The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   MCRG: #37 - Twilight of the Ring (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=40534)

DrSpengler 12-22-2012 06:06 PM

MCRG: #37 - Twilight of the Ring
 
I was reading TMNT (Vol. 1) #37 today so I could review it. It had been a loooong time since I'd read the issue, so I'd forgotten so much about the story. It struck me as one of the more thought-provoking Vol. 1 issues and got me in the mood to try and spark up some discussion.

The subject matter involved the Turtles having to get in touch with their spiritual roots as animals, their "reptile heritage", and coming to terms with the fact that they're a part of both the human and animal worlds due to the nature of their creation (normal animals that were turned into "men"). "Souls Winter" had just handled that exact topic an issue ago, with one of the Turtles literally fighting for his right to have a soul, but I think "Twilight of the Ring" actually wrung a little more out of the concept.

What really struck me, though, was the actual point of their quest to defeat the Adversary and save the Father of All Reptiles. The setup was that all dominant life works in a cycle (or ring) and there are rises and there are falls. The reptiles fell after the age of the dinosaurs and that mammals rose to inherit the Earth. But the Adversary broke the cycle by imprisoning the Father and, if nothing was done, mammals would rule the Earth forever.

By killing the Adversary and freeing the Father, Leonardo basically ensured the inevitable destruction of all mankind.

It was an interesting ending, in that it was played like any other victorious "happy ending", but it becomes less so the more you think about it. Leo did the right thing in a cosmic sort of way by restoring the balance, but restoring the balance meant ensuring that one day humanity (mammals) will fall and the reptiles will again inherit the Earth.

The issue was packed with twists like that. Such as Donatello being possessed and becoming the Shaman of the Father, only to get trashed by the Adversary near the end and reveal that Leo was the true Shaman the whole time. Or the Adversary being revealed to be a giant rat and the ultimate enemy of the reptiles; an interesting inversion considering who their adoptive father is.

What was really cool was that I hadn't realized before that McCollum and Anderson had been building toward "Twilight of the Ring" with their two Turtle Soup shorts, "Donatello: The Ring" and "Raphael: Snapper". In both stories, the Father speaks to each Turtle about their forgotten reptile heritage, but in a way each Turtle can understand. To Raph, he appears as a giant snapping turtle and pummels the crap out of him; knowing that violence is what Raph best responds to. For Donatello, he appeared during a moment of introspection and contemplation, as that's Don's strong suit.

A shame they never finished the series with Michelangelo and Leonardo segments, as I'd like to know how the Father would have elected to speak to them.

Anyway, it was a story that really piqued my interest. And being a one-shot in Vol. 1 during the guest era, it doesn't really get as much notice as the only arcs like The River or Souls Winter. One of the strongest stories, regardless, with an ending that gets a little more bitter the more you thin about it (especially if you factor in the global flooding scenario from Tales #69 and ponder that by freeing the Father and restoring the ring, Leo may have been a potential cause of the end of human civilization).

FoxZerro 12-27-2012 02:20 PM

They have recently upped the security on websites at work and unfortunately TMNT-Entity was a casualty. I really love what you wrote here Spengs and it has inspired me to dig out my copy of the Ring and reread it.

ToTheNines 12-27-2012 07:55 PM

I remember as a kid reading through all the Mirage/Image/Archie synopses and this one really sticking out. Particularly the part where Don urges Leo to go on without him and they part ways, crying, with Leo leaving Don one sword.

When I started collecting comics I guess I just glanced over it because I don't like the way the turtles are drawn (the art overall is great though). But yeah, certainly an under rated and very deep issue, with a pretty great portrayal of Donatello. I also loved how they specifically referenced "The River" and their time spent with Renet millions of years in the past.

Oculus Orbus 12-27-2012 08:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1035895)
When I started collecting comics I guess I just glanced over it because I don't like the way the turtles are drawn (the art overall is great though).

I always thought that was a shame, because all the backgrounds, and specially the way it changes and gets odd is so beautifully drawn and detailed, and the use of the duo-shade is so fantastic, but yet the turtles themselves are a bit off.

Cipher 12-27-2012 08:14 PM

You want to discuss it because it kicks ass.

I love this issue, along with McCollum's "Turtle Soup" entries, for all of the reasons you've stated.

A lot of my favorite Turtles stories are also the most downbeat surreal, and this is the big thing that puts Mirage above the other incarnations, with its revolving door of indie artists and writers.

In particular, I like that this little arc takes the time to explore something largely ignored in the Turtles mythos: their animal nature. Admittedly, the results here are a little hackneyed and strange, and at the end of the day I think it's delivered with a bit more gravitas than it earns, but it's a strong, unique arc nonetheless. I'd love to see that element explored in the future.

By the by, the Steve Murphy/Michael Zulli short included in, I believe "Shell Shock," and more recently the IDW Classics #1 trade, acts as a really nice spiritual companion to McCollum's stories, although thankfully more subtle. As does Zulli's "Splinter in the Eye of God?" short reprinted in the same trade, albeit set in the "Soul's Winter" universe.

Oh, also, animistic spiritual Donatello is the best. That will always be part of his Mirage characterization for me.

-- EDIT --

Oh, man. I was talking about "O-Deed" from the "Shell Shock" book, which I'd remembered as just Michelangelo having a dream about being a series of Turtles, being mumbled at by a strange man, and then telling a teary-eyed Splinter. Re-read it yesterday and it turns out it's not subtle at all, and it's pretty squarely about Murphy's brand of environmentalism. So ... never mind.

CyberCubed 12-27-2012 09:43 PM

This is why its ridiculous to listen to PL about how all these mid-Vol. 1 issues are, "non-canon." Not only do they not contradict anything in Mirage canon, but they actually contribute MORE to the mythos than they take away.

I think its disgusting that to this day people skip most of these guest issues, and even the Image series, just because PL wants people to. They're missing out on great stories

Venom 12-27-2012 10:22 PM

MCRG: #37 - "Twilight of the Ring"
 
Okay, this seems to be edging out the others, so we'll start off with this issue.

Since Spengs has already written a very well-thought post, I'm merging that thread with this one to keep discussion tight.

DrSpengler 12-27-2012 10:25 PM

Regarding McCollum and Anderson's take on the TMNT, yeah, they were a little strange. I think it was mostly in the area of the heads; they lacked the "cheeks" or "beaks" or whatever you wanna call those puffy things.

But their ability to draw nature and environments was some of the absolute best in the series, right alongside Veitch, Zulli and Laird. The forest in "Twilight of the Ring" in particular is so massively immersive and full of personality. The way it gradually changes with each page, the deeper the Turtles venture in, then how everything dies once the mission is accomplished; such a great unaddressed detail in the story that subtly sets the ambiance without spelling things out for you.

Matches Malone 12-28-2012 01:12 AM

This was an issue that definitely stuck out in my mind as well. Definitely really interesting themes that Spengler touched on. I tend to identify the turtles as ones who inherited Japanese heritage from Splinter and American culture from New York, but it's easy to overlook the fact that they were originally reptiles and don't often think about that fact beyond how much they apparently love it in the movies.

Overall, I thought the issue was pretty solid, but drags a bit on pacing with a few pages of heavy dialogue and exposition, which I thought could have been done more economically with the artwork and the writing itself. Still, the concept definitely outweighs the execution (which is still very adequate) on exploring a spiritual and ancestral side of the turtles.

One thing that has always bugged me a bit is how just a few issues later in A.C. Farley's "Halls of Lost Legends," the opening scene is very similar to this one with the turtles wandering in the woods on a training exercise involving the "sensing the intangible." However, it is Don who is unable to understand and obtain any usefulness of this exercise. Just an odd coincidence, that's all.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1035947)
Regarding McCollum and Anderson's take on the TMNT, yeah, they were a little strange. I think it was mostly in the area of the heads; they lacked the "cheeks" or "beaks" or whatever you wanna call those puffy things.

Yeah, they didn't look "turtlely" enough. Almost like bald humans with shells on their backs. It wasn't too bad though, and as others mentioned, the overall artwork is really nice. I really like the horror atmosphere, especially near the end of the book.

Oculus Orbus 12-28-2012 05:34 AM

I'm with Matches in that the concept outweighs the execution. It's a very interesting idea, but it develops a bit rushed at times, as if it was condensed, and some parts really suffer from it, such as those with the turtles wandering around the forrest after they've been attacked. To me, the way Don embraces the idea of the Adversary seems a bit excessive.

But whenever I re-read most of the stories in Volume 1, it's always nice to remember that kind of edgy feel they had, specially now that we've pretty much lost that side of the franchise in the IDW run. If you look at the composition of the pages, there's a sense of innovation –wich might not always work, but at least is there.

DrSpengler 12-28-2012 10:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Matches Malone (Post 1035992)
One thing that has always bugged me a bit is how just a few issues later in A.C. Farley's "Halls of Lost Legends," the opening scene is very similar to this one with the turtles wandering in the woods on a training exercise involving the "sensing the intangible." However, it is Don who is unable to understand and obtain any usefulness of this exercise. Just an odd coincidence, that's all.

Yeah, I just read "Halls of Lost Legends" the other day for TMNT Entity and that kinda stuck in my craw, too.

Obviously, the real world explanation is that the guest creators weren't coordinating with each other (which is how re ended up with 3 American Indian-influenced stories in a row during the #20s), but when you're reading through the series it pokes out awkwardly. Sort of like how in The River, the Turtles deal with Indian folklore and spirits and such, then an issue later in Dreams of Stone, they're openly incredulous toward the idea of Indian mythology and Radical's claims.

And I'll also echo that Twilight of the Ring might have benefited from a two parter. The shorts we got presaging the issue helped, but the main adventure itself does have some artifacts leftover from condensing (a big deal is made about Mike and Raph rallying to hunt the Adversary, only to not be seen until the very end).

I was fine with Don going a little cuckoo, since the characters repeatedly said that his voice had 'changed" and I interpreted that as a sign he was possessed by the Father and wasn't entirely himself.

Andrew NDB 12-28-2012 04:17 PM

Probably on my Top 5 TMNT comics of all time list.

CyberCubed 12-28-2012 04:25 PM

Too bad PL declared it non-canon. I think we should declare PL's continuity timeline non-canon.

Matches Malone 12-28-2012 04:43 PM

A war fought with canons is the worst kind indeed.

Oculus Orbus 12-28-2012 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1036158)
Too bad PL declared it non-canon. I think we should declare PL's continuity timeline non-canon.

Well, that's just Peter Laird's continuity. Leave it or take it, you're always free to read the issues anyway you like.

CyberCubed 12-28-2012 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oculus Orbus (Post 1036170)
Well, that's just Peter Laird's continuity. Leave it or take it, you're always free to read the issues anyway you like.

But when the guy is the creator of the franchise and the head of Mirage, his words tend to hold a lot of weight.

For the record I do consider most of the guest issues to be canon as well as Image. I just wish PL never posted those editorials in the books.

Xav 12-28-2012 05:50 PM

Does it really matter? Peter doesn't even own TMNT anymore.

Cipher 12-28-2012 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1036155)
Probably on my Top 5 TMNT comics of all time list.

Oh, wow. Top five?

Not sure if I'd rank it that highly, but I do want to add that I think this, along with Anderson and McCollum's other issue, "Juliet's Revenge," is a seminal story of Mirage Volume 1, right alongside the main Foot arc, "The River," "Leatherhead, Too," "Sons of the Silent Age," and "Dreams of Stone."

Donnie 12-28-2012 06:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1036155)
Probably on my Top 5 TMNT comics of all time list.

I have to echo this statement. Fantastic issue, concerning both the writing and art.

I loved the characterization and how Donatello thought he was the Shaman, it took him out of his straight-logic self for a bit and that was nice.

Andrew NDB 12-29-2012 05:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1036189)
Oh, wow. Top five?"

Yup. Off the top of my head I'd say my Top 5 is probably...

1. TMNT Vol. 1, #21 - Return to New York 3/3
2. TMNT Vol. 1, #43 - Halls of Lost Legends
3. TMNT Vol. 1, #37 - Twilight of the Ring
4. TMNT Vol. 1, #28 - Sons of the Silent Age
5. Leonardo Special

If I could compress all three issues of "The River" into one entry it'd probably rate but as standalone issues, probably not.

Venom 12-29-2012 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1036265)
Yup. Off the top of my head I'd say my Top 5 is probably...

1. TMNT Vol. 1, #21 - Return to New York 3/3
2. TMNT Vol. 1, #43 - Halls of Lost Legends
3. TMNT Vol. 1, #37 - Twilight of the Ring
4. TMNT Vol. 1, #28 - Sons of the Silent Age
5. Leonardo Special

If I could compress all three issues of "The River" into one entry it'd probably rate but as standalone issues, probably not.

Wow, I never realized our taste was that similar! Sons and Halls are also amongst my top favorite issues.

DrSpengler 12-29-2012 03:36 PM

Going back to my original post,

The fallout of this issue really puts an entirely new spin on Tales of the TMNT #69. Obviously, neither story was written with the other in mind and the fall of human civilization had been built up to in Tales #24, 30 and 45, but "Twilight of the Ring" still compliments the story really well.

The whole point was that by restoring the ring, Leo was ensuring the downfall of humanity. And since the Adversary had kept "the mammals" in control longer than intended by imprisoning the Father and breaking the ring, it's no surprise that as soon as Leo restored the ring, human civilization collapsed.

Basically, the Turtles are the cause of the end of the world seen in Tales #69, if you think about it.

Thanks for nothing, Leo.

Venom 12-29-2012 03:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler
Basically, the Turtles are the cause of the end of the world seen in Tales #69, if you think about it.

Thanks for nothing, Leo.

Sure would explain why Future Raph is so grumpy. :P

Isn't it interesting how much of an affect Murph had on the Mirageverse, hell, the Turtleverse in general! Wasn't the back up in Puma Blues the first we saw of Future Raph? Then he went on to flood Earth in TMNTA...

Venom 12-31-2012 11:43 AM

After finally reading this again Saturday, I've been mulling over some of the points brought up, like Leo killing the Adversary.

Reptiles ruled the planet for hundreds of millions of years before becoming a victim of circumstance and mammals rose up.

Now, if the Ring was broken before Leo killed the Adversary, is its death an impetus for the cycle to be sped up since mammals have only ruled for roughly 65 million years?

We do see the fall of man on Earth in the future Mirage stories, but we also know that man still survives on other worlds.

Another question I've pondered is why the Father spirit used Don, the most logical, left-brained Turtle of the group, to be the catalyst with which drew Leo to encountering the Adversary rather than assuming direct control (;)) over Leo.

Perhaps it would have spooked the others from joining Leo on the journey and using Don ensured the others went along?

I would have been nice to have seen the Turtles go back to Splinter and hear what his explanation was, since he "knew" what they were heading out to face and seemed very disturbed by it (though, it could have been his owrrying the Turtles would stop loving him and viewing him as their father after their journey?).

As an interesting footnote, the artwork made it seem we had another instance of black April during the first few pages. :)

Oculus Orbus 12-31-2012 11:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 1036923)
As an interesting footnote, the artwork made it seem we had another instance of black April during the first few pages. :)

I never noticed that, but now that you say it I can see it. I wonder if that's intentional, or it's just the way the drawing came out (it happens sometimes).

FoxZerro 12-31-2012 04:51 PM

Just reread the issue and I feel about the same as I did after the first time it is a really really really great story but it feels too short. When you look at some of the other guest artists stuff that was given more than one issue, its a real shame that this was condensed down to own full issue and a couple of shorts in anthology titles. I will have to go and read the two other stories that are part of The Ring, and it shouldn't be hard considering I received a full set of Turtle Soup Vol. 2 for Christmas.

Judging this book on its own merits though. The one thing that was definitely nailed is the character of each Turtle. Even just looking at the first page where they are hiking in the woods you clearly know which Turtle is which. A lot of great Prop work went into each Turtle's individual design and it reall helps bring the story to life. Each Character looking so unique from the start makes each one more real and when you are seeing Raph, Leo, and Mike so clearly defined its that much more jarring when you see how out of character Donatello is acting.

The fact that Donatello is so off the mark is such a great plot device that it can almost go unlooked. Donatello clearly has an empathy for life and its value, but he is also the most logical of the Brothers. It makes sense for him to want to find the answer behind all of the Aliens and Monsters they've been encountering, but the fact that he is so willing to accept a spirtual answer speaks volumes against what we've seen so far. Even if you're not a super fan and you're casually reading this issue they do a nice job of showing the incredulousness of the other Turtles at what Donatello is claiming. In fact I think that is the reason why intially he was chosen, because his brother's would clearly show concern for his condition and that in turn would lead them to try and help their wayward brother.

While Donatello is clearly the star of the show each turtle has their moment to shine which makes the story that much better and just confirms how firm a hold McCollum and Anderson have on the characters and the mythos so far. Raphael lashing out at mammals and the way that they waste the gift of the earth is perfectly in character, as is his concern over Michelangelo when he goes missing. Finally the fact that they bring up the fact that just ten issues ago Raphael had returned back to his natural state just shows great continuity and it was the perfect comeback from Donatello considering how we know Raphael felt about the whole situation from his soliloquy in issue 28.

Further evidence as to why the guest era shouldn't just be overlooked or dismissed considering the level of consistency that many of the artists decided to maintain throughout.

Michelangelo probably gets the least amount of time to shine in this issue but that's unfortunately the way that it seems to be in the Mirage books. Though he does show my favorite part of the world of the TMNT, the lack of bandana. I love seeing the Turtles without bandana's and its usually reserved for when they are sitting around the house. To have Michelangelo out in the world without his bandana is fantastic, since of the four he is the one that I would tap to wear one the least.

Finally Leonardo is the best character to be charged with the task of being the Shaman, since he has always felt like the most spiritual turtle. Which is why I question if there really was some greater force behind their quest or if it was a trap set by the adversary. Leonardo would have been more than capable of going out and handling the matter on his own. Which makes it that much stranger that the Great Turtle Spirit would have chosen to bait and switch Donatello in order to bring the true savior in Leonardo out into the woods. Why risk the lives of the other three when only one could go out and complete the task. It makes me believe that Donatello was being led by the adversary and once the actual great spirit found out it intervened. That would explain the reason why Don goes so far off the deep end in the later part of the book in his mind a war is literally being waged between the influence of the adversary and the assistance of the great reptilian spirits.

My favorite moment in the entire issue has to be Page 25. The pacing of the words is great. The way it is laid out Leonardo feels like he's doing commentary on the situation as it happens. Not to mention the artwork alone on the page is so awe-inspiring. Just beautiful.

Overall a great issue, and one I was quite happy to read and think on again.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Matches Malone (Post 1035992)
They didn't look "turtlely" enough. Almost like bald humans with shells on their backs. It wasn't too bad though, and as others mentioned, the overall artwork is really nice. I really like the horror atmosphere, especially near the end of the book.

I almost feel as if that was part of the message, how human they had become despite the fact that they are reptiles. Even the humanized Reptiles shown as Leonardo and Donatello dream the same dream still look distinctly animal. It really adds something overall if that is what the artist was going for.

Unfortunately the look of the Turtles did initially affect my recollection of the issure. I read McCollum and Anderson and instantly my mind jumped to Juliet's Revenge. I couldn't even begin to remember what Twilight of the Ring was about.

Venom 01-03-2013 11:14 PM

This topic seems to have run it's course in just under a week, so let's move along to #12 - The Survivalists!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.