![]() |
Character Analysis: Mirage Splinter
So, I was able to pick up the "Leonardo: Blind Sight" trade and read it for the first time yesterday, and while it leaves a bit to be desired as a Leonardo story, I was struck by the fact that it's one of the more ambiguous Splinter pieces in the series.
Which got me thinking: Now that it looks like we'll have about as much material in the Mirage universe as we ever will, and certainly as much Splinter as we're likely to get, how does this version of the character stack up? In other words, Mirage Splinter: Wise ninja father-type, or just an unrepentantly awful dude? Maybe those two choice are a bit extreme, but of all major Turtles characters, Mirage Splinter is easily one of the most morally ambiguous. We also have comparatively little material to go off of: His appearances throughout each Mirage volume are very sporadic, and he sits several major events out (notably "Return to New York"). When we do see him, he seems torn between either the wise sensei later incarnations portrayed him as, and an out-and-out vengeful old-worlder who can never quite get over his misplaced sense of honor. I think it's clear either way that this is a substantially more militaristic Splinter than any later version, as even his 1:1, advice-giving sessions with the Turtles often focus on overcoming fear, vengeance, clan honor, etc. (ex., Vol. 1 #9, Tales Vol. 2 #55, Turtle Soup's "The Meaning of Fear" and many more). But is that his primary motivation throughout the series? Does he ever really change? Some key Splinter stories, mostly of the "Splinter is a dick" variety: Quote:
|
Yeah, Mirage Splinter was pretty wicked (as in "wicked witch")
|
Yes, definetely a dark character
I grew up with the Mirage comics, and I don't remember seeing a "positive" characteristic from Splinter. As a teenager, I thought Splinter was the darkest character in Mirage--even darker than the Shredder.
I wouldn't want to go deep into this. |
This goes into one of the many things I detest about Mirage; we estentially have a Splinter who raised the Turtles be weapons of revenge, a trait in fiction that is normally reseved for villians, and often takes actions or descisions that support his own selfish ends. And 'Soul's Winter' was very condeming of splinter, and the results of 'City at War', where his quest for revenge was the indirect catalyst for so much damage and destuction. That story served as a direct condemation of his revenge quest against the shredder he set the turtles on in the first place. His two redeeming qualities is he does deeply care for his family, and will do anything to protect them, and his misplaced honor, while warped by some people's standards, was still a sense of honor nevertheless.
If you like the take that the turtles are a true Shinobi assasin clan, then this is a very developed. layered, and compelling potrayal of the character. If, however, you are one of the crowd who thinks the turtles only learned ninjitsu techniques and martial arts but but use them to follow a more heroic path, then you will loathe this potrayal. (And yes, someone who learned how to be a ninja and practiced the arts, but turned around used ninjitsu for heroic purposes instead of becoming a hired assasin, would still be called a ninja in Japan as a practicioner of said arts) |
One thing Tales retconned is how weak Splinter is as a fighter. I remember reading the attack in April's shop and how Splinter wasn't doing any fighting, whereas in the 4kids version he was fighting right alongside the turtles.
|
The earlier Mirage comics definitely portray him as more of a cold & calculating sensei valuing revenge & honor above all else. As Cipher suggested, the closest thing representing a change in his character arc is the traumatic event he endured during City at War. Many of the stories we see featuring Splinter post-CAW portray him as kinder and more fatherly (Tales v2, TMNT v4). It's a stretch, but maybe when he was forced to eat his own kind to survive, he was symbolically getting rid of that negative, vengeful energy that fueled him in the past?
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I'd be interested in a future universe confronting Splinter's character a little more head-on, as Zulli did in his stories. Maybe even do something where Yoshi and Saki's feud was brought on by something less black-and-white, or where Splinter, as a pet rat, doesn't even fully understand what was happening before tasking himself with avenging his owner. It's pretty gray in Mirage as is. I also got a copy of the first "TMNT & Other Strangeness" book the other day, which has some pretty interesting (and I believe Eastman-and-Laird-approved) things to say about both Saki and Splinter. I may post relevant bits later. |
I always thought the early Eastman/Laird art style somehow made him look demonic in the first issue but strangely adorable between issues 3-12. Eh, don't let his fuzzy dog-like appearance fool you though, that rat is one morally twisted hypocrite.
|
I don't get why you're all condemning Mirage splinter when he acts the same in every other incarnation.
The only real difference is since Splinter IS Yoshi in like 4 other incarnations (Fred Wolf, Archie, Nick and IDW) he doesn't have as much urge to kill Shredder in terms of vengance. Even though in the Nick cartoon he should because he thought Miwa died. In Mirage and 4kids, I can't remember, but didn't he want Shredder dead in both? Pretty sure Exodus in Season 3 was all about Splinter and the Turtles willing to kill themselves as long as Shredder died, and that's what would have happened if the Utroms didn't save them. |
Quote:
|
Mirage Splinter's moral ambiguity is one of the things that makes him my favorite Splinter, he is the atypical Yoda character, the wise old master with great powers hidden in his frail old body. But Splinter isn't pure, he is flawed almost human yet he is a animal.
He is a fuller character then the most other incarnations of him. |
I wonder if a lot of this had to do with the fact the TMNT were originally meant as a parody and I'm not 100% certain the characters in those movies were all likable, ya'know?
Splinter in the original stories is a dick and uses the Turtles as his instruments to reach out and continue on a war that probably would have gone unnoticed. But perhaps it's also hard for Splinter to let it go in that sense, seeing as he's a mutated rat 'n all lol But ya, I dont know... there are a lot of unsavory characters in those old movies the TMNT were inspired from. Splinter only became the peaceful father-figure in the cartoon and from then on it's stuck outside the original Mirage comics. Since then he's only gotten wiser and more one with zen and nirvana. But the comic character remains in darkness, hands stained with blood and thirsty for revenge. At times he teaches what he cannot praise, it seems. But I agree with Kappa that, because of all these 'lil things we're examining... it shows the character is far more developed, complex, and real than the rest of the characters, really. More or less, arguably at least. Quote:
And you said Shredder. That threw me off. Did you still mean Splinter? |
movies?
issue one is a homage to Frank Miller and Jack Kirby. So much that the Daredevil origins are the same as the turtles origin |
LOL
Yup... movies :lol: That was good... Ya, the original Turtles stories parallel Daredevil's. Anyway, I'm tired. Point still stands as fa as the character archetype thing goes.. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
...
A bit of a late reply to this thread, but since it's still fairly recent (only a few months old) and I just finished the Blind Sight arc, I thought I'd offer this interpretation:
If one takes the Mirage Splinter as a more or less manipulative master type of character, it could be said that this vision is supportive of that view. Remember that Splinter gives Leo the vision, and so it's possible that Splinter also has some knowledge (or command) of what kind of vision he gets. I don't know if it's what's intended, but here's how I took the ending: - Leo mentions Kubira to Splinter. Splinter says something like "Kubira - the rat of the Zodiac, cunning and resourceful." This is possibly a reference to Splinter himself. - After Leo leaves, Splinter says something like Kubira gives thanks for having his swords returned to him. My take - Splinter is cunning and resourceful for giving Leo a vision which comforts him, returning his confidence and sight to him. He therefore has "his swords" - Leo - returned to him. The man in the vision ("the one who Leo supposedly killed") was suggested to him by Splinter all along, as Leo was having the vision. In other words, it's not that Leo REALLY didn't kill the man, but rather that Leo was having a vision, and while he was having the vision, Splinter gave the SUGGESTION that Leo didn't really kill the man, thereby returning Leo's vision and confidence to him, thereby restoring Splinter's "swords." Thoughts? Also, Leo mentions something about how he never noticed Splinter's aura before...I wonder if that has any significance to it as well? |
Quote:
Quote:
http://www.onelifecounselling.com.au.../ouroboros.jpg |
Mirage Splinter was usually pretty dark, for sure. I think he's very very shady in the new cartoon, too.
Also in Volume 4, in the Battle Nexus, Leo shows up and Splinter is there. Instead of rushing to see Leo, who thinks Splinter is dead, Splinter acts kind of indifferent and decides to drink some tea. They did all have a pretty cute group hug in Volume 1 when the Turtles got back from space, though. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Relevant: Tales of the TMNT #55, the one that's supposed to take place just before the turtles' fateful encounter with the Purple Dragons. Putting aside the questionable continuity details--the turtles know about Hamato Yoshi--we have the apparent inconsistency of having Splinter being super well adjusted and fatherly the day before he suddenly becomes all manipulative and uncaring.
|
Part of me wonders if Laird realized that very issue when he was working so closely with Lloyd on the 4Kids series. That Splinter readily admits he kept the story of Shredder and Hamato Yoshi a secret to keep the Turtles training from being tainted by revenge.
Could Splinter's characterization in 1.1 basically just be chalked up to the fact that it wasn't intended to become a series? |
It looks like they try to recon a bit fatherly into him, and despite some issues, I do like the idea that Splinter developed a fatherly bond with the turtles as times passes as he trains them to be his stand-in to kill Saki.
It would have been nice with some deeper insight in Splinters mind as he stays on his mission while getting more attached to the turtles. |
One wonders how a story about what was going through Splinter's mind as the Turtles were out fighting Shredder would play...
|
Quote:
My guess is that they never thought the comic would be as huge as it was, and they believed the idea of the ninja revenge was a good one shot story. Once the series took off though, they wanted Splinter to be a bit more of a likable character. Thankfully, they didn't turn him completely into sunshine and rainbows though. One of my favorite moments with the character is when he's fed up with April's whining and tells her to leave. |
Quote:
I'm conflicted by his manipulative characterisation in the first issue - on one hand he comes across as uncaring and selfish, almost sociopathic in his tunnel vision, even. On the other hand, his determination to see his 'students' obtain revenge which has been fifteen years in the making is pretty hardcore and really displays the patience/methodical nature of the rat (and patience and being thorough are also traits of a sociopath). This to me really fleshes out the revenge story and gives that first issue the 'oomph' that makes it so special - the motive, the burning desire to put things right (in his eyes). There's an interesting dichotomy there between father/manipulator and children/killers. Originally I too believed that Splinter's actions were reprehensible, but having lost almost everything he probably felt that his desire to avenge Yoshi was the only thing that would get him through the days. His commitment to this goal no doubt planted itself inside him long before he developed his affection for the turtles. By then he'd be past the point of no return - it will have consumed him. I guess it raises questions about the rights and wrongs of revenge (well, believing you have achieved vengeance at least). That may well be the biggest question to take from that first issue. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I do think it's hard to stomach Splinter as solely a vengeful guy, raising his sons only to kill. There are two ways Splinter can go: a grey character who really does love his sons, or the truly dark manipulative character whom the Turtles slowly realize does not care for them. I think he's been shown as both in Mirage. I guess I prefer the former, although the latter would make for interesting development for the Turtles as they realize their dad is a pretty bad guy. Either way, they are raised as child soldiers, essentially.
I kind of do prefer later IDW's version of the Turtles where they have to work up to killing, and have a lot of moral problems with it (even if it's truly bad people they are killing). That makes them more relatable to most of us who haven't killed anyone. It also provides room for development if the main characters don't start off as killing. Spoiler:
|
...
Quote:
|
My Q&A with Peter on the latest Ask PL blog entry:
Q: A lot of people have debated about the Mirage Splinter that he was a "bad dad" figure, that he raised the TMNT only to kill Shredder one day. Do you see this as true?" Peter: No. I certainly think that particular obsession of Splinter's harmed the Turtles in certain ways, and set them on a path of conflict with the Foot that haunted them for a long time… but Splinter also clearly came to love the boys and treat them with great affection, as a good father. Which I followed with: Q: Nagi beats up Tang Shen => Yoshi kills Nagi => Saki kills Yoshi => Turtles kill Saki => Shredder Elite & Foot stalk the TMNT. "City at War" kind of put it under the microscrope and made the TMNT themselves sort of aware of it (and subsequently, able to step out of it), but what are your thoughts on the whole sort of... unnecessary (in the sense that it could be avoided) circle of vengeance seen throughout Vol. 1? It's always been a fascinating part of the Mirage material to me, but I was wondering your own thoughts on the matter." Peter: It's part of the subtext of the basic TMNT story -- that violence begets violence, even when violence is used to STEM violence. And it's the one great flaw that Splinter as a character had in the comics, which makes him a much more interesting character, in my opinion. And I agree. You remove that flaw from the equation, the bottom drops out. |
as much as i love the mirage splinter, his stance was a bit confusing. i really enjoyed him in C@W though.
the IDW versions of splinter is my favorite. he is similar to the original movie splinter (caring and wise fatherly sensei) yet he is a fully capable ninja who can kick ass. |
Agreed on the IDW Splinter. He encompasses what I like most about Splinter. Hell I love all of the Splinters. As someone said earlier, the nick splinter even comes off as multifaceted, self serving and dark in moments. In some ways Splinter is more interesting to me than any of the turtles.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:50 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.