both as an artist and a writer was "Tales of Leo"
Beautiful piece over all. And another vote also for "I, Monster", someday if I get a Turtles tattoo it is going to be a still from that issue! |
I love Lawson's work inVol 2 , mainly, but increasingly the later stuff as seen in vol 4. It just feels like the turtles whenever seeing/reading it.
|
Early Vol 1 stuff definitely
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:44 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.