![]() |
TMNT trade sales.
I'm not sure how many people here check the monthly sales figures in the comics biz, but I found it interesting that Kevin's Raphcentric book put out through Heavy Metal blitzed the omnibus release in the sales, selling approx. 1,362 units, while the Omnibus came in at 158 with only 873 units. Forever War Prologue came in at 170 with 832 units.
There are a huge number of factors that go into the numbers, but I'm actually kinda surprised that the Heavy Metal one was so far ahead. It is an extremely nice book, and the colors -- particularly in the Casey debut -- are great! This is just through Diamond here, so I'm not sure if that takes the online sales through B&N on board. Hate to say it, but the odds of more trades any time soon may be slimmer... |
i think the fact you can get kevin's book on amazon is a HUGE factor.
wish the collected book was on amazon.:( |
I'm going to echo King Kahn. Amazon, promotion through Heavy Metal, I'd wager those are huge factors.
Cannot stress Amazon enough. The more widely these things are available, the better they sell. To which we always here the response "The better they sell, the more widely available we can make them." Mirage's attitude towards trades seems self-defeating at times. Or hell, how many reviews of the book are out there? Is Mirage sending them to major comic reviewers? What about getting to the material that might actually make a comic snob's head turn, like "City at War"? |
I'm not surprised by those numbers at all. The only way for them to go up is for Mirage to take publishing seriously. Since they don't do that, I think these numbers are completely fair.
|
Is it just me, or is there some comic snobs out there who turn their noses up at TMNT like literary snobs turn their noses up at Stephen King fiction? It seems to me like the general opinion is that it's Mirage's fault that people don't take TMNT as a "serious" comic. Seeing as how I'm not very familiar with the company's practices, what exactly did they do to get people to treat TMNT like back-seat entertainment?
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Does Amazon, Borders and B&N go through Diamond? I would expect so... actually it says they do on their website. I could be wrong, but that says to me that the larger stores aren't interested in stocking them. Like I said, I could be wrong. Comic shops will only stock things they know they'll sell. I'd assume book stores are the same. |
Quote:
But in the case of TMNT vs Batman, it's apples to apples, and absolutely ridiculous for anyone to write either off. It's all genre. Some if it straddles the edge of literary merit, and for those types of readers, Turtles should be up their alley as well. "City at War" is really only a step or two away from "The Dark Knight Returns." Quote:
Quote:
My first instinct is to say "trades in bookstores," which I really think is the future for this sort of thing, but from what you're telling me the stores might not be willing to? Maybe there's no way to break in without re-branding the franchise in another way (like the new movie). Or maybe I'm just throwing out baseless conjectures. I'm not a business student, just a fan who really wants to see his favorite stories be reprinted and wants to know how that can be done. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I've tried to track down the collected volume in countless places, but most comic book places hadn't gotten copies. I checked through a bunch in NY, and NH.
So, its pretty awesome how even when a person knows full well that they won't be able to find it unless they go through a comic shop, can't even find it at comic shops. And not because it sold out. I'm with Roseangelo, Mirage can't really complain, considering they do **** for distribution. |
The distribution is done by Diamond though, not Mirage. If the comic shop isn't selling it it's because they don't think it'll sell or because none of their standing orders ordered it. Dan still gets emails from people asking if Turtles was canceled because their LCS said that there hasn't been anything since Dreamwave shot their book. It'd be good to get posters or more advertising out there though, which does help distro.
Also, TMNT comics are snubbed by a lot of people in the comics biz, largely because they have no idea about them. Axel Alonso, who heads the Marvel Knights division, said that the TMNT isn't really a book he'd look at because it's a kids' thing. It's the stigma associated with the cartoon show and the Dreamwave book. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
You can make all the excuses you want for them Tristan; you can try to bend the words any way you like, but the words don't change the facts. The only entity that can change those facts is Mirage. Not Dan. Mirage. As in Gary and/or Peter. And until then, this conversation is just going to keep recycling itself. |
Quote:
Go to Diamond's website. They distribute to Amazon, B&N, Borders, Wal-Mart, Target... ****, even Toys R Us! Look! That means that anything available in Previews should be available to order/buy through any of those stores -- same way they should be available through comic shops -- but obviously whoever's going through those books and ordering the stock is choosing not to. Now, I've said from the start that I don't think enough is done to promote the comics, but so has everyone else, and I'd say it's a drum that's going to get beaten a lot in this discussion, but you can still promote the **** out of a book and have stores just not stock it. Quote:
you keep saying "Mirage" instead of Gary and/or Peter... Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
You know, you keep saying all these things online, but why didn't you just bring this up with "Mirage" at San Diego? Quote:
And you can keep on pigeon holing me as much as you like, making me look like the bad guy, but the fact is that I speak to both "Mirage" and "Mirage" relatively regularly, so I'd say I've got a slightly better perspective on things than yourself especially when it comes to "facts". I'm not saying I know everything, but I am saying that you don't know me and you clearly don't know "Mirage". I love how quickly we got back to this. I just said it was interesting that Kevin's book did far better than the Mirage ones. Both of them. I suspected it might, but not in the numbers it did. |
Quote:
Not that there can't be a significant amount of overlap. Quote:
|
I thought I'd chime in this thread and tell you guys Paneltopanel's website was definitely happy with the sales. Told me the turtles were seeminlgy "recession free". Here's hoping for a Vol. 2!
I am actually surprised that Kevins book sold more copies? Is this due to distribution factors? Heavy Metal have a hand in distributing his book, as opposed to Mirage?...Because that would make complete sense:lol: |
Lord there's way too much drama around here... it feels like CW.
|
Look, I'm not looking for a fight with anyone. I'm just saying that Mirage needs to take responsibility for their low sales, especially if they want to continue publishing and they need better sales to justify doing so. If the current comic book industry isn't responding to what they're doing, then they need to adjust to that like any other company would.
None of the artists, including Dan, have the decision making power to make such changes. They work for Mirage, and have for a long time. Everyone here on this forum loves and adores them as part of the heart and soul of Mirage, and for good reason. But when it comes down to business, they are not Mirage. I would certainly like to see TMNT comics continue to be published, but it's not a problem anyone here can do anything about. |
I wrote this post before reading Roseangelo's newest commment. She basicaly said the same with fewer words, but I'm posting it anyway.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Roseangelo said that Mirage is only Gary and Peter, but I'm pretty sure what she's trying to say is that in this case the responsability relies on the people that occupy Gary and Peter's position within the company. Of course we all know than Mirage staff is bigger. The thing is that not all of them have the power to change the problem discussed here (lack of sales / distorted perception of the brand.) In my opinion, "Mirage" should do the following things (and please excuse if the have already done this): 1) Hire a marketing department: they should mainly determine the profile of the current comic reader population. What do they like, what do they dislike. Then, with that information... (cont.) 2) Create a advertising campaign. It should not be centered on the turtles or in "did you know the real TMNT is hardcore?" messages, but in selling an idea and way of living (that we want the reader to identify with) rather than the actual content of the title. 3) Adjust the comic content. For example, if it turns out that 90% of the population likes Udon comic-style drawings, it wouldn't hurt try going that direction. Also things like "I'm doing this comics for myself, if you don't like it don't buy" is fine and actually shows some artistic integrity. But we should be aware that by doing that, the comic is not going to be bought by comic readers, not even by TMNT fans, but only by people that has the same tastes than the author. In short, if we keep treating TMNT as an underground, secret title, we'll keep getting underground, small sales. 4) Talk (in person) with the people in charge of picking which titles are sold in Amazon, Barnes & Noble, etc. With results of the previous investigation, and projection of the benefits of the advertising campaign and future projects, we should aim to convince them that this is good business. 5) Crossovers! It has been said before, of course. Also, the selection of the character(s) we want the TMNT to crossover with should be done with care. Two thing have to be taken into account: exposure and type of audience. The character should be one with an audience we want for ourselves, and the bigger, the better. Erm... interchange "we" in the above sentences with "Mirage". Thanks. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
let's just hug it out... no need for arguing... what we have here is a room full of raphaels... this is business 101... if nobody is buying the comics that are currently available then businesses will not order the next one fearing the risk of losing sales... i am sure this is pretty clear and everyone in the thread understands this... simple supply and demand here...
as for getting more sales... if mirage is worried about it then i have faith that whoever is responsible for getting sales will step up and do whatever they need to do... if YOU (the tmnt fan) are worried about the low sales then spread the word, create some badges to put on your signatures, facebooks, and myspaces.... create a fan website (i did), do your part to help spread the tmnt word... instead of butting heads on a tmnt forum... we can show peter and the rest of the mirage crew that their fans are the best there is (which we are :D ) and can rally behind their company in support of what they do... and personally, i enjoy the "cult" feel of tmnt... marvel and dc does not give me that feel with their more popular characters... which isn't a bad thing in itself but having that "cult" feeling gives me more enjoyment and self worth... i feel i have rambled on long enough... time to go back to the hole i crawled out from... -mm p.s. smile! |
As I had stated something similar back in this thread:
http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=27598 "The top 50 indie graphic novels is listed for July sales. The TMNT 25th Kevin Eastman book ranked #17 and TMNT Collected ranked #48. Keep in mind this is the indie graphic novels rank. No idea where they'd rank with the overall chart of trades/books, meaning all publishers." http://www.newsarama.com/comics/0908...y09-sales.html From this bit I had no idea where the Future Tense trade had ranked but obviously it would've been under the top indie 50 listing. Until Tristan found the true numbers, does anyone care about the topic. When I mentioned this bit no one really said anything. To me this was a sign. Whether we see anymore trades is all Mirages call. I doubt the more recent trades like: Soul's Winter Zulli tpb, the 5 Tales of TMNT Vol. 2 tpb's, Tales Vol. 1 re-issue tpb, TMNT '07 movie tpb, had anywhere near the numbers of FT and TMNT Collected. They were probably worser numbers. So what Mirages perception of "good" sales are is anyones guess. The problem with Mirage is that they won't reach the mass book market. I'm not sure what anyone thinks of the Amazon, B&N etc has a huge impact on the comic book trades. But we must keep in mind that Diamond serves both the mass and direct markets for comic trades. The sales to those other places doesn't count in the direct market (the comic stores) that Diamond distributes to both. Diamond serves most of the comic publishers to get the stuff to those mass book stores/sites. But any sales there DO NOT count in the comic market that Diamond is the core distributer of. Its just everyone makes it sound like the Eastman book sold better 'cause it was also at amazon, etc. Sure it sold more volume with that extra load of orders. But the 1300+ copies doesn't include amazon numbers. Only comic store orders. I must admit in my ratio to the common comics stores I go to (Edmonton, AB) since the last 2 Mirage trades came out, between 6 comic stores: 2 FT books, 1 TMNT Collected, 6 Eastman books. Thats between 2 or 3 of these places having them not all of those stores. I think the Eastman book did better 'cause Heavy Metal as a publisher has been around longer and their book was in color. I think Mirage suffered cause the books listing in Diamond probably didn't get noticed by most store owners when they ordered (even with the spotlight treatment). Mirage is and will be no different then the comic book glut among the indie publishers. But the price may have killed it too. You can get trades of huge omnibuses from other publishers and the stuff'd be in color (the 6x9 sized ones I mean). TMNT Collected had no color. There was no reason the book couldn't have been printed in a thinner stock of white paper which may have lowered costs for the book. Now I could be wrong too about that. In hindsight I think Archie should've reprinted the FT book. It'd be in color like TMNT Adventures book one recently. Probably more copies too out there too. How come Dave Sim, Terry Moore and Jeff Smith can keep their books available in a backstock way through Diamond and the mass market, why can't Mirage? Tristan, I heard in the past I think on these boards that Mirage doesn't want to get the books to the mass market 'cause they don't want to take the books back when a store wants to give it back. I don't know how the book distibution biz works but I think bookstores have the right to send a certain amount back from the initial core order. This is what I heard Mirage was leary of. But other indie publishers can handle this? Its also not the bookstores fault that they don't order the Mirage books from Diamond. Its just Mirage won't make it available to these bookstores. I mean long term woudn't it be a consistent source of decent revenue? Theres a demand for the old TMNT comics but I'd also guess that the fandom is small or only for the comic book audience. You always hear a comic reader say they've never read or seen the old TMNT comics or they say I'd like to see that stuff again. Maybe TMNT is only best for the limited exposure of the direct market audience? I don't know what else to say about this. |
Quote:
Quote:
I'm also pretty sure that when the new movie comes around, with the swing shift of the spotlight being back on the comics, those stockists will be grabbing at them, touting them as the new "in" thing. It'll be the same with all the comic shops telling you that the TMNT comics were canceled years ago. Quote:
I also remember Dan saying something along the lines of them not wanting/being able to deal with returns. Quote:
Quote:
All this said, I was talking to Dan and Gary just recently, and both are very pleased with the response to the book! |
I'm just glad books 2-5 are still avlible on the Turtles site. I just got Collected book 4 in the mail today.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Yes, it is up to the publishers to make their mark and make their books marketable, but ultimately, if a shop chooses not to stock something, that's all there is to it. |
The point DK2 was correctly making is that bookstores couldn't order TMNT trades if they wanted to. You can walk into any Borders or B&N and ask a clerk to order ANY book for you that is in print so long as they can find it in their database of in print books. At Mirage's own choosing, their trades are not made available to these lists and the distributors that keep it all running. That is why they aren't listed on Amazon. It has absolutely nothing to do with name recognition or anything else. Mirage doesn't want to deal with returns. End of story.
What are returns? If stores end up with excess stock and/or want to send all or part of their inventory back to the publisher, they get to do that and get credit back from the publisher. All those bargain books that sit on tables in the front of bookstores are books that have been returned to the publisher and then resold to the stores for a discounted price. And Jurassic Park actually sells fairly regularly and is kept in stock by most stores of significant size. Not in massive amounts, but if a copy gets sold it'll automatically get reordered and will be back on the shelf within a week (i.e. replenished). |
Quote:
|
As an aside (although totally related), I always wondered: why doesn't Mirage at least try that whole "Amazon Affiliate" thing?
(As I understand it, which may be incorrect) That's where you set up a "store" on Amazon, ship them a number of copies of your book, and then they take care of purchase and fulfillment (w/ a percentage of each sale going to Amazon, I think). I don't know too much about it, but I always thought that would be an inexpensive "experiment" for Mirage to pursue. Then, if the books sold well there, they'd have all the more reason to get them into actual bookstores (as I think we all agree that they should be). |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:54 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.