![]() |
So it seems PL didn't quite approve of all Tales V. 2 issues
Andrew asked PL this on his blog, I don't think many people saw it:
Quote:
I should also say that there are still some of those issues of "Tales" which I have yet to read even in their final printed form... and the one you ask about is one of those. -- PL. -------- This is why people shouldn't take what PL says is canon and what's not canon, even some Tales V. 2 issues probably wouldn't be considered canon according to him. Of course it doesn't matter now, but this is why people should stop saying, "Image is not canon because PL deemed it so," anymore. I do have to agree with PL however that a story about Leo and Radical being in love was a horrible idea, and I wish he WAS around to shoot that one down before it went into production. Can't believe Murphy did that one. |
I guess I need to read that issue...but then I'd have to read all the Complete Carnage and Radical issues....then all of Mirage...then all TMNT comics. It's be a huge ordeal.
|
It was already known that Peter went through a period were he didn't approve Tales V.2 stories. It's also been discussed that Murph might have taken the opportunity to sneak in some stories that Peter would never approve...such as Swan Song and The Pantheon.
Quote:
|
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't just about everybody at Mirage essentially disown The Pantheon? I swear I remember Tristan saying something about that.
|
Who know. I know I have, and I love Murphy and Allen as a team. I died a little after reading that story, brought to us by the guys that made TMNT Adventures so awesome. Ok, I might be exaggerating a bit...but not much.
|
The Pantheon and Swan Song were both removed from continuity when I was asked to work on the guidebook.
Tales #36 was one of the issues. Murphy was managing editor and got it going while Peter was working on the film I believe (or was absent for some other reason). I'm pretty certain Peter came back not too long after though, as the official follow up (the one that involved Copperhead and Diamondback in their first forms, and brought Miller back to the forefront) was nixed by Peter. Was never sure why, but eventually we got #50 (which I think Pete dug) and the others came not long after. |
I really liked Swan Song. Can't remember anything about The Pantheon though.
Tristan, do you remember any of the others that were removed from continuity? Doesn't make much difference really (apart from a bit of recolouring on Mark's timeline I guess), I'm just curious. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
and thus why the world of comics can be so damn confusing and shuned by those not apart of its fandom...lol
so damn confusing...i think its easier to do as i have seen some people said "make up your own damn mind about whats cannon and not cannon" - technodrome people with my literary librerties. Though I have to ask...why is it the the story lines are so confusing with this series? Is it simply a result of taking liberties with time gaps to insert more stories. Or is part of it the desire to keep the turtles teenagers longer by drawing out time. |
I'm a growing fan of Major Spoiler's motto about comics "F*ck Continuity!"
|
All the more reason why folks should be more concerned with reading the stories that are *good*, moreso than the stories that "count".
Personally, I've never acknowledged "The Pantheon", even when it was first published. Such a waste of Chris Allan... |
This actually kind of answers a lot of my questions about "Swan Song". The reasons I personally didn't the issue were that it felt really rushed and undeveloped for something that really was suppose to be the focal point of later Leonardo's life.
It just felt completely empty to me and looking at all the comics around it doesn't seem to fit in at all. Knowing now that it was kind of rushed to get in under the radar well that makes sense to me overall. I still find it to be a lacking story and am kind of glad it's not considered "canon" for that reason. I don't think I need to add anything about my feelings about "Pantheon" as pretty much everything has already been said here. :tsmile: |
If you're reading that, I like the lady not far beneath that said I look like a very young teenager that has never seen the original cartoon ever. Clearly.
|
In case anybody is confused on the reference to the original quotation, here it is:
http://peterlairdstmntblog.blogspot....46002028401270 |
When/why did Peter Laird create a separate blog for TMNT? This is news to me.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
-ms |
Crazy to think he was funding a comic and wasn't even reading the stories after they were done. Guess he really is sick of TMNT.
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:44 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.