The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Writing Wise, Eastman or Laird? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=33888)

Slap-Happy 04-30-2011 09:35 AM

Writing Wise, Eastman or Laird?
 
I've wondered this a few times, but who do you guys like more as a writer? Eastman, or Laird?

I personally like Eastman's stories better. They're all ,for the most part, grounded in reality, and are usually more dark than Lairds, which have many sci-fi elements that just aren't for me.

What be your guys' take on this?

Jester 04-30-2011 09:53 AM

When I read the topic title I thought it was asking if you'd ever written (David) Wise, Eastman, or Laird. :P Man I need to learn to read...

As for who I like better writing wise, I haven't read enough Mirage Turtle stuff to really make a guess, but I'm more sci-fi than gritty action when it comes to movies...so probably Peter.

CyberCubed 04-30-2011 10:01 AM

Aside from the early issues. most of Eastman's stuff comes off as short stories that just focus on action and don't really go anywhere.

Yeah, seeing the Turtles in an urban setting is great, but essentially you feel like you're just reading some back-up strip, which is what most of them were.

DrSpengler 04-30-2011 10:44 AM

I... really don't care for either of them when they're on their own. Eastman's "Heavy Metal" style works fine for the short back ups like "Fun With Guns", but it quickly becomes overbearing and juvenile when he tries to stretch it out over multiple issues, like "Bodycount".

I've read a lot of Eastman's non-TMNT work, particularly his 3 or 4 do-overs of "Melting Pot", and I really don't care much for his style of writing. It's very much the childish, "it isn't mature unless it has blood, boobs and swearing!" type of stuff that I've quite frankly outgrown.


As for Laird, well, he's an entirely different end of the spectrum. I do believe he brings a more sophisticated, character-driven sensibility to his writing, but his presentation is tremendously unpalatable. The fundamental plot concepts (drawing upon Volume 4, here) may be very exciting and interesting, but his complete and utter inability to pen dialogue that doesn't nauseate and his uber-"slow burn" approach to pacing kills build-up and enthusiasm for the ongoing plots.


Eastman and Laird were kind of like Yin and Yang. Together, balancing each other's strengths out, they're great. Apart? Not so much.

Powder 04-30-2011 10:47 AM

As usual, I couldn't agree more with Dr. Spengler.

Though if forced to pick I'd likely go with Kevin as I prefer street brawls to intergalactic brawls.

Jester 04-30-2011 10:49 AM

My thoughts in reverse. E&L complement each other, but if I had to choose, Pete.

oldmanwinters 04-30-2011 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 844681)
I... really don't care for either of them when they're on their own. Eastman's "Heavy Metal" style works fine for the short back ups like "Fun With Guns", but it quickly becomes overbearing and juvenile when he tries to stretch it out over multiple issues, like "Bodycount".

I've read a lot of Eastman's non-TMNT work, particularly his 3 or 4 do-overs of "Melting Pot", and I really don't care much for his style of writing. It's very much the childish, "it isn't mature unless it has blood, boobs and swearing!" type of stuff that I've quite frankly outgrown.


As for Laird, well, he's an entirely different end of the spectrum. I do believe he brings a more sophisticated, character-driven sensibility to his writing, but his presentation is tremendously unpalatable. The fundamental plot concepts (drawing upon Volume 4, here) may be very exciting and interesting, but his complete and utter inability to pen dialogue that doesn't nauseate and his uber-"slow burn" approach to pacing kills build-up and enthusiasm for the ongoing plots.


Eastman and Laird were kind of like Yin and Yang. Together, balancing each other's strengths out, they're great. Apart? Not so much.

^^^This.^^^

I'd love to see David Wise apply his talents to a comic book sometime. I certainly think he's the best writer of the three. Just look at what he created with five 21-minute TV episode scripts. Plus, he can do both action and humor without making it all feel dragged out and over-convoluted.

Jester 04-30-2011 11:07 AM

You're becoming a real Wise fan-boy. Not that there's anything wrong with that. :D

oldmanwinters 04-30-2011 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 844701)
You're becoming a real Wise fan-boy. Not that there's anything wrong with that. :D

Oh, Jack Mendelsohn, Michael Reeves, Francis Moss, Paul Dini, Greg Weisman, Greg Daniels, etc. they're all good. I'm a fan of writers who excel given the challenge of 21-minutes or less to create a self-contained story.

Donnie 04-30-2011 11:10 AM

Peter.

I like the sci-fi elements, and although I agree his writing style is slow, his ability to go further in depth than Eastman on character development is a deciding factor for me. I've been unhappy with Peter's personal treatment of the Turtles in the distant past, but I am way more understanding of it these days, and since we're just talking about writing style anyways...yeah, Peter.

Powder 04-30-2011 11:16 AM

You just like Pete 'cause his favorite turtle is Donny! ;)

4000th post!

oldmanwinters 04-30-2011 11:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 844704)
You just like Pete 'cause his favorite turtle is Donny! ;)

4000th post!

Congratulations, your Pokeman has evolved.

Jester 04-30-2011 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 844707)
Congratulations, your Pokeman has evolved.

Powder has evolved into....um....Powder with 4k posts....


I got nothin'. :D

Donnie 04-30-2011 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 844704)
You just like Pete 'cause his favorite turtle is Donny! ;)

4000th post!

You are correct! :)

Congrats on 4,000!

FearlessLeader 04-30-2011 11:39 AM

I prefer Jim Lawson!

Seriously the stuff he writes is a lot of my favorite Turtles tales :tgrin:

Though seriously I can't choose between Eastman and Laird because it really depends on what I feel more like reading at the time. I do like gritty, street drama, but I also am a huge sci-fi fan and especially enjoy all the little Trek jokes Laird tends to sneak in.

So together they are best, but a part I slightly tend to favor Laird personally.

I also really love the any work by Dooney and Tristan! Turtles really had some seriously talented writers working on it!

oldmanwinters 04-30-2011 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 844701)
You're becoming a real Wise fan-boy. Not that there's anything wrong with that. :D

I just realized I had read the title of this thread wrong; I thought it was a question of whether one preferred the writing of David Wise, Kevin Eastman, or Peter Laird (probably the three men who were most responsible for the creation of the TMNT mythos). Hence, my reasoning for the reiteration of my love for the writers on the old cartoon.

ToTheNines 04-30-2011 11:50 AM

Laird wrote the justice force issue. He fails.

oldmanwinters 04-30-2011 12:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 844722)
Laird wrote the justice force issue. He fails.

I actually like the original Justice Force issue; it's a fun homage to the Silver Age of comics from cover to cover. Now beyond that... eh, I just wanted to get rid of the Justice Force, especially when they started showing up everywhere in Volume 4. I thought the problem was making them into somewhat serious characters. They all just worked much better as a straight-up parodies.

discordiatookie 04-30-2011 01:32 PM

I dig their earlier issues equally. However, as time progressed, I much prefer Laird rather than Eastman's writing. Pretty much for the same reasons as Spengs said.

And I also thought, coming in here, that it was a David Wise, Eastman, Laird thread :lol:

Abnormal Freak 04-30-2011 02:46 PM

Eastmaneastmaneastmaneastman. His more adult stories (which he clearly prefers to write over non-adult) can be rather juvenile, as pointed out, but he's not trying to do anything else; his stories are unabashedly filled with guts and boobs and swearing and all that good stuff teenage boys enjoy, and it's fantastic! I far prefer his writing, including his solo TMNT stories (well, and the ones he wrote with others beside Laird) to Laird's solo writing. Just a hell of a lot more fun, and doesn't have sci-fi geekery.

That and Eastman just has a fantastic way of telling a comic story in a cinematic fashion. Obviously his layouts are mostly what do this, but I think that could still be considered part of the writing process. (It's kind of like the camera in Dario Argento movies telling more of a story than Argento's usually paper-thin scripts. http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/smi...on_biggrin.gif)

Bodycount, Fistful of Blood, Roninbebop... Those are some of the best books in my comics collection. :p

adz 04-30-2011 04:35 PM

I hafta go with Eastman on this one. I prefer his gritty comedic style, that and he was able to tell good stories about the turtles without sending them off to space. Don't get me wrong I also like Peters style but Kev's seemed to resenate with me more.

ToTheNines 04-30-2011 05:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 844724)
I actually like the original Justice Force issue; it's a fun homage to the Silver Age of comics from cover to cover. Now beyond that... eh, I just wanted to get rid of the Justice Force, especially when they started showing up everywhere in Volume 4. I thought the problem was making them into somewhat serious characters. They all just worked much better as a straight-up parodies.

Yeah, it was alright. But much like The Shredder wanting to destroy Turtle-Prime, I would love to murder the justice force in that issue to prevent them from existing in the 4kids show or Volume 4 (they were SO unnecessary in both).

Powder 04-30-2011 07:18 PM

I feel you, I'm very anti-superhero. That's why I like the TMNT, they're vastly different from that.

Let 'em burn, damn justice force.

Spitfire 04-30-2011 07:29 PM

To be honest I'm a fan of neither either separate or together. Both strike me as the kind of guys who know how to come up with awesome cool looking characters but then have no idea what to do with them. I won't say their story ideas are bad it's just the presentation is lacking. After reading other comics written by better writers I've noticed this about their material. I also felt other guys wrote TMNT better then they ever did.

I also never got the dialogue. They would tone down harsh language but have hyper violence in their books. In one issue, I believe #3, one of them yells "Holy hippo spit." Not only is that line retarded but to what end? So they don't say ****? We can show a guy get beaten to a bloody pulp and blow himself into chunks with a grenade but we can't say a swear word? Comes off as oddly juvenile.

The first issue worked so well because it was a parody but after the series moved away from that and tried to be serious I had more and more issues with how the dialogue was written.

Also I think Bodycount is one of the worst TMNT comic stories. Yeah it's cool to see Raph blast guys heads open with an Uzi but in terms of actual writing it's really really bad. It had no purpose. Not only does it hold no place in the continuity but it was just an excuse to have several over the top action set pieces using Eastman's favorite TMNT characters. It probably would have worked better animated to be honest.

ToTheNines 04-30-2011 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 844783)
I feel you, I'm very anti-superhero. That's why I like the TMNT, they're vastly different from that.

Let 'em burn, damn justice force.

Well I love superheroes and still hate the JF to hell, so that's really saying something lol

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spitfire (Post 844785)
Also I think Bodycount is one of the worst TMNT comic stories.

Very true.

Samhain 04-30-2011 08:23 PM

Neither honestly. But, if I had to pick one, I guess Laird. Eastman's stuff just gets boring to me. Boobs, guns, blah. I need more substance.

oldmanwinters 04-30-2011 10:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 844772)
I would love to murder the Justice Force in that issue to prevent them from existing in the 4kids show or Volume 4 (they were SO unnecessary in both).

Yeah, I feel your pain, especially since they became so associated with all those Turtle Titan misadventures.

Jester 04-30-2011 10:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 844827)
Yeah, I feel your pain, especially since they became so associated with all those Turtle Titan misadventures.

You spoke the unspeakable name!!!

ToTheNines 04-30-2011 11:41 PM

I know we're on a superhero hating trend here, but the first Turtle Titan episode actually could have been quite cool if Silver Sentry and Malignus were replaced with Radical and Complete Carnage.

Powder 04-30-2011 11:54 PM

Amen to that, definitely. I was bummed they never showed up.

oldmanwinters 05-01-2011 12:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 844841)
I know we're on a superhero hating trend here, but the first Turtle Titan episode actually could have been quite cool if Silver Sentry and Malignus were replaced with Radical and Complete Carnage.

Dude, so true! Once I first saw Silver Sentry in Unconvincing Turtle Titan, I was afraid the series had jumped the shark for its original tone. Fortunately, my fears were alleviated once Mikey came to the realization that ninja skills better suited his style than the superhero business.

And then came future episodes...

Cipher 05-01-2011 02:03 AM

Jim Lawson.

Vivi 05-01-2011 09:21 AM

Vol 4 of the comics is one of my favourites, so I'd have to say at this point Laird. But he would be infinitely better if he wrote faster.

azrael 05-01-2011 02:42 PM

I cant honestly say I kind of read all of it at once so it blended together only Vol 3-4 Lawson (tales v2) Dooney, and Zulli were the few that really left on the impression in my mind. I have not read everything so I am still not done but I have read Vol 1-4 Tales 1-4 (this is the main stuff) Only thing I can remember Eastman writing is the 2 issue Casey Jones story.... I cant verse that against vol 4 since its honestly not finished. I will wait and try to find something and reread it. I feel as if they make (together) an awesome team, eastmans fast paced action and laird with a steady story


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:59 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.