![]() |
Thoughts on a second TMNT book?
Now I know this probably insn't a financially feasable idea for IDW, but how would people feel about IDW running a second TMNT series besides the main one? (I don't count the micros, as they don't always focus directly on the TMNT- Nor the Nick Cartoon tie-in book)
I'd personally like to see something like the old Tales of the TMNT, set in the IDW-verse, and split into four issue arcs with each story written and drawn by a diffrent team. It would be a way to see more old TMNT characters re-introduced and new stories told, without distrupting the flow of the main book. It would also give old Archie and Mirage writers that are popular with the fans, a chance to write the turtles again. What would others think of the idea? |
The micros are exactly what Tales of the TMNT is.
|
I would be down for another Turtles book.... get Lawson back and the rest of the Mirage guys, if any of them want to do more stories. That would be great. With one exception: the main book needs to keep the creative team for at least 10-14 issues before switching again.
|
The micros get the job done. The IDW Turtle universe isn't really big enough yet for an actual Tales series, so that would be years off. Even then, books like that are harder for most readers to follow since there's no real structure to the run, where as the Micro's and Mini's keep up with the current story lines.
|
I think this was discussed in the past somewhere round here... Anyway, I agree with ToTheNines. The story is not so big as of yet to be able to withstand something like the tales series. And even if it was, so far there hasn't been a lot of gaps in the continuity to fill in with additional stories. Tales worked perfectly for mirage because of the lose continuity they were working with. IDW is a whole different story, they are building a very cohesive and continuous storyline with a very high peace with no room for anything else. Actually it's so high peaced that they been using the micros to push the storyline forward rather than really delve into each of the turltes (and other characters) personalities. The best example for this is raphael, who after living alone in the streets of new york for about a year has no problem integrating with his brothers. I expected to either see some tension on that side of the equation or at least get a rationalization where he explains why he has adapted so well. Someone could argue that probably having shared a past life together had something to do with it, but I would have liked to see it explained somewhere in the books... but I digress.
As far as getting a new series separate from this one, I feel a little conflicted. While I would love to get more turtles, I also realize that we are getting a lot as it is. We have the comics, the new series and the movie. Getting another comic would be great, but it would compete against the other and it might not end up being beneficial... though if they made a super dark version of the turtles I'd totally be down for that! haha. So to sum things up, I think that the amount of comics we are getting is just right. A solid series with the ocasional miniseries to back it up is a model I can get behind of. |
I'd love to see IDW just do a Tales Of The TMNT vol. 3 using the regular Mirage guys, past Tales artists, IDW artists, and new guys. Set it in Mirage continuity, run things by Lawson and/or Berger for credibility's sake, bada bing.
|
I'll third the opinions above me. The micros are doing their job and the universe isn't really established enough to sustain a spin-off at this point.
I'm kind of torn on multiple books for one property anyway. On the one hand, it can let lesser characters shine and produce some fun stories. On the other hand, it's a pain to keep up on and keep track of. It seems like a Big Two kind of thing that IDW rarely does. (They've always kind of/sort of had two Transformers books, but that's about it.) That, and between the current series and Mirage and Archie reprints, IDW is already inundating fans with Turtles material. And we have a cartoon-based series coming soon, so it's really enough. Quote:
|
I don't understand what the point is. We have micros coming out, we have mini's like the Secret History of the Foot Clan, we have annuals, and we have specials like Infestation.
IDW has already been putting up a second TMNT comic most months. |
I don't know, I think a second series would help expand the world greatly. The fast pace has cut back on character development, and I'd love to see side stories with characters like Leatherhead, Rat King, etc. I guess it's just me. And as for a Mirage continuation, that'd be really cool for the Mirage fans.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Well, they already are pushing books that are Mirage, I don't see how hard it would be to specify the universe they take part in in advertisements or even in a logo on the cover. I would just like to see that happen. I could understand if they wanna get their foot in the door for a few years first, sure, but I see no reason not to. Might as well go full steam ahead! & let's face it, Mirage books were not that adult. I doubt there'd be much, if anything, that Nick would be against. The IDW books have about the same amount of violence and implied swearing, give or take... Well, they're a little softer, but still, there's nothing jarring about the former by comparsion.
|
Even cooler than a new Tales of the TMNT taking place in the Mirage universe would be a "Tales of the TMNT Multiverse" title. It could use Mirage, the OT, the 4kids universe, the movies, and random one-shots, etc.
|
I'd be alllllllllllllll for that. Definitely.
|
I was always more of a fan of Tales more than any other series. These stories were usually one shots and took place all over the TMNT world.
I agree that the Foot series and micros serve as a second series. Maybe once the micros are over we could get a Tales series. Here's another idea, but you would have to get Peter and Jim on board. How about Mirage Presents: TMNT This could serve as a Tales like series that takes place in the Mirage universe. |
Ehhh, I'd rather leave the Mirage continuity to Laird and his "X number of issues per year" clause.
|
Quote:
IDW already does something similar with Transformers and GI Joe, I believe. I'm satisfied with our current offerings, though, as we have the ongoing, the micros, the minis, the annuals, and soon the Animated book. All in addition to the Mirage reprints! Still, I'd personally love to see the newspaper strips finally collected! |
Quote:
|
no I don't think so. I like it the way it is.
we're getting 1 issue per month, plus color classic and the occasional micro series it's perfect. not need to change a good thing |
I'm content with Mirage continuity being a closed book, regardless of whether or not Laird utilizes his X number of issues priviledge. If he does new stories: cool. If he doesn't: okay.
So far as I'm concerned, IDW currently DOES have a second TMNT book, albeit they rotate between micro and mini series so there's constantly something fresh happening to concurrently flesh out the ongoing series. It's gone Hero Micros - Foot Clan - Villain Micros and I don't think we've had a break in between (maybe a 1 month gap at worst, but I'd have to go back and check). Plus bonuses like the Annual and Infestation II. I'm pretty content with how IDW is currently handling things; a primary ongoing and a rotation of supporting limited titles to fill in the gaps and give us two titles a month. The last thing I want is for them to flood the shelves with an excess number of Turtle books and risk absolute burnout. I remember the earlier days of their Transformers license when there were 5 or 6 Transformers titles all out at the same time. That was oversaturation and it backfired horribly (there was very little quality control going on with that much product being shoveled out). I think two books a month is just right. |
Quote:
this this this this... said what I wanted to say... originally. this perfect |
A Tales series would be cool, but like others said I don't think it would work at this point. IDW could also do what they did with GI Joe and Transformers and start where their previous volumes left off in their original continuity. I don't know if I'd want that, though because I wasn't a huge fan of volume 4.
|
DO IT NOW!!!! it took them over a year to figure out Krang existed!!!!
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:19 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.