![]() |
Splinter's origin
Does anybody else prefer Splinter's origin from the original cartoon over the comic's, movie's, and 2K3's versions? I'm talking about Splinter being a human, Hamato Yoshi, who turns in to a humanoid rat, as opposed to Splinter being a rat who turns in to a humanoid. I mean, a rat mimicking ninjisu just seems extra silly to me, even in the TMNT universe.
|
I definitely prefer it since it makes more sense than a rat learning ninjitsu from his cage. Also the whole Saki/Splinter rivalry makes a lot more sense if he was Hamato Yoshi. Also I always liked the idea of the quest of trying to make Splinter human again even if it was forgotten in the OT.
His real origin is "meh", I hope the new toon has the OT origin again. |
I actually prefer the Old 'Toon origin as well.
|
I prefer the original origin.
And not just because it's less problematic in terms of racial themes. Though...that helps. |
I prefer the original comic version
|
Quote:
|
Truthfully I like the original origin over the OT origin
-but I c ur guy's point. I think the OT origin is much more plausable I like the Original Origin bc its darker and edgier. The cycle of revenge is pretty awesome. It makes the stakes a lot higher and adds more emotion. |
Like them both for different reasons.
|
Splinter as a human before being turned into a rat was my favorite as it showed Yoshi with the baby turtles in the cartoon series and great animated effects (back then) of his transformation into a rat.
|
I always thought just a regular rat learning martial arts and mimicking his master was so stupid and unbelivible. I'll belive in all sorts of crazy mutants, and wierd stuff, but a rat learning martial arts just always seemed like the total unplausible things that always bugged me.
Splinter being human makes so much more sense for why he's good at martial arts, plus it's why he's wise, and teaches the turtles about the world. Plus from the story stanpoint you have more to work with, splinter being a rat he wouldn't really be any wiser than the turtles. |
I prefer the origin as a mutated rat....
Quote" splinter being a rat he wouldn't really be any wiser than the turtles."... Im not agree....Rats a very smart/intelligence animals,he knows about human world because was a human pet and learn all about them... and rats and humans share a lot of genetic code...:D Its could be a good explain! |
OT Splinter as a human first makes more sense. rather than him just being a rat who learns martial arts .
|
1987 cartoon
Quote:
|
a rat with a long lifespan mimicking martial arts, isn't really the most bizarre thing in the tmnt universe
|
Not really the other things make more sense since its either sci-fi or fantasy.
|
Both the origins are good but the old toon one just makes more sense. A rat learning ninjitsu by mimicking the movements just doesn't make sense to me.
|
I prefer him being Yoshi. I find it silly as well. But they really need to fix that plot hole about him turning into a rat when the last thing he touches are in fact turtles.
|
I prefer the original origin, with Splinter as a rat, although I see the advantages for story telling with the OT origin.
I've known a lot of rats, and they were all very intelligent and had excellent memories. Do I think pre-mutated Splinter was capable of understanding the moves he was mimicking and the things he was seeing and hearing? No. But I can buy that the mutation was able to give him new insight, like turning the lights in a dim room all the way up. Honestly, pre-mutated Splinter learning ninjutsu makes a lot more sense to me than him saving the baby turtles. There are a lot of happy coincidences in either story, but if they weren't there, we wouldn't have a story, so... *shrugs* |
Quote:
|
Both origins have there pros and cons. I think in the Mirage Universe it makes more since for him to be a rat.
Splinter being Yoshi always sort of bothered me. So Saki and Yoshi both competed in martial arts and Saki framed him. Why couldn't Yoshi just prove that he was framed? And why would he live in the sewer? |
I do like the comics better as far as characters/stories go, but really, I think the OT origin for splinter makes more sense. Sure, rats are intelligent, & pets are known to have deep bonds with their owners/masters but that just seems a tad rediculous. Lets not forget here, the turtles were at first a parody anyhow so perhaps Kev & Pete got a real chuckle out of that concept w/o realizing it would skyrocket the way it did. Clearly the producers of the toon realized the absurdity of it cause they changed it.
|
The reason I can't get behind Splinter being human in more serious versions is that it would completely change the focus of the series.
Rat Splinter is defined by his quest to avenge his master, and attempting to attain a presence of mind greater than the animal he came from. Those are huge, huge parts of who he is as a character. Human Splinter, however, has to be consumed by his former life and attempts to regain it. It's the only path that makes sense for him. It requires a different focus for the character, and the whole vengeance aspect of the series. If he were a former human turned into a rat, that would absolutely consume him. Also, a rat learning ninjustsu from its cage is nowhere near the most absurd element of Turtles, no matter which version you're dealing with. |
Turtles
Quote:
|
That is part of the OT origin that bothers me, Yoshi is framed. Instead of trying to prove he was framed he accepts his exile. Then he goes to America and instead of trying to start a new life he goes and lives in the sewer. That just never sat well with me. I mean here is a man who is supposed to be one the best fighters in his clan and just excepts what has happened and moves on. Then when he is turned into a rat it really doesn't bother him. In fact when he got to be human again he found he liked being a rat more.
|
Well we don't know if he just accepted it, he was exiled likely not being able to prove he didn't do it. Counting Saki got control he probably tried killing him so he had to run and hide in the sewers in another country. A big part early on was about trying to make master splinter human again. The series later dropped that element but it was there. Remember that the only take we have of that origin is the OT version, a more serious version that cleans it up a bit can easily be made. In this version it makes sense why Shredder hates Splinter/Turtles so much since he was Hamato's rival and he was going to be chosen over him.
|
Both origins are little strange. I think it comes down to just how much strangeness your willing to accept. I really like the rat origin. Especially liked it in the original movie where he clawed Saki's face.
|
Well, I think Yoshi lived in the sewers in the OT because he had no money. Rent is mad expensive and it would be tough for him to get a good paying job. I mean his best bet would be like a martial arts teacher and I doubt he could get a loan to get his own building to teach and hiring could be limited.
|
Quote:
But then I guess his ear regenerates in the 3rd movie er something. |
OT Splinter from human being turned into a rat is much more logical than a rat mimicking ninjitsu. Seriously, you can't just copy martial art, you have to practice it and have battling hands on experience. The rat was just punching air in it's cage.
And why the heck does the rat is super genious remembering and mimicking it's master? And how can he learn to speak and read without a teacher? Why won't my cat mimick my daily routine? Why am I taking this too seriously? |
Quote:
Ditto for the original three movies, in which he also never fights. It's very possible that those versions of Splinter possess a masterful knowledge of martial arts, as well as the spectral plane, but aren't physically practiced or strong. Thus, he trains the Turtles to fight for him and avenge Yoshi. Only in the 4Kids cartoon and 2007 movie is Splinter both originally a rat, and also a god at actual fighting. |
Thing is, Splinter would have to be a god of martial arts fighting for the Turtles to be that good. You think they could learn all the moves and triple backflips just cause he told them how? He would have to had to SHOW them how and actually spar with them, at least when they were kids starting out. I assume he did but by the time the Turtles were teens (and Issue 1 began) he was already too old to do much.
|
Quote:
We see Splinter kick Raph's butt in Dooney's "Challenges" book. And while Splinter doesn't see a whole lot of action in the rest of the series, we do see him training the turtles in the Mirage books. So we know he's not exactly frail. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Flashback
Quote:
|
I prefer the OT origin. I allways liked Splinter being Yoshi originally, as I thought the 'rat in the cage mimicking martial arts' was a bit goofy. (Yes, I know where talking about a franchise with four anthropomorphic Talking Turtles, but the rat learning martial arts always seemed even goofier than that) I really hope the new Nick 'toon uses the Yoshi origin.
Your Kahn decrees it! |
Splinter
Quote:
And "Splinter No More" is like some kind of parody on racism. |
OT splinter often comes out as a wuss, he runs away from the murder attempt charges, he lives in the sewer. So somehow he got too poor to support himself or not only ran from Japan to New York but also went literally underground.
And he's the real Heir of the Foot Clan leadership knowing the Kur-li move. He should have been more set on regaining the leadership and drag the foot out of the corruption |
The thing is that, to accept the comic origin, you have to be comfortable with the thought that normal animals in that universe are able to understand humans actions and emotions and mimick them.
Not only it undermines the importance of the mutagen, but it also allows for a story where, for example, the turtles befriend some animals in a forest, talk to them, teach them ninjitsu, and then I don't know, sing and recreate a scene from Snow White. So I prefer to see Splinter as a human. Of course not with the exact same origin from the OT, as Cowabunga Carl said it's pretty ridiculous. But I prefer the notion that Splinter knows martial arts because he learned them when beign a human, than to accept a world where normal animals have human-like qualities. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
For this fiction....I Prefer a world where normal animals Have human-qualities!!!! ...because ...(and please dont misunderstand this comment! :embarass: )...I presume Humankind are "Mutated monkeys" so then... Splinter and the turtles can exist in that world as "Mutated rodent/turtles" with all the feelings/skills/qualities that belong to humankind...(I repet ...just in case ...for this fiction world/universe) :tgrin::trazz: Same for Usagy and all the Mutated animals in neighbor dimension!!! ;) |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:45 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.