The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Tmnt #20 Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=41795)

TomWaltz 03-18-2013 08:27 PM

Tmnt #20 Discussion
 
Here you go, my friends -- a little preview of things to come this week.

Enjoy... and thanks!

Tom W.

http://bit.ly/117n8ff

CyberCubed 03-18-2013 08:37 PM

Love what I'm seeing so far. I wonder if putting Mike and Kala together is intentional, giving Mike had a crush on her in the original cartoon.

Looks pretty great in terms of action, almost looks like the cartoons (and I mean that in a good way). I love how Ben Bates style works well with the more sci-fi or cartoonish aspects of the TMNT franchise.

I hope he comes back sometime for future issues, the guy has been pure gold.

Desslok 03-18-2013 08:39 PM

Awesome! This should be a good one. :tgrin:

909 Turtle Fan 03-18-2013 08:40 PM

Live action wheww!!!!!

mrmaczaps 03-18-2013 08:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomWaltz (Post 1073220)
Here you go, my friends -- a little preview of things to come this week.

Enjoy... and thanks!

Tom W.

http://bit.ly/117n8ff

nice! thanks for sharing!!

turtlefan27 03-18-2013 08:58 PM

I CANT WAIT FOR THIS TO COME OUT!!!!
:tgrin:

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 03-19-2013 09:13 PM

Michelangelo has some of the best lines in this preview, as well as in SHOTFC #4's preview.

Plasticplayhouse 03-20-2013 04:49 AM

This is so good. I've really enjoy this arch, its been fun and exciting!

MikeandRaph87 03-20-2013 03:09 PM

Having just read it...

Spoiler:
Is that Stockman's exosuit from "Mission of Gravity" that Krang's projection is in fighting Raphael and Zak?


Spoiler:
My question on how act I leads to act II of the three act saga with General Krang has been answered. I am very pleased with this issue except one thing. Why so upbeat when Krang has Fugitiod?

On a final note, Karai stole one of the mutagen containers and just killed oe utrom. I thought she was going to take all of it!

Slade 03-20-2013 04:15 PM

I got conflicting dates in this one. Is it next week?

DrSpengler 03-20-2013 07:08 PM

Here's my review of TMNT #20 over at TMNT Entity.

A solid conclusion with a bittersweet ending.

I felt Krang put up the sort of fight that the Shredder didn't in #12 and really enjoyed how the whole confrontation went down. Even with an arm chopped off, Krang still retained the upperhand and essentially *won* the fight, getting exactly what he wanted from the beginning.

The philosophical discussion regarding teleportation and the soul was a surprise inclusion. Partly because I wasn't expecting such a topic to come up, but also because no one *ever* addresses the whole "teleportation or cloning?" thing in sci-fi stuff (at least, not that I've read). While I think there's a much deeper discussion in there, the talk got all the space it needed and gave Don something to think about.

Gonna miss Bates. Now, it may just be the power of suggestion, but whenever he showed the Turtles' bandanas in closeup, they looked torn in a way similar to how they look in "Secret History"... which takes place right after this arc. So a sideways explanation for how the Turtles got their unique bandanas in "Secret History" or just my eyes playing tricks on me? Probably the latter.

Vi11AiN6 03-20-2013 08:00 PM

Why is it I love the panel with Donnie having his mask off?

I've always enjoyed the scenes with the turtles wearing hats and/or not wearing masks, it's such a human element to the characters... I love it and it's always good to see that..

Good job and look forward to it!!!!

It just means I'll read issue #19 , 19 more times!!!!!!

Panda_Kahn_fan 03-20-2013 11:56 PM

No offense, but I don't really think Fugitoid was being literal about how the teleporter works, he was just trying to get his point across to Donnie. The Neutrinoes (or any other race) wouldn't be so nonchalant about teleporting if that were really the case.

DrSpengler 03-21-2013 06:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1074034)
No offense, but I don't really think Fugitoid was being literal about how the teleporter works, he was just trying to get his point across to Donnie. The Neutrinoes (or any other race) wouldn't be so nonchalant about teleporting if that were really the case.

Well, I certainly hope that's the case.

Otherwise, whoah, what an ethics catastrophe.

ToTheNines 03-21-2013 08:33 AM

I liked this one pretty well. Even still, this arc probably would have been better suited as a 3 parter.

My only real complaint is the April/Casey moment. First of all, I can't get myself interested in their romance since it's pretty much a constant in the TMNT multiverse. And as a chronology stickler, I hate the fact that Casey almost said "I love you" even though he's only known April for like 2 months. I was fine with the kiss, but it's waaay too soon to be saying crap like that, especially since I'd like to believe Casey is able to play it cool enough to not blurt that out and end up coming off as lovesick virgin.

Shout out and farewell to Ben Bates. I definitely enjoyed his run. I thought Ronda was particular good in this one too.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 03-21-2013 08:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1074079)
Otherwise, whoah, what an ethics catastrophe.

Why? As long as you don't get put back together wrong like in "The Fly," it shouldn't matter... or are you saying it is wrong because other living things are affected?

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1073948)
So a sideways explanation for how the Turtles got their unique bandanas in "Secret History" or just my eyes playing tricks on me? Probably the latter.

I actually think you may have something here, but only Waltz or Curnow would be able to confirm. People have been bitching about Mateus's bandanas for three months now, so probably before Bates started doing the panels for this last issue... and fan discussions DO influence the writing of this book.

DrSpengler 03-21-2013 09:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ***The One True Shredder*** (Post 1074111)
Why? As long as you don't get put back together wrong like in "The Fly," it shouldn't matter... or are you saying it is wrong because other living things are affected?

Well, discarding any concepts of the soul and whatnot, that method teleportation kills a person and replaces them with a clone. I think that's pretty unethical.

Crabfight 03-21-2013 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1074102)
as a chronology stickler, I hate the fact that Casey almost said "I love you" even though he's only known April for like 2 months. I was fine with the kiss, but it's waaay too soon to be saying crap like that, especially since I'd like to believe Casey is able to play it cool enough to not blurt that out and end up coming off as lovesick virgin.

This is a good point. It's easy to forget as a reader that is hasn't ACTUALLY been 2 years in their universe. Casey could probably stand to keep his cool a bit.

That being said, I don't mind that they're moving this forward now. I'm not overly interested in the book making the Casey/April love thing a huge focus, so if they get it out of the way earlier, maybe it can just be a constant.

Also, are we sure that he was about to say those specific words? I don't have the comic in front of me right this second, but he could have easily been about to let her know that he simply has feelings for her that are stronger than friendship. That feels pretty believable for a college guy (lovesick or not; experienced or not) after spending two relatively unusual months with an attractive girl. This continuity has pulled Casey away from being overly crude and patronizing (i.e., no more 'babe? sweetcakes? princess!"), so I can see it happening.

TonySiegel 03-21-2013 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1074102)
I liked this one pretty well. Even still, this arc probably would have been better suited as a 3 parter.

My only real complaint is the April/Casey moment. First of all, I can't get myself interested in their romance since it's pretty much a constant in the TMNT multiverse. And as a chronology stickler, I hate the fact that Casey almost said "I love you" even though he's only known April for like 2 months. I was fine with the kiss, but it's waaay too soon to be saying crap like that, especially since I'd like to believe Casey is able to play it cool enough to not blurt that out and end up coming off as lovesick virgin.

Shout out and farewell to Ben Bates. I definitely enjoyed his run. I thought Ronda was particular good in this one too.

honestly, who knows what he was gonna say? this new iteration of casey is not as masculine as past versions of his character have been... especially with the fact of his father's abuses that have been dealt upon him....

i guess he wanted to express himself deeply to april, after all she seems to be a strong fixture in his life along with his new mutated family...

corvus 03-21-2013 11:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1074102)
I liked this one pretty well. Even still, this arc probably would have been better suited as a 3 parter.

My only real complaint is the April/Casey moment. First of all, I can't get myself interested in their romance since it's pretty much a constant in the TMNT multiverse. And as a chronology stickler, I hate the fact that Casey almost said "I love you" even though he's only known April for like 2 months. I was fine with the kiss, but it's waaay too soon to be saying crap like that, especially since I'd like to believe Casey is able to play it cool enough to not blurt that out and end up coming off as lovesick virgin.

Shout out and farewell to Ben Bates. I definitely enjoyed his run. I thought Ronda was particular good in this one too.

I'm nineteen. I've said that after four months...not much of a lovesick virgin either. Lol.

Bobby Curnow 03-21-2013 12:11 PM

My read of that line was he was going to say "Those green knuckleheads love you as much as you love them-- you know that. And so do I"

The actual words as Casey was saying them meant an extension of love in a platonic sense to himself (in terms of Turtles & April). Like: "The Turtles love you, and me too" But Casey stopped himself right before the "I" because he realized that the platonic sense obviously wasn't accurate. There's clearly something more between them, even if it's new and awkward.

So he wasn't saying a big dramatic "I love you" but it was clear between them that it wasn't just a "I love you, my bestie friend!" either. They're somewhere in between, which to me at least, seems accurate for their age and all the crazy stuff they've already been through together.

corvus 03-21-2013 12:39 PM

If I just moved away from my alcoholic step father and lived with five mutants in a bomb shelter beneath an abandoned church I'd be all over the first girl I saw. Though Karai would be more my type haha.

Panda_Kahn_fan 03-21-2013 05:37 PM

Outside of my disdain for the teleportation issue *shivers*, the Krang war was a really awesome story arc. Loved the old playmates toys being made into modern war vehicles in the comics, and loved the attention to detail with the Neutrinoes. Hope to eventually see more OT/Archie stuff in the future! :)

oldmanwinters 03-21-2013 06:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1073948)
The philosophical discussion regarding teleportation and the soul was a surprise inclusion. Partly because I wasn't expecting such a topic to come up, but also because no one *ever* addresses the whole "teleportation or cloning?" thing in sci-fi stuff (at least, not that I've read). While I think there's a much deeper discussion in there, the talk got all the space it needed and gave Don something to think about.

Oh, yeah, this was probably the single most interesting part of the entire issue to me, which was completely unexpected!

I mean, wow... considering how prevalent molecular transporters have been in science fiction since all the way back to Star Trek and Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory (I guess?) is it really true that TMNT #20 has been the first piece of fiction to think about the subject from that perspective. I don't know if Tom Waltz intended for the idea to be so profound, but I it really was an eye opening realization. To compare everything that gets teleported to the copy n' paste concept really was some brilliance!

And I agree with what Spengs said in another thread, reading the Krang Wars & Secret History of the Foot Clan concurrently really was the ideal way to open up both the sci-fi and spiritual potential of the IDW TMNT book. We fans may be living in a creative golden age.

Metropoliskid41 03-21-2013 07:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1074339)
Oh, yeah, this was probably the single most interesting part of the entire issue to me, which was completely unexpected!

And I agree with what Spengs said in another thread, reading the Krang Wars & Secret History of the Foot Clan concurrently really was the ideal way to open up both the sci-fi and spiritual potential of the IDW TMNT book. We fans may be living in a creative golden age.

I agree! Great 1-2 punch with these arcs running concurrently.

Redeemer 03-21-2013 07:46 PM

I really loved how they portrayed krang and
Spoiler:
which utrom did they kill????I also loved how Leo chopped Krang's arm off!!!! so epic!!!!!! as far as the whole teleportation thing goes, yeah pretty awesome explanation :D

Martin 03-21-2013 09:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1073948)
Gonna miss Bates. Now, it may just be the power of suggestion, but whenever he showed the Turtles' bandanas in closeup, they looked torn in a way similar to how they look in "Secret History"... which takes place right after this arc. So a sideways explanation for how the Turtles got their unique bandanas in "Secret History" or just my eyes playing tricks on me? Probably the latter.

Yeah I noticed that too, but I think that's just probably bates adjusting his artstyle to fit Matheus work, and not so much of an explanation to why they ended up like that.

I'm a bit torn about Ben leaving. On the one hand, I'm really excited to see Santoluco's work on the main series, but Ben really grew on me on this last couple issues. The fight scenes that he draws look really good, and he really does his homework when it comes to studying up on his subject matter. This is his response to a comment in a drawing that he posted to deviantart:

Quote:

Hey thanks a ton! Learning about the weapons was one of my favorite parts in preparing for the job. There is SO MUCH that can be done with each Turtle and how they use their weapons that we rarely (or maybe never) see. I wish I could have done more strikes with Raphael but thinking back, I guess I did get to draw a lot of attacks for all four Turtles.
I hope we'll see him again one day.

ToTheNines 03-21-2013 10:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1074182)
My read of that line was he was going to say "Those green knuckleheads love you as much as you love them-- you know that. And so do I"

The actual words as Casey was saying them meant an extension of love in a platonic sense to himself (in terms of Turtles & April). Like: "The Turtles love you, and me too" But Casey stopped himself right before the "I" because he realized that the platonic sense obviously wasn't accurate. There's clearly something more between them, even if it's new and awkward.

So he wasn't saying a big dramatic "I love you" but it was clear between them that it wasn't just a "I love you, my bestie friend!" either. They're somewhere in between, which to me at least, seems accurate for their age and all the crazy stuff they've already been through together.

Point taken. Reading through again, I see what you mean.

snake 03-22-2013 03:08 PM

Great issue! I had to pick up cover a and b, they were so nice looking I couldn't pick!
One of my favorite things about this issue was the entire krang battle.
One question, are krang or the neutrinos going to return? I really liked krang, as its a fresh new take on him, so I really hope he will be back. Anyways, great issue! It makes up for the "meh" issue 19!
9/10!

Taylon 03-23-2013 04:07 PM

Re: 'The philosophical discussion regarding teleportation and the soul was a surprise inclusion. Partly because I wasn't expecting such a topic to come up, but also because no one *ever* addresses the whole "teleportation or cloning?" thing in sci-fi stuff (at least, not that I've read). While I think there's a much deeper discussion in there, the talk got all the space it needed and gave Don something to think about.' - Dr Spengler
This is why 'The Prestige' left me feeling sad about the ending of Robert Angier. For all his faults, who was left?

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 03-25-2013 11:22 AM

I don't really find the teleportation thing an ethical issue, but my explanation for that is quite lengthy and I don't have time to write it up right now. If anyone cares, the last letter printed in the letters section was mine. So happy to see it in there, even if Bobby had to edit it (it was originally a bit longer).

DrSpengler 03-25-2013 11:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Taylon (Post 1075118)
This is why 'The Prestige' left me feeling sad about the ending of Robert Angier. For all his faults, who was left?

The Prestige! I hadn't thought about that movie in a long time. It actually handled the issue of clone/teleportation really well and is one of the few pieces of media I've seen that broaches the subject.

(though I'd still like to track down that old Canadian cartoon that tackled the topic)

EDIT:

Eventually I got the right combination of keywords into Google to get me my answer. It was a short indie cartoon by John Welder called "To Be":

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdxucpPq6Lc

drewizzle88 03-27-2013 02:59 AM

really good book, I'm really enjoying this series, I like how some loose ends were tied up yet plenty to look forward to. can't wait to see what Eastman has in store for us next month.

Ninjinister 03-27-2013 05:05 AM

Was this one the victim of another shipping snafu? I just noticed there's a topic on an issue that never hit (my) shelves.

Metropoliskid41 03-27-2013 09:10 AM

If #20 or Secret History of the Foot Clan didn't show up for you I would guess its due to shipping damages, about half the books of both titles that my local shop got in were folded in half to fit into the box by the brainiacs in the Diamond packing dept. I don't know where Diamond finds these people, but they certainly must be scraping the bottom of the workforce barrel.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 03-27-2013 09:27 AM

I don't see why you guys don't just order the books online myself.

Metropoliskid41 03-27-2013 09:39 AM

Because I thoroughly enjoy the weekly trip to the comic shop to talk comics with the shop owner & my close friend, and I like supporting a local business, especially one in an industry like comic retail that its tough to make it in, oh and theres the part that I get a pretty big discount on all of my books too.

Chris 03-27-2013 03:31 PM

Gotta agree with you there, that weekly chat with mates at my local store is one of the highlights of me weekend.

Slade 03-27-2013 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metropoliskid41 (Post 1076379)
If #20 or Secret History of the Foot Clan didn't show up for you I would guess its due to shipping damages, about half the books of both titles that my local shop got in were folded in half to fit into the box by the brainiacs in the Diamond packing dept. I don't know where Diamond finds these people, but they certainly must be scraping the bottom of the workforce barrel.

Glad I read this. I was getting pissed off

Ninjinister 03-27-2013 09:11 PM

Yeah I've got the last of Secret Origin of the Foot Clan, but still no TMNT 20. Comic shop today said they don't know when it'll be in.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:15 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.