![]() |
The IDW Collection Topic
So we have a lot of info coming in about these we should keep it all in one easy to find place.
Volume 1 contains issues #1-7 and the Raphael one-shot. Release date: November 23 http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant...9205505&sr=8-1 Full wrap around cover - Posted by Birdman37 http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-ixuh9Mq3bM...-cvrfinal1.jpg Volume 2 contains issues #8-11, and the Michaelangelo, Leonardo, and Donatello one-shots. Release date: November 15th. http://www.amazon.com/Teenage-Mutant...9205505&sr=8-2 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Volume 1: Change is Constant 104 pages http://www.amazon.com/dp/1613771398/..._sx4Job02GCQ3S Please feel free to post updates here and I'll do my best to add them to this first post. |
Only 7 issues for the second collection? The first one had 8.
Only two volumes in and they're already lowering the issue count. I was hoping they would include issue 12 since this is just the same collection as the Mirage one just split into two volumes. |
I think that issue 11 feels like a natural finishing point for that collection, ending with the last Eastman/Laird combo for what was to be many issues.
And Eastman confirms that, pretty much: Quote:
Of course, I would much prefer all them in one book, and not two, but ending it on issue 11 seems perfect to me... |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Does nothing please you? |
In all honesty, they should release the Micro-series issues in order, or at least have Leo in the correct spot since Mike and Don's stories really are one-shots stories.
|
Quote:
Vol 1 contains books 1-7 plus the Raph one shot Vol 2 contains books 8-11 plus the other three one shots. I'd imagine that they'll be in the same order as the most recent Mirage collected book (minus the Fugitoid story.) So Vol 1 would be: 1, 2, 3, Raph, 4, 5, 6, 7. Vol 2 would be: Michelangelo, 8, Donatello, 9, Leonardo, 10, 11. |
Quote:
|
Ah, I see! No worries man, sorry..
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Come on, we all knew Cybercubed would find something to gripe about...right?
|
The Circle of Gripe:
New information is posted, a few minutes pass, C3 complains about it. Repeat. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
And to address a more pressing concern, why aren't Dave Sim or Gerhard listed as authors in the Amazon listing for TMNT Ultimate Collection vol. 2? I hope they don't screw Sim over somehow. |
Well the next volume should collect #12-18 at the least...and the only guest writer in that gap is #16 which is Mark Martin.
|
I should not be surprised with the quick turn around on a second hard cover volume. I am sad to see the 1988 version i have is being split into two books. I may have to wait and see the quality of the first before I invest in the second book.
I have no complaints on the content, since having finally read 1-11 with one-shots i do agree its a good point to pause at for the second volume. I am still curious to see how they treat book three and onward. |
Why do they keep reprinting the same issues of the original comics over and over again? It's getting old IMO. I want to see some new material.
|
Quote:
On the one hand, I completely understand why IDW is collecting the issues they're collecting now and even splitting them up as they're doing -- it makes good business sense and a TPB of these issues has never seen as super wide of a release as they're about to via IDW. On the other hand, however, I don't have to be excited about it. I already have all these issues, and in various TPB forms too. When and if IDW makes it to a "City at War" TPB, I'll start paying attention. I'm very glad they're doing what they're doing, though, and giving the classic comics some much deserved exposure. |
a) The issues are oversized and in a hardcover book. That alone is pretty damn awesome. Add on top of that good materials and print quality, and these new books should blow away all past collections.
b) As said, it's a new company. It would be bat$#!7 insane for them to skip the pivotal first issues. c) The previous books had small print runs and are unavailable to buy new, and mostly go for pretty high prices. These books have the potential of drawing in a larger audience, and should hopefully be around for a long time. It doesn't matter that people like us insane-o fans already own past collections. |
Well if the next collection does 12 through 18 that will be issues that haven't been collected since those 20 year old TPB's.
|
Quote:
|
My biggest question is are they going to continue to release these TPB's as a full volume one hard cover set or will they shift to a softcover post #11.
|
I actually wonder if they're going to jump to the original Tales before continuing Vol. 1.
Those 7 issues of Tales are always collected early on, and they're already gotten two collected TPB's from Mirage, one from the 80's and the one from 2007. Since they like re-printing the same stuff over and over, I'm wondering if those 7 Tales issues are next. Hopefully they remember to include the Spinal Tapped story. |
They may not tap into the "tales of tmnt" just yet. Partially because they are not working on a their own tales series yet. maybe when they launch that aspect they will tap into the tales series.
|
the way I see it they have two choices. Release the books in some sort of timelined order attempting to connect the stories into a continuity or in the order they were released originally.
I prefer 2. I'd rather they get released in order. I'd like to have all the stories canon or not. I got a question. Is issue #8 the original or the redo without Cerberus? |
i wonder if they will skip to return to new york, then on to City at war.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
But seriously, why would they do that? |
Why do people keep saying they're going to skip issues?
Eastman doesn't care what's canon and what's not, this isn't Peter Laird who was willing to retcon half of Volume 1. I am willing to bet they'll just collect them in the order they were released. |
It would be cool if they included the remade issue #8 as a bonus in this second collection. That would even out the issue count with the first book and it would be nice to see the dialog and such as Murph wrote it.
|
Quote:
|
I like the fact that the second edition is coming out only 2 months after the first. If we get one collection every 2 months, (assuming these sell well for them to continue), we could get through the bulk of Vol. 1 rather quickly.
If we continue to get at least 7-8 issues per volume, we could get done with Volume 1 in a year. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Honestly as long as they keep them all in separate books I don't see it being a problem. They can easily use the alternate timeline stories for a Tales style book that compiles those types of stories together. The main line could be the canon stuff from Volume 1 and they can branch off from that for the other stuff.
Or they can just release it all in order regardless, which is what they should do. |
Quote:
Bode's stuff (which includes #32) might not be particularly wacky, but they're still out of tone with and contradicty to the Mirage TMNT Universe. #37 (which was by McCollum and Anderson, BTW) would be still included with canon stuff, though, same with Farley's stuff and maybe even the full-color vol. 1 issue by Corben. |
Didn't Eastman co-write some of those stories? I doubt he wants them removed.
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:04 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.