The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Image or Volume 4, which did you like more? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=41827)

CyberCubed 03-20-2013 10:31 PM

Image or Volume 4, which did you like more?
 
This is going to be an interesting poll. After the Mirage run of Volume 1 and 2 ended....the Mirage universe continued with Image Volume 3 and Peter Laird's Volume 4. Both made a number of changes to the TMNT canon:

Image:

- Donatello smashed his shell and became a cyborg for the majority of its run before turning back to normal

- Raphael's face got scarred, and he took over the mantle of the Shredder and began leading the Foot Clan for some time. Eventually the Foot Clan betray him and Raphael stops being the Shredder.

- Leonardo's hand gets bitten off, but it regenerates.

- Splinter turns into Man-bat (literally) before being changed back to normal.

- The Turtles meet Shredder's daughter Pimiko, they battle new enemies like King Komodo, Deathwatch, more Triceratons, and Lady Shredder.


Volume 4:

- Utroms land on Earth and all alien lifeforms now walk around among humans just like in Fast Forward in the 4kids cartoons.

- Splinter finally dies of old age, and in Mirage canon Splinter has finally passed.

- April discovers she's a drawing by Kirby's magic crystal.

- Raphael gets bitten by vampires and mutates into his Gamera form.

- Donatello gets shrunk to a tiny size and fights mutated lizards from the Utroms spilled mutagen.

- Mike gets kidnapped into outer space by Styracodons after the Regenta queen uses him. He teams up with Triceraton commando's to get revenge.

- Leonardo and Karai battle Aztec Warriors from another dimension who are killing Foot Soldiers. Leo goes to the Battle Nexus and meets an alternate universe Shredder and Splinter.



So as you can see, Image and Volume 4 changed the main cast A LOT. Some of these changes were reversable, others have stuck. What did you like more?

Powder 03-20-2013 10:51 PM

Vol. 3 is my favorite part of the turtles' comic history. Coolest art/re-imaginings, some neat new characters, cool crossovers, great tone/writing, love it.

Cipher 03-21-2013 01:03 AM

I'm torn.

Volume 4 does more to bring the story and characters forward, but the Image series is better executed.

CyberCubed 03-21-2013 07:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1074043)
I'm torn.

Volume 4 does more to bring the story and characters forward, but the Image series is better executed.

Yeah it kinda amazes me how much Image actually did in only 23 issues. The pacing of that series was quite fast.

Also glad to see the Triceratons tried to attack Earth again in Image, this is something the Mirage run never did. (Because unlike the 4kids series, the Triceratons never invade Earth)

DrSpengler 03-21-2013 07:44 AM

It's a difficult choice. Both directions have some substantial problems in execution.

I felt the Image series advanced some characters, especially Raph and Mike, in ways that no other series have matched. At the same time, I felt they regressed some characters, like Casey. There were some awful arcs (Lord Komodo, Deathwatch), but when the book was good it was great.

Vol. 4 didn't really grow any of the characters in any signifigant way and a lot of it felt like the Turtles were just floating in limbo rather than doing anything of substance. The tedious dialogue, insulting product placement and masturbatory tone didn't help. But it had some really strong moments and while it didn't advance the characters much, it advanced the world (the Utrom thing) and in a way it felt like the world was changing but the Turtles didn't know how to change with it, which may have been the idea.

In the end, I think I'd choose Image just because it's more fun to read. And at the very least, when it gets stuck in a lame storyline, that storyline only spans 4 issues tops. Vol. 4 keeps characters stuck in weak arcs that go on forever.

CyberCubed 03-21-2013 07:55 AM

What I liked most about Vol. 4 was that Splinter finally died. Ever since the first issue in 1984 Splinter talked about being gone and the Turtles having to live with themselves, but it never actually happened.

Splinter finally dying, and of natural causes (rather than some lame superhero-y hero's death) was great and had a long time coming,

Especially since we'll probably never see Splinter die in any other incarnation.

Oculus Orbus 03-21-2013 09:39 AM

Volume 4 for me. It sure had some pretty weak moments, but overall I really enjoyed it.

frank_one 03-21-2013 11:19 AM

Volume 4! I loved it!

corvus 03-21-2013 11:28 AM

I loved volume 4...then I got to the last issue. Had a lot of potential but was cut short. So I voted image.

frank_one 03-21-2013 05:28 PM

20 votes and a tie (10-10) at the moment, wow!

CyberCubed 03-21-2013 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 1074309)
20 votes and a tie (10-10) at the moment, wow!

I knew it would be nearly even, both series do some really good things and some really bad things.

I love how both did try to expand the Mirage universe though.

mrmaczaps 03-21-2013 05:57 PM

Volume 4.
Only read a couple issues from volume 3 and didn't care for them....
But I would like to own them all if I can find a full run.

Cipher 03-21-2013 08:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1074084)
Vol. 4 didn't really grow any of the characters in any signifigant way and a lot of it felt like the Turtles were just floating in limbo rather than doing anything of substance. The tedious dialogue, insulting product placement and masturbatory tone didn't help. But it had some really strong moments and while it didn't advance the characters much, it advanced the world (the Utrom thing) and in a way it felt like the world was changing but the Turtles didn't know how to change with it, which may have been the idea.

Yep. Laird's wonderful with ideas, but really drops the ball on execution.

I get the feeling looking back on it now that Volume 4 was really him channeling his inner Kirby and thinking that enough bombastic, cosmic ideas and the right tone could make up for any problems with dialogue or pacing. I think he's also expressed that, rather than doing an A-to-B drama, he was more interested in the kind of meandering world-building along the lines of, again, guys like Kirby during his New Gods stuff, or more recent indie series like Cerebus or Bone. I feel like he envisioned each chapter as just him getting the chance to this world and the characters adventuring in it, endgame be damned.

The problem is that goal was terribly communicated to the reader. From its opening issue it always seemed like there was an active, serialized plot that was going to come together. Only years later do I realize what he was going for instead.

That's the thing that gets me about Volume 4. It's consistently almost great. Its concepts are wonderful and I think it does a lot for the Mirage universe. It's just that, had it picked a clear approach and run with it (either open-ended world-building or tight serial), and had Laird just passed script duty over to someone like Lawson or Murphy, it could really have been something special.

ChaoticGood 03-25-2013 01:41 PM

I really thought the Image run was total crap from beginning to end.

CyberCubed 03-25-2013 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChaoticGood (Post 1075668)
I really thought the Image run was total crap from beginning to end.

Any reason why?

ChaoticGood 03-25-2013 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1075703)
Any reason why?

I thought the plots were cheap, poorly thought-out and sensationalistic. The art was incomprehensible more often than not, and the characterization of everyone was almost totally flat.

Volume 4 had its problems, for sure (mostly pacing), but there was never the sense that the characters weren't worth caring about like I got from Image.

Chris 03-25-2013 06:41 PM

Whilst I love them both for different reasons I've got to give the edge to Volume 4. I loved the world building it was doing and really hope we get a conclusion some day or at least notes on how it would have all turned out.

Abnormal Freak 03-25-2013 07:25 PM

Vol. 3 is everything I love about comics.

OA 03-25-2013 10:37 PM

For some reason, I could never get past April being drawn as her origin. I'm willing to accept a lot but that crossed the line for me.

Donnie 03-25-2013 11:13 PM

Volume 4, no doubt. I'd take mini-Don over cyborg Don ANY DAY.

CyberCubed 03-26-2013 12:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donnie (Post 1075875)
Volume 4, no doubt. I'd take mini-Don over cyborg Don ANY DAY.

Ironically enough Don sort of became a cyborg again in Vol. 4 when he wore that robot turtle armor that resembled Metalhead in some way.

Martin 04-01-2013 10:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donnie (Post 1075875)
Volume 4, no doubt. I'd take mini-Don over cyborg Don ANY DAY.

This... :lol:

I'm also voting vol 4. It had its weak moments, yes, but I really liked the big narrative and how many changes were introduced. Everything branched out in so many different directions, it was really cool. Shame it was cut short though.

Turns 04-03-2013 01:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by corvus (Post 1074168)
I loved volume 4...then I got to the last issue. Had a lot of potential but was cut short. So I voted image.

Volume 3 was also cut short though. We did eventually get a fanmade conclusion from Andrew (which was great) but that doesn't change the fact that neither of them were ever officially wrapped up.

My vote is for volume 4. Although I hated April being a cartoon and Raph being a vampire, neither were as bad as Donnie being a cyborg (which in my opinion was the worst thing that happened in tmnt comic history). I think it was pretty cool how Raph took over the foot but its not enough to counteract cyborg Donnie.

CyberCubed 04-03-2013 08:32 AM

Why does everyone think Don being turned into a cyborg is so bad compared to April being a drawing?

For one thing we all knew that Don's condition would be reverseable. Even when Image was going on for the first time, it was rather obvious he was going to turn back to normal eventually. Donatello being taken over by an AI for a while was fitting given how much he is interested in technology.

April's condition was not reversable and completely changed the character.

Tuxedo Moroboshi 04-03-2013 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1079107)
Why does everyone think Don being turned into a cyborg is so bad compared to April being a drawing?

For one thing we all knew that Don's condition would be reverseable. Even when Image was going on for the first time, it was rather obvious he was going to turn back to normal eventually. Donatello being taken over by an AI for a while was fitting given how much he is interested in technology.

April's condition was not reversable and completely changed the character.

This has to be one of those rare moments where I agree with CyberCubed. :o


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:21 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.