The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Diving Into the Comics (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=33684)

Thorneyeagle 04-12-2011 08:51 AM

Diving Into the Comics
 
Hey

So, I am a long time fan of the TMNT series. Well honestly its more a fan of the 80's TV show since I grew up with that. I seem to have missed the comic book craze by a few years since almost no one i knew growing up read any. Thus, it wasn't till recently I went and looked into the source material for the Turtles to discover the vast collection of comics.

I want to get into the comic world of the Turtles only...hard to know how to go about it since there is currently no Trade collection (i hope i have the term right) in print currently for volume 1.

[It also kills me that i recently met someone with most of the first volume in original comic form...arrrg so jealous of him]

Any suggestions from hardcore long term fans in regards to diving into the Turtle world. Especially with the new comic comming out from IDW in the new few months. [I plan to try and follow that series]

Should I start with the first volume and try to find an online copy, if such a thing exists of course...or should I simply hope for a reboot and trade edition to be printed as hinted at by many articles online.

fyi - I did look around for a similar article and without going through the entire achrive I havent' seen much

Venom 04-12-2011 11:07 AM

Well IDW is going to begin release trades of Volume 1 beginning this fall, around late-July or August. If you can't wait until then, Mirage still sells some of the Collected Books rather cheap. The most expensive will be Book One, but it can be had for about 60 bucks or so; the others are under 10 bucks except Book Seven for some reason - it goes for about 20 and up.

First! also released the first 11 issues in color across four books; those aren't too bad on the budget, either.

Those books together mentioned above collected the first 29 issues of Volume 1. The rest of the issues aren't expensive, nor is Volume 2.

CyberCubed 04-12-2011 11:42 AM

There are 4 volumes, that all tell a continuous story, plus two Tales of the TMNT volumes.

plastroncafe 04-12-2011 11:51 AM

You may want to give your local library a once over. Some branches have pretty extensive graphic novel collections.

Thorneyeagle 04-12-2011 12:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 839095)
Well IDW is going to begin release trades of Volume 1 beginning this fall, around late-July or August. If you can't wait until then, Mirage still sells some of the Collected Books rather cheap. The most expensive will be Book One, but it can be had for about 60 bucks or so; the others are under 10 bucks except Book Seven for some reason - it goes for about 20 and up.

First! also released the first 11 issues in color across four books; those aren't too bad on the budget, either.

Those books together mentioned above collected the first 29 issues of Volume 1. The rest of the issues aren't expensive, nor is Volume 2.

I will do some research when I get home from my internship to check prices and such for the first two volumes. I don't remeber seeing them...or it may have been the price of the first that detured me...I sadly dont' have the income to afford a mass purchase.

I may wait for IDW prints, I am hoping they will reprint the whole first two volumes. Though thats wishful dreaming.

took a second to look and okay they are cheaper then I thought...seems though they are only selling volume one and they have volumes 2-5. I will check amazonfor book 1 real quick

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 839113)
There are 4 volumes, that all tell a continuous story, plus two Tales of the TMNT volumes.

From the research I have done, The third volume seems to have been dropped from continuity in the fourth volume. I will probably avoid that. The fourth I am also hesitant right now becuase its unfinished and it would rattle my nerves to not have an ending lol


Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 839116)
You may want to give your local library a once over. Some branches have pretty extensive graphic novel collections.

Being in college has limited my access to public libraries greatly. Last I checked I dont' remeber much of a graphic novel collection at my home town book store. We do have our comic book stores around and I have been striking out on anything TMNT...they always offer to order it for me at best.



~~~So I guess the feeling I am getting is to try and get my hands on at least the first two volumes to read in their entirety.

Powder 04-12-2011 04:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thorneyeagle (Post 839119)
From the research I have done, The third volume seems to have been dropped from continuity in the fourth volume. I will probably avoid that. The fourth I am also hesitant right now becuase its unfinished and it would rattle my nerves to not have an ending lol

I've not seen ONE fan who actually abides by the fact it was de-canonized or whatever you call it. We've been finishing the series ourselves alongside the original artists/writers. The issues will be out in due time. Read the hell out of vol. 3, man. It's my favorite because of the crazy contrast of the bold black & white art, the way the turtles are drawn, the changes they go through, & the fact that the overall storyline moves at the speed of a freight train. Plus (next to Bodycount) I'd say its the most violent.

oldmanwinters 04-12-2011 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 839197)
I've not seen ONE fan who actually abides by the fact it was de-canonized or whatever you call it. We've been finishing the series ourselves alongside the original artists/writers. The issues will be out in due time. Read the hell out of vol. 3, man. It's my favorite because of the crazy contrast of the bold black & white art, the way the turtles are drawn, the changes they go through, & the fact that the overall storyline moves at the speed of a freight train. Plus (next to Bodycount) I'd say its the most violent.

I would say it was decanonized in Peter Laird's vision for Volume 4 & Tales of TMNT Volume 2. Thinking practically, if Peter Laird ever picks up his pen to write another issue of TMNT for the Mirage license, I don't think he will assume the continuity with events of Image Volume 3. All (to my knowledge) the writers who contributed to the Tales V2 line did so without the assumption that Volume 3 should inform their plot in any way. From a historical perspective, we have to realize that Image Volume 3 wasn't canon when the later Mirage universe developed.

That said, canon in comics is a fluid and fickle thing, and I will consider these next two installments to be the canonizing bridge between the Image and later Mirage timelines.

Roseangelo 04-12-2011 05:03 PM

Don't let people throw you off with this canon/non-canon nonsense. Read what you can find, and enjoy all of it for what it is.

The collected collections are a good place to start. If you can find a deal on the first collected book, grab it, but also know that IDW will have a new edition coming out soon. Hopefully they will follow with more collected books.

Sometimes you can find large lots of TMNT comics on eBay for good prices.

Thorneyeagle 04-12-2011 05:13 PM

Hmmm...It is something to consider. It does look like it would have a good story line.

Currently though I want to focus on "Diving into the thick of things" per say. I am currently viewing the TMNT comics from the outside without any real experience or real knowledge of them.

From the looks of it getting my hands on trade copies of the first volume is my best bet. Sadly though volume 1's first book is very expensive from what I have found...the main site doesn't have it for sale. The rest are for 7 dollars which is amazing....[i think that is the whole volume 1 in those five books]

though volume three i will prob consider once i finish one and two...depending on if i wait for IDW to do printings or not.

TristanHuwJones 04-12-2011 05:36 PM

Rose is spot on, Thorney Eagle. I had everything all lined up in issue chronology as I collected and read them, and it was only after I'd been through everything that I worked out what I wanted to keep as my own personal continuity and what I didn't and I just kept the ones I didn't in a separate box. Find what you can, read what you can, take what you want from it all :)

Adam 04-12-2011 05:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 839205)
Don't let people throw you off with this canon/non-canon nonsense. Read what you can find, and enjoy all of it for what it is.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 839220)
Rose is spot on, Thorney Eagle. I had everything all lined up in issue chronology as I collected and read them, and it was only after I'd been through everything that I worked out what I wanted to keep as my own personal continuity and what I didn't and I just kept the ones I didn't in a separate box. Find what you can, read what you can, take what you want from it all :)

Exactly.

Also -- do this for other comics you enjoy, too. You pretty much HAVE to with characters that have been around long enough (and been popular enough) to have amassed thousands of stories anyway.

Wolverine's real name is something other than Logan? Not in my world, fella.

discordiatookie 04-12-2011 06:00 PM

I found it quite daunting when I first started. But a lot of fun. Addictive too. When I was coming to the end of my Mirage collecting, I was feeling a wee bit empty inside. What now? Archie! Only got a coupla issue left to get of that. My sights are now changing to the UK Hero Turtle comics from Fleetway. So my advice to you is: have fun, be patient (there's too much to get all at once, it may take awhile) and enjoy!

Thorneyeagle 04-12-2011 06:07 PM

I love the fact that these characters and stories are so beloved by its fans. Please understand as much as I would love to have all the comics to read from each of the four main volumes to read...Its just not in the income cards as a college student.

I am sadly being forced to make some tough choices and and focus on a good entry point...If my fortune changes I will work towards a more complete submersion into these worlds. Either that or I just crack and let "Addiction" take hold, lol.

I am just sad that the trades from mirage are hard to get a hold of...well the first one that is....No fun starting mid story...I fear continuity/price...I may have to wait for IDW's reprints.

I did buy a 25 year color re-print a while back...couldn't resist.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Adam (Post 839225)
Exactly.

Also -- do this for other comics you enjoy, too. You pretty much HAVE to with characters that have been around long enough (and been popular enough) to have amassed thousands of stories anyway.

Wolverine's real name is something other than Logan? Not in my world, fella.

your comment with the thousands of stories is actually one of the reasons I have been so hesitant to get into comics on a whole most recently...I typically hate starting mid story especially when its not always easy to catch up...the continuity doesn't bother me to much when I have access to it all to read for myself.

Quote:

Originally Posted by discordiatookie (Post 839228)
I found it quite daunting when I first started. But a lot of fun. Addictive too. When I was coming to the end of my Mirage collecting, I was feeling a wee bit empty inside. What now? Archie! Only got a coupla issue left to get of that. My sights are now changing to the UK Hero Turtle comics from Fleetway. So my advice to you is: have fun, be patient (there's too much to get all at once, it may take awhile) and enjoy!

Very true on so many levels....

DrSpengler 04-12-2011 06:27 PM

Though "continuity" is nice for the seasoned diehard, I think the comics industry would be much better off if readers were more concerned with "good" stories over "stories that count".

It'd be like depriving yourself of All-Star Superman just because it's "omg non canon".


I really can't give you much better advice than to wait for IDW's tradepaperback collections.

They're coming this summer, so only a few months from now, and are CERTAIN to be more affordable and better quality than the stuff available on the aftermarket.

Of course, I wouldn't discourage you from buying those $7 trades from Mirage's official site, though understand that you're only gonna get about 3 issues per trade and they may be in rather rough condition.


If you pare down much of the content (mainly guest issues, Tales Vol. 2 issues and short back-up strips), the TMNT series actually reads pretty compactly and coherently. It's once you try to "slot in" a lot of those Tales Vol. 2 stories and back-up shorts that things can approach annoying/confusing territory.

TristanHuwJones 04-12-2011 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 839241)
If you pare down much of the content (mainly guest issues, Tales Vol. 2 issues and short back-up strips), the TMNT series actually reads pretty compactly and coherently. It's once you try to "slot in" a lot of those Tales Vol. 2 stories and back-up shorts that things can approach annoying/confusing territory.

This... :ohwell:

DrSpengler 04-12-2011 06:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 839250)
This... :ohwell:

Well, that's not to say many of those guest stories, Tales Vol. 2 issues and back-up shorts aren't good, mind you. ;)

My ill-typed point was that, when it comes to trying to read the primary narrative of the series, well, showing this to someone new to the comics is more likely to scare them away than anything else.

Thorneyeagle 04-12-2011 07:03 PM

The confusion there..may be that you aren't taking the simple route and just following the issue number. You seem to have them divided separately

Ic..reread that page...including the forward. I like the chronology project you have put together. However, i feel it may take away the fun of an initial experience with the turtles. Good for a thorough study though.

my plan is to try and read the issues in order....hoping the story lines make sense.

my guess is that guest strips may not make a reprint?

DrSpengler 04-12-2011 07:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thorneyeagle (Post 839258)
The confusion there..may be that you aren't taking the simple route and just following the issue number. You seem to have them divided separately

Ic..reread that page...including the forward. I like the chronology project you have put together. However, i feel it may take away the fun of an initial experience with the turtles. Good for a thorough study though.

my plan is to try and read the issues in order....hoping the story lines make sense.

That is, of course, the recommended route. To read everything in numerical order and then figure out for yourself where crap goes or whether you even want to include it.

That's how I did it, anyway.

Quote:

my guess is that guest strips may not make a reprint?
Probably not, but you never know. IDW tends to reprint things pretty barebones and only including numerical ordered issue numbers, ignoring "slotting in" things where they make sense. Though that doesn't rule out a potential trade collecting all the back-up shorts together.

Venom 04-12-2011 07:32 PM

Shoot Spengs, you've did the chronology work for them - they have no reason not to do them in story order (they should give you credit for the timeline, though.).

Also, check my checklist thread. I stumbled across an unpublished Archie story by Milton Knight - "Coney Island Days".

DrSpengler 04-12-2011 07:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 839287)
Shoot Spengs, you've did the chronology work for them - they have no reason not to do them in story order (they should give you credit for the timeline, though.).

Nahhhh, they don't gotta do dat. Though IDW doesn't have the best track record for putting "extra" care into their trade collections (their Transformers Classics trades being a good example, though I hear their Jurassic Park Classics trades aren't any better), I'd like to think they've improved. I guess we'll find out when their first TMNT volume comes out, if it has the Microseries or not.

Quote:

Also, check my checklist thread. I stumbled across an unpublished Archie story by Milton Knight - "Coney Island Days".
Oh yeah, I've known about that one! Have it linked in my review for TMNT Adventures #27. :)

TristanHuwJones 04-12-2011 07:46 PM

I've mentioned this before I think, but their Transformers hardcovers are in (story) chronological order. I believe that's what we're getting in July isn't it? A hardcover collection starting with 1-11?

Venom 04-12-2011 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 839299)
I've mentioned this before I think, but their Transformers hardcovers are in (story) chronological order. I believe that's what we're getting in July isn't it? A hardcover collection starting with 1-11?

Yeah, based on what we know thus far. The big question is if IDW realizes 1-11 includes 4 microseries and a Fugitoid book to be complete?

DrSpengler 04-12-2011 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TristanHuwJones (Post 839299)
I've mentioned this before I think, but their Transformers hardcovers are in (story) chronological order. I believe that's what we're getting in July isn't it? A hardcover collection starting with 1-11?

Their Transformers Classics weren't (in the sense that they didn't include the minis in their proper chronological place, to say nothing of the UK stories, and of course they also skipped main issues that they'd have to pay Marvel licenses for).

They'll be redoing them soon, though.

Their in-house Transformers collections wee first released in volume collections, then in kinda-sorta chronological collections and are now being released AGAIN in 100% accurate chronological collections including all the stuff they skipped in previous efforts.

IDW has a habit of calling "do over" on a lot of their trades, and especially with Transformers fans, triple or quadruple dipping in order to get the best quality product isn't unheard of.

Though, it IS nice to know that they make the effort to "try again" and get things right, though in many cases, a marginal amount of editing and research would have gotten things correct the first time.


They're track record in these matters isn't the best, but IDW's *current* atmosphere of "getting collections right" is vastly different from 2 or 3 years ago when they were making all those myriad of mistakes.

So I'm hopeful that their first attempt at TMNT collections includes all the necessary material for story coherency (in this case, I'm mainly just calling for the Microseries).

Still, if they don't get it right the first time, we can at least rest assured that there'll be a double dip at some point in the future...

Thorneyeagle 04-12-2011 08:56 PM

It would be sad if the "micro series" or "guest comics" are not put into trade book. I don't know much about the comic world...but I would presume this is not normal? or is it just harder to do with extra licenses and such needing to be handled?

Whatever the case I hope the IDW release is good..I decided to wait for it and pick up that version...will be cheaper than the Mirage one that seems to be hard to get a hold of.

Be nice if they did a Volume 1 release. Like a novel size book release of all the comics at once, but I have a feeling that is a lot of material to cover in one printing.

cartoonistaaron 04-12-2011 09:29 PM

Hey Thorn, I was a broke college kid not too long ago. I was surprised at what I could find cheap on eBay and in local comic shops. Last week, in fact, I picked up a first print of Raphael #1 for five or six bucks.

That same shop has copies of the First series of "colorized" collected books for pretty cheap, and I know other local shops have copies of that stuff, too. And I'm not exactly in a major metropolitan area.

If I were you (and I know this might not be real popular among the "TMNT Faithful" but I'll say it anyway) I'd stick with Volume 1 to get started. I found the Image series nigh-unreadable due to the terrible artwork. I didn't like the Mirage color stuff and I think I got thru maybe two issues of the last Mirage volume - it was just kinda boring. (I'm saying this as a fan of comics like Hate, Flaming Carrot, Ralph Snart, The Tick, that type o' stuff. If you're into superhero stuff, you might look at it differently.)

There's a long period during the original Mirage Studios series where the stories are wildly out of continuity - I remember them being released irregularly with constant guest artists, which (I thought) was awesome. Once they settled back into continuity during City At War, the book lost something, it just didn't have that "spark," and I stuck with it out of habit more than anything.

Have fun hunting this stuff down!

discordiatookie 04-14-2011 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cartoonistaaron (Post 839376)
Once they settled back into continuity during City At War, the book lost something, it just didn't have that "spark," and I stuck with it out of habit more than anything.

Whereas I feel that the spark is still ever present, mayhap shining a bit more bright when we are getting a multi issue story arc by the core Mirage team, as opposed to outsider issues. Not to say that I don't like them, hell I even dig the Hedden/McWeeney issues (but only once in a while :P).

But thats the thing with having so many different people working on the TMNT: there's something for everyone.

azrael 04-14-2011 07:01 PM

Look IMHO you can get 1-11 plus the micros skip to Return to new york then pick up shades of grey and city at war.

Thats enough of volume 1 to start 2 and mirage still has all of vol 2 stuff

Thorneyeagle 04-14-2011 08:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by azrael (Post 840191)
Look IMHO you can get 1-11 plus the micros skip to Return to new york then pick up shades of grey and city at war.

Thats enough of volume 1 to start 2 and mirage still has all of vol 2 stuff

Looking to try to read most if not all of volume 1...good or bad. I just happen to have started with volume 2 as of yesterday. Gonna wait for the trades for 1 and probably sometime between now and may get the micro series.

azrael 04-14-2011 08:19 PM

Lol they are gonna sell those like hot cakes about 5 of my friends are going to start collecting them. If you want an awesome read check out Vol 3 by image. I made the mistake of believing (no research on the subject) that it was all one storyline. I was wrong vol 1 reads as if tales and an actual storyline was being combined as one.

Vol 2-4 are wrote all the same as in being consecutively. I like small arcs making a bigger story so I really enjoyed parts of Vol1 and all of 2-4

discordiatookie 04-15-2011 08:25 AM

Look IMHO if you were to miss out reading all of volume one, only reading the 'core' issues, then you are going to miss out on so so much.

Vol 2, whilst good, is a bit of a strange starting point, in that it is pretty much taking place just after City At War, so you're not going to be getting the whole story. If I recall, I think I picked up vol 2 before CAW as well, and was like 'I have no clue what has been happening!'.

I started off by discovering the First colour collections of issues 1-11, in a second hand book store. I then picked up the Richard Corben colour issue (33? I can't remember right now!) and some of vol 4 (which was all my local comic shop had in at the time) so I was pretty lost. Then I hit the net, and some (well quite a bit) of ebay auctions, and took it from there. Like I said before, daunting, but a lot of fun!

FearlessLeader 04-15-2011 09:06 AM

Thorneyeagle just curious have you seen the 2K3 TV series done by 4Kids??

When I started collecting and reading the comics I got them as I hunted and found them in comic shops or at conventions (the first ones I actually bought and read were the 3 in the River trilogy so at times yes I was confused :tlol:)

It did help that while certainly not perfect (especially during the City at War arch) reading them while watching the 4Kids cartoon I at least had a semblance of idea of what was going on thanks to the TV show.

Thorneyeagle 04-15-2011 12:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by discordiatookie (Post 840383)
Look IMHO if you were to miss out reading all of volume one, only reading the 'core' issues, then you are going to miss out on so so much.

Vol 2, whilst good, is a bit of a strange starting point, in that it is pretty much taking place just after City At War, so you're not going to be getting the whole story. If I recall, I think I picked up vol 2 before CAW as well, and was like 'I have no clue what has been happening!'.

I started off by discovering the First colour collections of issues 1-11, in a second hand book store. I then picked up the Richard Corben colour issue (33? I can't remember right now!) and some of vol 4 (which was all my local comic shop had in at the time) so I was pretty lost. Then I hit the net, and some (well quite a bit) of ebay auctions, and took it from there. Like I said before, daunting, but a lot of fun!

Fortunatly I have a synopsis idea as to what kind of happens in the first volume [okay not really]...so I like to act like I know whats going on in the second volume. Depending on the results of my Mirage purchase, I might buy the rest. Though today is payday and I am tempted to hit one more comic book store.


Quote:

Originally Posted by FearlessLeader (Post 840393)
Thorneyeagle just curious have you seen the 2K3 TV series done by 4Kids??

When I started collecting and reading the comics I got them as I hunted and found them in comic shops or at conventions (the first ones I actually bought and read were the 3 in the River trilogy so at times yes I was confused :tlol:)

It did help that while certainly not perfect (especially during the City at War arch) reading them while watching the 4Kids cartoon I at least had a semblance of idea of what was going on thanks to the TV show.

I haven't seen much of the 2k3 series. I know its out there and I am tempted to buy it off Amazon to watch it. I hope this works. Granted I only own the first season of the 1980's version...so I have to make my mind up. I know I wont buy more of the 80's becuase It was great but the first five are the ones forever in my memory as the greatest thing ever made.

I am still suprised the 4kids version has been decent...I guess its becuase its not a japenese dub.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.