![]() |
Why aren't there any Japanese actors cast for this movie?
For a movie based on a franchise where the main villain and hero mentor are Japanese and are supposed to be fighting ninja's, there don't seem to be any Japanese actors cast for this movie.
|
Because Micheal Bay.
|
|
Why would you ask this question? Nobody here knows.
|
Quote:
|
Its really bizarre given how deeply TMNT is surrounded by Japanese mythology.
And the main villain is supposed to be Japanese, in fact he's ALWAYS been Japanese excluding the Utrom Shredder who still pretended to be Japanese when he was in his human disguise. And Splinter should be Japanese as well no matter which origin they go with. |
It is a good question to ask, but I don't know if you will find an answer for it since we are still unsure of who exactly is being cast for Shredder (or if Shredder will be appearing, separate from Col. Schrader), or if Colonel Schrader will be Shredder. I can see your point CyberCubed that the actors playing Splinter/Hamato Yoshi and Shredder should at least have some Japanese ethnicity since the whole TMNT premise is based in Japan. But I think the casting could get away in hiring an actor outside of the race for Splinter/Hamato Yoshi, because I don't think you could visually portray human race on an animal, or rat in this case.
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
This is what directors, producers, and Hollywood always do. They just go for somewhat big name ppl and cast them instead of using the ethnicity from source material. It always ends up being the newest or longest, notable white dudes who get the roles for no apparent reason, even if they're not the right match. This has always been the case, and it doesn't surprise me. I hate it.
|
Whitewashing is one of the crappiest things hollywood ever came up with. Believe me, I hate it. We don't have the answer to that question, though.
|
To be fair, the ninja do stay in NY, they could be American recruits. Splinter don't need to be played by any specific ethnicity, he is a rat, unless you go for the Fred Wolf origin, which then you should have a guy that at least can go for being Japanese in flashbacks when Yoshi was human. And have Shredder even been cast?
As for now only Burne have gotten a ethnicity change and a gender bender. |
Quote:
Personally, I don't care if Shredder turns out to be Japanese. Especially if he doesn't even turn out to be a ninja... |
|
So the actor playing Splinter isn't Japanese, so it's safe to assume they aren't going with the cartoon origin of him being Hamato Yoshi, unless they just have a flashback where he doesn't speak or something. Will they stick to the original comic/movie origin where he's Yoshi's pet rat that picks up ninjitsu by watching him?
If Shredder isn't Japanese and there is little to no Japanese element in this movie, how do the turtles become ninjas? |
Because Kevin clash is soooo Japanese, and his origin in the first film was nothing like the cartoon....
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I suppose Woodburn could do the same although based on what I've seen him in (which admittedly isn't much) he hasn't played anything but a crotchety American. I'm guessing it's pretty much his "thing". I think we can all agree he wouldn't pass for a human Hamato Yoshi. It'd be weird if we got so much from the Fred Wolf show and didn't get Splinter's origin from the show. Then again for all we know Splinter's origin in this movie could be that he was once 'Harry' the janitor in The Foot military base and didn't didn't get along with Schrader so in a hilarious tug of war with a mop goes careening into the closet were the ooze is kept. He trains the TMNT to get revenge on Schrader for taking his favourite bucket. |
Quote:
Quote:
And I'm not really addressing you when I say that, you actually seem to have a sense of humor about it, I'm talking to these other people who are up in arms a out the whole thing. And remember, you loved Japanese Elmo! |
The only 2 people that needed to be Japanese would have been Shredder and Splinter, but Splinter technically didn't learn to speak until he was in NY which would have made him have a New York accent if anything, even though he remember Ninja moves, usually your accent is determined by who you are around recently.
Shredder has been replaced in the story by an army guy that I am sure is an American soldier since it happens in NY as well, so I don't see who else would need to be Japanese? I never understood people complaining about Avatar, it never says anyone is Asian or Eskimo in the entire cartoon, they were certain tribes never said they were Asian, Eskimo, African American, Indian. Saying Splinter should talk as if he is Japanese in the story arcs where he is a rat and doesn't learn to talk until he is mutated in New York is the same as in Weeds when Kevin Nealon thinks the Hispanic baby should speak Spanish just because he is half Mexican. |
There is no reason for Splinter to be Japanese outside of the children's spinoffs where the mutagen is a "touch this become that" farce and he has a Japanese man hiding inside of him.
|
Who cares if no Japanese actors are cast. What's the big ****ing deal anyways? This is an American film
|
Quote:
|
America. **** Yeah!
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I'm flexible on who portrays who in TMNT except for Shredder. He needs to be Japanese or at least east-asian. If they cast a Chinese or Korean actor to play him, while still messed up, at least it's better than him being white. (BTW, I am white, but I, like many, just want as much authenticity as possible). I think TMNT (1990) Shredder was awesome. Anyway if you look at the casting for the new film, outside of April they aren't casting big stars I guess you can count Whoopi but I can't see her playing a big part in this... so that may be a good sign that they'll go for a Japanese actor, because clearly here in the west we have very few actors of Japanese heritage who could fill the boots of a star if they were going for that.
While the turtles aren't voiced or mo-capped from Japanese actors, I think it's a fair bet that some (or most) of the stunts/martial arts will be performed by asians, so there's that. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Because 1 of the 4 words in the title is inherently... you know... Japanese. And every member of the group of their most infamous rogues' gallery is supposed to be.
|
Quote:
|
Here's hoping for no white girl Karai at least. On the plus side, if no one's Asian, they can't make them into terrible Asian stereotypes? Nah, they'll find a way to work that in probably.
I still don't get why they whitewash movies so heavily, especially movies that have anything at all to do with martial arts. They've made a bunch of fighting game movies over the past decade and pretty much made the stars be white characters or white actors, and big shock they are all awful. You know what fighting-game-into-movie was the most successful ? Mortal Kombat. The one with an Asian lead. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Bebop looks thoroughly black to me. |
Wait what? Hollywood failing? Again?
To hell you say! |
Quote:
|
I've wondered this same thing myself. They need to inject some Japanese in here quick. Maybe no Japanese actors are willing to work with the folks doing this movie.
(...and people who rationalize it by saying it's an American film probably won't mind if Michael Bay changes the turtles into hermit crabs. I mean they both have shells right. Pff...) I figure: Movie Title: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Ninja: Japanese word Seems like there'd be cultural Japanese elements abound throughout every incarnation since it's partially named after something fully Japanese. Especially a movie. They even speak a lil Japanese in the new show. The new show totally gets it. Shredder and Splinter have always been Japanese...to my best knowledge. Whether you're a Japanese man with a Japanese name or the pet of a Japanese man or the rival of a Japanese man with a Japanese name you should be Japanese looking and/or sounding in a movie adaptation. I'll even take Japanese-ish. ...as far as I'm concerned to impress me you have to be better than the first movie's Shredder. |
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:07 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.