The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Kevin Eastman On The "Aliens" Issue....Briefly (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=37321)

Bob 04-25-2012 11:08 AM

Kevin Eastman On The "Aliens" Issue....Briefly
 
Not much, but this is so interesting and weird at the same time that I thought it deserved its own thread. Apparently Kevin Eastman had this to say at the Boston Comic Con. He was asked this question:

What are your thoughts on the turtles being aliens in the upcoming film?

Eastman: Fans should check out issues #2-3 of the originals because there are possible hints that the turtles could be alien.

This is the link: http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansit.../news/?a=58434

Does anyone have any idea what he's referring to? Or is he just messing?

TurtleTitan97 04-25-2012 11:12 AM

#2 of TMNT is where they meet Stockman and April, and at the end of #3 Splinter meets the Utroms in an epilouge.

Galactus 04-25-2012 11:25 AM

I must've read #2 a thousand times and #3 a fair amount and if there's any hint that the turtles are aliens in either one then it's gone completely over my head.

Maybe he's getting mixed up and means the TCRI story in #4 which would help cement the idea that the alien aspect that has been referred to by Bay and Leibesman is that the ooze or similar product that will mutate them will be of alien origin.

I realise they are just trying to get tongues wagging but I'd rather they do that with some other ways, like hinting at possible antagonists or general approach. The whole evasiveness on the alien issue from everyone involved is annoying

CyberCubed 04-25-2012 12:09 PM

The problem is nobody associated with the movie flat-out denies that they're going to be aliens. That's what bothers me.

If someone asked if the Turtles are going to be robots or monsters, you'd get a "Hell no!" from them. But when they're asked are they aliens, they just kinda brush it off.

Its sad to see Eastman sell out like this.

Bob 04-25-2012 12:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 940572)
The problem is nobody associated with the movie flat-out denies that they're going to be aliens. That's what bothers me.

It’s because they are aliens. And Eastman and Laird sold out a hell of a long time ago, way before this film.

Toby Barrett 04-25-2012 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 940572)

Its sad to see Eastman sell out like this.

Where in the world have YOU been? XD

Candy Kappa 04-25-2012 12:18 PM

I'm tired of looking at the same picture in every single TMNT related article.

ThePickleweed 04-25-2012 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob (Post 940576)
It’s because they are aliens. And Eastman and Laird sold out a hell of a long time ago, way before this film.

quoted for truthiness

Plasticplayhouse 04-25-2012 12:49 PM

i never understood why people feel that eastman and laird sold out. they created the franchise and expanded on it. wanting to expand/rejouvinate is not selling out. back in the day a lot of comic fans thought they sold out because they made the toon. look how many fans we have and how much further the turtleverse has reached because of it! i am an original comic guy and always will be. i read the books before the toon ever aired, but i appreciate all that the toon has brought us. without that (aka them selling out) we would have never had the first movie and most likely the first series may not have lasted as long as it did...who knows?! point is i dont believe they are/were sellouts. the only selling out that i saw was the actual sale of the franchise.

CyberCubed 04-25-2012 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob (Post 940576)
It’s because they are aliens.

Which sucks.

Toby Barrett 04-25-2012 01:24 PM

Really? I had no idea you felt that way Cyber...

ZariusTwo 04-25-2012 02:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 940607)
Which sucks.

Fearing change as always Cyber?

Bob 04-25-2012 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 940607)
Which sucks.

Just saying. No one has denied it yet because it’s true. I’m dubious of it myself, but I am not ready to pass judgment just yet. Part of me would actually welcome a unique take on the franchise, and there's a fair chance that that's what we're going to get.

ToTheNines 04-25-2012 02:22 PM

I don't get the whole freaking out over changes thing...

I mean, look at Chris Nolan's Batman movies. Are they quintessential Batman? **** no, but they're still very cool movies.

Not to say Liebesman is as good a director as Nolan, but change can be a good thing. If you don't agree, go back to your comics and DVD's. They aren't changing anytime soon.

ThePickleweed 04-25-2012 02:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 940654)
I don't get the whole freaking out over changes thing...

I mean, look at Chris Nolan's Batman movies. Are they quintessential Batman? **** no, but they're still very cool movies.

Not to say Liebesman is as good a director as Nolan, but change can be a good thing. If you don't agree, go back to your comics and DVD's. They aren't changing anytime soon.

ive said it before, and ill repeat it again. its not the changes per se, its the team making the changes. if brad bird, or steven Spielberg, or david fincher were making changes.......im willing to trust their judgement that its for the best, that theyve thought things through, that it'll serve the story, that it may be beneficial. i have faith they are going to make a quality film.

you tell me brett ratner, michael bay, m night shamaylan are making those same changes, and im on edge. im expecting them to make crap on celluloid.

aliens or not, my expectations for this are low. change CAN be good. this creative team is not.

"but dont worry, im a veterinarian."

ahhhh, quality.

CyberCubed 04-25-2012 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 940654)
I don't get the whole freaking out over changes thing...

I mean, look at Chris Nolan's Batman movies. Are they quintessential Batman? **** no, but they're still very cool movies.

Not to say Liebesman is as good a director as Nolan, but change can be a good thing. If you don't agree, go back to your comics and DVD's. They aren't changing anytime soon.

Is Batman's backstory more or less the same? Yes.

The TMNT being aliens alone completely changes who they are. It would be as if Superman isn't from Planet Krypton anymore, but instead a human who was born on Earth.

Spitfire 04-25-2012 05:10 PM

Being the product of an alien created mutagen does not make them aliens. I don't accept that logic at all and if they were aliens I think they'd have said something about it before 25+ years later.

Galactus 04-25-2012 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bob (Post 940576)
It’s because they are aliens.

Really? It's never been confirmed. I still think the more likely scenario is that they will have a more faithful origin and this alien talk is to get people riled so when the movie gets closer they can either go "we've changed our plans to please the fans" or "we always meant the ooze was alien people just jumped to conclusions".

Quote:

Eastman and Laird sold out a hell of a long time ago, way before this film.
Not that simple.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 940654)
I don't get the whole freaking out over changes thing...

I mean, look at Chris Nolan's Batman movies. Are they quintessential Batman? **** no, but they're still very cool movies.

Not to say Liebesman is as good a director as Nolan, but change can be a good thing. If you don't agree, go back to your comics and DVD's. They aren't changing anytime soon.

Batman Begins drew characters and scenes from several seminal Batman graphic novels. The Dark Knight is more loose but it's all still from the comics.

No version of Batman has steered far from the original. He's never been given super powers or had his parents survive or be an alien. Such a change would unecessary. If you want to make a Batman movie you make a Batman movie. If Bay wants to make a movie about aliens then do it, just don't call it Ninja Turtles.

Oculus Orbus 04-25-2012 06:02 PM

I don't mind changes, as long as they somehow add to the story and mythos. Now, making them aliens is not adding or improving, it's just making a completely different thing.

I really don't know what Eastman is trying to say with that quote, but the TMNT never ever were supposed to be aliens in any of the incarnations. I've read those issues hundreds of times and never noticed those hints he's talking about.

Nintendophile 04-25-2012 06:58 PM

It seems like they're trying to say the Turtles are "of alien origin" by means of the fact that the mutagen was of alien origin. Earth turtles + alien ooze = "alien turtles"??? But, like a previous post said, Eastman has "claimed" the canister of ooze that mutated the turtles is the same as the one that gave Daredevil his powers. So, following their convoluted logic, would these people also say that Daredevil is an alien? :trolleye:

Candy Kappa 04-25-2012 07:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Galactus (Post 940721)
No version of Batman has steered far from the original. He's never been given super powers or had his parents survive or be an alien. Such a change would unecessary. If you want to make a Batman movie you make a Batman movie. If Bay wants to make a movie about aliens then do it, just don't call it Ninja Turtles.

Unless they want to make a movie about that else-world story where Kal-El becomes Batman :lol:

Galactus 04-25-2012 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nintendophile (Post 940756)
It seems like they're trying to say the Turtles are "of alien origin" by means of the fact that the mutagen was of alien origin. Earth turtles + alien ooze = "alien turtles"??? But, like a previous post said, Eastman has "claimed" the canister of ooze that mutated the turtles is the same as the one that gave Daredevil his powers. So, following their convoluted logic, would these people also say that Daredevil is an alien? :trolleye:

That's what they're avoiding saying. They continualy point out that an alien aspect to their origin is well engrained in their mythology as a way of rationalising their claim but avoid saying that's how they intend for it to be in the movie which fuels the original theory that the turtles will be aliens themselves.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Candy Kappa (Post 940759)
Unless they want to make a movie about that else-world story where Kal-El becomes Batman :lol:

Ah yes and that would be true to a comic story. Same as if they did a story based on Batman - The Superman of Planet X. Not sure who those movies would appeal to but it there. Giving him Bruce Wayne powers from the off would be something else entirely.

When the franchise was in limbo someone pitched a Batman movie were Bruce was a working class mechanic and Alfred a badass old guy. Naturaly the WB didn't pay attention to this, just as I feel Viacom shouldn't pay attention to TMNT as aliens.

Archon_Turtle 04-25-2012 08:04 PM

Kevin and Peter "selling-out" is what created the OT and built most of your childhoods...so I'm not sure why you're being dicks about it.

...just sayin'.

Xav 04-25-2012 08:37 PM

Peter and Kevin didn't sell out when they made the OT, they still owned the rights to the franchise.

Nintendophile 04-26-2012 01:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Galactus (Post 940780)
That's what they're avoiding saying. They continualy point out that an alien aspect to their origin is well engrained in their mythology as a way of rationalising their claim but avoid saying that's how they intend for it to be in the movie which fuels the original theory that the turtles will be aliens themselves.

Yeah, they're being purposefully vague, and it's all coming down to a game of semantics. Kind of frustrating.

At this point, just about any outcome would seem unideal. Either:

A) They actually make the Turtles an alien species from another world, which would pretty effectively divide the fan-base.

B) They were never going to make the Turtles aliens, and were purposely using word-play to make it sound like they were, to create an artificial buzz around the movie, which fans wouldn't take too kindly to, feeling like they've been teased and lied to.

Or

C) They pull the ol' switch-a-roo, and say something like "We've listened to the fans, and have decided to keep the Turtles origins true to previous incarnations", which could be taken as "FINE, you've b*tched and moaned enough, so we've changed it back, HAPPY now?", which would feel like pandering instead of an act of appreciation.

It's just been blown up into such a big fiasco, that it seems like however it resolves itself, there's going to be a large chunk of the fan-base that aren't going to be happy. BUT, I guess that was pretty much going to happen anyway, even without all this hullabaloo. lol. Turtles fans are almost always divided. We're an opinionated bunch. lol. :tlol:

CJStyles 04-26-2012 02:06 AM

Eastman and Laird didn't sell out... they bought in!

Andrew NDB 04-26-2012 02:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nintendophile (Post 940911)
Yeah, they're being purposefully vague, and it's all coming down to a game of semantics. Kind of frustrating.

At this point, just about any outcome would seem unideal. Either:

A) They actually make the Turtles an alien species from another world, which would pretty effectively divide the fan-base.

B) They were never going to make the Turtles aliens, and were purposely using word-play to make it sound like they were, to create an artificial buzz around the movie, which fans wouldn't take too kindly to, feeling like they've been teased and lied to.

Or

C) They pull the ol' switch-a-roo, and say something like "We've listened to the fans, and have decided to keep the Turtles origins true to previous incarnations", which could be taken as "FINE, you've b*tched and moaned enough, so we've changed it back, HAPPY now?", which would feel like pandering instead of an act of appreciation.

It's just been blown up into such a big fiasco, that it seems like however it resolves itself, there's going to be a large chunk of the fan-base that aren't going to be happy. BUT, I guess that was pretty much going to happen anyway, even without all this hullabaloo. lol. Turtles fans are almost always divided. We're an opinionated bunch. lol. :tlol:

Whoever wins, we lose.

Nintendophile 04-26-2012 02:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 940914)
Whoever wins, we lose.

Exactly. It's gotten past the point of discussion.

Archon_Turtle 04-26-2012 02:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xav (Post 940801)
Peter and Kevin didn't sell out when they made the OT, they still owned the rights to the franchise.

I think you're confusing "sell out" with "sell off"

Xav 04-26-2012 04:09 AM

I'm not, but that's what Eastman has said.

Venom 04-26-2012 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xav (Post 940925)
I'm not, but that's what Eastman has said.

If you read the context in which Kevin is stating they didn't "sell out", it was typically in regards to E&L losing their "indie cred" when the OT debuted. In this case, he was referring to the artistic integrity being compromised.

Even up into the mid-00's, after Kevin sold his creative interest to the Turtles over to Peter, was still saying he didn't "sell out" his share of the Turtles then went on to clarify his remaining ownership. That is a case of him meaning "selling off", to an extent.

Stingray69 04-26-2012 01:54 PM

Why is it then when somebody becomes successfull, there automatic sellouts?

Venom 04-26-2012 02:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stingray69 (Post 941073)
Why is it then when somebody becomes successfull, there automatic sellouts?

In the case of Eastman and Laird, from what I've read about the comic scene in the early 80's and gleaned from older posters on other sites, the two were seen at first as being these indie superstars; 2 guys who dug comics came up with a goofy idea they thought was fun, made a book about and struck indie gold by selling hundreds of thousands of copies of their book. The indie equivalent to hitting the lottery, if you will.

Then in the late '80's, when the cartoon and toy deal was made, a lot of the folks who got the comics and played the RPG felt E&L had become greedy and lost their integrity by letting their creations become very diluted versions to cater to little kids. Those same kids that grew up to be most of us.

We younger comc fans somewhat humorously refer to the older, original fans of the comic as an almost legendary, mythical entity like "the Lost Generation" or something because you rarely find someone these days who regularly followed the books back then.

Galactus 04-26-2012 02:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nintendophile (Post 940911)
Yeah, they're being purposefully vague, and it's all coming down to a game of semantics. Kind of frustrating.

At this point, just about any outcome would seem unideal. Either:

A) They actually make the Turtles an alien species from another world, which would pretty effectively divide the fan-base.

B) They were never going to make the Turtles aliens, and were purposely using word-play to make it sound like they were, to create an artificial buzz around the movie, which fans wouldn't take too kindly to, feeling like they've been teased and lied to.

Or

C) They pull the ol' switch-a-roo, and say something like "We've listened to the fans, and have decided to keep the Turtles origins true to previous incarnations", which could be taken as "FINE, you've b*tched and moaned enough, so we've changed it back, HAPPY now?", which would feel like pandering instead of an act of appreciation.

This is how I feel.

I do think they hope that if it ends up options B or C that fans that got so up in arms about the alien issue will be so happy and relieved they'll flock to the movie.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 940914)
Whoever wins, we lose.

I wouldn't go that far. We could end up with a good movie with options B or C. To be fair they could make a good movie with the turtles as aliens, they could make almost everything else incredibly faithful to the overall plot and feel of the Mirage book bar the origin...although I don't hold out much hope of that.

1984TMNT 04-26-2012 04:58 PM

Honestly, I think all of this alien talk was taken out of context. The Origin of the turtles is alien because the ooze that transforms them is a by-product of the transmat device the Utroms were working on.

Not entirely sure why people are still freaking out. Seems pretty obvious to me, at this point. People linked to the movie aren't saying much of anything about it at this point - which doesn't equate to "Yes, we are making the TMNT ALIENS!!!".

Galactus 04-26-2012 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1984TMNT (Post 941127)
Honestly, I think all of this alien talk was taken out of context. The Origin of the turtles is alien because the ooze that transforms them is a by-product of the transmat device the Utroms were working on.

Not entirely sure why people are still freaking out. Seems pretty obvious to me, at this point. People linked to the movie aren't saying much of anything about it at this point - which doesn't equate to "Yes, we are making the TMNT ALIENS!!!".

Bay's words were very exact. The conclusion to draw from his initial words was that the turtles would be aliens.

Of course it could be a mistake on his part. Leibesman's followup is more reassuring but he's only pointing there's an alien element to their origin in almost all versions of the TMNT which may lead people to draw the conclusion that will the case in the upcoming movie but there's zero confirmation or denial on the issue of the characters themselves being aliens. Kevin's take on this seems to muddy the waters further.

There's nothing to take out of context. If we are to believe Bay the turtles will be aliens. If we are to believe Leibesman and Kevin this may not the case but if it is it's not a stretch from what we've gotten before in their opinions.

1984TMNT 04-26-2012 05:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Galactus (Post 941150)
Bay's words were very exact. The conclusion to draw from his initial words was that the turtles would be aliens.

Of course it could be a mistake on his part. Leibesman's followup is more reassuring but he's only pointing there's an alien element to their origin in almost all versions of the TMNT which may lead people to draw the conclusion that will the case in the upcoming movie but there's zero confirmation or denial on the issue of the characters themselves being aliens. Kevin's take on this seems to muddy the waters further.

There's nothing to take out of context. If we are to believe Bay the turtles will be aliens. If we are to believe Leibesman and Kevin this may not the case but if it is it's not a stretch from what we've gotten before in their opinions.

This is all your opinion, just like I'm stating my opinion. I simply expressed that it's conceivable that people are taking his words out of context. What to conclude is subjective, so stating with certainty that one should come to only one conclusion is asinine.

You just proved my point here -
Quote:

but there's zero confirmation or denial on the issue of the characters themselves being aliens
Sorry, I don't see it or interpret it that way. You really believe Michael Bay's 2 sentence description of a movie that didn't even have a complete script? They guy was up there helping promote Viacom and most likely will have little to do with the new movie. They probably gave him a brief summary of what the hell the TMNT were right before he went on stage, in all seriousness (which included: aliens come to earth; are trying to get back by building portal to home world; by-product ooze created as result, accidentally comes into contact with turtles; presto - mutant turtles). He probably took that, and on his own, declared these turtles will have an alien origin. He never said "these turtles ARE aliens" - in fact, he said "These turtles are from an alien race, and they’re going to be tough, edgy, funny, and completely lovable.”; therefore, concluding that they are alien IS in fact taking his words out of context, if they in fact turn out to not be aliens.

Do you really think Kevin is going to be "totally stoked" by them completely changing what the TMNT are? If you do think that they are going to be Aliens, then, ok. I just don't think that is going to happen. If I'm wrong, I'll come back here and eat crow once we know "officially".

I think it's pretty ridiculous that we even have to debate this. lol

Jester 04-26-2012 06:32 PM

That's exactly it. We don't know 100% if they are or aren't going to be aliens, but no one has come out and said that the Turtles will not be aliens either. They've vaguely hinted that we are idiots because the origin of the ooze is alien. Gee, thanks for alleviating my fears by calling me a moron for worrying because some knob said they are "from an alien race" which is very easy to misconstrue as the Turtles themselves are aliens and not just the mutangenic compound is of alien origin.

It may not happen, and I hope it doesn't, but they've been very vague, and it's still something that I'm a little worried about. And I don't think it's as far fetched to worry about it as you think.

Galactus 04-26-2012 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1984TMNT (Post 941161)
This is all your opinion, just like I'm stating my opinion. I simply expressed that it's conceivable that people are taking his words out of context. What to conclude is subjective, so stating with certainty that one should come to only one conclusion is asinine.

That's the natural conclusion that most would draw from bay's words.

Quote:

Sorry, I don't see it or interpret it that way. You really believe Michael Bay's 2 sentence description of a movie that didn't even have a complete script? They guy was up there helping promote Viacom and most likely will have little to do with the new movie. They probably gave him a brief summary of what the hell the TMNT were right before he went on stage, in all seriousness (which included: aliens come to earth; are trying to get back by building portal to home world; by-product ooze created as result, accidentally comes into contact with turtles; presto - mutant turtles). He probably took that, and on his own, declared these turtles will have an alien origin. He never said "these turtles ARE aliens" - in fact, he said "These turtles are from an alien race, and they’re going to be tough, edgy, funny, and completely lovable.”; therefore, concluding that they are alien IS in fact taking his words out of context, if they in fact turn out to not be aliens.
That is a possibility.

As others on here have said on here Bay is the kind of producer that likes to get deep in to oversee everything and why not? It's his money and his name attached. I can accept that he may have worded it wonkily but in his followup he simply told us to chill and made a reference to the script, he did not say fans and the press had taken his words out of context. Leibesman made a statement specificaly to talk about the issue and never corrected it and now we have Kevin muddying the waters.

Regardless of their intentions to the characters. They obviously want the public to think there's a strong possibility the turtles will be aliens. They want the press attention otherwise they'd publicaly debunk the whole TMNT as aliens issue.

Quote:

Do you really think Kevin is going to be "totally stoked" by them completely changing what the TMNT are? If you do think that they are going to be Aliens, then, ok. I just don't think that is going to happen. If I'm wrong, I'll come back here and eat crow once we know "officially".
I think Kevin is not the type to rock the boat in general and especialy if he's being employed by them. I think he'd say he was stoked even if he was rolling his eyes at all their decisions. I also think it's very possibile he'd be legitimateky excited at a movie which changed the turtles to aliens. Anyone remember that dark and gritty series Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation? I don't think he'd capable of being the "bad guy" on issues like this.

1984TMNT 04-27-2012 11:08 AM

Meh, I see your point and it's valid. I think mine is as well. I sure hope they don't f things up. We'll have to wait and see.

The one thing I will say, however, is that Michael Bay's company is producing the film - he's not directing it himself. There is a biiig difference between the two, and I'm not confident that he wants to be as involved with the details as you and others fear.

We'll see, however.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:04 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.