![]() |
(Possible Spoilers) The IDW TMNT New Issue Discussion Thread
I went to my local shop and picked up cover A (The Raph cover) of IDW's new ongoing TMNT title. I've just finished reading it and I thought I'd create a thread where we can talk about each issue as it hits. So on to TMNT 1:
Spoiler:
|
I figured you'd be a Raph cover guy! Did the shop have each turtle option available? I'm probably going to pick up my issue later today.
|
All 4 Turtles were there. They may have had the fold out cover...but I didn't check them thoroughly. I was just excited to see Turtles on the IDW rack.
|
Oh and one more thing:
Spoiler:
|
So far I haven't heard anything that makes me flinch.
But the day is young. |
Its an interesting issue, with a bunch a questions that needs to be answered.
One thing that bugs me is, Spoiler:
I hope there's a good explanation behind this lol |
Quote:
Spoiler:
Oh and pl212, you might spoiler tag....just in case. |
Jester's new avatar is spooky!
|
Sorry man. I wanted a IDW Raph and this was the most "avatar-esque".
Spoiler:
|
Quote:
but why would I need it when the title of the thread says it anyways :/ |
Quote:
But yeah... I'm not sure about 18 month-old Turtles that are supposed to be ninja. Sounds pretty dodgy at best to me, on paper. Is it possible you're/we're missing something? |
Quote:
Edit and yes Andrew Spoiler:
|
Quote:
What's Casey look like? |
I dunno. I find the issue to be.... WEIRD.
Spoiler:
|
Quote:
Spoiler:
I found it weird. |
Quote:
For now, thanks so much for your kind and loyal support! I'm excited to watch the debate over the new series on Technodrome -- you folks are the best fans in the world! We're gonna have fun! Talk soon... Tom |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I dunna about that. Part of me thinks that...
Spoiler:
|
Quote:
I think this was a good start, it showed a bit of everything and left me wanting more :D |
That's for sure. September seems all too far away.
|
I just read it -- some things that stuck out to me or ideas I had:
Spoiler:
|
Quote:
Spoiler:
Check it out , what do you think ? |
Quote:
Spoiler:
|
Spoiler:
|
Straight up, I dislike the new origin. Some parts of it are clever, some are just off. But I won't let it bother me once the story gets rolling. And I appreciate the fact that they're not just regurgitating what we've seen before.
Anyways, there were no incentive covers at my closest store (which ain't close) but I got Leo and Raph. |
So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.
|
I got all four basic covers today from my local shop. I was able to hand pick a copy of each from the shipping box. I am very lucky I did too because they only had a few Donnys, and Leos. There were only two Raphs and only one Mikey. Had I gotten there late I would have walked with only 3 out of the 4 brothers. Is anyone else noticing a cover to be more rare than the others? (not counting the variants of course)
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
wow, after reading some of the posts, i'm kinda excited to get my hands on this
|
Just read it and I really enjoyed this one.
I got a kick out of the nods to other versions of the turtles like the cowabunga t-shirt. As far as art goes, I think the turtles are the weakest. The humans look good (except for a few panels of April, who looks awkward in some and cute in others). Spoiler:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I haven't read the issue yet but you guys are getting me excited. I actually like what Im hearing about the origin story. Different is welcome, atleat IMO.
As far as Dan Duncan's art.... yeah, I would have loved a ''Star'' artist attached to this book to give it a little attention. Maybe Ethan Van Sciver or Finch. But so far I love everything about the way he draws the turtles. From the Over-exaggerated facial Expressions to the weird plastron designs. LOVE IT ALL. It's different but maybe that's what this franchise needs. Change. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Just read it and liked it a lot. I like the fact that they decided to entirely change the origin story and do something else. IDW can go any way they want to now.
Spoiler:
|
tl;dr-version: Too much story with too quick of a pace, not enough moments to explore characters.
Long version: It seems a little bland and cliché at this point, but the thing I care the most about are well-written, complex characters, and that's rarely something you achieve in the first issue, so yeah, I'll wait a few issues before I pass any real judgment on this one. They possibly tried to cram a little too much story into it and not enough true character-moments, but then again, I don't know what the different pay-offs will be, and maybe they need to begin this many stories at once for whatever-they-have-planned to work. Like I said, I'll wait and see where this is going, but if I had to give the first issue a rating, it would be 3/10 The 3 points comes from Raph's story which is the most interesting so far :P |
I like it. :) The new stuff brought to the table is a welcome change; it's absurd to think that this book should be like the other origins, and I'm intrigued to see where things go.
And I like Duncan's Turtles and Splinter, and Old Hob looks pretty cool, but I'm not terribly fond of his humans. Then again...I was never terribly fond of Eastman and Laird's humans either. :p I'm not entirely sure yet what to think of the coloring. On one hand, it seems a little drab; but on the other, it's not the boring, shiny, blatantly obvious computer coloring of most books I flip through, so it gets a lot of appreciation from me for looking pretty unique and creative. I wish the Eastman covers weren't special variants and were as easily obtainable as the Duncan covers. So bummed I couldn't get hold of Eastman's cover for #1, which I specified I wanted several months in advance. :\ (I'm thinking an employee at the shop snagged it, possibly to sell online. The shop certainly had more than ten copies available so they should have gotten that particular incentive variant.) Duncan's covers are awesome so I'm pleased with my Leonardo cover, but I'd have far preferred to have Eastman's art in my hands. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:45 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.