![]() |
Phelous reviews Turtles Forever
Title says it:
http://www.phelous.com/node/1124 Great Review :) He really nails the overall theme of the dtv and even though I really liked the Turtles Forever I have to admit that he's totally right with all concerns about the Fred Wolf Turtles! |
Eh, our own Professor of Poltergeist, Mark Pellegrini, did a much better job:
http://www.adventuresinpoortaste.com...orever-review/ I have a hard time sitting through the "raving mad retro-purist" schtick. |
Agreed with oldmanwinters. I love Phelous, but that title card with the retro Turtles facepalming the 2k3 Turtles was all I needed to see to know where this review was headed. I hope that people won't be turned off of the special or the 2k3 series in general because of it. That'd be such a shame.
|
I'm always open to hearing different takes on things I like but I just couldn't take this guy seriously. That video encompassed everything I hate about most modern day reviewers. Way too much blind bias, overreacting, shouting and or cursing, stating the obvious, nitpicking, and a need to be funny (or what the reviewer feels being funny means). Don't get me wrong, I love a good rant, but this wasn't one of them imo.
|
I saw where it was heading when he called the Fred Wolf turtles "the real turtles"
I love his reviews, but this one was not his best. not just due to his attitude against the movie, but it just felt less "Phelous" |
Of the "Team That Guy" reviewers, I've never cared for Phelous, but I'll watch because of the Turtles.
|
Oh boy, you know what time it is kids! That's right it's Jester's Play-by-Play Running Commentary!
So he's gripping about the voices. Been there, done that. NEXT! Wait...Turtles 3 version of the Cartoon Turtles. Weren't they pretty much the same thing thanks to parents groups? I guess I should cut him slack, I've done the same level of nitpicking. But I'm part of the fan community, it's almost my job or something. Why are all of the clips of the FW series so far from the pilot "season"? *face palm* How often did the 4Kids Turtles actually say "What the Shell?!" in Turtles Forever? Anyone have a tally? I know I thought the FW Turtles were dumbed down, sure, but Phelous seems to be driven totally nuts by it. I'm sure there were plenty of times, much later in the FW series mind you, that the Turtles DID walk around with out costumes in broad daylight.... someone help me out here. The "Boys in Blue" gag really did happen quite frequently in the FW show. Wait... what does it say that I'm taking the time to point by point refute his point by point "review" of TF? Man, I need a life. I think I'm gonna stop... I'd be here a while if I keep playing "Point Counter Point." Suffice it to say, it ain't nothing that wasn't said better by Doc, like Winter's said above. OK... one more. If the Turtles have analogues in this universe, why wouldn't Shredder look for himself AND Krang? Just because Krang is an extra-dimensional being, doesn't mean he doesn't exist outside his home dimension. There... I'm done. I hope... GAH... here I am again. Karai explains that she was monitoring Ch'rell and was alerted that he disappeared. How she got the the Technodrome may be a leap of logic... but then again, I'm sure the Foot have some sort of Utrom life scan tech... who knows. I'm done now. I promise. Nope... not quite. just gotta say, the Shredder Costume he has makes me laugh. That is all. About the FW Turtles not taking anything seriously... Didn't Raph say, "Not unless we have to." in Turtle Tracks? Then again, I guess the events of TF would be an excuse to "have to" be serious. Wait? TMNT III, Copyright New Line and 20th Century Fox? What? Is New Line a 20th Century Fox imprint in Canada? |
Quote:
|
Weird. Because here Warner Brothers is New Line parent company.
|
Quote:
So most New Line Movies released in the 80s and 90s aren't owned by Warner over here, except they reacquire the License, which they mostly don't do except it is a BIG License were they can get alot of money from (for example the Nightmare in Elm Street Series, which most parts weren't owned by them until 1999 again. The Turtles Movies were never that big since the mid 90s for them so Fox stil ownes Part 2 & 3, while various Indipendent Labels hold Part one (in Germany f.e. it is now WinklerFilm and in the UK it's Fortune Star) The fourth Movie is owned by Warner over here, but was sublicensed to different Companys in most Countries (In the UK Warner is holding full control, while in Germany Universum has it) That's why we will never get a Boxset with all 4 Movies... |
That was a waste of my time. He says he never seen the 2003 show, I'm guessing he's never seen the 1987 show either judging by that review.
|
Quote:
|
BTW, does anybody have the link to this video that shows off all the goofiness of the old Shredder? I recall seeing it posted here once.
|
"I don't wanna conquer this place... I wanna conquer EARRRRTH!"
|
I agree with most of his points, and yes, the Turtles were parodies of themselves. Especially Leonardo, who was always like the over-serious wet blanket of the team, and now suddenly he's as goofy as the others.
He did go overboard and stuff, but I do agree with his comments. I wish he'd at least show Mirage Raph put 2K3 Raph in his place... |
I think what was more annoying and repetitive than the parody FW Turtles in TF, was Phelous' repetitive one joke review. :P
|
My view on it.... it was an old video cause we made it maybe a week after it hit TV. My main nitpicks were how overly-goofy the Turtles were, the Party Wagon, and the fact that TV aired the cut version.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mSLt_ppJfLE |
Quote:
But am with the flanderization of the FW Turtles (OT Leo doesn't deserve to be portrayed as... "another Mikey"). It's... really a poor taste. I mean, can you imagine if Batman The Animated Series makes fun of Adam West? Oh wait, that show didn't. I know 4Kids didn't do this out of "hurr hurr, our version is better than the 80's cause we're more hardcore hurr" thing... but it can come off this way to some viewers. So yeah, so-so with this review. Meh, who knows, maybe the Nick cartoon will make fun of the 4Kids one and then call it even. EDIT: I lold on his version of the OT's theme though. |
Quote:
|
I would point to the BM:TAS episode that guest stared Adam West, but that was much better than Turtles Forever. :P
|
The Fred Wolf Turtles in Turtles Forever are closer to the depiction of the turtles as the show got toned down but even based on those they went overboard with the crying, laughing at their own jokes, always having grins and never taking anything seriously. Particularly in Leonardo and Donatello's case. Donatello was brilliant in the OT and Leonardo always took a fight seriously. So they felt very out of character while Michelangelo was just kind of... there and Raphael was the only marginally well handled OT Turtle. The turtles would at least be able to figure out if they were in a different dimension. They dimension hopped plenty in the OT. Though some argue this takes place early in the OT at which point they had not dimension hopped so much if at all.
Shredder and Krang got to be very silly in the OT so this depiction isn't that far off their post season 1 depiction. The potshots at the equipment (stuff the OT turtles didn't use) and the OT vehicles felt rather needless. They could have standed to depict them as at least a little more serious when danger was afoot because the OT turtles would not cower in a fight or cry like they did. That just took the cake. But you know what I hadn't realized so much before was the 2K3 turtles were kind of "off" in this one as well. They were too easy to frustrate and kind of became a blur of "we're super serious now" losing some of their individual personalities as well. While Mikey was uh... Fast Forward Mikey. Donatello, Raphael and Leonardo all kind of seemed to act like Leonardo would before he grew as a character in the 2K3 series. And Donatello not believing they could make a portal stick? Did they dumb him down in this too because he's seen all kinds of transport technology among other unlikely things. April and Casey hardly got screen time and when they did April sure didn't act as smart as we know she is. So thinking about it, the flaws in depiction of characters doesn't rest solely on the OT characters but arguably the 2003 series characters were simplified to the point of being blunt as well. Which only made the whole "the OT are goofballs" and "why so serious 2K3?" all the more blatant. It's still a very entertaining movie with a lot of fan service and a very fitting end to TMNT pre-Nickelodeon. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
I always interpreted his skepticism as being more due to the fact that the warp stick was made simply by rewiring a flashlight. That is valid, because the warp scepters in the past had very advanced technological/magical backgrounds. It shouldn't be forgotten, though, that:
1) OT Donatello never really said anything like "Science isn't all about facts; it just takes some positive thinking" (I'm paraphrasing, but you get the line I mean.) 2) The flashlight warp stick still worked, so what kind of point were they trying to make by making OT Don sound like an idiot, and then validating him? Furthermore, that stick, detecting the particles from the Technodrome's warp, and the exploding shuriken, are just about the only times any of the OT Turtles did anything truly competent in the whole movie, and these things just don't stand up to logic. First of all, if there was an OT Turtle who was objectively less-competent than his 4Kids counterpart, it was probably Donatello. Often, his machines malfunctioned; probably for the sake of comedy. This isn't really a diss, as I thought 4Kids Donatello went too far on the side of hypercompetence, but it's still an inconsistancy. Second, when the Turtles warp back, they bring the OT vehicles and engage in a scene that makes them out to be pathetic; their laser beams can't hurt the mutants. If OT Don could build a working warp stick out of a common flashlight, how the shell could he fail to build a working laser out of advanced parts he salvaged from Stockman's lab?! Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Unfortunately, they came kind of late to feel vindicated, really... and then we have the OT Turtles crying like wussies. *srsly, when I first saw this, I cringe* There IS an episode this happened btw, but they were hit by Krang's Coward Gun... but yeah I wish that happened in that crossover. Actually, I wish there was an epilogue. OT!Raph uses the personality change ray gun on his Leo and Don, turn to the audience and say "So no flaming, K?" That would really make sense and save their characters. Quote:
Of course, 4Kids does weird things, especially their anime series... but I'll leave it to Little Kuriboh's YGOTAS for that mockery. |
Quote:
|
Ugh, this is painful to watch. Not Turtles Forever, but Phelous' review of it.
Normally, I love stuff from Channel Awesome, and very rarely do I find myself disagreeing with anyone from there. This is one of those few times, AND HOW! I honestly have to wonder if Phelous remembers much of anything about the 1987 cartoon outside of the pilot season. Seriously. And the whole "real Turtles" thing really got on my nerves, but that might be because I'm a comic fan (and believe me, I grew up with the 87 TMNT, too, but geez, his nostalgia goggles are on tight). I guess I shouldn't have expected a very fair review, though, considering the title card. *sighs* And it seems his biased opinions are really influencing his fans, too. It's bad enough how many people dismissed the 2003 cartoon due to their attachment to the 87 series and how they think everything else sucks, but this just makes it all worse. Turtles Forever wasn't perfect, but this was far from a fair review, and honestly, I feel like he was just pointing out the same things over and over again. :ohwell: Man, this review pisses me off... |
But y'know... it's kinda nice. It shows how the Turtles back then gave such a huge impact for them in their childhood.
I wonder if the kids who watched 4Kids TMNT will feel the same 20 years from now, and feel personal slights if they think they're badly misrepresented? |
Ya, I know. And actually, I'm sure plenty of the kids that grew up with the 4Kids TMNT will be just as passionate. Hell, a lot of them have already grown up (2003 was 9 years ago, afterall), too.
Though, I do want to say that while the 87 TMNT were a bit misrepresented in this movie, the same can be said about the 2k3 TMNT (I really felt it was a mistake to use so much of the lingo and characterizations from FF and BttS, as the Turtles were severely dumbed down in those two series/seasons), as well as the 84 TMNT, for that matter. Sure, they might have been really badass in this movie, but they were pretty one-dimensional, and I always cringe whenever I see the scene of 84 Shredder get knocked off the roof with garbage cans in a comedic way. It seems everyone unfamiliar with the original comics thought that scene was hilarious, but I personally hated that part. So, yes, I can see where someone would be upset that the 87 TMNT weren't completely accurate, but I felt Phelous couldn't see past that. And he admitted never seeing the 2003 series, so I know he can't exactly catch that the 2003 TMNT were also misrepresented. And, as I said, the same thing happened to the 84 TMNT, as well (though at least it worked in their favor, with the exception of Shredder). My point is, the 87 TMNT weren't the only ones that were a bit off, and honestly, I really do mean a bit off, as I still feel like most of the people that think they were way off don't entirely remember the bulk of the old cartoon. The only ones that were a major issue, imo, were Donatello and Leonardo. |
I think I'll blame 4Kids inability to write decent comedy. That was the 87's strength really, because they were really funny with their snark and aware of the cliche of an action cartoon.
See how 4Kids tried to make their Mikey the resident comic relief? By making him annoying and obnoxious? OK, that went well. With the 87 Turtles... I felt they went overboard trying to desperately sell that these guys are funny by reducing their common sense (really a huge shame they never referenced the FW Turtles' attachment with the trench coat/fedora). |
Quote:
There's a sequence devoted to Silver Age campery although one could argue that it's as much meant to represent Dick Sprang era comics as much as the 60s show but it's there. And to be honest after season 3 I can't think of many instances was Leonardo acting like a leader beyond saying things like "let's go turtles" and "let's get serious fellas" when needed. He did that in Turtle Forever. The rest of the time he was just as light hearted as the rest. How can anyone watch "Unidentified Flying Leonardo" or "Leonardo Is Missing" or "Snakes Alive" and tell me that Turtle Forever did that version of the character an injustice. Quote:
But this was done to highlight the differences with the '87 turtles. When you take into account the amount of effort to reproduce the look of not just the characters but also the vehicles and locations in perfect detail. Then there's actual lines taken from the OT and homages to various episodes such as Don using a wrench as a hammer etc they got the bebbter end of the deal by far. Let's not forget it was OT Don's weird science that saved the day more than once and it goofy Bebop and Rocksteady that saved the day overall. |
And as we've pointed out many times, Bebop and Rocksteady essentially kill Ch'rell and save the entire multiverse.
Seems fitting that Rocksteady/Bebop would become the saviors of the universe. |
I'm sorry I understand what they were going for but watching the silliest episodes of OT S4 and nowhere in them do they act as goofy as they do here. In fact/ironically they seem to resemble 2k3 Mikey more than their OT selves.
|
I have to agree with sdp here. Like it or not, the FW Turtles are OOC and Flanderized. When 4Kids Mikey was even fed up with them in the movie? Yeah, not good.
|
Seeing the review again, I'm a bit more calm now and can see some of his points, but to me this review is waaaaay too biased.
I have nitpicks about Turtles Forever, too. Most of them, though, are actually more about the 2003 side, but I do think the special could have done a few things differently. I don't think any of that is enough to make it seem "bad", though. If I actually had to nitpick the 1987 TMNT in this, most of what I'd nitpick is stuff Phelous didn't even get into. But, here goes. 1. He sort of has a point about Leonardo and Donatello, as they should have been more serious than Raphael and Michelangelo. But even they had a lot of goofy moments in the old show. This is probably the only point I'll make that actually sorta matches with a point he makes, though. 2. The old toon TMNT never referred to each other as Leo, Don, Raph, or Mikey. They ALWAYS referred to each other by their full names (for whatever reason). 3. They never said the word "ooze", they always said "mutagen". And that's about the extent of my nitpicking about the 1987 TMNT (any other nitpicking I have with the special has to do with characters other than the 87 ones). Outside of these points, I thought they were done justice, and that the special was quite the tribute. Ya, the 2003 TMNT get annoyed with them... but that's not a reflection of how the people making the special feel. It's a reflection of how those CHARACTERS feel. Perhaps they may have laid it on a little thick, but it's to be expected, particularly from 2003 Raphael. Phelous doesn't even MENTION how 2003 Splinter stood up for the 1987 Turtles. Nor does he mention how the comic book Turtles seem to acknowledge them, like 84 Mikey saying "I kinda dug the initials on the belt buckles", and then that they actually go out for pizza (something that the 2003 TMNT kept berating). Hell, how about the fact the friggen' 87 Donatello was the one that saved ALL OF EXISTENCE with his exploding throwing stars? Did Phelous mention that at all? No. Because he was just too blinded with rage to see any of the positive stuff, outside of 87 Splinter's treatment. His arguments about Shredder are null and void, when you consider this is the same Shredder who was being bossed around by his own mother while out on his evil missions, in one episode. To be honest, I find it ironic that Phelous kept saying that the people who made Turtles Forever must not have seen but only 2 or 3 episodes of the show, when it's pretty clear to anyone who's really into the 87 show that Phelous himself was mostly just remembering the not-as-silly 5 episode pilot season when he was pulling his examples. Also, that freakin' title card... gosh, it pisses me off. With that title card, Phelous is doing exactly what he's accusing this special of doing. Ya, I know he didn't draw the title card himself, but I'm sure he instructed whoever did (that being, I think, Andrew Dickman). Still, putting aside any hypocrisy with the explanation that he was merely doing to the 2003 TMNT what the movie was doing to the 1987 TMNT, I want to point out that it's not the same thing at all. I mean, having the 87 Turtles' silly traits (such as the one-liners, being obsessed with pizza, and not take much of anything seriously) become exaggerated isn't a hateful portrayal of them. Perhaps a little Flanderized, as was mentioned before, but certainly not mean-spirited. But the way that the title card for Phelous' review has 2003 Donatello picking his nose? That's pretty damn hateful and not an exaggeration of his character at all, but a straight up defamation of it. In short, Phelous did make a few good points, I'll give him that. But he clung to those same points over and over again, and glossed over most of the actual good points that the movie had going for itself. There were so many fanwanks that he didn't even mention (a lot of them surrounding the 87 cartoon), that I honestly don't think he's anything more than a casual fan, at best. |
I'm debating re-watching Turtles Forever as well as both series to see just how off each team is...but that would take forever. I want results now... NOW... NOW!!!
|
I've said it before, I'll say it again, anyone whining about the OT turtles portrayal in TF missed the entire point of the film. Another person completely blind to the jabs the film made to the other aspects of the franchise. The film was completely self aware and not meant as some hate speech against the OT. Remove the rose tinted glasses, see the OT for what it was, and realize they acted exactly how they should to perfectly contrast them to the more serious turtles.
People act like the OT turtles did nothing to help and were so incompetent in every fight that they had to be rescued. They in fact contributed quite a bit, the portal stick for example, and held their own just fine in all the fight scenes. Their style was different but it worked just like it did in the OT. All the turtles learned in the end that even if they were different they were still turtles. As much as the OT was mocked for being silly the other turtles were mocked for how hardcore they thought they were. Hardly one sided. |
Quote:
|
Who the f**k is Phelous and why should I care what he thinks about something?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Nothing. Okay then. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:33 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.