The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Off screen violence in new TMNT (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=3806)

Karpo_007 05-13-2003 10:55 AM

Off screen violence in new TMNT
 
When we first heard that new TMNT was going to be on a saturday morning slot, many people, including myself were worried that it would be just another cartoon written for kids. Luckily we were wrong, the show has probably one of the best writing teams I have ever seen on a cartoon show. And same goes for the animation.

And what I especially do like about this cartoon is, that characters can die. It makes the world much more realistic. Of course every death scene has happened off screen, but what wonders me is how they can get away with even that.

To my understanding both He-man and JLA are aired on a later timeslot, but neither of these shows have showed any death in them. Those are the best examples of modern cartoon I can compare the TMNT to. Im extremely happy how the show has turned out, and I like how much the writers are allowed to do, but It is a saturday morning cartoon. And I don't know any other Saturday morning cartoon that would have death in them.

Shaggz 05-13-2003 11:59 AM

Death is inevitable.
 
I agree. I couldn't believe that scene with Shredder, Hun, and Yoshi. That was pretty graphic for Saturday morning. First they electrically shock Yoshi like crazy then they show Shredder raising his claws before delivering the death blow. That was all very graphic, and done quite beautifully I might add. I never expected such a mature show after the last TMNT cartoon, and I couldn't be more satisfied.

Ultimate Muscle was hilarious a couple weeks ago! One of the wrestlers(BoneCold) shot this little green guy(Minch) right in the face with a retractable knife blade that extends from his arm. In the Japanese version it is clearly obvious that he was killed, but in the translation it was said that he broke his hip. It was ridiculous because he was then shown lying on an alter with his son grieving over his father's "hip surgery"/death. What's more, this week he did a Yoda/Obi/Vader type scene at the end where he was looking down on everybody. None the less it was quite comical, but I feel it is unnecessary to avoid such issues like death even on a children's cartoon show.

Without having death being present, when it is necessary, it can really take away from the impact of the story. Showing Yoshi's death was important to the story, but what about the others?

Karpo_007 05-13-2003 12:12 PM

Im not sure are the other deth important to the story, but it usually goes to show how dangereous and ruthless Shredder is, or in last episode how dangerous the mutants are. And Like I said before, it makes the world of the show much more believable.

Aztec General 05-13-2003 01:07 PM

Death in the new TMNT series has furthered the story as well as shown Shredder to be a truly vile enemy.

I too am shocked (pleasantly) at the level of violence in the new series. The writers of this series are not only extremely talented, they have guts. I truly admire that. Let's be honest, the Mirage comics (which this show is largely based off of) were quite violent and serious. The comic storyline would not be able to work if it was watered down to the usual Saturday morning level; let alone the level of the original TMNT cartoon :dead: .

This show truly deserves great praise. It is action packed, daring, violent, exciting, and at the same time humorus. Mirage, 4Kids, Dong Woo, and Fox have really outdone themselves. The only other recent cartoons that I can think of that are comparable are Batman:TAS and X-Men (90's). But even the Batman show didn't have any kind of story structure. Every episode was a self contained 30 minute adventure (minus a few 2 parters). The entire first season of this show has a coherent story structure with evolving characters. I can't wait for season 2.

Karpo_007 05-13-2003 01:14 PM

Yes, the team behind this show is amazing. This could very well be the best cartoon show I've seen. But Batman TAS, as cool as it was didn't have any death in it, every enemy were always saved by a miracle. If villain should drop from a plane, of course he would land in a tree. :lol: But of course Batman TAS was made at the same time as old TMNT cartoon, and back then there just couldn't be death in cartoon shows. And I tought there couldn't be today either, until I saw the new TMNT show.

TheShredder 05-13-2003 02:02 PM

Having off screen death is probability the only way they can doe it. Does anyone notice they kick people alot in this show? They never stab anyone with a sword.

Aztec General 05-13-2003 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheShredder
Having off screen death is probability the only way they can doe it. Does anyone notice they kick people alot in this show? They never stab anyone with a sword.

That's true and it is kind of annoying. There's no reason why Leo and Raph can't strike opponents with their weapons. They don't have to show blood or the weapons piercing the skin, the act of striking implies enough.

Tokka-B 05-13-2003 02:50 PM

Ok, obviously none of you watch Nick or CN....there is blood and death in many of their shows often more than once per show! that shows you death and blood don't make a show more mature, it is probly something that has become more of a child's thing....

Karpo_007 05-13-2003 03:28 PM

Ok, so what other saturday morning cartoons have more death and violence than TMNT? You say there are many, so start listing. And saying that violent death in cartoons are childrens thing... :lol:

About the sword thing, my guess is they think it's to violent.

Anarchistguy 05-13-2003 04:44 PM

To be frank with you, I think the amount of violence in TMNT 2003 is pretty normal. I don't know what you guys get excited about. Jackie Chan Adventures was pretty "violent" too and no one got excited over it. And what about the Dragonball cartoons, Batman TAS and Batman Beyond?

Karpo_007 05-13-2003 04:51 PM

Like I said, I compare it to modern cartoons like JLA and He-man. Neither of those have death in them. So you say there are other saturday morning cartoons with more violence and death, list them.

EDit: Batman TAS or Beyond do not have any death, the spin of movies of those do however. But as far as I know neither wasn't aired in saturday morning either.

Anarchistguy 05-13-2003 05:06 PM

Okay,

Dragonball Z has death, MANY deaths
hell, even Sailor moon has death

Tokka-B 05-13-2003 06:04 PM

Sheesh, as if Looney Toons isn't enough... :roll: :roll: :roll: THERE ARE THOUSANDS!!

Kameko 05-13-2003 06:14 PM

Fer Frickin' sake.....

We're not talking about Wile E. getting flattened by an anvil and popping back up, perfectly fine, a second later. We're talking about people actually dying, possibly horrible deaths, and NOT being perfectly fine the next episode (or scene, for that matter...)

Stefano 05-13-2003 06:33 PM

who cares it makes me feel like a big boy wacthing it. Now its no so kidsy

Peanut 05-13-2003 07:00 PM

I've never been able to stomach an entire episode of Dragonball Z but the deaths I have seen seem to be pretty mellow. The guy disappears into a ball of blue light and you see shreds of clothes around his body. That's about it. Of course correct me if I'm wrong.

Meira-Bates 05-13-2003 07:30 PM

Not to mention Dragon Ball Z is anime, it was made for Japanese audiances originaly...big cutural diffrences and such...and the DBZ most people have seen is edited. Same goes for Sailor Moon.

PWDESAI 05-13-2003 07:33 PM

I have to agree with you guys here, I couldn't be any happier than I am now with how this show turned out. We all had mixed feelings after hearing the intro song i'm sure ;) but thank God the theme song didn't foreshadow or reflect upon the cartoon itself. TMNT 4 LIFE

Shellfox 05-13-2003 08:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by anarchistguy
Okay,

Dragonball Z has death, MANY deaths
hell, even Sailor moon has death

yeah but by the end of the arc, all but a handful of people are dead, almost all of them badguys in DBZ

And bleeding from the mouth and nose really shouldn't count torwads violence cause they do that in most comidy shows.

Personally I'm just waiting for that one parent to get made at soming they see in TMNT, forcing protests and watch as the guys are transformed into such a squecky clean version of them selves that the old toon TMNT will seem like hell raising monsters in comparision

Krangfan 05-13-2003 08:41 PM

You guys are forgetting one of the best examples of violence in the new TMNT: Baxter Stockman's eye patch! And who knows if he survived after is Foot Tech Ninjas failed :dead: :sick:

Jephael 05-13-2003 08:53 PM

I do believe he'll appear again in the "Return to New York" trilogy, but in some other form ( :twink: )

J Legault 05-13-2003 09:21 PM

He will when he becomes a freaky cyborg and battle the Turtles for Revenge!

Tetsu Deinonychus 05-13-2003 09:28 PM

I find it odd that they're combining Volume 2 with "Return to NY".

Back on Topic: Also eps. like Garbageman have important lessons so hopefully Parents notice that more than the violence, and consider the show good for kids.

Karpo_007 05-14-2003 02:34 AM

So far 2 people have said there are many examples, but no one has been unable to say a name of a saturday morning show with more death and violence. Except anime but like said before you can't comapre that to TMNT.

Pepzi 05-14-2003 05:10 AM

cartoon violence.... it's what ilive for....:D

Karpo_007 05-14-2003 06:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TetsuDeinonychus
I find it odd that they're combining Volume 2 with "Return to NY".

Back on Topic: Also eps. like Garbageman have important lessons so hopefully Parents notice that more than the violence, and consider the show good for kids.

Well the violence for the most part is not to graphical. I don't think parents will be complaining about it.

PWDESAI 05-14-2003 11:28 AM

Well he-man jla is actually pretty graphical, and some of those gay cartoon cartoons have blood in them sometimes. I don't think violence is what makes a cartoon tv show good, it's the writing and the animation. More so the writing. Good character devlopment is better than killing random people.

The Master Meglomaniac 05-14-2003 11:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karpo_007
Like I said, I compare it to modern cartoons like JLA and He-man. Neither of those have death in them. So you say there are other saturday morning cartoons with more violence and death, list them.

EDit: Batman TAS or Beyond do not have any death, the spin of movies of those do however. But as far as I know neither wasn't aired in saturday morning either.

Mr.Fixx died in Batman Beyond when his airship crashed into the sea, you never saw Mr.Fixx. Also Blight died when he blew up his sub, after that he was never seen again. Also I think Mysterio died in the Spider-Man TAS cartoon when the cave complex under Wonder Studios blew up, he was never seen in the series again after that either. Not to mention Batman's parents died in dreams and flashbacks in the Batman TAS show. Oh and they had a death camp in the "Days of the Future Past Part One" episode of X-Men TAS. Also Darksied killed Dan Turpin on screen in "Apokolips... Now!, Part 2" with his Omega beams in Superman TAS.

Shellfox 05-14-2003 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Master Meglomaniac
Also Blight died when he blew up his sub, after that he was never seen again. .

But at the nd of that ep, didn't batman sorta indicate that his dad may have still been alive, same with Inque.
I don't think they were so much dead as open ended and the writers just never found a good place to use them, kinda like what they did with stalker in the first ep then brought him back later.

AAnd I still say, be happy with the amount you get, cause at some point some straight laced parent will get bent out of shape about some one dieing on the show then, say hello to the return of the old show style stories

The Master Meglomaniac 05-14-2003 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shellfox
Quote:

Originally Posted by The Master Meglomaniac
Also Blight died when he blew up his sub, after that he was never seen again. .

But at the nd of that ep, didn't batman sorta indicate that his dad may have still been alive, same with Inque.
I don't think they were so much dead as open ended and the writers just never found a good place to use them, kinda like what they did with stalker in the first ep then brought him back later.

AAnd I still say, be happy with the amount you get, cause at some point some straight laced parent will get bent out of shape about some one dieing on the show then, say hello to the return of the old show style stories

Perhaps but when a villain's hideout blows up and they never appear series again what else can they be doing but becoming worm food. However you can use the Clayface arguement to counter that when everyone thought Clayface had died in the orginal Fox run of Batman TAS, but he came back in the second WB run of Batman TAS. However it is certain that Darksied kiled Dan Turpin on camera in Superman TAS and that show lasted another season.

Edit: Also they showed those Sentinel run termination camps (really death camps) in X-Men TAS in the "Days of the Future Past" episodes and that didn't result in the series being watered down.

Anarchistguy 05-14-2003 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shellfox
Quote:

Originally Posted by The Master Meglomaniac
Also Blight died when he blew up his sub, after that he was never seen again. .

AAnd I still say, be happy with the amount you get, cause at some point some straight laced parent will get bent out of shape about some one dieing on the show then, say hello to the return of the old show style stories

If those parents give Mikey some kind of rope with a turtle shell on it, I'm gonna be REALLY pissed.

Karpo_007 05-14-2003 01:26 PM

I have watched whole Batman TAS and Beyond series, All I can remeber is that the enemies were always saved by a miracle in Batman TAS. I don't rememeber an episode with flash backs of Wayne's Parents dieing, All I can remember is that it happend in Mask of Phantasm. Well it is a long time ago, I could be mistaken.



Quote:

But at the nd of that ep, didn't batman sorta indicate that his dad may have still been alive, same with Inque.
I don't think they were so much dead as open ended and the writers just never found a good place to use them, kinda like what they did with stalker in the first ep then brought him back later.

AAnd I still say, be happy with the amount you get, cause at some point some straight laced parent will get bent out of shape about some one dieing on the show then, say hello to the return of the old show style stories
This is how I remember it in Batman beyond to. On top of my head I cannot come up with any clear death from that show, but the un cut version of "Return of Joker" was pretty violent. But thats how it always is in DC and Marvel, nobody dies for real. Of course Shredder did come back to...

And we shouldn't worry, this show won't become the old one. Laird would probably pull the plug long before that could happen.

Anarchistguy 05-14-2003 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karpo_007
The un cut version of "Return of Joker" was pretty violent.

It's not that I'm doubtful, but what was so violent? I'm getting memory blanks.

Quote:

in DC and Marvel, nobody dies for real
Nobody dies in Marvel? What about Gwen Stacy in Spiderman

Quote:

And we shouldn't worry, this show won't become the old one. Laird would probably pull the plug long before that could happen.
I sure hope you're right... :|

[/quote]

Karpo_007 05-14-2003 03:48 PM

Well im rememebring the cartoon, not 100% for sure about it...

The Master Meglomaniac 05-14-2003 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karpo_007
I have watched whole Batman TAS and Beyond series, All I can remeber is that the enemies were always saved by a miracle in Batman TAS. I don't rememeber an episode with flash backs of Wayne's Parents dieing, All I can remember is that it happend in Mask of Phantasm. Well it is a long time ago, I could be mistaken.



Quote:

But at the nd of that ep, didn't batman sorta indicate that his dad may have still been alive, same with Inque.
I don't think they were so much dead as open ended and the writers just never found a good place to use them, kinda like what they did with stalker in the first ep then brought him back later.

AAnd I still say, be happy with the amount you get, cause at some point some straight laced parent will get bent out of shape about some one dieing on the show then, say hello to the return of the old show style stories
This is how I remember it in Batman beyond to. On top of my head I cannot come up with any clear death from that show, but the un cut version of "Return of Joker" was pretty violent. But thats how it always is in DC and Marvel, nobody dies for real. Of course Shredder did come back to...

And we shouldn't worry, this show won't become the old one. Laird would probably pull the plug long before that could happen.

There was a flashback of Batman's parents dying off camera in a dream in the episode Dreams of Darkness. Batman dreams due to Scarecrow's fear gas that his parents go into a tunnel, that transforms into a giant gun with blood dripping out of it and then the gun fires.

There was a clear death in Superman TAS when Darksied used his Omega Beams on Dan Turpin on camera and that show wasn't watered down after that event. Also there have been many permnate deaths in DC and Marvel, Batman's parents, Uncle Ben Parker, Bucky I, Robin II (Jason Todd), Flash (Barry Allen), Captain George Stacy, Baron Heinrich Zemo, Gwen Stacy, Mirror Master I (Sam Scudder) and that's just off the top of my head.

Karpo_007 05-14-2003 04:05 PM

Ok, so there are few cartoon besides TMNT that have death to. Was Spider-man aired in saturday morning to? I have watched the whole Spider-man cartoon ages ago, but I don't rememeber those death scenes or hoe graphical they were. The current leve in TMNT is fine, and will not get any parents excited.

The Master Meglomaniac 05-14-2003 04:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Karpo_007
Ok, so there are few cartoon besides TMNT that have death to. Was Spider-man aired in saturday morning to? I have watched the whole Spider-man cartoon ages ago, but I don't rememeber those death scenes or hoe graphical they were. The current leve in TMNT is fine, and will not get any parents excited.

Not Spider-Man, Superman TAS. It used air Sat mornings on Kids WB, however I live in Canada so I had to watch it on Global which aired it Sun mornings. Anyway it happened in in the episode "Apokolips... Now!, Part 2" Now I must warn you there are spoilers ahead. In that epsode Darksied kicks Superman's butt and chains to the top of a giant Apokolipitic tank. Darksied tells the people of Earth that now their hero is broken that they have no chance and they should simply bow to him. Police Detective Dan Turpin then insights a normal crowd of humans to fight against Darksied's forces. I believe Turpin even manages to get Superman free some how. Anyway Darksied is ticked off and is about to kill the whole crowd when the forces of new gensis appear and inform Darksied that Earth his under their protection. Darksied decides to cut his losses and his forces to retreat rather start a new war with New Gensis. Darksied creates a boom tube portal leading back to Apokolips, but before he leaves he says "Remember every victory has its price" and uses his Omega Beams to vaporized Dan Turpin. Superman calls Darksied a murderer and flys after Darksied, but Darksied manages to escape. Superman is so ticked he starts trashing Darksied's tank with a blows so powerful that they cause minor earthquakes. The episode ends with a funeral for Dan Turpin and Superman looking over his grave. The episode is tributed to Jack Kirby.

Shellfox 05-14-2003 04:36 PM

No ones debating that Dan Turpin died in the show, but the way he died wasn't very graphic if I remeber right, one moment he was there, the next he was gone.
Yes there a hand full of Comic book chacters that stay dead but the vast majority don't, even Gwen Stacy was reserected after a fasion

The Master Meglomaniac 05-14-2003 06:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shellfox
No ones debating that Dan Turpin died in the show, but the way he died wasn't very graphic if I remeber right, one moment he was there, the next he was gone.
Yes there a hand full of Comic book chacters that stay dead but the vast majority don't, even Gwen Stacy was reserected after a fasion

I thought we debating whether any other characters have died on Sat morning cartoon show. I don't know if this counts but in the Batman episode "Over the Edge" on the WB run Batgirl is exposed to Scarecrow's fear gas and has a nightmare that where she dies and what results from that. In said nightmare Scarecrow knocks Batgirl off the roof of the City Hall and you see her dead body, of course since that was a dream it may not really count. Well Gwen Stacy
thing is up for debate, I believe a clone of her is running around or something, but the rest of the characters I have mentioned have stayed dead.

Edit: of course the cartoon to have the most graphic violence was the Spawn cartoon on HBO. Of course that wasn't a Sat morning cartoon and frankly it more violence, sex and swearing then a lot of R rated movies.

Karpo_007 05-15-2003 01:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Master Meglomaniac
Quote:

Originally Posted by Karpo_007
Ok, so there are few cartoon besides TMNT that have death to. Was Spider-man aired in saturday morning to? I have watched the whole Spider-man cartoon ages ago, but I don't rememeber those death scenes or hoe graphical they were. The current leve in TMNT is fine, and will not get any parents excited.

Not Spider-Man, Superman TAS. It used air Sat mornings on Kids WB, however I live in Canada so I had to watch it on Global which aired it Sun mornings. Anyway it happened in in the episode "Apokolips... Now!, Part 2" Now I must warn you there are spoilers ahead. In that epsode Darksied kicks Superman's butt and chains to the top of a giant Apokolipitic tank. Darksied tells the people of Earth that now their hero is broken that they have no chance and they should simply bow to him. Police Detective Dan Turpin then insights a normal crowd of humans to fight against Darksied's forces. I believe Turpin even manages to get Superman free some how. Anyway Darksied is ticked off and is about to kill the whole crowd when the forces of new gensis appear and inform Darksied that Earth his under their protection. Darksied decides to cut his losses and his forces to retreat rather start a new war with New Gensis. Darksied creates a boom tube portal leading back to Apokolips, but before he leaves he says "Remember every victory has its price" and uses his Omega Beams to vaporized Dan Turpin. Superman calls Darksied a murderer and flys after Darksied, but Darksied manages to escape. Superman is so ticked he starts trashing Darksied's tank with a blows so powerful that they cause minor earthquakes. The episode ends with a funeral for Dan Turpin and Superman looking over his grave. The episode is tributed to Jack Kirby.

You were talking about Uncle Ben, Gwen stacy and Captain stacy, so you were saying that Spider-man had some death to. I have never watched that much Superman, but I don't remrmber any clear death scenes in Spider-Man TAS. But it is so long time ago that I could be mistaken.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:27 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.