The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   IDW's "no kill" policy (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=42986)

MikLeo 06-01-2013 03:06 PM

IDW's "no kill" policy
 
I read that IDW wont allow the turtles to kill. Any info on the subject if its true or not?

Tazi 06-01-2013 03:07 PM

IDW is kind of toned down in violence compared to mirage, that's true, but we don't really know yet, where exactly the limits are, or are we?

where did you read it btw?

CyberCubed 06-01-2013 04:23 PM

For the record its only the Turtles who don't kill, the villains can kill obviously. We did see Yoshi and his sons murdered by Shredder in Japan.

Matches Malone 06-01-2013 05:09 PM

This question has been danced around several times by the editor and writer. Some suspect Nick/Viacom have issued such a policy, but my guess is more likely that Nick selected a creative team that already isn't too interested in having the turtles kill. In Waltz's latest video interview, he more or less confirms that they don't want their heroes killing. He is correct in his assertion though, that it is appreciated that at least they attempt to address the issue, albeit to varying degrees of success. Of course, it's still not completely clear whether it is a strict "no killing ever" policy, since they currently have the "Destroy Shredder Manifesto" in place, so perhaps there will be exceptions.

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=42532

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1105833)
For the record its only the Turtles who don't kill, the villains can kill obviously. We did see Yoshi and his sons murdered by Shredder in Japan.

For the record, OP says that in his initial post...

snake 06-01-2013 05:14 PM

What about foot soilders? They've been knocked around in a few issues.

Matches Malone 06-01-2013 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snakeweed101 (Post 1105855)
What about foot soilders? They've been knocked around in a few issues.

Knocked around, yes, but the topic is about whether the turtles are allowed to kill.

snake 06-01-2013 05:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Matches Malone (Post 1105868)
Knocked around, yes, but the topic is about whether the turtles are allowed to kill.

Yeah, I know, but can the turtles kill any foot soilders? I mean, they can still be killed if its shown off panel. For example, Donetello knocks a foot soilder to the wall with his Bo, the foot soilder slumps over. It wouldn't be violent but still implies that he's killed.

MikeandRaph87 06-01-2013 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikLeo (Post 1105804)
I read that IDW wont allow the turtles to kill. Any info on the subject if its true or not?

This is a huge issue that has been teased since the beginning! Its the biggest problem I have with the series since it won't clarly say the turtles are not murderers. The TMNT don't kill as that was exclusive to the black and white comics at the very beginning and I truly hope it stays that way. Its a divisive issue upon fans at least on this site. I will drop this comic if a turtle does the same that a villain would and slay an opponent but others are waiting on the edge of their seats for it to happen. Its divivded mostly in camps of Other Media vs B&W comics. I believe it goes against the ethics of the turtles and what they stand for but other actually don't think it is a core value of what makes the TMNT.

corvus 06-01-2013 06:29 PM

It never shows the foot ninjas suffering from seizures and PTSD after getting knocked unconscious by a giant mutant turtle with nunchucks.

Matches Malone 06-01-2013 07:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snakeweed101 (Post 1105873)
Yeah, I know, but can the turtles kill any foot soilders? I mean, they can still be killed if its shown off panel. For example, Donetello knocks a foot soilder to the wall with his Bo, the foot soilder slumps over. It wouldn't be violent but still implies that he's killed.

Bobby has confirmed that they haven't killed any Foot soldiers, just knocked them out. Plus, it's been touched upon every once in a while making it clear that they "walk the path of peace" and it's a struggle enough to decide to kill someone who is a legitimate threat, let alone a Foot soldier flunkie who they can easily take out without killing.

Powder 06-01-2013 07:24 PM

Though I enjoy violent turtles in the right place & time (vol. 3, Bodycount), I don't really care either way about this alleged policy. The IDW turtles are awesome but they are admittedly a little soft, so I'm fine with them taking a more peaceful path. If they do start to cross that line though, I hope it's just. I don't want it to become a sudden thing, it should be eluded to. There should be a 'sensible' mindset about making that choice to off their opponents, such as letting someone go who ended up killing a person they care for and from then on deciding not to let those with malicious intentions go free.

Cipher 06-01-2013 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1105908)
Though I enjoy violent turtles in the right place & time (vol. 3, Bodycount), I don't really care either way about this alleged policy. The IDW turtles are awesome but they are admittedly a little soft, so I'm fine with them taking a more peaceful path. If they do start to cross that line though, I hope it's just. I don't want it to become a sudden thing, it should be eluded to. There should be a 'sensible' mindset about making that choice to off their opponents, such as letting someone go who ended up killing a person they care for and from then on deciding not to let those with malicious intentions go free.

I think it's fine narratively, but it's already been an issue in terms of believability when you have characters with bladed weapons fighting their way through hordes of opponents without taking a life. Those were the situations in which the Mirage Turtles drew blood most of the time as well -- they weren't wanton murderers, and with a few notable exceptions, usually only killed when surrounded in a do-or-die situation.

I do hope it's something the creative team at IDW is in full control of, though with the amount of black blood we've been seeing lately, I suspect there's some mandate from higher up that things not get too (literally) dicey.

drewizzle88 06-01-2013 07:55 PM

I thought they had killed before, an example I could remember was in issue 12 I thought Leonardo killed this women. But I guess not? :tconfuse:


ToxicRevolution 06-01-2013 08:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by drewizzle88 (Post 1105920)
I thought they had killed before, an example I could remember was in issue 12 I thought Leonardo killed this women. But I guess not? :tconfuse:


Spoiler:
Considering that's Karai and she's a major part of the City Fall arc... No, he didn't kill her.

drewizzle88 06-01-2013 09:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToxicRevolution (Post 1105935)
Spoiler:
Considering that's Karai and she's a major part of the City Fall arc... No, he didn't kill her.

I don't guess I realized that was her, just remember back when I read the issue I was surprised he killed a woman, damn I'm an idiot!

Weapons@theready 06-01-2013 09:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1105887)
I believe it goes against the ethics of the turtles and what they stand for but other actually don't think it is a core value of what makes the TMNT.

I want to know where you get your idea of Turtle Ethics

Coola Yagami 06-01-2013 09:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by drewizzle88 (Post 1105960)
I don't guess I realized that was her, just remember back when I read the issue I was surprised he killed a woman, damn I'm an idiot!

Unless Leo mastered the Iron Headbutt of Death, I doubt that would have killed her anyway.

Half Sh3ll Hero 06-01-2013 10:00 PM

I wouldn't mind a few justified killings... as long as they were few and far between. The Mirage Turtles are bad ass. But I like the tone that the IDW Turtles sets. If only we could have a balanced medium of both.

snake 06-01-2013 10:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 1105974)
Unless Leo mastered the Iron Headbutt of Death, I doubt that would have killed her anyway.

That made me lol.

beardcore84 06-01-2013 11:45 PM

Splinter has taught the turtles that no violence shall be used unless absolutely necessary. He is wrought with self conflict over even having a "shredder must be stopped policy". I'm SO glad the turtles don't kill, because it would lower then to their enemies level, and also, if and or when they do kill shredder etc or someone does die, not necessarily from being murdered, it will make it a much bigger deal.

MikeandRaph87 06-01-2013 11:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beardcore84 (Post 1106031)
Splinter has taught the turtles that no violence shall be used unless absolutely necessary. He is wrought with self conflict over even having a "shredder must be stopped policy". I'm SO glad the turtles don't kill, because it would lower then to their enemies level, and also, if and or when they do kill shredder etc or someone does die, not necessarily from being murdered, it will make it a much bigger deal.

Amen brother! Its like you are in my head!

Venom 06-02-2013 01:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beardcore84 (Post 1106031)
Splinter has taught the turtles that no violence shall be used unless absolutely necessary. He is wrought with self conflict over even having a "shredder must be stopped policy". I'm SO glad the turtles don't kill, because it would lower then to their enemies level, and also, if and or when they do kill shredder etc or someone does die, not necessarily from being murdered, it will make it a much bigger deal.

The Turtles would not be lowered in any way - their lives are in danger when in combat and as professionally trained ninja they have very right to defend their lives with the loss of the enemy's.

Staying on the topic-at-large, I remember the IDW team stating that year 2 would focus a lot on the ethical and moral ramifications of taking a life, but thus far we've not truly seen it (unless that was one damned important Oot that Karai offed!).

It's rather interesting, as Tom is former military; now a man is entitled to his past but I'm sure he's had some personal experience dealing with the very real issue of threat and death.

Not being in the military or law enforcement myself, I can justify those people killing because if you're on the side with a barrel pointed at you, you simply cannot think of that other person as another human being with a family, a job back home, a mortgage to pay and mouths to feed. No. That person becomes a target as a real, serious threat to your very survival.

The Turtles are not cold-blooded killers, but they are trained to ensure their individual self-preservation and survival of their family, as Raph was close to doing in #22 when Casey went down.

Tazi 06-02-2013 06:07 AM

I know IDW is going here with more of superheroesque no kill policy (unless they gonna kill Shredder), and I can live with it, they're no more the kids of an assasin from feudal japan, they're reincernated teens with some blurry memories from their past. But the thing that really bugs me is dispite they don't wanna kill, they still use deadly weapons like swords and sai, or there's Donatello and Mikey hitting foot ninjas on their head, full force with their weapons. I don't want their weapons to be changed, ever, but "no kill" and "lethal force" are not exactly bread and butter. So it bugs me, but I can live with it. At least it's still better than Batman for example, where not killing Joker leads to thousands of people dying in Gotham, and it's okay for Batman, cuz killing one person would be worse than a whole genocide... WHAT? :teek:

Erik Burnham 06-02-2013 10:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tazi (Post 1106120)
But the thing that really bugs me is dispite they don't wanna kill, they still use deadly weapons like swords and sai

This brings to mind something I've always wondered.

Do people generally assume that the sai (though certainly dangerous) are sharp as opposed to blunt? The more I see them discussed, the more it seems that way. (Or are they considered more deadly owing simply to being of metal composition?)

Just curious!

Cipher 06-03-2013 12:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Erik Burnham (Post 1106421)
This brings to mind something I've always wondered.

Do people generally assume that the sai (though certainly dangerous) are sharp as opposed to blunt? The more I see them discussed, the more it seems that way. (Or are they considered more deadly owing simply to being of metal composition?)

Just curious!

I think it's the fact that Raphael has been shown stabbing things with them countless times across various media. (Even in the old Fred Wolf series, where he plunged them into robots on the reg.)

Aren't they sharp sometimes, though?

Andrew NDB 06-03-2013 01:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Erik Burnham (Post 1106421)
This brings to mind something I've always wondered.

Do people generally assume that the sai (though certainly dangerous) are sharp as opposed to blunt? The more I see them discussed, the more it seems that way. (Or are they considered more deadly owing simply to being of metal composition?)

Just curious!

I've always assumed the very tips of them are deadly sharp, though I've kind of enjoyed the idea that the "insides of the 3 prongs" are somehow sharpened too. Though this is probably not true or accurate.

Kendamu 06-03-2013 02:33 AM

Sai aren't actually sharp on the sides in real life. They're cylindrical prongs used to bludgeon people. While they're not really sold with completely sharpened tips, they are pointed and could still puncture a soft area if jabbed outward hard enough. They can also be easily be given sharp points if you want to put the effort into it.

I kind of roll my eyes when Raph slashes something with the sides of his sai. It doesn't make me nerd rage or anything, though. I'm over it before my eyes are finished rolling.

ToxicRevolution 06-03-2013 06:08 AM

Hmm, thanks for the sai info. Honestly didn't know that, I agree with Cipher that the misconception (in the Turtle community, at least) is due to Raphael constantly stabbing things with his sai, and the points always looked very sharp in pretty much all the TMNT incarnations, IMO.

Martin 06-03-2013 06:43 AM

I think you guys are confusing stabbing with slashing. While I wouldn't call them sharp, I've gotta say they aren't blunt either. The tip of the sais are shaped like a cone, perfect for stabbing, which is one of the uses of the sais. The thing you gotta understand though, is that sais are mainly a defensive weapon; they are ideal for blocking attacks and disarming your opponents, but we rarely see any of that in the comics. Btw, could someone at IDW give each new artist a little info on the correct handling of each weapon? I have to say that I don't know a lot about the bo and katanas to judge whether or not they are being used the right way, but as far as the sais go, most of the artists don't even draw raph holding them the right way.

It's funny how a lot of the artists don't really know what they are drawing. I understand that this is not common knowledge, but a five minute video on youtube would be research enough. Props to Ben Bates on this matter, he is one of the only people who draws raph holding the sais the correct way. Ross also gets it right most of the time, but sometimes he doesn't, so I'll give him second place.

Btw, here is a thread were we already discussed the usage of the sais in case you are intetested:

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=41612

Vi11AiN6 06-03-2013 06:57 AM

What kind of Ninja doesn't kill?

Again this is why it's actually
Teenage Mutant Karate Turtles


I'm not complaining, I like the series ad is. I just wish there were more realistic depictions of ninjitsu/martial arts.

Ninjinister 06-03-2013 08:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vi11AiN6 (Post 1106532)
What kind of Ninja doesn't kill?

While it was likely that all ninja were trained to kill, a significant number of them probably didn't.

Andrew NDB 06-03-2013 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninjinister (Post 1106554)
While it was likely that all ninja were trained to kill, a significant number of them probably didn't.

Even if true, you can bet the number of ninjas that when push comes to shove would actually have a problem killing if their back was against a wall... would be zero.

LH 06-03-2013 10:43 AM

Don't ninja have some sort of an honor code that would make it a last resort?

Andrew NDB 06-03-2013 10:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leatherhead (2012) (Post 1106594)
Don't ninja have some sort of an honor code that would make it a last resort?

They do not. They're not samurai.

Tazi 06-03-2013 11:17 AM

Not 100% sure, but I think 4kids Leo was into bushido... But even bushido doesn't say anything about not killing the enemy. From the little I know of it, it's more about dying with honor, and appreciate the moments when you stayed alive.

About Raph's Sais the others said most of the things, it's a defensive weapon, but you can still use it for stabbing, tho we can say that Leo's katanas are the most dangerous from all of their weapons, because if I'm not mistaken, katana is the only type of sword you can slice a human into twice by one move.
Ah and yes, Leonardo actually use Ninjatos, which is a weapon very likely invented by Hollywood.

Andrew NDB 06-03-2013 12:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beardcore84 (Post 1106031)
I'm SO glad the turtles don't kill, because it would lower then to their enemies level

Which ones? In the IDW universe no villains kill either, apparently, unless they're in Feudal Japan or on an alien world.

Quote:

Ah and yes, Leonardo actually use Ninjatos, which is a weapon very likely invented by Hollywood.
They're katanas that are often times drawn incorrectly as ninjatos. Because a straight line is easier to draw than a curved edge, I guess. Technically speaking, Leonardo should use daisho -- katana and wakizashi combo, but he obviously doesn't.

CyberCubed 06-03-2013 12:18 PM

Are we sure Sai's can't slash something? Even in Mirage I remember a few instances Raph used his sai to cut something like a wire or tree bushes in a forest.

frank_one 06-03-2013 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1106621)
They're katanas that are often times drawn incorrectly as ninjatos.

Or maybe they're ninjatos that are often incorrectly called Katanas. I mean, Leo is ALWAYS shown holding ninjatos with the only exception of the very first mirage isssues. This is something I've always wondered. After all he is a ninja, katanas are samurai's sword.

Venom 06-03-2013 01:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1106622)
Are we sure Sai's can't slash something? Even in Mirage I remember a few instances Raph used his sai to cut something like a wire or tree bushes in a forest.

In real life, a sai cannot cut a wire; they can, however, make for a sloppy weedwhacker when using a slashing motion in thick brush.

Source: I own a pair of sai and actually tried this.

MikeandRaph87 06-03-2013 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 1106659)
In real life, a sai cannot cut a wire; they can, however, make for a sloppy weedwhacker when using a slashing motion in thick brush.

Source: I own a pair of sai and actually tried this.

Can you share a picture of you using sais as a gardening tool?:P :lol: I'm curious to see how it would work now!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:50 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.