![]() |
Did Mirage's weak rogues gallery impact the 4kids cartoon?
I was just thinking about this, and how the Mirage comics have a very poor rogues gallery. This impacted the 4kids cartoon because the writers didn't have many villains from the comics to use.
In Mirage both Shredder and Rat King are killed in their debuts (although they appear later in other forms), Baxter and Karai have limited appearances, and other than that its just the Triceratons and Savanti Romero. The 4kids writers had to take the "non-existent" Mirage rogues gallery and actually develop the characters and add new essential ones like Hun and Bishop. This is why the 4kids writers didn't have many villains to use, because Peter Laird didn't let them use any Fred Wolf/Archie characters. While sometimes 4kids villains could be a hit, like Hun, Bishop, Ch'rell....other times it was a miss like Garbageman, Touch and Go, Ultimate Draco, etc. And they didn't have many characters to use from Mirage. |
Rogues Gallery?
the Mirage TMNT wasn't about them fighting evil or uphold justice like the 1987 and 2012 TMNT. It was about them surviving in a world where they are alone. So the "weak" villains aren't gonna be as important as in other versions. |
Quote:
And there was little beyond them aside from the Triceratons and Savanti. |
Ultimate Drako? ( not Draco ), a miss?
do you people NOT realize he caused SAINW? I'm so sick of people giving Drako flack, sure, he didn't have much story, actually a lot of story got cut out due to Laird's orders, but really? even Ultimate Ninja gets more love and he's a total dork to me. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Mike's episode wasn't boring, his was hilarious. Leo's was.....alright.
|
The Fred Wolf writers had even less to work with, they only had about 12 or so issues.
|
They did have a limited set of villains, but I think it's quite unfortunate how many of them weren't put to use. Mostly one-off characters, but nonetheless a part of Mirage history. I'm very bummed Complete Carnage never got to be a part of it. I don't mean to show favoritism for the comics or anything but I really didn't care for 2k3's original characters. Bishop was alright albeit generic, & I like Sh'Okanabo but the rest... Eh.
|
Quote:
Unless Complete Carnage gets a complete re-design we'll never see him outside of Mirage comics. |
They didn't seem to care that Green Mantle was pretty much a ripoff of the Green Lantern.
|
I've never watched the 4kids show in-depth, just a few episodes here and there, but yeah I did notice it seemed a bit more superherocentric when compared to the Mirage or OT turtles. If the Mirage series was a dark scifi series, and the OT was a kids show, then the 4kids version seemed more like an adult comic fans take on the turtles mythos.
If I'm not mistaken, wasn't there like a Justice League like team in the 4kids series? If there's a Justice League there would have to exist a more expansive super villain Rogues Gallery to compliment it, even if they weren't directly connected. There would have to exist something in that universe to justify a team of super-powered heroes to team together. So did the weak rogues gallery impact the cartoon? Maybe to a degree. When it first aired we all expected Shredder to be the main villain, but with no other villains as colorful or nostalgic (which might always play a part in the popularity of TMNT) as him maybe it did. Again I'm no expert on the series, but it seemed like any other villain who was worth noting was associated with the Shredder, and the villains who weren't didn't stand out too much (with a few notable exceptions). |
True, Bishop was the only major villain who stood out who wasn't connected to Shredder.
Baxter, Karai and Hun all worked for Shredder, as did the numerous Foot and agents like Touch and Go. Bishop, the Triceratons and one off characters were the only other villains till Fast Forward. |
Eh, whether or not they had a lot to work with, boy did they put out a shell of a good product. Despite the Shredder being an utrom, they still managed to make him probably the coolest version of the character. They created Bishop, who ended up being the franchise's second coolest villain after the Shredder. And finally, they created Darius Dunn and Shokanabo (I know I'm spelling that wrong), neither of which were the greatest villains ever created. However, they made the Fast Forward season a very fun one.
|
From this cartoon i didn't like Hun, i really dislike him. the worst part is when the creators put him on mirage comic's universe, when other characters like Krang deserves to be present in mirage comics.
Is true this show creates a lot of filler villains because the original mirage comics hasn't many villains. |
I honestly LOVE the 2003 cartoon, even though there are a lot of people who take issue with it here, some of whom I have a lot of intellectual respect for. Hun was obviously a reference to both Rocksteady and Tatsu, and I'm not the only person who sees this. Ch'rell was a reference to Krang AS WELL AS Shredder; the biggest difference between Ch'rell and either of those villains in the Fred Wolf series is that he is a legitimate threat, a truly evil entity that likes hurting others, just a bad seed, whereas Krang and Shredder might have liked seeing others inconvenienced, they were nowhere NEAR as evil, or as effectual, because being evil requires talent for being bad. The Fred Wolf versions just aren't very good at being bad.
I wanted to see Complete Carnage and Radical in 2003 myself, they could have been better utilized than some of the filler characters who WERE used. I will never understand why they weren't. I've never really thought about how the Mirage did have a "weak" rogues gallery in the sense that most of the villains were, originally, underdeveloped, or at least shrouded in a certain amount of mystery-- the 2003 series, if nothing else, did a GREAT job of fleshing out what were originally more like character sketches than actual characters. |
Quote:
|
Makes me wonder what he thinks of Mr. Braunze, now. He wasn't terribly interesting, and he was wholly omitted from 2k3.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I, too, agree with posts above that it's unfortunate we never got to see Complete Carnage in the show. And I don't think he's so similar to Etrigan he'd never be allowed outside the indie market. I mean, he looks exactly like him to be sure, but appearance usually isn't the driving factor in being able to put forth a copyright suit; he'd have to be an unironic stand-in for the character, meant to capitalize on the existing IP's popularity, which he's clearly not. |
The Justice Force is a pretty obvious reference to the Justice League, and they didn't get sued for that.
|
Quote:
|
The only thing the weak rouges gallery hurt was probably the toy sales. The stories where still more than solid. That being said, some villains proved to be rather bland in 4kids.
The only villain related misstep I believe was that The Rat King was entirely miss used. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:47 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.