![]() |
Did anyone not like Leatherhead's origin in Archie?
In all incarnations Leatherhead is a normal gator before being exposed to mutagen. In Archie he is a human named Jess Harley who is transformed into a gator by Mary Bones.
I just don't like the idea of Leatherhead being human before mutation. It kind of ruins the brotherly/rivalry feel he has with the Turtles. |
Before learning about his true origin, I didn't mind. It wasn't any different than most other mutants.
After learning about his actual origin, it became extremely cheesy because, as you said, mutant gator Leatherhead has a connection with the Turtles in that they, along with Splinter, are the only 6 known creatures to have been affected by the Utroms mutagen. What's even more interesting is how LH's mental health slowly deteriorates, and how it lends a hint of why Future Raph becomes more feral in his later years. |
Quote:
|
The Archie series' magical Turnstone-based mutation of Leatherhead doesn't bother me. TMNTA was never meant to be the Mirage series and was mandated to be deliberately different. I don't recall much reference to Leatherhead's human past either-- he gets magicked, throws a fit, wrestles intergalactically, and accepts/chooses his alligator form.
Also, all the variation in the origins of humanoid animals throughout the run of TMNTA/Mutanimals fascinated me as a kid-- toxic waste, mystical animal races, human/spirit relations, magic and magical talismans, aliens and alien experiments. More fun than endless mutagen spills. |
Well the only reason it stands out to me is this wasn't just another mutant, this is Leatherhead, one of the most important secondary characters in TMNT history.
Mondo Gecko was human pre-mutation too, but that didn't bother me because it made sense. Although I do like him being a gecko like his original cartoon origin before mutation. |
If you want an origin to complain about-- how about Tattoo in the Fred Wolf cartoon? Hamster exposed to mutagen equals tattooed sumo wrestler. Huh?
|
Quote:
Still I never liked the idea of Leatherhead being a human before he changed. There are just some things that just don't work. Then again Murphy never brought back Baxter Stockman or introduced Casey Jones in the Archie series at all, so stranger things have happened. I don't know why Murphy ignored two important characters. The only time we see Baxter is in the episode adaptions. At least Casey gets a reference in "Year of the Turtle." That made my day. |
Quote:
I don't see what the big deal is, but I'm such a Archie flag waver, that I'm obviously very biased. Having LH be Jess Harley first at least is a change up from "Human or animal is exposed to Shredder and Krang's mutagen" that we got for EVERY mutant in the Fred Wolf series. Say what you will about what Murphy did to LH's origin...at least he tried to make it unique, like several of the other "Mutanimals" (which to be fair, aren't all mutants. I'm looking at you Wingnut and Screwloose.) Besides, it's a totally different character than the Mirage LH. |
Every incarnation of Leatherhead has been a normal gator except Archie:
Mirage = gator Original cartoon = gator 4kids series = gator Nick series = Most likely gator I don't mind changing origins for characters, but only if it fits. As said above, Leatherhead's human origin just seemed forgotten anyway as Archie series progressed. |
Quote:
|
Okay-- so Archie has the only incarnation of Leatherhead where he didn't start as a gator, I don't see how that makes it an unfitting origin for Leatherhead.
Jess Harley was a bayou-dweller who turned to theft to escape poverty. He stole a magic item tied to his fate: being turned into an alligator man whose path would lead to him to finding the Turnstone during a battle and ending the Final Conflict. Strange as it seems, being an alligator adventurer was an improvement to his status in life and he embraced it. It's not exactly Shakespearean, but I thought it was cool when I was ten and still do. His first appearance in TMNTA #6 came just over a year after his first Mirage appearance in Tales v1 #6 so I'm not sure how much of what you're emphasizing as crucial Leatherhead backstory was even established at that point. And, as also stated above, Archie purposely introduced differences between their versions and what Mirage was doing. |
Quote:
I am not just saying this about Leatherhead now, even as a kid it bothered me. Why couldn't he just be a normal gator that Mary Bones mutated/transformed into an intelligent being instead? Also, why is the photo in your sig asking that when we've seen those Turtles in, "Year of the Turtle?" |
Quote:
|
Quote:
And what of the Hamato Yoshi becomes Splinter origin? Why isn't that as earth shattering? Splinter is a lot more consequential a character than LH. Quote:
|
Quote:
The series had various writers and artists throughout its run. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
how many TMNTA comics ended with The End posted after the story like in your picture? Its been a long time since I've read them and was wondering if maybe this was a subtle way of telling us that the road had come to and end for TMNTA
|
Quote:
|
Well... in the archie/classic toonverse, there were tons of mutants... so they didn't have the 'six only mutated creatures' thing going on.
What was the Casey Jones reference? |
Quote:
|
Am I the only one who figured some old toon elements still kinda happened in the Archie series, we just never saw it?
Such as Napoleon Bonafrog existing, Baxter becoming a fly, meeting Casey Jones, etc. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Casey is in the Archie comic adaptions of the 3 movies, but of course that doesn't count. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Never thought of it that way, but wow, HA! Definitely some etch 'n sketch staches over there.
|
Makes you wonder why Murphy did use Leatherhead and Rat King in the Archie series, (remember at the time, they were just introduced in Mirage and barely debuted in the cartoon), yet he left out Baxter and Casey Jones.
It really is weird. Its like the only TMNT universe where Baxter and Casey Jones had no usage at all. I know not every TMNT universe has to use the same characters, but some are just staples that you expect to see because they're part of the mythology. |
If it makes you feel any better NT:TNM didn't use any Mirage staples save the Turtles, Splinter, and (in a very limited way) Shredder and the Foot.
|
Quote:
Anyway I recall rumors that if there were a Season 2, both Casey and April would have been brought back. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I know we saw Baxter in the cartoon episode adaptions, but that wasn't new material. Also as said, we never see Baxter again after issue #4 besides a brief flashback.
I guess Baxter never became a fly in this version? |
Quote:
I'd be tempted to just ignore mini #1-3 and series #1-4 except Murphy eventually brings elements from those stories into the branched-off TMNTA continuity. |
Quote:
#5 starts with the Turtles/April/Splinter and Shredder/Krang/Bebop/Rocksteady already established. Basically the Archie Turtles have the same origins as the Fred Wolf Turtles, as do Shredder and co. They have the same lives/adventures up to episode 6 of the cartoon, and then it drifts from there. And yes, I know they retconned some toddler turtle stories into there later on, but that's it. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
The lack of Casey Jones entirely is unforgiveable though. |
And yet I forgive it.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:54 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.