The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   (Possible Spoilers) The IDW TMNT New Issue Discussion Thread (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=34913)

Jester 08-24-2011 11:44 AM

(Possible Spoilers) The IDW TMNT New Issue Discussion Thread
 
I went to my local shop and picked up cover A (The Raph cover) of IDW's new ongoing TMNT title. I've just finished reading it and I thought I'd create a thread where we can talk about each issue as it hits. So on to TMNT 1:
Spoiler:
We are introduced to April, Casey, Baxter, and the shadowy figure of "General Krang" a military "man" who is bankrolling Stockman's genetic experiments, which the Turtles and Splinter are a part of. He's also working on a super soldier mutagen for Krang. Is Krang an amalgam of the ole Utrom Shredder and Agent Bishop?
The events occur in the present day, 18 months ago, and 15 months ago. Seems that the Turtles will mutate to a teenage state. I still hope Splinter is a father and not just a pal. The Turtles and Splinter are all part of an experiment. So far no Yoshi, but we do get an attempt at an explanation as to why a rat could learn ninjitsu: the genetic experiments are attempting to "splinter" the rat's "human" abilities from that of the rat. The Turtles are part of a human body armor experiment.
April is the one who names the Turtles after the Renaissance greats. She seems to have a larger part in the Turtles origin this time around.
I'm, not sure what I think of the changes so far. I mean we're only one issue in so I don't know what might come in the months to come, though each arc is only 4 issues long, so the blanks had better be filled in quickly. So far I'm concerned by the modified "genetic experiments" origin and the lack of Hamato Yoshi.

oldmanwinters 08-24-2011 11:47 AM

I figured you'd be a Raph cover guy! Did the shop have each turtle option available? I'm probably going to pick up my issue later today.

Jester 08-24-2011 11:50 AM

All 4 Turtles were there. They may have had the fold out cover...but I didn't check them thoroughly. I was just excited to see Turtles on the IDW rack.

Jester 08-24-2011 11:55 AM

Oh and one more thing:
Spoiler:
A dumpster diving Raph finds a "COWABUNGA!" t-shirt and exclaims, "Oh, now that's just wrong." before discarding it. Kinda funny, but seems every Not-Fred Wolf interpretation of the Turtles has used that gag.

Andrew NDB 08-24-2011 12:06 PM

So far I haven't heard anything that makes me flinch.

But the day is young.

pl212 08-24-2011 12:17 PM

Its an interesting issue, with a bunch a questions that needs to be answered.
One thing that bugs me is,
Spoiler:
they were just turtles 18 months ago and a few months later they know how to fight and have been taught by Splinter :/

I hope there's a good explanation behind this lol

Jester 08-24-2011 12:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 871310)
So far I haven't heard anything that makes me flinch.

But the day is young.

Really, I'd have sworn the
Spoiler:
only 18 month span between baby turtles/unmutated rat to fighting Hob and his goons would do something flinch-esque. I mean, what does that mean for the family dynamic, and the ninja training that the Turtles and Splinter have been mutants for A LITTLE OVER A YEAR!


Oh and pl212, you might spoiler tag....just in case.

oldmanwinters 08-24-2011 12:20 PM

Jester's new avatar is spooky!

Jester 08-24-2011 12:22 PM

Sorry man. I wanted a IDW Raph and this was the most "avatar-esque".
Spoiler:
Casey is introduced getting pummeled by his blitzed pops. Raphael breaks down their door to aid in the domestic dispute. Thoughts Andrew?

pl212 08-24-2011 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 871315)
Oh and pl212, you might spoiler tag....just in case.

Ok I spoiler tagged it :D
but why would I need it when the title of the thread says it anyways :/

Andrew NDB 08-24-2011 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pl212 (Post 871314)
Its an interesting issue, with a bunch a questions that needs to be answered.
One thing that bugs me is,
Spoiler:
they were just turtles 18 months ago and a few months later they know how to fight and have been taught by Splinter :/

I hope there's a good explanation behind this lol

Oh, is that what you meant? I was confused by the "they will mutate to a teenage state" part.

But yeah... I'm not sure about 18 month-old Turtles that are supposed to be ninja. Sounds pretty dodgy at best to me, on paper. Is it possible you're/we're missing something?

Jester 08-24-2011 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pl212 (Post 871319)
Ok I spoiler tagged it :D
but why would I need it when the title of the thread says it anyways :/

Because I'm sure even thought the title says it, some one will gripe that we didn't tag stuff...despite the title saying there will be spoilers.
Edit and yes Andrew
Spoiler:
less than 2 years takes place between pre-mutated animals and "ninja butt-kicking."

Andrew NDB 08-24-2011 12:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 871317)
Sorry man. I wanted a IDW Raph and this was the most "avatar-esque".
Spoiler:
Casey is introduced getting pummeled by his blitzed pops. Raphael breaks down their door to aid in the domestic dispute. Thoughts Andrew?

I think -- as the beginning of what I am assuming will be a blossoming Casey-Raphael friendship and introduction of Casey -- it is thematically more powerful than them just running into each other in the park by chance.

What's Casey look like?

Raph's Girl 08-24-2011 12:43 PM

I dunno. I find the issue to be.... WEIRD.

Spoiler:
Ok so we have Chet who in the Mirage comics was the kid who purchased the turtles and then lost them in the sewers. Now he's working for Baxter (who works for General Krang) to make this super soldier serum thing. April starts out as the college intern and ends up naming the turtles because she's taking a class in Renaissance art.

Yes it's nice that April is now more part of their origin and Chet has a bigger role. But the origin is just....off somehow. The way they name Splinter is kinda stupid as well (and is it just me or did Lindsey look like Irma?) But they become fighters in only a couple months?? Plus Casey is obviously YOUNGER than April. He's just a kid being abused by his alcaholic father.

And the whole thing with General Krang. I hope he ends up being human and not some alien.

Oh and the turtles... They're obviously Sea Turtles...but the poor things should have more water than that!

pl212 08-24-2011 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 871321)
Oh, is that what you meant? I was confused by the "they will mutate to a teenage state" part.

But yeah... I'm not sure about 18 month-old Turtles that are supposed to be ninja. Sounds pretty dodgy at best to me, on paper. Is it possible you're/we're missing something?

Sorry for the confusion I was assuming anyone who posts here have already read the issue and knew what I was talking about.
Spoiler:
So 18 months before they were "ninja turtles" they were in a lab as actual turtles. A few months later they became what we all know now.

I found it weird.

TomWaltz 08-24-2011 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pl212 (Post 871314)
Its an interesting issue, with a bunch a questions that needs to be answered.
One thing that bugs me is,
Spoiler:
they were just turtles 18 months ago and a few months later they know how to fight and have been taught by Splinter :/

I hope there's a good explanation behind this lol

All will be revealed in time, my friends...

For now, thanks so much for your kind and loyal support! I'm excited to watch the debate over the new series on Technodrome -- you folks are the best fans in the world!

We're gonna have fun!

Talk soon...

Tom

Andrew NDB 08-24-2011 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pl212 (Post 871332)
Sorry for the confusion I was assuming anyone who posts here have already read the issue and knew what I was talking about.
Spoiler:
So 18 months before they were "ninja turtles" they were in a lab as actual turtles. A few months later they became what we all know now.

I found it weird.

I haven't read the issue yet so I'm only going off of your guys' cryptic blurbs, but does it seem that we might be headed toward the Turtles formerly being humans, merging with humans, or something along those lines?

pl212 08-24-2011 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 871335)
I haven't read the issue yet so I'm only going off of your guys' cryptic blurbs, but does it seem that we might be headed toward the Turtles formerly being humans, merging with humans, or something along those lines?

I believe so, it seems like something along those lines but merging with humans would make the most sense to me right now.

Andrew NDB 08-24-2011 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pl212 (Post 871337)
I believe so, it seems like something along those lines but merging with humans would make the most sense to me right now.

Well, I'm not against such a thing as long as it's not something rubbish like the Fred Wolf "touch this and touch that" mutagen.

Jester 08-24-2011 12:58 PM

I dunna about that. Part of me thinks that...
Spoiler:
The genetically modified Turtles and Rat will come into contact with some of Baxter's/Krang's super soldier mutagen and grow to their humanoid size. Maybe the good people at Stock-Gen train them in ninjitsu...you know through Weapon X style virtual reality immersion technology.

pl212 08-24-2011 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 871339)
Well, I'm not against such a thing as long as it's not something rubbish like the Fred Wolf "touch this and touch that" mutagen.

lol exactly.
I think this was a good start, it showed a bit of everything and left me wanting more :D

Jester 08-24-2011 01:02 PM

That's for sure. September seems all too far away.

LeoNerdo 08-24-2011 01:04 PM

I just read it -- some things that stuck out to me or ideas I had:

Spoiler:
The 4 turtles are sea turtles. I dig that since the Mirage gang used to put ads in some books and links on their website for Save the Sea turtle foundation websites. Another thought on this is that sea turtles only have flippers and no toes/claws like the red-eared sliders do they? To me that means there may be some kind of human involvement in the mutation process for it to make sense for them to form hands, fingers, feet and toes.

General Krang is some type of "warlord". That's pretty cool. He's also paying for the super soldier mutagen Baxter is creating. Maybe down the line somewhere he tests it on himself (presuming he's human) and mutates in to an ugly brain guy. :tlol:

pl212 08-24-2011 01:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeoNerdo (Post 871344)
I just read it -- some things that stuck out to me or ideas I had:

Spoiler:
The 4 turtles are sea turtles. I dig that since the Mirage gang used to put ads in some books and links on their website for Save the Sea turtle foundation websites. Another thought on this is that sea turtles only have flippers and no toes/claws like the red-eared sliders do they? To me that means there may be some kind of human involvement in the mutation process for it to make sense for them to form hands, fingers, feet and toes.

General Krang is some type of "warlord". That's pretty cool. He's also paying for the super soldier mutagen Baxter is creating. Maybe down the line somewhere he tests it on himself (presuming he's human) and mutates in to an ugly brain guy. :tlol:

Spoiler:
General Krang seemed like a cyborg/android to me, I don't know if I was over analyzing but it seemed like you can see his metal arm underneath his sleeve.

Check it out , what do you think ?

Jester 08-24-2011 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pl212 (Post 871345)
Spoiler:
General Krang seemed like a cyborg/android to me, I don't know if I was over analyzing but it seemed like you can see his metal arm underneath his sleeve.

Check it out , what do you think ?

Spoiler:
I think you may be right. Looks like a gloved hand and a metal arm underneath. We may have a rogue Utrom.

LeoNerdo 08-24-2011 01:16 PM

Spoiler:
Ah, I hadn't paid very close attention to that panel. Good point. I dunno if that's a metal arm or a sleeve, though it's certainly possible. The gloved hand is rather conspicuous unless he's had some type of accident in the past. Could be an android or Utrom-like character though.

ToTheNines 08-24-2011 01:23 PM

Straight up, I dislike the new origin. Some parts of it are clever, some are just off. But I won't let it bother me once the story gets rolling. And I appreciate the fact that they're not just regurgitating what we've seen before.

Anyways, there were no incentive covers at my closest store (which ain't close) but I got Leo and Raph.

Jester 08-24-2011 01:32 PM

So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.

The Fifth Turtle 08-24-2011 01:37 PM

I got all four basic covers today from my local shop. I was able to hand pick a copy of each from the shipping box. I am very lucky I did too because they only had a few Donnys, and Leos. There were only two Raphs and only one Mikey. Had I gotten there late I would have walked with only 3 out of the 4 brothers. Is anyone else noticing a cover to be more rare than the others? (not counting the variants of course)

ToTheNines 08-24-2011 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 871351)
So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.

I think it's cool. His interior art trumps his covers (which is odd). I'm definitely eager to see more.

Andrew NDB 08-24-2011 01:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 871351)
So what do you guys think about Duncan's artwork? I'm not a huge fan so far.

OK, brutally honest: I really dig his style but not so much his plastrons (they look kinda "soft" and angular) or his Turtle expressions (a little... too much?). I'm concerned that his artwork isn't really going to bring the "Oh wow!" factor that a new TMNT comic kind of needs on the shelf right now -- TMNT has a... let's call it a "certain reputation." At this point, when some random person discovers this comic in their shop and flips through it it needs to POP or the book won't be given a second look or chance. Coupled with the so-so coloring, I'm a little worried in that department.


Quote:

Originally Posted by LeoNerdo (Post 871349)
Spoiler:
Ah, I hadn't paid very close attention to that panel. Good point. I dunno if that's a metal arm or a sleeve, though it's certainly possible. The gloved hand is rather conspicuous unless he's had some type of accident in the past. Could be an android or Utrom-like character though.

I don't think it's too profound to pretty much assume that if IDW went to all the trouble of importing Krang from the Fred Wolf cartoon they wouldn't make him something other than either the disembodied brain-like warlord or a rogue Utrom warlord. I'm sure "General Krang" has a secret we'll be let in on soon enough.

TheCanadiandrome 08-24-2011 01:54 PM

wow, after reading some of the posts, i'm kinda excited to get my hands on this

Revan 08-24-2011 01:55 PM

Just read it and I really enjoyed this one.

I got a kick out of the nods to other versions of the turtles like the cowabunga t-shirt. As far as art goes, I think the turtles are the weakest. The humans look good (except for a few panels of April, who looks awkward in some and cute in others).

Spoiler:
I am a bit unsure how I feel about the turtles being normal turtles only 18 months before squaring off with Old Hob's goons. So far, I like the old origin better where they grow up as a family rather than mutating into an older state. But I'm sure we will get a clearer picture what is going on in the months to come.

General Krang intrigues me. Especially that gloved hand with what appears to be a metal arm under the sleeve. Burnow island reminds me of "the island" from the x-men origins: Wolverine movie.

Either Chet is a dork with a stutter or he is very nervous working on this project. Probably just a nerd with a speech impediment but perhaps he knows he doing some illegal work. Might indicate Krang up to no good. :tgrin:

Raph is the "feisty" one. :tlol:
And April seems VERY attached to them. Like, Buslady attached. :ohwell:

Raph eats out of the trash? :teek: Yuck. But they are animals after all.

Sad that Casey appears to be a teenager and April is many years older.


Quote:

Originally Posted by pl212 (Post 871337)
I believe so, it seems like something along those lines but merging with humans would make the most sense to me right now.

I don't understand how they could be human. We are lead to believe the four turtles in the terrarium are the teenage mutant ninja turtles.

ToTheNines 08-24-2011 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Revan (Post 871367)
Sad that Casey appears to be a teenager and April is many years older.

Not totally true. April's a college intern which means she's 19-22, and just because Casey's getting beat up by his dad doesn't mean he's that young. I'm 20 and I'm living at home for the time being.

LeoNerdo 08-24-2011 02:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Revan (Post 871367)
Just read it and I really enjoyed this one.

I got a kick out of the nods to other versions of the turtles like the cowabunga t-shirt. As far as art goes, I think the turtles are the weakest. The humans look good (except for a few panels of April, who looks awkward in some and cute in others).

Spoiler:
I am a bit unsure how I feel about the turtles being normal turtles only 18 months before squaring off with Old Hob's goons. So far, I like the old origin better where they grow up as a family rather than mutating into an older state. But I'm sure we will get a clearer picture what is going on in the months to come.

General Krang intrigues me. Especially that gloved hand with what appears to be a metal arm under the sleeve. Burnow island reminds me of "the island" from the x-men origins: Wolverine movie.

Either Chet is a dork with a stutter or he is very nervous working on this project. Probably just a nerd with a speech impediment but perhaps he knows he doing some illegal work. Might indicate Krang up to no good. :tgrin:

Raph is the "feisty" one. :tlol:
And April seems VERY attached to them. Like, Buslady attached. :ohwell:

Raph eats out of the trash? :teek: Yuck. But they are animals after all.

Sad that Casey appears to be a teenager and April is many years older.



I don't understand how they could be human. We are lead to believe the four turtles in the terrarium are the teenage mutant ninja turtles.

I thought just the opposite about the art direction. I think the Turtles and Splinter look fine, but the humans or rather Chet in particular looks pretty awkward in almost every panel he appears. I'm not real crazy about the design on Old Hob either, but I guess I'm curious to see how he got a gang of humans to take orders from him.

Samhain 08-24-2011 02:15 PM

I haven't read the issue yet but you guys are getting me excited. I actually like what Im hearing about the origin story. Different is welcome, atleat IMO.

As far as Dan Duncan's art.... yeah, I would have loved a ''Star'' artist attached to this book to give it a little attention. Maybe Ethan Van Sciver or Finch. But so far I love everything about the way he draws the turtles. From the Over-exaggerated facial Expressions to the weird plastron designs. LOVE IT ALL. It's different but maybe that's what this franchise needs. Change.

Andrew NDB 08-24-2011 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Revan (Post 871367)
I don't understand how they could be human. We are lead to believe the four turtles in the terrarium are the teenage mutant ninja turtles.

Wait, but they're sea turtles now, right? Sea turtles in a terrarium... isn't that like an oxymoron?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Samhain (Post 871377)
As far as Dan Duncan's art.... yeah, I would have loved a ''Star'' artist attached to this book to give it a little attention. Maybe Ethan Van Sciver or Finch.

Both of those guys are DC exclusive but yes, someone certainly in that vein, if only just for the first story arc.

Buffy 08-24-2011 02:34 PM

Just read it and liked it a lot. I like the fact that they decided to entirely change the origin story and do something else. IDW can go any way they want to now.

Spoiler:
I also think it's a bit weird that the turtles have learned martial arts in only a year time. Maybe they used the technique Neo used in the matrix. :)

PAAATE 08-24-2011 02:39 PM

tl;dr-version: Too much story with too quick of a pace, not enough moments to explore characters.

Long version: It seems a little bland and cliché at this point, but the thing I care the most about are well-written, complex characters, and that's rarely something you achieve in the first issue, so yeah, I'll wait a few issues before I pass any real judgment on this one.

They possibly tried to cram a little too much story into it and not enough true character-moments, but then again, I don't know what the different pay-offs will be, and maybe they need to begin this many stories at once for whatever-they-have-planned to work.

Like I said, I'll wait and see where this is going, but if I had to give the first issue a rating, it would be 3/10

The 3 points comes from Raph's story which is the most interesting so far :P

Abnormal Freak 08-24-2011 02:55 PM

I like it. :) The new stuff brought to the table is a welcome change; it's absurd to think that this book should be like the other origins, and I'm intrigued to see where things go.

And I like Duncan's Turtles and Splinter, and Old Hob looks pretty cool, but I'm not terribly fond of his humans. Then again...I was never terribly fond of Eastman and Laird's humans either. :p

I'm not entirely sure yet what to think of the coloring. On one hand, it seems a little drab; but on the other, it's not the boring, shiny, blatantly obvious computer coloring of most books I flip through, so it gets a lot of appreciation from me for looking pretty unique and creative.

I wish the Eastman covers weren't special variants and were as easily obtainable as the Duncan covers. So bummed I couldn't get hold of Eastman's cover for #1, which I specified I wanted several months in advance. :\ (I'm thinking an employee at the shop snagged it, possibly to sell online. The shop certainly had more than ten copies available so they should have gotten that particular incentive variant.) Duncan's covers are awesome so I'm pleased with my Leonardo cover, but I'd have far preferred to have Eastman's art in my hands.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:45 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.