The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Anyone like how they tried to push the censors for a Saturday morning cartoon? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=29050)

CyberCubed 11-18-2009 12:39 PM

Anyone like how they tried to push the censors for a Saturday morning cartoon?
 
The 2k3 series did some things I thought were very surprising for a Saturday morning kids cartoon. Leonardo gets stabbed in "Exodus," Splinter gets impaled in the dream sequence of "The Darkness Within." Karai, if I'm remember correctly, gets slashed through the stomach during Season 5, although no blood is shown.

"Same as it Never Was" and "Insane in the Membrane" are probably the two darkest episodes of the show.

On top of that, there were a lot of deaths. Some Foot Soldiers and Triceratons had to have been killed in some of those fights. Mike pulls the grenade pin on a Triceraton and he explodes off-screen. Foot Soldiers get blown off buildings. Draco turns to dust. A man is shot during "H.A.T.E."

Shoko'nobo gets a grenade in his mouth and blows to pieces. Shredder gets his head cut off. Demon Shredder gets slashed in half. Hun shoots hundreds of bullets into the mutant outbreak monsters. In BTTS, April says, "Casey came home with blood that wasn't his."

Sometimes it surprises me what they were able to get away with for a Saturday morning children's cartoon. There are probably some other things I can't remember right now, but its nice to see how far things were pushed.

Makes me hope the new Nick series doesn't tone things down again too much. Let's wait and see.

Cipher 11-18-2009 02:21 PM

Ch'rell racks up quite on off-screen death toll as well. From the Purple Dragon in the first episode to Hamato Yoshi to the people on the roof of the Foot building in "Exodus" (yeesh) and when the Utroms finally read his list of crimes...wow.

And although most onscreen kills were either very subtley implied or reserved for non-humans, you did have bits every once in a while like Hamato Yoshi killing Mashimi in the flashback episode. Right in front of the viewer.

It's by no means an adult series. But they did get by with a surprising amount for a Saturday morning timeslot. Especially during a time when 4Kids was removing all references to death from their Japanese shows.

TheShowstoppa 11-18-2009 02:22 PM

I have a lack of faith in anything Nickelodeon has done in the past 5 years, and I don't expect there to be much of a difference between that lack of faith when TMNT airs. Personally, I'll be tuning my (then) 3 year old nephew into TMNT, but it'll be a different monster for him than it was for me.

I watched Enter the Dragons Part 2 the other day and thought, "Wow, that was brutal." when some of the foot mystics and the Shredder was killed. Now, did I dislike it? No. I thought it was edgy and the way a TMNT show should be.

I look for the Nick Cartoon/CGI show to make a jump back to the 88 style and be a lot more campy, a lot more wise-cracks, and make me want to shoot myself in the face.

2K3 is my TMNT show, and it's what the ideal TMNT show should always be like. Was it perfect every episode? No. But was it made with a lot of heart and done extremely well? You better frakin believe it.

ToTheNines 11-18-2009 03:01 PM

Dude, I know Nickelodeon isn't the greatest channel ever, but Avatar did have some balls. If I would have judged the 2k3 show based on the other FoxBox/4kids shows... I probably never would have watched it. Just be patient and see what happens.

Jephael 11-18-2009 03:10 PM

I was pretty shocked the first time I watched Tales of Leo and Michelangelo said "Man, it sucks being cold blooded!"

oldmanwinters 11-18-2009 04:01 PM

Well, Nick/Viacom could always decide to try an MTV series if they so wanted. No rule says it has to be shown on Nickelodeon or NickToons, although signs indicate that seems to be the direction they want to go with this upcoming series.

Icebot 11-18-2009 04:02 PM

Insane in the Membrane was never shown on Saturday morning because it was too graphic to 4kids. And let's not forget how they cancelled Nightmares Recycled. One thing that always surprised me about the show is how the turtles are always jumping off of tall buildings and not getting hurt. And how can they jump from one rooftop to the next so easily?

jaymq 11-18-2009 04:05 PM

Spoiler:
Before we knew Shredder was an Utrom, he got beheaded by Leo, read something somewhere saying someone got in trouble for allowing that.

Ninjinister 11-18-2009 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Icebot (Post 735400)
One thing that always surprised me about the show is how the turtles are always jumping off of tall buildings and not getting hurt. And how can they jump from one rooftop to the next so easily?

It's called being a ninja :D

The Terror of Death 11-18-2009 05:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher Classic (Post 735365)
Especially during a time when 4Kids was removing all references to death from their Japanese shows.

I'm still scratching my head at that. These guys spend all their time editing guns, violence (even comedic violence), Japanese text and references to Japanese culture, yet all of that appears in TMNT constantly. Totally redonkulous.

Anyway, to name a all the other instances of censor pushing; Bishop was impaled by the hook in Bishops Gambit, a couple mutated animals were killed by the EPF soldiers and one pedestrian was apparently eaten alive by a mutant pigeon at the end of Outbreak, Zog died in Rogue in the House, Raph almost clubbed Mikey with a pipe in Meet Casey Jones, Karai cutt off a snake’s head and a few droplets of blood were briefly seen spurting out in New World Order, Don snapped an alien’s neck in The People’s Choice, the Brotherhood ate all the inhabitants of that planet in The Trouble With Augie, Bishop was dissected and then spent decades doing the same to mutants and aliens, Marlin the hunter died in Hunted, The Ancient One’s daughter was killed by Mashimi in Tales of Yoshi, The Merwomen passed away in Sons of the Silent Age, the Y’Lyntians and their city sunk into lava in The Entity Below, Nobody was shot in Nobodys Fool, and Leatherhead stomach was cut open by buzz saws during the flashback in Good Genes.

Furthermore, the turtles inadvertently helped Zixx smuggle explosives to those warring aliens in Milk Run. Some buildings were destroyed in Enter the Dragons and so was a military base in Space Invaders but we never find out if people were in them. Also, the heavy implication of the Purple Dragons and Darius Dunn murdering both Casey and Cody’s parents. Savanti and the Sliver probably bit the dust as well.

I also liked how the violence was a tad more realistic and brutal than most TVY7 western action cartoons. The turtles almost always aim to kill whenever they fight Shredder, mutants, demons, and aliens and we actually see them succeed sometimes. Leo and Raph also tried to slice/stab Bishop, Karai, and Hun a few times (they always miss). Splinter had his leg broken by Draco which resulted in him carrying the cane. Leo was beaten half to death in The Shredder Strikes Back and spent the next three episodes healing up. All the guys and Splinter were severely injured in Exodus and had to recuperate at Casey’s farmhouse for a few episodes in season four. Casey was bandaged up by the attack from Nano and had bruises all over his body after his beating by the purple dragons in Fallen Angel. Leo had a piece of his shell broken for all of season four and five. Casey tried to kill the Purple Dragons in his debut episode. Jencko almost clubbed someone to death and the guy had to be taken to the hospital. Not too mention the news reports of deaths due to gang violence preluding the City at War arc.

mumbo230 11-18-2009 06:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Terror of Death (Post 735419)
I'm still scratching my head at that. These guys spend all their time editing guns, violence (even comedic violence), Japanese text and references to Japanese culture, yet all of that appears in TMNT constantly. Totally redonkulous.

Different teams for each show basically.

TMNT wasn't their only edgy show. While editing was present in Shaman King, there was a bit of blood left in that series, one of the characters said "jackass," and while death was...glazed over somewhat, there was onscreen death IIRC and the concept was still there (I mean, it's a show about ghosts). Contrast that with their most notorious dub, One Piece, and...yeah.

4Kids actually got in trouble for Shaman King from the Parents' whatever-ma-bob Council thing for the level of violence in that show.

But yeah it all kind of depended on who the showrunner was for how much a show would try to get away with.

Powder 11-18-2009 08:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 735397)
Well, Nick/Viacom could always decide to try an MTV series if they so wanted. No rule says it has to be shown on Nickelodeon or NickToons, although signs indicate that seems to be the direction they want to go with this upcoming series.

Farfetched, but I've been hoping for that. Yet Id hate the generation of viewers to be the bubblegum std bearing tweens who share the same passion for 'the hills' & all that other bullsh!t

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle 11-18-2009 08:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moosandra (Post 735403)
Spoiler:
Before we knew Shredder was an Utrom, he got beheaded by Leo, read something somewhere saying someone got in trouble for allowing that.

Who got in trouble for that? I do remember the moment I saw that for the first time. Jaw. Hit. The. Floor. HARD! So is there really a story of someone getting yelled at for Shredder's decapitation?

ToTheNines 11-18-2009 08:38 PM

One of my favorite ballsy moments was Splinter shooting Saki in the stomach with an arrow in Exodus-1.

Cipher 11-18-2009 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 735456)
One of my favorite ballsy moments was Splinter shooting Saki in the stomach with an arrow in Exodus-1.

I love the Ch'rell vs. everyone fight in that episode. One of the best in the series.

And yeah, that arrow was hardcore. Splinter was aiming for the stomach on purpose. He was specifically trying to kill Ch'rell inside the exo-suit.

Aztec General 11-18-2009 09:48 PM

I give mad props to the 4Kids crew! They put on the best action animated show on television from seasons 1-5. Brilliant all around. Good story telling, character development, creativity, action, violence, push the limits, and still stayed true to Mirage.

It's a shame that FF and BTTS were so unwatchable. But hey 5 good years is nothing to sneeze at!

oldmanwinters 11-18-2009 10:06 PM

A wee bit off-topic but ...

When it comes to Saturday morning censorship, this is my favorite what-not-to-do illustration:
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a56...btacensors.jpg

Come to think of it, I'm not sure 2k3 TMNT broke any of these rules directly, with most of the violence and death being implied off-screen. Although we did see guys busting through the glass quite a bit.

nomekop 11-19-2009 05:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 735466)
I give mad props to the 4Kids crew! They put on the best action animated show on television from seasons 1-5. Brilliant all around. Good story telling, character development, creativity, action, violence, push the limits, and still stayed true to Mirage.

It's a shame that FF and BTTS were so unwatchable. But hey 5 good years is nothing to sneeze at!

My thoughts exactly ;)

Seasons 1-5 from 2k3 are best animated TMNT show yet, hope Nick tries at least get close to it! :roll:

Spitfire 11-19-2009 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 735466)
Good story telling, character development, creativity, action, violence, push the limits, and still stayed true to Mirage.

If you seriously believe that you've never read a Mirage comic. Very few comic adaptation episodes are worthwhile. Most of them end up being empty shells. In some cases they just drug out a story too long or like in the case of "City At War" it was ruined by being cut down too much.

And as far as violence goes I don't know what you're talking about. I don't see any blood in this series or death really. Maybe the DCAU shows have spoiled me but when I think of a kid series with boundary pushing violence it has to at least be on par with that.

Cipher 11-19-2009 01:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 735466)
and still stayed true to Mirage.

Uh, no. I know I'm just re-iterating some of what Spitfire said, but the comics and cartoon are still two very different animals, and not just in terms of censorship and plot. The storytelling and tone is completely different between the series. For example, censorship aside, the 4Kids show is actually better at action and cohesive storylines than the comics. Hands down. The comics, however, are much more somber, tactful, and occasionally artistic. The similarities are really just cosmetic: a few adapted plotlines, nothing more.

And yeah, the comic adaptation episodes are the perfect example. Outside of a small handful, they have all their layers stripped away to make them straight-foward kiddy affairs. You want the one or two episodes that actually felt like they could have been comic issues? Look at "Milk Run" and "DNA is Thicker Than Water."

Quote:

It's a shame that FF and BTTS were so unwatchable. But hey 5 good years is nothing to sneeze at!
One of those is not unwatchable. And the "five good years" don't necessarily correspond to the order of the seasons. I'd feel like a dick for saying this if half the fanbase didn't agree with me.

Quote:

When it comes to Saturday morning censorship, this is my favorite what-not-to-do illustration:
Gun violence, puncture wounds, child endangerment, religious iconography, alcohol, drug use, sexuality, strangling. And I'm not sure, but...glass-breaking? Either way, the only ones I can think of that TMNT violated was gun violence and puncture wounds, but never directly on camera.

Spitfire 11-19-2009 01:39 PM

You're allowed to have guns as long as their laser guns. real guns are the issue. Only a few shows had real guns. I think the window breaking thing is a spoof on the Spider-man series. They weren't allowed to show him breaking a window or punching someone...

Cipher 11-19-2009 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire (Post 735531)
You're allowed to have guns as long as their laser guns. real guns are the issue. Only a few shows had real guns. I think the window breaking thing is a spoof on the Spider-man series. They weren't allowed to show him breaking a window or punching someone...

I was talking about the few times in TMNT when they actually had a character suffer a bullet wound (despite the shot not being seen). I think that was probably a no-no in the early 90s. Even on B:TAS, which featured realistic guns, I don't remember anyone specifically stating they'd been shot.

Turo602 11-19-2009 02:03 PM

Yeah but some shows are allowed to break some of the rules like Batman TAS they were allowed to use guns with real bullets.

CyberCubed 11-19-2009 03:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher Classic (Post 735530)
And yeah, the comic adaptation episodes are the perfect example. Outside of a small handful, they have all their layers stripped away to make them straight-foward kiddy affairs.

With the exception of City at War, since they left out the April, Casey and Splinter segments, most of the episode adaptions improved upon the original. The whole "Turtles in Space" and "Secret Origins" was done better in the show than the comics.

The comics definitely have a lot more depth, but the whole structure and action was done better in the cartoon.

Quote:

One of those is not unwatchable.
Neither are unwatchable.

Quote:

And the "five good years" don't necessarily correspond to the order of the seasons. I'd feel like a dick for saying this if half the fanbase didn't agree with me.
I don't see where you got this idea from. Ninja Tribunal is still vastly preferred over FF and BTTS from what I've seen. FF was good, and BTTS was a step-down from everything before it, but I don't see what point you're trying to make here.

ToTheNines 11-19-2009 04:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 735563)
Ninja Tribunal is still vastly preferred over FF and BTTS from what I've seen. FF was good, and BTTS was a step-down from everything before it, but I don't see what point you're trying to make here.

FF and BttS >>>>>>>>>>> Ninja Tribunal.

oldmanwinters 11-19-2009 04:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher Classic (Post 735532)
I was talking about the few times in TMNT when they actually had a character suffer a bullet wound (despite the shot not being seen). I think that was probably a no-no in the early 90s. Even on B:TAS, which featured realistic guns, I don't remember anyone specifically stating they'd been shot.

Commissioner Gordon almost died from a bullet wound in "I Am the Night." Great episode.
http://www.worldsfinestonline.com/WF...s/iamthenight/

Back to the TMNT... for me, the two most shocking parts of the series were Shredder's "beheading" (although it was soon revealed to be merely an android body) and Karai's apparent stabbing of Leo in Exodus Part 2 (again, off screen). There was also a prevalent creepy factor, especially with Stockman's constant mutilation over the course of the series.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher Classic (Post 735530)
Gun violence, puncture wounds, child endangerment, religious iconography, alcohol, drug use, sexuality, strangling. And I'm not sure, but...glass-breaking?

Don't forget smoking! :D

Aztec General 11-19-2009 04:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire (Post 735527)
If you seriously believe that you've never read a Mirage comic.

Don't tell me what I have or haven't read. They respected the source material and presented it in the most daring way possible considering the medium of choice.

Cipher 11-19-2009 06:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 735563)
With the exception of City at War, since they left out the April, Casey and Splinter segments, most of the episode adaptions improved upon the original. The whole "Turtles in Space" and "Secret Origins" was done better in the show than the comics.

The comics definitely have a lot more depth, but the whole structure and action was done better in the cartoon.

I'll agree with you on the "Turtles in Space" arc. That was better handled on the cartoon. Which is what I was saying. The few adaptations that were completely action-oriented to begin with turned out better. The adapted issues that were deeper had their layers stripped away.

Quote:

FF and BttS >>>>>>>>>>> Ninja Tribunal
Actually, I think it goes a little something like this:

FF > Ninja Tribunal > BttS

But that's neither here nor there. The point is there's a significant portion of the fanbase who prefer Fast Foward to Season Five.

Quote:

Don't tell me what I have or haven't read. They respected the source material and presented it in the most daring way possible considering the medium of choice.
Respected, sure. I guess. But "stayed true," I think doesn't quite hold up. The 4Kids universe has a very, very different tone from the Mirage universe. Again, their similarities are only cosmetic. It stayed true to half of what TMNT is at its core. The bad-ass ninja half, it hit and ran with. The surreal, subdued, experimental half, it never really touched on.

It's just tough to push anything deeper or more somber when the Turtles are riding around in the toy-of-the-week.

ToTheNines 11-19-2009 07:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher Classic (Post 735582)
FF > Ninja Tribunal > BttS

I'll agree with that, I was just grouping FF and BttS together since most people group seasons 1-5 together.

Coola Yagami 11-19-2009 07:48 PM

I'm also surprised they ran the comic inspired eps out of order. I mean, instead of being 'fight with Shredder- Baxter- TCRI/Triceratons -Shredder Strikes Back- Return to New York with ZOG in it and such..... they played everything all of whack. Like, Return to New York didn't have Zog in it cause they haven't introduced the Triceratons yet and such.

CyberCubed 11-19-2009 07:53 PM

Which was great. If they had actually had the Turtles go into space already by the 7th episode, it would have been horrible.

Season 1 was kept mostly realistic with a lot of TMNT Vs. Foot stories. I'm glad the space stuff was held over till Season 2.

Shadow_Coon 11-20-2009 01:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle (Post 735454)
Who got in trouble for that? I do remember the moment I saw that for the first time. Jaw. Hit. The. Floor. HARD! So is there really a story of someone getting yelled at for Shredder's decapitation?

During one of the various TMNT panels, it was either John Campbell, Mike Sinterniklaas, or Wayne Grayson (the first, I'm almost certain, but I could be wrong) who revealed that someone was not only reprimanded over the decapitation scene, but flat-out fired. I don't remember the specifics off-hand, I'm afraid.

The 2k3 TMNT series, at times, took me back to B:tAS in regards to some of the "edginess" displayed. The aforementioned decapitation scene and the scene where Bishop was thrown into a hook (off-screen) invoked close to the same feeling I had during that one B:tAS episode where Batgirl was knocked off a building and died after landing on her dad/Commissioner Gordon's car (even though it turned out it was just a nightmare sequence at the end of the episode).

This show pushed a few envelopes that I hadn't seen pushed in years during Saturday morning cartoons. Kudos to 4Kids in that regard.

As for that FF/BttS/NT dispute: I preferred FF and BttS over NT myself, but I understand that many others do not feel the same way as me. To each their own; there is no right or wrong in that regard.

Icebot 11-20-2009 12:28 PM

At the end of I Monster, I think it was creepy to see an ocean of rats and to see the Rat King fall into it. It really seemed graphic the way those rats would bite.

Aneras713 11-20-2009 07:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire (Post 735531)
Only a few shows had real guns.

Like Gargoyles or Batman: TAS.

Gargoyles had an episode were one of the main characters was shot and almost died. They rarely show that ep now though.

Dejablue 12-13-2009 07:06 PM

I remember that was the episode where Broadway was playing with Elisa's gun and it went off. That was pretty shocking. And if a DISNEY show can get away with using real guns. And blood. Then why can't others? I mean seriously did the board of directors just randomly decide to have mercy? Do you have to pick the winning straw? What?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H5RTA52X3yk (Deadly Force)

But while I say this. I can't come flat out and say that TMNT is a lesser show for not having these elements. I personally don't need them to enjoy this kind of show.

jaymq 12-13-2009 09:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shadow_Coon
Quote:

Originally Posted by Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle
Who got in trouble for that? I do remember the moment I saw that for the first time. Jaw. Hit. The. Floor. HARD! So is there really a story of someone getting yelled at for Shredder's decapitation?

During one of the various TMNT panels, it was either John Campbell, Mike Sinterniklaas, or Wayne Grayson (the first, I'm almost certain, but I could be wrong) who revealed that someone was not only reprimanded over the decapitation scene, but flat-out fired. I don't remember the specifics off-hand, I'm afraid.

The interview is actually on YouTube if you wanna check it out, Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle.

Additionally, sorry I didn't get back to replying, I had forgotten I posted in this topic. but yea, it was in the panel there I believe.

Edit: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mR4i5yn9HUY (I couldn't find part 1, so here's a link starting at part 2)

Leonardo Mystic 12-13-2009 10:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moosandra (Post 740817)
The interview is actually on YouTube if you wanna check it out, Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle.

Additionally, sorry I didn't get back to replying, I had forgotten I posted in this topic. but yea, it was in the panel there I believe.

Edit: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mR4i5yn9HUY (I couldn't find part 1, so here's a link starting at part 2)

LOL I love that panel. I was there that day. I will never forget it and John singing in Raph's voice.

909 Turtle Fan 12-15-2009 03:03 PM

the turtles got beat down in Exodus, lol, and i like how they were always saying "what the shell was that" or "lets get the shell out of here". i hope the new show spotlights the turtles' ninja abilities, more acurate use of their wepons, and i really hope the enimies are legit and not just a bunch of goofballs.

Dejablue 12-15-2009 03:39 PM

I like goofball villains who are actually very dangerous aka The Joker :lol:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:38 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.