The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Is Mirage continuity over? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=33581)

CyberCubed 04-04-2011 02:36 PM

Is Mirage continuity over?
 
With IDW "starting from scratch" and PL still leaving vol 4 on hiatus, is it finished?

It had a good 25 year run, but I'm going to miss the Mirage universe.

Venom 04-04-2011 02:45 PM

Dude, it ended two years ago when the sale happened. I just wished IDW would pick up the remaining projects Mirage had on the plate to publish *coughSourcebookcough* and put those out.

azrael 04-04-2011 02:47 PM

yes and no. Yes if PL never touches them again (shame). No if he does

Kendamu 04-04-2011 02:54 PM

I was really hoping that this wasn't going to be a hard reboot. At the same time, though, if it's a good series then I'll not really care all that much. I've been under the impression that the Mirage continuity is over since late 2009. It's not like I haven't had to suffer a reboot or get into an alternate storyline to find good comics before. Just because it's TMNT doesn't make it any different.

Besides, hopefully we get a CaW trade out of all of this.

Spitfire 04-04-2011 03:01 PM

Wait IDW is taking over turtles? Ugh. The art in all the IDW books I've read is usually quite poor. I hope a good team works on it, and they keep it adult. We don't need another TV series adaptation comic.

PizzaPower 04-04-2011 03:20 PM

from what i hear we are getting 2 tmnt series, one based on NICK and one totally on its own, plus we get graphic novels of the old mirage tmnt, so its going to be ok, but yea i wish we could at least get a official ending to vol 4.

Candy Kappa 04-04-2011 03:25 PM

I personally don't need a conclusion story, I do want more stories from Peter. But I don't need a ending

PizzaPower 04-04-2011 03:30 PM

i agree i want more stories by peter which is why i want vol 4 done and fnished by him.

TristanHuwJones 04-04-2011 04:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 835375)
Dude, it ended two years ago when the sale happened. I just wished IDW would pick up the remaining projects Mirage had on the plate to publish *coughSourcebookcough* and put those out.

No you don't. Not that one, anyway. That one's better being rebooted completely. What it was when I first started working on it and actually started editing it were two VERY different things.

Venom 04-04-2011 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 835414)
No you don't. Not that one, anyway. That one's better being rebooted completely. What it was when I first started working on it and actually started editing it were two VERY different things.

:teek: Really?! How so?

Well then, we still need a TMNT Universe Sourcebook since any reused characters could easily be identified (like Google don't exist :trazz:). It'd be interested to see how the old one was developing, though. Have you posted any excerpts on your site/fb profile?

TristanHuwJones 04-04-2011 05:13 PM

Not really, unfortunately. Regardless, the point it was at when I really worked on it wasn't what I was expecting it to be. I'd gone through and noted all the characters that appeared in the Mirage Universe, their appearances, etc. and probably about a fifth of that would've appeared in the book, and a lot of the entries contradicted later issues of Tales and some were just flat out wrong. I wasn't sure what was going on with the art either. I just remember getting a little worried when it became a flipbook and how condensed it was going to be.

CyberCubed 04-04-2011 05:24 PM

I think it's an insult to fans that they're wiping the slate clean. What are they releasing trades for if they're rebooting it?

It's like they're shutting out fans of the comics

DrSpengler 04-04-2011 05:38 PM

I read a lot of comics.

So I'm fairly desensitized to continuity reboots and multiple universes, by now. The Mirage universe-itself was full of soft reboots (retconning out Image Vol. 3) and elminating storylines and chapters here and there (any guest issue with questionable legal status); it was hardly a solid foundation to begin with. The highly episodic style of storytelling and the myriad of guest artists make it pretty uneven in quality, too, and hardly a coherent narrative when taken all at once.

And in the end, though Laird never finished his Vol. 4, I felt we got closure-enough through Berger's future-based stories.

The Mirage universe had already written itself into something of a corner and, while I would like to see that last volume completed, I can say that the elongated wait has effectively nulled my enthusiasm for it, even when the ocassional new installment comes out (though I'm always appreciative of them).

I'm open to a new continuity that starts from scratch. We'll always have the Mirage series; it won't be going back in time and replacing it. It'll just be one more alternate universe telling Turtles stories, and we should all be pretty used to that by now.

So long as the stories are good, I'm game. A new volume with Mirage-like sensibilities could be very cool and maybe even improve upon many of the creative hurtles that the original Mirage series tripped over (mainly, keeping something called "focus").

We'll just have to wait and see. I'd think that, considering the history of Turtle comics, particularly in recent years, waiting patiently is something we should all be VERY GOOD AT by now.

TristanHuwJones 04-04-2011 05:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 835440)
I think it's an insult to fans that they're wiping the slate clean. What are they releasing trades for if they're rebooting it?

It's like they're shutting out fans of the comics

Dude, as both a huge fan and as someone who worked on the comics, I could not be happier. Right before Tales wrapped up, Dan asked me to start looking at two things -- stories for Tales that would make up an ongoing story (still done as done-in-one's but continuing the way I had been writing my previous stories) and coming up with a reboot. I was excited about both ideas, but god, that reboot would have been awesome.

How are they shutting out the fans of the comics by starting again? They're shutting out new readers by not. Explain to me how continuing where Tales Vol.2 and Vol.4 left of is going to help the comic prosper and reach the readership it deserves. It can't. A HUGE number of comic readers these days won't even CONSIDER reading a black and white book. HUGE numbers. Also look at why so many Marvel and DC books are constantly going into "seasons" and renumbering at #1 -- nobody feels comfortable jumping on to a comic when the earlier issues pertaining to that run are virtually out of immediate reach. Example: I'd love to read Superman, but there are so many goddamn Superman books out there and the guy's been around for so long that there I am immediately put off jumping on to either Action Comics or Superman. Along comes All-Star Superman -- a book that acts as its own thing with a creative team I know little about except that they have huge respect for the mythos and are both capable talents -- What's that? I DON'T have to read any other Superman books to know how this one works? Sweet, I'm in!

Ultimate Spiderman did the same thing, and that didn't shut out anyone. If anything it HELPED sell more copies of the stories it was "Ultimatizing".

DrSpengler 04-04-2011 06:06 PM

"Impenetrable storytelling" is a problem comic series have been wrestling with for the longest time. You have to strike a balance between appealing to the longterm, hardcore fanbase and appealing to the newcomer who requires accessible stories.

It's not an easy thing to do and often times a straight-up reboot or a soft reboot are the only options.

I mean, dude, I assembled the Mirage Continuity Timeline and even *I* think it's a terrible thing to show newcomers. It's imposing and, quite frankly, most of the stories are so episodic and meaningless that even trying to read the books in that order would be a daunting and tedious task for the most diehard of fans.


First and foremost, I think we as fans should desire two things of this new series:

*That it tell good stories.
*That it succeed in sales.

A reboot has the best chance of offering both of those possibilities.

The Mirage continuity isn't going to cease to exist just because of some reboot and IDW isn't twirling its moustache, trying to insult or piss off the fanbase. They're thinking of how they can tell good, accessible stories while trying to make money so they can, hey, maybe do something hardcore fan-oriented down the line that won't make a lot of cash but will appease the old skool crowd (ala their GI Joe #156 ongoing).

Let's all just chill and look forward to what they have to offer, and if it sucks, THEN we can let slip the dogs of internet war.

Oculus Orbus 04-04-2011 06:12 PM

I couldn't agree more with both Spengler and Tristan. I'll be very happy if we ever get a conclusion to Volume 4, but only if it comes from Peter. In the meanwhile, I'm glad IDW is gonna do its own thing.

CyberCubed 04-04-2011 06:15 PM

I think the problem is they are releasing the Mirage comic in trades, so readers are expected to catch up that way.

Why don't they just do a cartoon based comic strictly? It's going to be all color and they said it won't be above PG. The turtles will probably all have colored bandanas.

TMNT hasn't got 70 years worth of comics like Batman and Superman, our continuity doesn't need a reboot.

DrSpengler 04-04-2011 06:19 PM

They're releasing the Mirage series in trades so that those interested in the original stories can have access to them; it doesn't matter if their ongoing is a totally different continuity.

IDW has also released trades of the Marvel Transformers and GI Joe series simultaneously with their releases of new, original Transformers and GI Joe volumes.

Releasing the Mirage series in trade IS their boon to the old school fandom and those interested in Turtles history. Just because they're releasing the Mirage series in trade doesn't mean they're required to write stories continuing its storyline.

Jester 04-04-2011 06:23 PM

*slow claps*
Well said, Doc and Tristan.

CyberCubed 04-04-2011 07:23 PM

Since they confirmed the book will be in color, do you really think they'll keep all red bandanas? I doubt it, and this series feels less like what we wanted and more like a kids TMNT comic instead.

Jester 04-04-2011 07:38 PM

WE DON'T KNOW ANYTHING YET!!!!

Sorry, but all this "OMG THIS IS GONNA SUCK!" from both the comic and the series is getting to me. We know very little right now. Stop complaining and wait until we have something solid.

And Vol 2. was in color...and they still had red bandanas. I know it was Mirage, but I don't see how "It's gonna be in color so are the bandanas." is a logical leap.

DrSpengler 04-04-2011 07:40 PM

I must be the only person who doesn't give a **** about bandana color.

I certainly don't view it as a telltale sign of product quality, that's for sure.

"OMG multi-colored bandanas ITS GONNA BE FOR BABIES!!!1!!"

TristanHuwJones 04-04-2011 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 835489)
Since they confirmed the book will be in color, do you really think they'll keep all red bandanas? I doubt it, and this series feels less like what we wanted and more like a kids TMNT comic instead.

What are you even basing that on?! That's purely conjecture on your own behalf. Calm down, and wait for more to come out. If you're that worried, GO OVER TO IDW's forums and tell them, or send them an email like everyone else. A huge problem with a lot of fan bases is that they sit in their own forums and piss and moan and get all negative without good reason and forget that it's as simple as sending a polite, thoughtful email or getting over to an OFFICIAL message board and putting in your two cents there.

TristanHuwJones 04-04-2011 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 835502)
I must be the only person who doesn't give a **** about bandana color.

I certainly don't view it as a telltale sign of product quality, that's for sure.

"OMG multi-colored bandanas ITS GONNA BE FOR BABIES!!!1!!"

I personally couldn't give a rat's arse either. I'll take it or leave it as long as the stories are good!

Powder 04-04-2011 07:42 PM

As DrSpengler said, my interest in Vol. 4 has subsided, more of less, over time. I also agree that I'm pretty much comfortable in making my own conclusions based on Dan's future tales & the like. We know that they break off, Splinter's long gone, etc. I'm more than happy to take a reboot. I'm happy to take anything that isn't crap, really. I'm not that picky when it comes to the turtles so long as everything looks nice & is written well. That means the bandanas, too. I would probably prefer all red, but it's not all that big of a deal to me...

CyberCubed 04-04-2011 08:05 PM

The comics would obviously take place before Vol 4, I don't see why that is not what they could have done. Instead we're going get this random reboot at a PG level and then another comic based on the cartoon too?

So why is this first one not being geared at the mature Mirage fans? It's not like the beginning of Vol 4 wasn't a good starting point.

DrSpengler 04-04-2011 08:07 PM

I think I'm done with this thread.

TMNachoT 04-04-2011 08:13 PM

well, if people do not read b&w comics, they should reprint the mirage comics in color.

TristanHuwJones 04-04-2011 09:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 835520)
I think I'm done with this thread.

Yeup. (like hell I need 10 characters!)

DK2 04-04-2011 09:52 PM

I'm all cool with IDW doing TMNT comics. I even thought it'd be the most plausible choice since they had a connection with Paramounts other licensed properties. I don't know if I'll get them (tired of buying comics as floppies lately), I may just wait for trades of their run. Lets not get over our heads and think IDW 's TMNT comic will have good numbers. Most of IDW comics hover around the 4 digit print runs. And their TMNT comic could be B&W still. These may lower the sales numbers and the interest from readers. I guess smaller then Walking Dead numbers since that has no colors either. I think this maybe the same feeling as when Image did the TMNT. A time when its not Mirage (besides Archie) doing TMNT comics.

Donnie 04-04-2011 10:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 835472)
Why don't they just do a cartoon based comic strictly? It's going to be all color and they said it won't be above PG. The turtles will probably all have colored bandanas.

Where was it stated that the non-Nick comic won't be above PG? Was this an official statement?

I personally like the colored bandannas better than all red, although I like all red too and wouldn't mind either way. I would even go as far to say that the colored bandannas don't make the TMNT look "childish"...if I had a bunch of brothers and we all wore the same colored shirt 24/7, I'd want to wear my own color. :roll:

Andrew NDB 04-05-2011 01:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 835489)
Since they confirmed the book will be in color, do you really think they'll keep all red bandanas?

Yes.

Quote:

I doubt it, and this series feels less like what we wanted and more like a kids TMNT comic instead.
That's why there will likely be a second, Nickelodeon-based comic.

Donnie 04-05-2011 10:15 AM

Does anybody know if CC was quoting an official source when he stated the non-Nick comic wasn't going above PG?

Venom 04-05-2011 10:23 AM

Taken from the article on ComicBookResources:
Quote:

Dunbier said the tone of IDW's "TMNT" comics would be closer to later interpretations in other media. "I wouldn't say 'all-ages' necessarily, we'll definitely skew a little closer to teenagers," he said. "For lack of a better term, I think we'll be PG+. Not PG-13, but just a little bit more than PG."
It's basically their tone in general for the franchise, not just the toon tie-in.

Donnie 04-05-2011 10:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 835788)
Taken from the article on ComicBookResources:


It's basically their tone in general for the franchise, not just the toon tie-in.

Gotcha. Thanks. Well, I was hoping for at least PG-13, but no biggie. I'm still going to wait to reserve judgment. I'm guessing by later incarnations they mean 2k3, 2k7, and Volume 4.

I just signed aboard IDW's forums to have my voice heard, so you'll be seeing me there soon under the username "Donatello". :D


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:47 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.