The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Savage Dragon & the Image Universe (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=33881)

sdp 04-29-2011 11:30 AM

Savage Dragon & the Image Universe
 
So, since a large part of the fandom considers Vol.3 in continuity that raises a few problems. If you do that TMNT is now a part of the Image Universe and that creates a ton of problems, I mean the TMNT really do share a Universe with the likes of Spawn/WILDCATS/GEN13/Witchblade? The turtles are no strangers to sci-fi or fantasy but the Image universe takes it up a notch, not to mention since Image characters are creator owned thats made a mess of the Universe.

Even if you choose to no think of Vol.3 as canon the TMNT still teamed up with Savage Dragon before and he is part of the Image Univese so technically they would still be a part of the Image U. Now if you go the great lengths of ignoring that the turtles are part of the Image Universe there is still the problem of Dragon, I mean why exactly are they in hiding when there are Super Freaks running around the world that are just as if not much weirder looking than the turtles and while there is some prejudice against them, for the most part they are accepted after all Dragon is a police officer and not all freaks are evil or feared. I should probably note that my familiarity with the Image Universe is limited but I am somewhat familiar with a lot of their characters.

Cowabunga Carl 04-29-2011 11:42 AM

I had honestly never thought of it like that. You bring up some very valid points I think. I will have to think about this for a while and i'll get back to you.

ToTheNines 04-29-2011 11:45 AM

For me, I just look at the Savage Dragon stories as "loose canon".

They happened, but there's no baggage brought by either universe.

Andrew NDB 04-29-2011 12:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 844481)
For me, I just look at the Savage Dragon stories as "loose canon".

They happened, but there's no baggage brought by either universe.

Pretty much. It's like your average DC/Marvel crossover... when Spider-Man shows up in Batman, it doesn't mean there's been some kind of multiversal merger -- it just means you're reading a crossover.

azrael 04-29-2011 12:36 PM

i was thinking the same... why are they still underground, so i came up with they do that cuz they are ninja.

Adam 04-29-2011 01:02 PM

It's canon but it ain't all gonna fit together perfectly.


Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 844466)
So, since a large part of the fandom considers Vol.3 in continuity that raises a few problems. If you do that TMNT is now a part of the Image Universe and that creates a ton of problems, I mean the TMNT really do share a Universe with the likes of Spawn/WILDCATS/GEN13/Witchblade? The turtles are no strangers to sci-fi or fantasy but the Image universe takes it up a notch, not to mention since Image characters are creator owned thats made a mess of the Universe.

This is a problem when trying to reconcile continuities of independent books. Since there is no editorial mandate that the books stick to certain aspects of continuity (as there would be with a Marvel or DC title), creator-owned comics are bound to go off in wildly different directions. That's the nature of the beast.

So, here's the answer Erik Larsen has previously given to your question: Think of each title at Image (or each family of titles) as existing in its own, separate universe. Then, you can think of crossovers as events that occur within multiple universes simultaneously.

So, when Larsen blows up the Earth (as he has done in the pages of Savage Dragon) -- that's not something that has to impact Spawn or Jack Staff or Bomb Queen. Those are different books with different story paths, and they're free to go wherever they want.

ShadowHawk, Bomb Queen, and Blacklight exist in their own universe. The Darkness and Witchblade and Cyber-Force and Hunter-Killer exist in their own universe. Dynamo 5 and Noble Causes exist in their own universe. Invincible, Brit, Capes, Guardians of the Globe, and Astounding Wolf-Man exist in their own universe. The TMNT were definitely part of the Savage Dragon family of books (along with Freak Force and Vanguard and SuperPatriot and Star and others), so they existed in that universe. And ALL of the above mentioned titles could be said to exist in a shared multi-verse (where occasional crossovers take place).

So -- yeah -- that's kind of a long-winded way of saying what the posters said above: don't sweat it.


Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 844466)
I mean why exactly are they in hiding when there are Super Freaks running around the world that are just as if not much weirder looking than the turtles and while there is some prejudice against them, for the most part they are accepted after all Dragon is a police officer and not all freaks are evil or feared.

The TMNT looked less out-of-place in Chicago than they did elsewhere. This is because Savage Dragon had established Chicago as being especially rife with mutants and super-freaks. In the context of that universe, it makes sense that the Turtles would still have to try to stay out of the limelight in their hometown.

sdp 04-29-2011 09:03 PM

I find the "oh its just a crossover" just a cheap cop-out, why have it if its not real in that case its a elseworlds issue and not canon like say Batman/Spawn crossover. I mean the DC/Marvel crossovers DID have an explanation and its still canon since the events have been given a small reference in DC books.

Adam 04-29-2011 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 844593)
I find the "oh its just a crossover" just a cheap cop-out, why have it if its not real in that case its a elseworlds issue and not canon like say Batman/Spawn crossover. I mean the DC/Marvel crossovers DID have an explanation and its still canon since the events have been given a small reference in DC books.

Just to reiterate, the idea of the multiverse theory of Image books is to make EVERYTHING canon while simultaneously letting each comic do its own thing.

Batman/Spawn may not be canon within the mainstream DCU, but it is canon with the Spawn series and with Frank Miller's other Batman work.

CyberCubed 04-29-2011 11:04 PM

Uh, we just see it as the Turtles crossing over with Savage dragon. His entire universe doesn't come with it, only what is shown in the comic.

The Turtle universe isn't the same as the Image universe, just the few particular characters.

Powder 04-30-2011 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 844619)
Uh, we just see it as the Turtles crossing over with Savage dragon. His entire universe doesn't come with it, only what is shown in the comic.

Well we sure got a lot of the image universe man... Horridus, Night Watchman, etc. from Vol. 3 & all that... Many got thrown in there.

Plus you have to count everyone that appeared in the mirage SD crossovers as well as the SD direct ones.
That kinda suggests everyone that SD has ever met exists in the same place as the turtles. Mars attack aliens included.

CyberCubed 04-30-2011 10:51 AM

Yeah, but we don't have to consider, "all of it."

For example, I don't consider any of the Image universe canon with the Mirage/TMNT Image universe. Meaning all those adventures Savage Dragon and other characters went on, "never happened," in terms of the TMNT universe, just what we saw.

As someone said, the entire baggage of other continuity doesn't come along with it.

Jester 04-30-2011 10:55 AM

When in doubt, go read Spengler's list...:P

oldmanwinters 04-30-2011 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 844694)
go read Spengler's List...:P

You made that sound like an epic piece of high literature. I wonder if they are going to adapt it into a movie?:P

Jester 04-30-2011 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 844698)
You made that sound like an epic piece of high literature. I wonder if they are going to adapt it into a movie?:P

Directed by Spielberg and everything....:D

Adam 04-30-2011 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 844687)
Yeah, but we don't have to consider, "all of it."

For example, I don't consider any of the Image universe canon with the Mirage/TMNT Image universe. Meaning all those adventures Savage Dragon and other characters went on, "never happened," in terms of the TMNT universe, just what we saw.

As someone said, the entire baggage of other continuity doesn't come along with it.

No, you certainly don't have to consider all of it -- you don't even have to consider any of it. You can take aboard whatever you want.

But... the entire Vol. 3 series is STEEPED in the Savage Dragon corner of the Image Universe. It's not just the many, many supporting characters who appear -- Mako, Horridus, the Knight Watchman/Galahad, Vanguard, Wally, Roxanne, Johnny Raeburn, Lurch, Dragon, Rock -- it's the settings as well (when they're in Chicago, the bar that Raph goes to is from SD; all the freaks he meets are regulars from SD. Hell, he even jokes with someone about the infamous "Chicago Bull" character from SD; and so on). As noted above, the turtles appeared in the Mars Attacks crossover, as well as other spots -- such as (though in the background) the big wedding in SD #41.

The point is -- the Turtles were entrenched in this stuff. Nobody's saying you need to read all Savage Dragon comics to enjoy those TMNT issues -- but everything that went on in Vol. 3 is canon within the SD corner of the Image universe.

So if Vol. 3 is also canon with "the Mirage universe" (and I know there's some disagreement about that on these boards) -- then it can very easily be argued that it's ALL canon.

Master Splinter 05-13-2011 09:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 844466)
So, since a large part of the fandom considers Vol.3 in continuity that raises a few problems. If you do that TMNT is now a part of the Image Universe and that creates a ton of problems, I mean the TMNT really do share a Universe with the likes of Spawn/WILDCATS/GEN13/Witchblade? The turtles are no strangers to sci-fi or fantasy but the Image universe takes it up a notch, not to mention since Image characters are creator owned thats made a mess of the Universe.

Even if you choose to no think of Vol.3 as canon the TMNT still teamed up with Savage Dragon before and he is part of the Image Univese so technically they would still be a part of the Image U. Now if you go the great lengths of ignoring that the turtles are part of the Image Universe there is still the problem of Dragon, I mean why exactly are they in hiding when there are Super Freaks running around the world that are just as if not much weirder looking than the turtles and while there is some prejudice against them, for the most part they are accepted after all Dragon is a police officer and not all freaks are evil or feared. I should probably note that my familiarity with the Image Universe is limited but I am somewhat familiar with a lot of their characters.

If TMNT are part of the Image Universe as a whole then don't forget that basically everyone is also dead no thanks to The Walking Dead... Zombies everywhere!!!

http://fc04.deviantart.net/fs70/f/20...rw-d34iy12.jpg

John Pannozzi 05-13-2011 10:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Master Splinter (Post 847774)
If TMNT are part of the Image Universe as a whole then don't forget that basically everyone is also dead no thanks to The Walking Dead... Zombies everywhere!!!

http://fc04.deviantart.net/fs70/f/20...rw-d34iy12.jpg

Funny, but I don't think the Walking Dead is part of the shared Image Comics multiverse, I think only the characters and series listed here are (plus a few others like all the Wildstorm characters like WildC.A.T.S., Wetworks and Gen13, and the Turtles themselves, obviously).

Adam 05-13-2011 11:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Pannozzi (Post 847792)
Funny, but I don't think the Walking Dead is part of the shared Image Comics multiverse

I'm assuming MS was joking, but in any case, you're right -- Walking Dead is considered separate. Even in that issue of Invincible -- Kirkman's other main book -- where Invincible was transported to multiple alternate universes and in one reality he was confronted with zombies -- it was clear that these were not the zombies from Walking Dead.


Quote:

Originally Posted by John Pannozzi (Post 847792)
I think only the characters and series listed here are

I wouldn't depend on that list -- it's by no means an official resource and it's missing a lot of stuff.


Quote:

Originally Posted by John Pannozzi (Post 847792)
(plus a few others like all the Wildstorm characters like WildC.A.T.S., Wetworks and Gen13, and the Turtles themselves, obviously).

WildStorm's something of odd case, due to their move to DC in 1999. But one could reasonably argue that they could still exist in a larger "shared multiverse". The whole multiple-realities kind of idea definitely helps iron out a lot of those inter-company crossovers, for one thing...

Master Splinter 05-13-2011 01:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Adam (Post 847810)
I'm assuming MS was joking

Very much so... :)

sdp 05-30-2011 08:59 PM

I understand but I still feel those are cheap ways to not think about it, surely someone here has to have the same mindset as me that if they crossover they share one universe. Especially since these are comics and most comic people share this mindset.

wilddiverse 05-30-2011 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852694)
I understand but I still feel those are cheap ways to not think about it, surely someone here has to have the same mindset as me that if they crossover they share one universe. Especially since these are comics and most comic people share this mindset.

It's not a cheap way to not think about it-- the official publisher stance is to not think too hard about how it fits together, but to make an entertaining comic. It's Image comics, not Research comics.

If you're proposing that you're right because comics readers share your hive mind, that is a factious argument, to say the least.

Raph's Girl 05-30-2011 09:28 PM

Lots of folks have crossed over into the Savage Dragon books. There was even a wedding issue that had the TMNT, X-Men, Batman & Robin, Hulk, ect. *lol*

sdp 05-30-2011 09:37 PM

You don't see people being ok with Lucas proclaiming Star Wars are kids movies and you shouldn't think about it and there are many other franchises like that where fans try to explain continuity errors writers neglect/don't care about, heck the Image fan issues were made to fit Vol.3 with the rest of Mirage while Laird's stance was that he was ignoring it.

Obviously Image has that stance since they don't own the characters or what the creators do with them so they can't keep tabs on everything that goes on in the shared universe like DC/Marvel does and this is their way of getting out of inconsistencies across books and not have to deal with it. I'm not saying you guys are wrong, I'm saying I'm not wrong to think this way and that my opinion is just as valid.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Raph's Girl (Post 852703)
Lots of folks have crossed over into the Savage Dragon books. There was even a wedding issue that had the TMNT, X-Men, Batman & Robin, Hulk, ect. *lol*


Well there's a difference between gag cameos/easter eggs and actual crossovers.

wilddiverse 05-30-2011 10:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852708)
You don't see people being ok with Lucas proclaiming Star Wars are kids movies and you shouldn't think about it

I am personally okay with that approach to Star Wars.

Quote:

Obviously Image has that stance since they don't own the characters or what the creators do with them so they can't keep tabs on everything that goes on in the shared universe like DC/Marvel does and this is their way of getting out of inconsistencies across books and not have to deal with it.
Yes. Obviously.

Quote:

I'm not saying you guys are wrong, I'm saying I'm not wrong to think this way and that my opinion is just as valid.
No one's contesting that, you're entitled to your opinion and please share it, but it seems like your post was more of a call for people to agree with your previously stated opinion than an argument on behalf of your opinion.

And your original post is unclear: do you think every issue published by Image Comics should be considered extensions of the Mirage continuity?

And are you proposing fans create a comic that corrects all the inconsistent and contradictory continuities of the Image Universe? :D

In all seriousness, I understand that you just want it all to fit together cleanly so everything counts, but the nature of Image Comics is such that there's just going to be pieces left over.

Adam 05-30-2011 10:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852708)
heck the Image fan issues were made to fit Vol.3 with the rest of Mirage while Laird's stance was that he was ignoring it.

This is tangential to the discussion, but I'd just like to remind everyone that Peter was fine with Vol. 3 while it was running. Not only that -- he and Kevin made many suggestions to the Image guys, some of which were used, some of which were not. This wasn't a case of a series being disowned by the creator -- even by the time it ended. It wasn't until years later that Peter said he wasn't taking those books into account anymore.

And I was always under the impression that Peter really just didn't want to be restricted by somebody else's interpretation of the characters; he wanted to be free to do his own thing, and not feel duty-bound to answer all of the unanswered questions and plot threads left dangling at the end of Vol 3.


Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852708)
Obviously Image has that stance since they don't own the characters or what the creators do with them so they can't keep tabs on everything that goes on in the shared universe like DC/Marvel does and this is their way of getting out of inconsistencies across books and not have to deal with it.

"Image" has no official stance regarding the TMNT. The whole Image-multiverse thing is Larsen's idea, and its purpose, as I stated, is to reconcile books. It's not "a way of getting out of inconsistencies" at all -- it's acknowledging that inconsistencies exist and coming up with a plausible explanation for them.

There is no way to get rid of the inconsistencies. This is especially true of independent books -- but even at Marvel and DC, where editorial can ensure consistency across a family of titles, things fall through the cracks. If you look at ANY character on a long enough timeline, you are going to see a LOT of inconsistencies.


Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852708)
I'm not saying you guys are wrong, I'm saying I'm not wrong to think this way and that my opinion is just as valid.

What opinion is that? I'm still not sure what you're trying to say.

ToTheNines 05-30-2011 10:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852694)
I understand but I still feel those are cheap ways to not think about it, surely someone here has to have the same mindset as me that if they crossover they share one universe. Especially since these are comics and most comic people share this mindset.

Trust me, it would be nice if it all worked out perfectly. But it doesn't. There's simply no way to tie it all in together. After volume 3, the Mirage Group wrote Volume 4 and Tales with total disregard for the Image Universe, and everyone at Image wrote their books with total disregard of the Mirage Universe. It was bound to happen.

sdp 05-30-2011 11:04 PM

Nah, I just didn't think every response to be "oh its irrelevant" when it technically is, its fine if you ignore it but I didn't expect to be the only person, especially since geeky discussions like these are normal in online forums/fandoms to overanalyze.

Heh, not proposing for a fan comic or even posts with explanations that corrects every inconsistencies/contradictions but I did want more discussion about it technically being a part of it. And like I mentioned in the OP, even if you ignore it I don't think it makes sense that there can be "super freaks" and a Cop Savage Dragon even if you ignore the rest of the comic. I have the same problem with Mutants and the rest of the Marvel Universe, I have yet to hear an explanation that seems logical to me.

As me? Yes I do think that the Mirage turtles are technically a small part of the larger Image universe, I'm not going to stress about it but I do acknowledge that. I also acknowledge that The Next Mutation universe is part of the much larger Power Rangers Universe because of the crossover.

wilddiverse 05-30-2011 11:15 PM

"Would you mind repeating that again, in English perhaps?"

Adam 05-30-2011 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852741)
And like I mentioned in the OP, even if you ignore it I don't think it makes sense that there can be "super freaks" and a Cop Savage Dragon even if you ignore the rest of the comic.

If you're referring to the "Why do the TMNT still have to hide themselves in a universe with as many weirdos as Image Comics?" question -- that's been answered already.

As for a super-freak being a cop -- Dragon is unique even in the freak-infested Image Chicago (there aren't any other super-freak cops; this is an issue that's dealt with at some length in the pages of SD).



Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 852741)
Yes I do think that the Mirage turtles are technically a small part of the larger Image universe, I'm not going to stress about it but I do acknowledge that. I also acknowledge that The Next Mutation universe is part of the much larger Power Rangers Universe because of the crossover.

I'm fine with thinking of the Mirage universe as "part of the Image universe", but it just doesn't seem all that necessary to do so. Can't they just be related -- or connected? Like a Venn diagram that overlaps in Larsen's corner of the Image U.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:18 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.