![]() |
Do you think the IDW comic and the Nick cartoon are going to "meet in the middle"?
What I mean by that is, both the IDW comic and Nickelodeon cartoon started out more or less uniquely (albeit, both taking major cues from the Fred Wolf cartoon)... but as time goes on and the Fred Wolf influence becomes more prevalent, do you see both universes becoming more and more alike?
For example, in the Nickelodeon cartoon I fully expect them to eventually bring in Bebop and Rocksteady (they're just saving them for a minute), and probably the leader of the "Kraang" will -- yup -- be a familiar enough Krang... and sooner or later you just know there will be a Technodrome. Similarly, IDW has already laid some pretty obvious groundwork toward introducing Bebop and Rocksteady as well as the Technodrome (Krang is already around, front and center). You see? They're kind of both headed toward the same destination, it seems... and all roads lead to Fred Wolf. We could say, "But the IDW comic is edgier! That's how it's different" and maybe it is, in some ways, but I found the Shredder battle in "The Gauntlet" episode of the Nick show to actually be considerably grittier than what we got in IDW... and the Turtles actually got legitimately pretty scraped up. And while no one expects the Turtles to be taking lives in the Nick cartoon, the IDW comic even goes so far as the make an official no-killing policy for the Turtles... in both cases more "heroes in a half shell" and not so much what people would think of when they hear the word "ninja." What say you? |
I'm sure there will be some more OT influence in the Nick series, but not to an obnoxious or dominating extent. Can't say for the current comics. For my taste there's too much already, but the gang at IDW has tried to assure us that will change...
|
This is actually the thing I fear the most for both the IDW series and the New Toon. I really really liked that from the beginning both seemed like their own new things.
Asie from borrowing Splinter's origin. The Nick cartoon hasn't begun to tread that close to Fred Wolf and I really hope that it doesn't. The IDW series though I feel like I should break out the Doomsday clock because it just seems inevitable. I remember reading the Raphael Micro and the amount of joy I felt seeing the two punks that would become Bebop and Rocksteady gave me, on the reverse I remember how disappointed I was when in the same issue they came back and it was revealed that it wasn't just a cameo, but the groundwork being laid for them to eventually enter the series. Sort of made Rocksteady's line of "I'm a god damn Rhino" more groan inducing than actual nostalia fuel. |
The IDW comic did an interesting job mixing the Mirage Fugitoid/Turtles in space story with the OT Krang and Neutrino war. I wouldn't count the Triceratons out though and I expect to see them eventually.
I'm actually surprised the Nick cartoon isn't more influenced by the OT since its aimed at kids. There's no Technodrome, no Neutrinos and so far Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady haven't appeared. We know General Traag is coming but he's being reimagined as a 17 foot tall stone warrior. What I think IDW will do next is sort of mix in Shredder destroying April's shop with a RTNY type arc. They also haven't brought in Rat King or Leatherhead yet which I'm sure are coming. I don't expect the two series to go all OT stuff since they're fairly different but I wouldn't be surprised to see some crossover characters like Old Hob wind up in the cartoon or Chris Bradford in IDW. |
Quote:
Gentleman's wager: if anyone still thinks we are leaning too heavily towards the OT in exactly one year's time from now... ..then you will have won the gentlemen's wager. Am I misreading him, or is he not saying, "If you're betting we're going to be knee-deep in Fred Wolf in a year, you'll be right"? Quote:
|
I wasn't all that sure, really. I chose to believe he meant there'd be less, but really, the expression or wording threw me off a bit.
|
What else OT influence can they do though? Most of the rest of the OT characters are also in the Archie series. There's nothing wrong with seeing a few more mutant characters.
Bobby already assured us that Don won't be building blimps, vans or dimensional portals. The only real storyline the OT had was largely covered in the first season. The rest of the show was Shredder/Krang just coming up with a new scheme every week and then being foiled by the Turtles. |
Quote:
|
I voted "No, not at all", but allow me to explain it. I'm loving the Nick series, and I keep feeling that it will only get better as episodes go by (until it gets worst, eventually, at some point in the future). When I watch it, I know what I'm seeing, and that is a kids show. It never tried to be something else. I'm not very fond on the FW cartoon, but I don't mind them using elements from there, and despite all indications or speculations, we still don't know how far that route they will go. Mikey is once again too stupid, the "Mutant of the Week" formula could get old very quick, Leo's obsession with "Space Heroes" is ridiculous, and on and on. But the show has good action, good characterization, and a promising plot that could develop into some great stories. I never felt like FW had any of those, or at least not to the same extent.
Now, IDW is a whole different story. I was so excited when the book came out, and really wanted to like it. I was very open to accept whichever direction they wanted to go, and at first it seemed like it was gonna be awesome. I feel horrible whenever I criticize a comic, but it was pretty much impossible for me to get into it since the very beginning. If they had gone for a "mature FW" kind of thing, it would've been fine with me. But they're in the middle of nowhere, if you know what I mean. They keep bringing FW elements and characters, wich is perfectly fine, but then the story never really gets interesting. It feels weak at many points, such as the Turtles walking around in the city, or the whole Old Hob character. Also, the bandana thing was very disappointing, not to mention the new origin, wich is a huge deal-breaker for me. At this point, I can't help but feel that it's already ruined, and even if things changed, I'd probably still feel like the book is not for me. I'm not saying it's bad, but I personally can't enjoy it. |
Quote:
|
They've handled all the OT characters fine just far. Slash's take was very good.
As for the the cartoons, the Nick show has a promising start but I'm not sure if it'll become repetitive at some point. The Fred Wolf show managed to have a repetitive formula but kept it entertaining somehow. I can't see that repeated. |
No, I don't think they're both headed toward the same destination, the Fred Wolf cartoon. They're more likely to gradually go on their own direction in the future. Don't know about the new cartoon, but I'm sure IDW comic will try to explore something different and maybe totally new after the Krang's War arc. I think this arc will be the closer to Fred Wolf stuff IDW comic will ever go and then it will start to go on his own way. The Secret history of the Foot clan upcoming series seems to support this, for the little we know.
At least.. I hope so. |
Quote:
I know that's a bit of hyperbole, they have done a lot of things very cool and original, but I think its because they did that stuff so well that it makes it sad when it feels like the book is now just doing retreads of extremely familiar territory. Like I said with my post about the Raph Micro I would be all about cameo appearances, but whole storylines and character's being lifted rubs me the wrong way. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I'll reserve a remark for after Secret History of the Foot Clan #4 is released. Perhaps I'm putting it on too high of a pedestal, but I feel like that mini is going to be my deciding factor on whether I'm completely sold on the IDW-verse or not.
|
Quote:
|
I like to think IDW can carve out its own niche similar to the way the Archie series started off similar to the original toon and then became something totally different.
Remember where Archie was 17 issues in? In that dire jungle tour in South America. Archie really took off around the Slash arc and when Krang attached himself to Shredder's head, and then it got consistently better after that. I think IDW will last as long as Archie did. Hopefully we get at least 50 issues out of the main ongoing at the minimum. |
I dunno guys. In my opinion, 17 issues and 8 micros is more than enough to get a quite comprehensive idea of what the book can be.
|
Quote:
It then took about 3 issues for the first Shredder confrontation. Then we had 2 Slash issues, and now the next 4-part arc is about the Krang arc. When it takes 4 or so issues to tell one story, you have to give it more time. Only the micros tell a quick one-shot tale that leads into something else. |
My gentleman's wager was-- if you think we're too fred wolf influenced in a year, you win. If you don't, I win.
But I'm the one offering the bet, and I know what's down the road. So chances are... I'm going to win the bet. Orbus, just want to say thanks for giving the book a try. You're right, it's not for everyone, and if we haven't sold you yet, we probably never will (though i'm curious for you to read #22). But thanks for giving it a go. I guess the Fred Wolf debate will never go away... I thought it would after Leo micro, Karai, Fugitoid, issues 13-16 (granted, we introduced Technodrome there, but otherwise...). To me it seems balanced NOW. But that's me. To each their own. |
Quote:
I think the first five issues for me personally were hard to get interested in because it was too much black and white comic influenced. The fact Slash showed up references wave 1 not the '87 cartoon,but yeah The Technodrome does. I think its just all the black and white comic elements that were being used were introduced for the most part at the same time just as most '87 cartoon elements were introduced around the same time. The elements of shows/comics not spread but introduced together gave some of us the illusion that it was a rehash of the black and white comics with reincarnation and then gave some others the illlusion that too much '87 cartoon elements were being introduced while in fact neither time the specific readers concerned didn't have to. Now,I suspect most of what we will see the next several months is laid on the table so the debate of too much Mirage/Image that I would scream or too much '87 cartoon that a couple others would scream can be laid to rest atleast for the next several months. |
The biggest reason I don't buy this book is that I'm not a fan of the reincarnation origin. It just doesn't seem to be TMNT with that.
|
Quote:
Splinter and Shredder being reincarnated is fine though. Its a nice twist of Hamato Yoshi being Splinter again and Shredder being reincarnated reminds me of the Demon Shredder from the 4kids series. |
The reincarnation angle is actually one of the things I can really get behind IDW TMNT on. And has mostly been done amicably so far. Down the line, when and if everyone has a bigger sense of "total recall" into their past lives, it even opens the door to some pretty cool flashback sequences. And who doesn't like flashbacks to Feudal Japan?
That said, it's hard to ignore Peter Laird's thoughts on the matter -- that it thence makes the TMNT seem like re-runs, and not original characters able to stand on their own right and identities. But I personally think the pros outweigh the cons in this particular instance. |
I like that it sort of reinforces that idea of the TMNT being a part of infinity, the ever present 'heroes', the only constant in a crazy universe, etc.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Deer meat being Fugitoid... and the white bread bun being Fred Wolf (the Neutrino/Technodrome angle/substitutions). It's an example of taking from a TMNT universe other than Fred Wolf, yes... but at the same time it could very easily be viewed as an example of taking things from another TMNT universe only to go and cover them in a Fred Wolf coat of paint. Which only lends credence to the "IDW seems to be steering the ship towards Fred Wolf, again and again" or at the very least, "IDW only seems to be borrowing from other TMNT universes as it suits their Fred Wolf leanings, or if it can be Fred Wolf-enized." That as it may, though, I maintain that it was done very effectively. I didn't mind one bit that Honeycutt was made a Neutrino and that probably actually provided the first "should I care about this?" port hole to the Neutrinos for me. But if I was looking for examples to explain to others how IDW TMNT is not Fred Wolfy? I probably wouldn't point at the Fugitoid special at all. |
Quote:
|
I think people are more surprised by seeing these characters in comic form that wasn't an adaption of the OT like Archie was.
I never actually thought we'd see Krang in the comics, and I definitely never expected to see the Neutrinos return. Its actually a strange feeling to see these characters from my childhood in a serious comic book aimed at older fans. Mainly due to PL's refusal of any of the cartoon-created characters for the comics, and the fact that the 4kids series wasn't allowed to use them either until Turtles Forever. I love Krang so I'm not complaining, but I can see how some people, "aren't used to it," so to speak. |
This thread is very interesting to me, in that everyone seems to think anything of the Fred Wolf toon is providing the book with a more kiddie tone. I say the more from that corner of the TMNT world the merrier, but make sure their properly redesigned to fit the tone IDW is going for. It would have gone a long way if they'd really toned down Dask, Zak and Kala's designs, and I'm sure they could have done it without making them unrecognizable.
To answer the question of the thread, I don't think this book will be "the same" as the Nick show. Ever. There might be mutants that people think are goofy, and some of the turtles might outright refuse to kill, but you'll never see the IDW turtles driving a turtle themed vehicle through the streets of NY, or them making exaggerated anime expressions, or Mikey acting like an actual retard, etc. And that's not a knock at the Nicktoon, it kicks ass too. |
Interesting indeed, and I think all of you guys make good points.
Our approach has always sort of been like making a stew (a turtle stew, har...). We take major ingredients from different TMNT incarnations and pour it into the same pot. It all gets mixed together. So yeah, everything is going to have a taste of OT to it, but at the same time, all of those OT ingredients are going to be toned down by the Mirage ingredients. And vice-versa. It all blends. At the end, while you can detect flavors from different universes, it hopefully has an overall "IDW" taste, especially the longer it sits on the fire. (weird metaphor) Some people will always think it will taste too OT, others won't. Hopefully for the people who think it tastes too OT, you'll scoop up a big chunk of Mirage every once in a while and be convinced to come back to the pot. |
I'm not confident the new cartoon will even be picked up for a second season. Outside of adults on the internet(okay just this site), I haven't meant anyone that actually likes it. That includes all the younger kids I know that'd be the shows target audience. I hope if the show gets cancelled it doesn't affect the comic. I also hope the comic kind of lays off the Fred Wolf stuff. Slash, Krang bebop & rocksteady and the neutrinos should be enough to keep the Fred Wold fans happy but the mirage tmnt fans need love too.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
That's good. I'm glad.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
In the case of the Cartoon, I totally expected it to follow the old Fred Wolf show. When Nick bought the turtles, they didn't buy them because of the Mirage stories, they bought them because of the level of fame they achieved with the OT and original movies. I see them leading the new show into the direction of the old show for financial reasons, while still creating a new universe. More TMNT fans are casuals that have an affinity for the Fred Wolf series, and not the source material, so it would make sense for them to cater to that audience. With IDW I know everything goes to nick for approval, but I'm sure Nick isn't dictating what characters are used and when, they would have no need to. |
It is indeed the best incriedients of all incarnations. I was so lucky and surprised as the same time as the turtles became their colourfull-masks. I totally didn't expect that.
Even Bebop and Rocksteady had an appereance with Alopex, how cool is that? But i wish they would come again in mutant form. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:21 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.