The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Will IDW TMNT Reach Issue #100?? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=42925)

Redrumh2o 05-29-2013 02:35 PM

Will IDW TMNT Reach Issue #100??
 
Just wondering what everyone thinks. I am not counting the micros and sub-series....just the Plain Jane storyline book to #100.

To me it depends on the success of the movie

#100 would put us to around what...Jan 2020??

Tazi 05-29-2013 03:01 PM

It will probably depend on the long term sales... which makes me curious about how well IDW-TMNT does, compared to series like TMNTA or Mirage v4 / Tales v2.
Anyone has numbers for these?

Redrumh2o 05-29-2013 03:15 PM

I was thinking that IDW would hold the line regardless as long as the show was still doing well and the movies were big.....if they didn't then someone else would just pick the line up and they would lose market share. Even if they had a year or two of break-even on the line...to me it would still be something to continue/hold on to....but that's just me

discordiatookie 05-29-2013 03:31 PM

I certainly hope so!

dkram230 05-29-2013 03:41 PM

At this point I see no reason why not. They have been pretty consistent at releasing them monthly and are giving the title a lot of support. I think the Nick TMNT show has at least another 4 years of popularity that will for sure carry the comic title. Not to mention the great artistry and storytelling that's going along with it.

One thing of importance to note is that IDW is a new company in terms of publishers- founded in 1999. Their bread and butter now are comics based on existing franchises such as TV, movies, games, etc. It was a great strategy to get them off the ground. Who knows if their focus will change in the future or if it ends up making business sense for whatever reason to drop the license from Viacom. But with how things are operating now I believe that this volume will reach at least 100.

Tazi 05-29-2013 03:44 PM

Btw, if it's 100 issues overall, we're almost halfway from that.
Next villian micro issue (Old Hob I think) will be the 40th original IDW TMNT comic, counting ongoing, micros, secret history, annual, and infestation 2 issues.
At the end of City Fall, we will be over 50.

discordiatookie 05-29-2013 03:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1104271)
If you mean "a hundred issues of IDW TMNT comics" then yes, I see that happening.

If you mean "an issue of IDW TMNT numbered 100" then no, that just doesn't happen in today's comic book marketing environment. #1 relaunches are too lucrative a gimmick to pass up on in favor of the "distinguishment" of higher numbering. At any rate, high numbers are considered poison, these days, as there's a stigma that they frighten away potential new readers like garlic to a vampire.

IDW's already relaunched Ghostbusters and they've relaunched Transformers I dunno how many times. Haven't they already relaunched GI Joe, too?

So I'm sure a renumbering/relaunch is in TMNT's future long before it even gets a sniff of #100. In the end, it's just a sales gimmick and doesn't impact the actual content of the book. I've made my peace with higher numbers being a relic of the past (if Action Comics and Detective Comics have abandoned original numbering, then the era is officially over). Realistically, it never served that great a purpose other than as shorthand proof of a title's longevity, I guess.

Two of my favourite comics, Invincible & The Walking Dead have both fairly recently passed issue 100. Guess that makes them different these days! I wonder if both books being from the same creator has something to do with it, mind you...

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 05-29-2013 04:03 PM

It was already stated that it doesn't include the micros and sub-series. I think if they choose not to "re-start" the numbering, it would be easy to make it to 100, based on how successful the book has been thus far and how well it is being promoted on here and on other forums.

Rat_King 05-29-2013 04:14 PM

Let's face it, it all comes down to the story. While relaunching is traditionally done to get new readers, events like "City Fall" do the same thing. I'm sure with Kevin so heavily behind it, it will do well and bring plenty of new readers on board. I think the trick will be to go back to the standard for IDW TMNT and then have Kevin hit it hard again another 20 issues later. Doing that, I can see them hitting 100. And there are so many characters people want to see and new versions of old stories. So, to reiterate, it all comes down to the story.

ToxicRevolution 05-29-2013 04:22 PM

That would be pretty great. It seems to be pretty popular, so if the popularity keeps up then why not? Some people here have made good points about #1 reboots being better for business and such.

oldmanwinters 05-29-2013 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1104271)
If you mean "a hundred issues of IDW TMNT comics" then yes, I see that happening.

If you mean "an issue of IDW TMNT numbered 100" then no, that just doesn't happen in today's comic book marketing environment. #1 relaunches are too lucrative a gimmick to pass up on in favor of the "distinguishment" of higher numbering. At any rate, high numbers are considered poison, these days, as there's a stigma that they frighten away potential new readers like garlic to a vampire.

I second this sentiment.

In fact, there is a sense in which the City Fall arc has me thinking we might soon be reaching a climax in this particular "volume" of the TMNT line.

Matches Malone 05-29-2013 04:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1104271)
If you mean "a hundred issues of IDW TMNT comics" then yes, I see that happening.

If you mean "an issue of IDW TMNT numbered 100" then no, that just doesn't happen in today's comic book marketing environment. #1 relaunches are too lucrative a gimmick to pass up on in favor of the "distinguishment" of higher numbering. At any rate, high numbers are considered poison, these days, as there's a stigma that they frighten away potential new readers like garlic to a vampire.

IDW's already relaunched Ghostbusters and they've relaunched Transformers I dunno how many times. Haven't they already relaunched GI Joe, too?

So I'm sure a renumbering/relaunch is in TMNT's future long before it even gets a sniff of #100. In the end, it's just a sales gimmick and doesn't impact the actual content of the book. I've made my peace with higher numbers being a relic of the past (if Action Comics and Detective Comics have abandoned original numbering, then the era is officially over). Realistically, it never served that great a purpose other than as shorthand proof of a title's longevity, I guess.

Pretty much my thoughts. While TMNT has been doing steady, it does not have the kind of hype or creator-oriented approach of The Walking Dead. Being a license, it is very doubtful IDW will resist renumbering TMNT before long. Heck, they've already done it to the Micro-Series for the villains; something I was actually quite surprised by. But in terms of 100 issues regardless of numbering, I think there's a strong chance of that.

CyberCubed 05-29-2013 04:53 PM

The main series can't reach 100 as only 12 issues come out a year. The series would have to go on for nearly a decade.

Martin 05-29-2013 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1104312)
The main series can't reach 100 as only 12 issues come out a year. The series would have to go on for nearly a decade.

Okay, so what I'm reading is "we need moar issues per month!!!!". Everyone is seeing the same thing? No? Ok, I'll just go now.

Well, now srly, yeah I see what you are saying and I really hadn't thought of it before. It does seem weird that the series would run that long even with an eventual relaunch. However, if we all agree that there'll be a renumbering before reaching the issue #100, would that make the the micros and minis count as well? because if we consider those, that would rise the number of released titles to approximately 24 per year (there were some months in which a second title wasn't released so this isn't a 100% accurate), what means that we would reach a 100 turtles comics in about three years (I think we are up to 37 total so far).

Bobby Curnow 05-29-2013 09:54 PM

I'm a huge fan of comics keeping their own numbering and not relaunching with #1s. I'd really like to get to something like 75 so it can be the longest "run" of a TMNT volume, but that's just a personal goal. We've got the basics of the story for another couple years, so I think #50 is very likely.

As long as sales hold strong, I think the mentality will be 'why fix it if it's not broken?'

We'll see. Ultimately not my decision.

Vi11AiN6 05-29-2013 10:03 PM

I certainly hope so! This is the best TMNT series in the whole franchise!
I've been reading TMNT comics since 1988!

MikeandRaph87 05-29-2013 10:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1104439)
I'm a huge fan of comics keeping their own numbering and not relaunching with #1s. I'd really like to get to something like 75 so it can be the longest "run" of a TMNT volume, but that's just a personal goal. We've got the basics of the story for another couple years, so I think #50 is very likely.

As long as sales hold strong, I think the mentality will be 'why fix it if it's not broken?'

We'll see. Ultimately not my decision.

I'm glad the editor has the exact issue goal as this fan! 75 is a great goal but of course taking it a storyarc at a time all the while!

With this new concept of #1s selling well then the drop off with each issue giving a month boost or so never sat well with me. I like seeing history with the numbers and showing a viable product with each increasing number of issue. Funny enough third party comics are getting to where it has higher numbers than DC and Marvel. Look at Archie and its associated titles like Sonic.

oldmanwinters 05-29-2013 10:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1104439)
I'm a huge fan of comics keeping their own numbering and not relaunching with #1s. I'd really like to get to something like 75 so it can be the longest "run" of a TMNT volume, but that's just a personal goal.

I support this goal! :tthumbsu::tthumbsu:

Jester 05-29-2013 10:18 PM

Nah! 99, tops.


:D

oldmanwinters 05-29-2013 10:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1104450)
Nah! 99, tops.


:D

I wonder if any title has ever tried to combine an "Anniversary/Milestone Issue" with a "Relaunch/New #1"? That would be a Collector's Item Field Day!

Shark_Blade 05-29-2013 10:54 PM

I hope so. With the new movie to be launch, I'm certain a new flood of fans will enter the TMNT comic world too. Exciting! :D

Sonic the Hedgehog has over 200 issues, and I remember being so happy when they reached #100, #200 and other anniversaries. Yes I collect them too. :3

Redeemer 05-29-2013 11:51 PM

I really hope so, I am just afraid they might try to relaunch after the movie....

CyberCubed 05-30-2013 09:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redeemer (Post 1104480)
I really hope so, I am just afraid they might try to relaunch after the movie....

I just hope they don't restart continuity altogether at some point. IDW is already the first major reboot since the Mirage universe, we don't need a reboot of a reboot.

Of course comics based on the cartoons like the Archie and Nick comics are exempt from this.

MikLeo 05-30-2013 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redeemer (Post 1104480)
I really hope so, I am just afraid they might try to relaunch after the movie....

I don't think so. What would be the point?

MikeandRaph87 05-30-2013 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1104461)
I wonder if any title has ever tried to combine an "Anniversary/Milestone Issue" with a "Relaunch/New #1"? That would be a Collector's Item Field Day!

Do you mean like Marvel did for Amazing Spider-Man. From issue #442-#499 it had dual numbers before it went back to just the one number with #500 back in 2003 and Fantastic Four did the same just before when it stopped its original numbering at #416 and had dual numbering up to #500 just before ASM returned to its numbering a month later. At DC Superman became the Adventures of Superman in 1987 before reverting back to Superman(title) in 2006 until its unfortuante demise in the Fall of 2011 along with the stragely combined issues of Wonder Woman hitting 600 for all of 11 issues. So yes it has been done just hope the company sticks to it. Numbers mean a rich history and show staying power and success not turning off new readers because of a high numbers labeled on the book like some think.

LH 05-30-2013 11:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1104439)
As long as sales hold strong, I think the mentality will be 'why fix it if it's not broken?'

Sounds like a good motto to me! :tthumbsu:

mgambino 05-30-2013 02:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1104461)
I wonder if any title has ever tried to combine an "Anniversary/Milestone Issue" with a "Relaunch/New #1"? That would be a Collector's Item Field Day!

Well, the past 3 issues of Skullkickers have each been a new #1 with a variant cover that has the real issue # on it. Not exactly the same, but a nice snarky take on comic relaunches.

corvus 05-30-2013 03:02 PM

I think so. They've been pumping out good stories steadily. Very few delays. I'd hate to see them renumber and get all the stuff twisted and confusing. I hate when publishers do that. If we get New 52 style tmnt I'm gonna quit reading.

oldmanwinters 05-30-2013 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1104666)
Do you mean like Marvel did for Amazing Spider-Man. From issue #442-#499 it had dual numbers before it went back to just the one number with #500 back in 2003 and Fantastic Four did the same just before when it stopped its original numbering at #416 and had dual numbering up to #500 just before ASM returned to its numbering a month later. At DC Superman became the Adventures of Superman in 1987 before reverting back to Superman(title) in 2006 until its unfortuante demise in the Fall of 2011 along with the stragely combined issues of Wonder Woman hitting 600 for all of 11 issues. So yes it has been done just hope the company sticks to it. Numbers mean a rich history and show staying power and success not turning off new readers because of a high numbers labeled on the book like some think.

Wow, I had no idea! The Big 2 sure can be crazy to generate sales!

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgambino (Post 1104759)
Well, the past 3 issues of Skullkickers have each been a new #1 with a variant cover that has the real issue # on it. Not exactly the same, but a nice snarky take on comic relaunches.

Heh, I love it! I have seen comics emphasize the sub-numbering of a mini-series even though they keep the true numbering hidden somewhere else on the cover.

CyberCubed 03-10-2014 01:58 PM

Just curious, but with only 12 issues of the main volume a year...what year would it take us to get to IDW issue #100 since we're at #32 now?

Powder 03-10-2014 02:19 PM

Basic math would answer that question, buddy. C'mon now, you can do it.

SDCC 03-10-2014 05:17 PM

So far we've a great rotation of talent, with consistently strong stories. All the while introducing new characters whilst effectively introducing old favourites.

They're keeping hold of Mateus, and they've even made Krang a character I can get on board with.

It's all there for a long run. Fingers crossed.

P.S - Does anyone know what the sales are like? And how they stack against comics from the big 2?

Powder 03-10-2014 05:47 PM

This thread regularly records sales- http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=35767

nimajneb 03-10-2014 05:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SDCC (Post 1225429)
So far we've a great rotation of talent, with consistently strong stories. All the while introducing new characters whilst effectively introducing old favourites.

They're keeping hold of Mateus, and they've even made Krang a character I can get on board with.

It's all there for a long run. Fingers crossed.

P.S - Does anyone know what the sales are like? And how they stack against comics from the big 2?

Yeah, I'd like to know this too.
Mateus is signed up to at least issue 50 so hopefully we'll see it double that!
There's always kick starter these days but I think it does quite well, IGN put it in there list of top comics that isn't marvel or DC so it's popular.
And the movie can only boost sales, surely.

SDCC 03-10-2014 06:04 PM

Good shout Power, cheers.

So then, a gentle decline in sales numbers.

Makes me think I need to buy each issue as well as get a review copy. It's so good it more then deserves me spending a few quid on it each month. Actually the more I think about it the more I feel stupid for not buying it. Not pulling my weight.

This is about to be rectified.

Joey Kamikaze 03-10-2014 11:22 PM

And of course if you want to count in the (16) micro-series issues, SHotFC (4) & Utrom Empire (3), the 2012 Annual (1) and the Infestation (2) & Conspiracy (1) tie-ins, this universe has already surpassed 50 issues. I know we're talking about actual numbered monthly issues, but having just finished a full series re-read... we've already gotten a lot of TMNT from IDW in the past few years.

Counting all of Utrom and the other side stuff + 32 issues as of a couple days from now, we're sitting at... 59 issues as of March 2014, unless I'm forgetting anything.

shuriken 03-10-2014 11:35 PM

The continued book should reach 100 in November of 2019, reaching 40 this November. Considering IDW keeps releasing miniseries we could get to a hundred issues in three years (overall). Barely finished CityFall so I have some catching up to do.

nimajneb 03-11-2014 03:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SDCC (Post 1225456)
Good shout Power, cheers.

So then, a gentle decline in sales numbers.

Makes me think I need to buy each issue as well as get a review copy. It's so good it more then deserves me spending a few quid on it each month. Actually the more I think about it the more I feel stupid for not buying it. Not pulling my weight.

This is about to be rectified.

IDW certainly gets my moneys worth - I've been buying the issues from my local cb store since the run began but recently I went back and bought the comixology collections to read on my way to work as it was easy to read on the sardine can, sorry train, to work. :twink:

SDCC 03-11-2014 04:49 AM

I've got up to #15 in physical form, plus I've got the Foot Clan tpb.

Recently though I made the jump to digital (I wrote a piece on it here).

The review copies I get sent are digital too.

So I'll be hitting Comixology and catching up! Lots to buy. I do hope that me buying through that gets noted though. Be nice to have them all on my tablet/phone and catch up.:tgrin:

Plasticplayhouse 03-11-2014 05:51 AM

i've purchased every issue to date; a couple issues, i've even purchased duplicates. i too hope that this series breaks 100. if they don't have a solid plot to take it that far yet, they could do a couple filler archs to buy time. maybe one based on the sons of the silent age issue from volume one. i would like to see idw cover the river series...maybe expand on it, but i doubt that'll ever happen.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:54 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.