The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Now that Laird is out of the picture, let's make Image canon again (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=28865)

CyberCubed 10-31-2009 12:34 PM

Now that Laird is out of the picture, let's make Image canon again
 
Who is with me?

The Image series is still considered "Volume 3" of the comics, because well....there is no Volume 3 otherwise. We went from Volume 2 to Volume 4, mainly because Image was considered Volume 3 at the time.

Image had some direct continuations in the Mirage universe, such as Shadow's real father being a mob boss, Raph taking over the mantle of the Shredder before losing it to Karai as Lady Shredder, Triceratons trying to invade Earth, and the return of Savage Dragon and dealing with some Image villains. It also leads into Volume 4 better than most people realize, especially with the time jump from when Shadow is around 5 in Image to when she's a teen in Volume 4. As well as Splinter's declining health, which started in this volume, you can even say the Foot Mystic stealing Splinter's life force is what eventually led to his heart attack.

The only things that need to be addressed is Don fully losing the cyborg armor and getting a new shell, Raph's face fully healing, and Leo's hand being re-attached.

So what do you say? Do you still read Image between Vol. 2 and 4?

Andrew NDB 10-31-2009 12:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 731304)
Who is with me?

This is something I'd be definitely on board with.

Quote:

So what do you say? Do you still read Image between Vol. 2 and 4?
Absolutely.

Quote:

The only things that need to be addressed is Don fully losing the cyborg armor and getting a new shell, Raph's face fully healing, and Leo's hand being re-attached.
Raph's face was going to gradually heal (and was, even towards the end we got), and Leo was actually going to regrow a hand. And according to Gary the plan was to do a story where Don's body begins to reject the cyborg parts and they have to -- quite painfully -- extract them from his body... and when they do, they discover he's regrown his shell underneath and he's fine.

oldmanwinters 10-31-2009 01:13 PM

I do kinda wonder whether or not Karai/Shredder's breach of the Foot Clan's "truce" with the Turtles in Volume 3 would contradict any Volume 4 content. Although the Turtles and Foot don't seem on good terms by the time Volume 4 starts, so maybe it would work fine.

I definitely think Savage Dragon should be official canon since the crossover special with Complete Carnage explains how Radical's powers were depleting and she doesn't seem to have any powers in post Volume 4 continuity.

Andrew NDB 10-31-2009 01:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 731314)
I do kinda wonder whether or not Karai/Shredder's breach of the Foot Clan's "truth" with the Turtles in Volume 3 would contradict any Volume 4 content. Although the Turtles and Foot don't seem on good terms by the time Volume 4 starts, so maybe it would work fine.

A good question, though you kind of answer it yourself.

It had been written in Vol. 3 that Karai had been gone for a very long time, that she was kind of under fire in Japan, and that the Council of 5 had to sort of pick up the slack in her stead in NYC -- hence why Raph had to take over as Shredder for a while... they needed a leadership figure.

My theory is that her returning to NYC as the Lady Shredder was more a showing of force to the NYC Foot (sort of a "see who's boss" thing) than it was any real beef with the Turtles. Though I could imagine Raphael's posing as Shredder might have irritated her a little.

Around 2005 I was talking to Gary Carlson about he and I working up a draft for a 2 issue completion that I would draw and tone and just post to the web. Maybe I'll do that yet... though it's been a long time and I wonder if Gary is still game.

sdp 10-31-2009 01:45 PM

yeah, especially now without laird i'd like image to be mirage canon. I haven't read any of it but as long as its not contradicted in a big way and some explanation can be made to any inconsistencies.

The only thing I don't like about this is that I'm not sure if I'd like the TMNT being a part of the Image universe which has a ton of crap I don't care about.

Andrew NDB 10-31-2009 02:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 731321)
yeah, especially now without laird i'd like image to be mirage canon. I haven't read any of it but as long as its not contradicted in a big way and some explanation can be made to any inconsistencies.

The only thing I don't like about this is that I'm not sure if I'd like the TMNT being a part of the Image universe which has a ton of crap I don't care about.

Vol. 3 was only ever peripherally part of the Image universe. And the Image universe isn't even really the Image universe anymore... most of the staples of it 10 years ago no longer is (Youngblood, WildCATS, Gen 13, etc., is all DC now).

CyberCubed 10-31-2009 02:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 731321)
The only thing I don't like about this is that I'm not sure if I'd like the TMNT being a part of the Image universe which has a ton of crap I don't care about.

Well that's the beauty of crossovers. You only have to care about the Image stuff that actually appears in TMNT issues, not what goes on in their own series.

Its not like you have to go and suddenly read all the Savage Dragon comics simply because he's in about 5 TMNT issues. There were some Image villains in TMNT, like Mako the shark and that Johnny Deathstroke, but I just view them as guest stars rather than being concerned with who they really are.

oldmanwinters 10-31-2009 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 731324)
Well that's the beauty of crossovers. You only have to care about the Image stuff that actually appears in TMNT issues, not what goes on in their own series.

Its not like you have to go and suddenly read all the Savage Dragon comics simply because he's in about 5 TMNT issues. There were some Image villains in TMNT, like Mako the shark and that Johnny Deathstroke, but I just view them as guest stars rather than being concerned with who they really are.

Yeah, Vanguard and the TMNT are pretty tightly intertwined though. I believe Johnny Deathstroke first appeared in one of the back stories of the first Vanguad mini-series. Also, he and his supporting cast showed up in quite a few of those TMNT Image comics. Anybody know the status of Vanguard at the moment?

Dragon Turtle 10-31-2009 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 731324)
Well that's the beauty of crossovers. You only have to care about the Image stuff that actually appears in TMNT issues, not what goes on in their own series.

I certainly wouldn't mind seeing a TMNT/Elephantmen crossover.

Kendamu 10-31-2009 02:35 PM

I'm on board. I just need to find some actual issues to buy. I've lost my Vol. 3 stuff because of moving over the years.

Well, 'cept for Bodycount. I still have that. That doesn't count as Vol. 3, though, right?

But, yeah, I love Vol. 3 and I enjoyed it a lot as it came out!

Andrew NDB 10-31-2009 03:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 731328)
Well, 'cept for Bodycount. I still have that. That doesn't count as Vol. 3, though, right?

Of course not. Especially since half of it was first published at Mirage.

Raph's Girl 10-31-2009 04:48 PM

Image appears to be an inbetween universe with crossovers with Mirage (TMNT/Savage Dragon stuff), DC (Superman/Savage Dragon), and even Marvel (the TMNT DID attend a wedding in Savage Dragon that included Batman, Robin, Superman, the X-Men, Hulk, Fantastic Four, ect). With the introduction of the multi-verse in Volume 4 I consider Image to be simply another earth (along with Archie, Dreamwave, ect).

Jephael 10-31-2009 04:53 PM

I believe everyone's entitled to their opinion on the matter. Some folks might not have been as fond of the Image Turtles as much as other people were, hence why Volume 3 is basically an alternate reality.

TMNTD 10-31-2009 04:54 PM

I'm on board. I actually liked Vol.3. I definately like it more than vol.4

CyberCubed 10-31-2009 04:55 PM

IIRC most people had no problem with Image being part of the Mirage universe, even though there was of course controversy with what happened to the Turtles.

I don't see a reason why everything that happened in Image couldn't fit into the Mirage universe, the Turtles have crossovers all the time. Usagi, Gutwallow, the Cowboys of Moo Mesa...how is Savage Dragon any different? We also know for a fact there are superheroes in the Mirage universe, so just look at it that way.

traf 10-31-2009 05:11 PM

If Image could get the license to publish TMNT comics again, maybe we could get a continuation of Vol. 3 or at least a proper conclusion. Though a lot of people didn't like it from what I understand.

Edit: Also, according to Erik Larsen, the way the Image Universe works is that each title exists in its own sub-universe and the crossovers are events that occur simultaneously throughout each title's universe.

Andrew NDB 10-31-2009 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raph's Girl (Post 731361)
Image appears to be an inbetween universe with crossovers with Mirage (TMNT/Savage Dragon stuff), DC (Superman/Savage Dragon), and even Marvel (the TMNT DID attend a wedding in Savage Dragon that included Batman, Robin, Superman, the X-Men, Hulk, Fantastic Four, ect). With the introduction of the multi-verse in Volume 4 I consider Image to be simply another earth (along with Archie, Dreamwave, ect).

But Savage Dragon crossovers happened in Mirage TMNT comics even before Volume 3.

Kendamu 10-31-2009 06:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by traf (Post 731371)
If Image could get the license to publish TMNT comics again, maybe we could get a continuation of Vol. 3 or at least a proper conclusion. Though a lot of people didn't like it from what I understand.

Edit: Also, according to Erik Larsen, the way the Image Universe works is that each title exists in its own sub-universe and the crossovers are events that occur simultaneously throughout each title's universe.

A lot of people didn't like what was being done to the Turtles in Vol. 3, but with where it was going it would've gotten a lot better for people. It was really killed when it hit its stride.

CyberCubed 10-31-2009 06:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Goongasnootch (Post 731386)
A lot of people didn't like what was being done to the Turtles in Vol. 3, but with where it was going it would've gotten a lot better for people. It was really killed when it hit its stride.

Keep in mind this was before Raph turned into a dinosaur, Don turned into the size of an action figure, and April became a drawing in Volume 4.

The funny thing is Laird did the same thing to the characters that people complained that the Image series did, the only difference is we at least know Raph and Don will return to normal by the end of Volume 4.

And the same thing was going to happen in Image anyway, with a return of status quo.

Cipher 10-31-2009 07:06 PM

I like Image. I'm fine with it being its own branch-off universe, and I'm fine with it being placed into Mirage continuity if the connecting stories are ever written.

As far as healing injuries goes, I actually would have liked to see Raph maintain his ocular damage. Everyone loves eyepatch Raph, don't they?

AquaParade 10-31-2009 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher Classic (Post 731389)
Everyone loves eyepatch Raph, don't they?

http://i35.tinypic.com/24bu5py.jpg

Hell yea!

Powder 10-31-2009 07:52 PM

Totally irrelevant, but the image series is by far my favorite.

oldmanwinters 10-31-2009 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 731366)
IIRC most people had no problem with Image being part of the Mirage universe, even though there was of course controversy with what happened to the Turtles.

I don't see a reason why everything that happened in Image couldn't fit into the Mirage universe, the Turtles have crossovers all the time. Usagi, Gutwallow, the Cowboys of Moo Mesa...how is Savage Dragon any different? We also know for a fact there are superheroes in the Mirage universe, so just look at it that way.

I think the thing with Savage Dragon and related characters is that it was established as early as Savage Dragon/TMNT (the second one), it is clear that the Turtles travel to Chicago. At least at that point, the TMNT lived in NY and Savage Dragon (et al) lived in Chicago.

EDIT: Huh, now that I think about it, the TMNT went to Chicago in both Savage Dragon crossover specials.

Coola Yagami 10-31-2009 10:20 PM

Wait, the Mystics were in the Image comics too?

CyberCubed 10-31-2009 10:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 731418)
Wait, the Mystics were in the Image comics too?

There was a Foot Mystic named Cheng who drained Splinter's life force, essentially making him weaker and weaker. He also helped Splinter change from his mutated bat-form back to normal when Raph was still the leader of the NYC Foot clan.

Its really more or less the same as the type of Foot Mystics from Tales #2 and #11.

Coola Yagami 10-31-2009 10:42 PM

Were there Foot Mystics before Volume 3?

RossMay 11-01-2009 12:18 AM

I never thought about that (when mystics show up). In the finale to "Return to New York" Shredder mentions that it was both mystic and scientific agents of the Foot who brought him back to life, so I guess that's their first mention. Pretty sure they first appear in Volume 3.

Andrew NDB 11-01-2009 01:14 AM

All right, I've reached out to Mr. Carlson again. Last time we spoke (albeit, it was a long time ago... 4 years) he even ventured that Frank Fosco might contribute a bit of art himself.

Coola Yagami 11-01-2009 01:31 AM

Wait, wait,wait.... So the Foot Mystics that would appear in Tales volume 2 AND the 2K3 cartoon originated from Volume 3?????

CyberCubed 11-01-2009 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 731451)
All right, I've reached out to Mr. Carlson again. Last time we spoke (albeit, it was a long time ago... 4 years) he even ventured that Frank Fosco might contribute a bit of art himself.

That's really interesting. If the pages were fully scanned online we could even print it out and make it into a comic ourselves. And if its coming from the writer himself, its as an official ending to Volume 3 as we're ever going to get.

With the "Forever War" seeming like its never going to happen, it would be nice to see another series actually get its proper closure.

ZariusTwo 11-01-2009 05:03 PM

I would only make Raph's stint as The Shredder canocial. Everything else is truley bad fanfiction or someone taking drugs

Cipher 11-01-2009 05:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZariusTwo (Post 731576)
I would only make Raph's stint as The Shredder canocial. Everything else is truley bad fanfiction or someone taking drugs

I'm not sure where you're coming from with this. From the issues I've read, everyone was in character, and the plotlines were only slightly more surreal than a lot of the Mirage stuff (and even then, it's a matter of perspective). I feel like Volume 3 gets slapped with what I like to call "Dragon Ball GT Syndrome." ie. People picking on faults that aren't unique to that part of the series just because it isn't by the original author.

CyberCubed 11-01-2009 06:21 PM

There was also a plotline with Leatherhead delving into madness, and becoming more savage and less intelligent. Its an element that was used in the 2k3 series too.

That leads into Volume 4 nicely too. If you remember Leatherhead was at Splinter's funeral, but watching from the swamp rather than with everyone else.

Dragon Turtle 11-01-2009 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 731451)
All right, I've reached out to Mr. Carlson again. Last time we spoke (albeit, it was a long time ago... 4 years) he even ventured that Frank Fosco might contribute a bit of art himself.


What is Frank Fosco up to these days, I've haven't much from him since his TMNT run, but if they don't wrap up their plot lines, I say keep Vol. 3 out of continuity.

Other then a few interesting plot developments, I didn't find Vol. 3 to be that remarkable.

Andrew NDB 11-01-2009 08:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 731590)
What is Frank Fosco up to these days, I've haven't much from him since his TMNT run, but if they don't wrap up their plot lines, I say keep Vol. 3 out of continuity.

That's fair enough, I suppose.

Quote:

Other then a few interesting plot developments, I didn't find Vol. 3 to be that remarkable.
Like all the remarkable developments in Vol. 2?

Dragon Turtle 11-01-2009 11:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 731609)
Like all the remarkable developments in Vol. 2?

Honestly, I'm not that much of a fan of Vol. 2, but it's officially still part of Mirage continuity, as official as Mirage continuity can be these days.

Cipher 11-02-2009 12:59 AM

Volume 2 isn't really a fair comparison. It's obvious they were going slow-burn with the story and the title was canceled prematurely. It did a lot of things right - character moments, some of the most surreal moments in any Turtles fiction, etc. The actual action/plots didn't quite do it, but only because they didn't have time to play out like they should have.

plastroncafe 11-02-2009 10:09 AM

Gotta say, I did not like Volume 3 when it first came out. At all.
These days though, I think they're great comics that, if nothing else, typifies what was going on in Comics in the early to mid 90s.

So while I'm not a huge fan of Bat!Splinter, and the whole Maiming for the Sake of Maim as canon, they are vastly more entertaining than they once were.

Andrew NDB 11-02-2009 12:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 731634)
Honestly, I'm not that much of a fan of Vol. 2, but it's officially still part of Mirage continuity, as official as Mirage continuity can be these days.

I know that. But it seemed like you were gauging Vol. 3 on a scale of how many "remarkable developments" it had... I'm just saying, if you want to do that, let's point the magnifying glass at the Volume before it. Or the Volume after it.

And Volume 3 was in Mirage continuity for the duration of its entire run. Peter Laird himself even lauded it in the pages of the Image TMNT TPB.

Quote:

These days though, I think they're great comics that, if nothing else, typifies what was going on in Comics in the early to mid 90s.
I don't know if I agree with that. I mean, you take any issue of Volume 3 and put it next to... I don't know, Youngblood, Spawn, WildCATS, the Spider Clone Saga, Knightfall, Death of Superman, Gen 13, Generation X, or any of those decidedly very stereotypical 90s comics... it doesn't look or read like any of those.

Though I get the whole, "they got battle-injured and hurt, and Pimiko wore a skimpy outfit with heels" thing that's somewhat indicative of the time... but that's really about it.

plastroncafe 11-02-2009 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 731703)
I don't know if I agree with that. I mean, you take any issue of Volume 3 and put it next to... I don't know, Youngblood, Spawn, WildCATS, the Spider Clone Saga, Knightfall, Death of Superman, Gen 13, Generation X, or any of those decidedly very stereotypical 90s comics... it doesn't look or read like any of those.

Though I get the whole, "they got battle-injured and hurt, and Pimiko wore a skimpy outfit with heels" thing that's somewhat indicative of the time... but that's really about it.

When I think of 90s comics I think of:
- glorified and graphic violence to the X-TREME
- Highly Stylized/Anatomy Doesn't Work That Way figures

Which...let's face it, Image books cornered the market on both.
I know that's why I bought Savage Dragon back in the day...


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:44 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.