![]() |
Question about LGBT characters in the IDW comics.
Since I'm not reading the IDW books with any sort of regularity--the last arcs I bought were the space arc and the Foot Clan mini--I'm curious: have any gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender characters been introduced in the series since it began? If there haven't been, has there been any word about whether the licensors at Nickelodeon would allow them to do so if they wanted to?
|
Who knows, sexuality isn't really a topic of focus when it comes to the Turtles and their associates.
Woody may have been. Possibly Baxter; even Old Hob or Dax - who knows?! If the mutant frogs do show up, or an iteration of Mona Lisa, they could play with the ability to change sexes due to environment thing, but it would be for kicks, which IDW seems to have more integrity than that. |
None yet, although, to be fair, we don't really have confirmation of plenty of characters' sexual orientations. Could Baxter be gay? Sure could be! Who knows.
I do know that IDW as a company doesn't have any issue with it, though, as openly gay characters have shown up in other titles (and been treated very well). I also doubt this is anything Nickelodeon would veto, as the backlash for doing so if word got out would be huge. |
Tmnt is the one comic that I don't think is necessary for any LGBT characters to show up or for existing ones sexuality to be discussed because relationships aren't a big part of it. When it comes to things like X-Men, where relationships were a big part I think its important that LGBT see someone they can relate to or admire (Anole, northstar) but unlike most superheroes the turtles being heterosexual has never really been a huge part of the story.
|
Does it really matter? It seems both April and Angel have a thing for Casey so I suppose they're straight.
Although I would certainly enjoy Angel flirting with April to get Casey's attention, but it doesn't seem like they're going down that route. |
In case they add LGBT characters in the future, I hope they will have a good reason for them, not just because others do it, or for the sake of doing it. And if they gonna do, I hope they won't make them stereotypes.
|
I do not care nor is there a need for ANY "sexuality" in the TMNT comics.
This is like saying "where are the gay characters in Star Wars or Transformers" Why does this need to be explored in a comic book? Why ? What does it matter? If we are going to explore homosexual characters the why not explore jewish characters and handicapped characters. I don't ever want to see any of the turtles explore romance. April/Casey/Angel is enough to deal with in a comic of mutants, aliens, and ninjas. |
Too bad for you, there's already Shredder/Kitsune and Mikey/Neutrino princess. (ah and Victor and the ex-savate boss' woman, but never mind that)
And by the way: Sexuality is about the most determining, and influential thing for humanity, most of mankind's motivations can be tracked back to it, so why should they leave it out, making the story more of an irrealistic fable than it should be? Tho I don't want turtles to be sexually attracted to other species either, that doesn't makes much sense. But I wouldn't mind this thing actually explored in the comics, like how they the only on of their kind, the hopelessness of ever finding their female counterpart, and basically being alone forever for example. In vol.4 Mikey and the dinosaur alien girl, was the border-line case for me: strange, but I could live with something like that. |
Maybe Hun is gay in this version.
|
I'm just going to say this and be done with it. I hate this topic in comics and I don't want any of this in the Turtles. I worry that something like this will happen and IDW(I don't think they would) would create another male turtle and have one of the guys turn out gay and I'd have wasted a good bit of money because I'd never finish reading.
Not trying to make that sound like I'm against gay people or anything, I just wouldn't enjoy reading something like that. |
Spoiler:
|
I have no problem with gay characters in the rights, X-men, WildCATS have had gay characters. I'm simply stating I don't want ANY sexuality gay or straight explored in my TMNT!!!
I don't care if it's simple attraction like Casey and April, but I don't want to know anything sexual about these characters. Go read Vertigo comics for that. In closing I will say this: You want gay characters in TNNT? Just go back and watch the OT! Krang and Shredder were the gayest duo who couldn't do anything without each other |
Quote:
|
How do we know that Angel's tension towards April means that she has feelings for Casey? Couldn't she just care for Casey as a friend, and be frustrated at April because she is interested in HER? Just a thought... by I honestly don't see why this sort of thing is important. We haven't seen any tension of a sexual nature between Raph and Alopex (even though she was obviously created as an homage to Ninjara), nor have we seen the classic "Leonardo likes Karai" motif in this series yet. Not done to the extent it usually is, anyway.
|
Quote:
Unless you're counting all the romantic times they shared in the comics when she asked him to kill someone. |
Quote:
Since this Angel is Casey's age rather than 13-14 like the 4kids one, it isn't wrong to see Angel and Casey together. It might be a welcome change of pace from the April/Casey pairing. |
Quote:
I love comics, adult, horror, etc, I fell in love with the TMNT when I was 8, now my son is 8 and he loves the TMNT. Maybe it's because of Nick or the association with kids but I think the IDW series is great as is. Also I don't see why there needs to be a LGBT character in a series just for the sake of having a token "gay" in the series. If Baxter Stockman is gay, why would that need to be addressed? Is him being gay more importantthan his work with Krang? My sister is gay and in a same sex family. I love her and support her but I don't feel there has to be a gay character in IDW's TMNT. |
Quote:
2) How many gay people do you know in real life? How many people do you know who don't know a single gay person? 3) Extrapolating from that, if the IDW series last long enough and the Turtles meet an ever-expanding cast of characters, wouldn't it feel glaring if the series never introduced a single openly gay person? 4) It's important that that starts being something expected in a series with a large enough cast, not just for promoting acceptance and offering decent role models in media, but because it's an aspect of believability So, yeah. "It's freakin' TMNT" wouldn't justify the series omitting an entire demographic. Sometimes gay characters need to show up not because the series has to say something about social inequality, but just because, hey, some people are gay and we need to get over that. It's not an issue at this point in the series with the cast as small as it is, but it's still worth considering. |
Quote:
Is it "necessary"? No, just as it's not "necessary" to have characters who describe themselves as heterosexual or who are white--and yet, there they are, without anyone asking writers to justify their inclusion. In short, there's a double standard which I think needs to be acknowledged, in which only a limited number of experiences are validated "just because". And it's not as if they couldn't have easily be included. Yes, there are plenty of characters whose sexuality is as of yet unestablished, but there's also plenty of characters who have been confirmed as straight and cisgendered; absolutely none of them which couldn't have been made gay, bisexual, or trans*, had the creators wanted to. Say, for example, the Fugitoid, who has a wife and children relegated to backstory limbo. It could have easily been a husband and children, and it would have changed nothing in the actual story. (Plus, it would piss off homophobes, which while not nearly as worthwhile as the validation of queer people's experiences, still brings me personal pleasure.) Or heck, take the Yoshi/Tang Shen/Saki triangle. I can easily conceive of a take where it's a bisexual Yoshi who is forced to choose between Tang Shen and Saki, and is made to pay for it. There's unmined ground there, particularly if Yoshi survives as Splinter. And here's why I think Nick has some say. If we agree that characters' established sexualities aren't vital to their stories, then that means that any character could have theirs changed without compromising them. Leonardo. Shredder. Splinter. And yet, I'm certain there are characters who couldn't be so changed without some pushback from Nickelodeon, starting with the turtles themselves. The question then becomes one of just how far-reaching the directives are. Do they extend to all existing characters, or just the major ones? Quote:
it's appeal, ergo, its sales? And yes, I think we should ask ourselves why recent Star Wars or Trasformers stories don't have queer characters. It's a perfectly valid question. Quote:
Counter-question: what on Earth do we gain by limiting ourselves to telling stories about the fraction of humanity which already stars in 95% of our popular fiction? |
Aside from my sister I have lots of gay friends probably more than normal, I live in a city with a lot of gays. Point is I don't care if someone is gay, what I saying is IDW isn't doing Mirage, they have their own spin and I AM saying there is no need to explore Sexuality period! The Turtles are freakin Ninja's for god's sake and they don't kill. So if they arent cutting peoples heass off then why explore other real life themes like sexuality.
FYI Is IDW catering to an adult audience? REALLY?!?!!!!? It has the Nikelodeon label on it! If it was for adults it would look like Heavy Metal or ConAn. |
Quote:
It's at least as 'adult' as any network drama or PG-13 movie, you know? Certainly enough that it doesn't need to shy away from anything besides gratuitous sex or violence. The "Nickelodeon" stamp doesn't do anything more than identify the company that owns the IP; it's on the Mirage collections as well. New Animated Adventures is their all-ages imprint specifically because the main series is not. Quote:
Any of those characters could be gay. If the Turtles keep meeting more and more people, just playing the odds, one of them is going to be gay. I'm sure you don't mean anything by it, but doesn't it seem a little wrong to say that including an openly gay character necessitates a social agenda? It's going to be part of their story, sure, but it could simply be an aspect like a character's race, etc. No need to even get into the bedroom details -- sexuality is also love, and just as we've seen completely nonsexual indications of straight relationships, it wouldn't be crazy to see some for gay relationships. That's all. I think more and more this should be something we expect from series with expanded casts, rather than the exception. Both because it's the best way to normalize it and, again -- it doesn't matter what kind of story you're telling -- just playing the odds, your characters are likely to encounter a gay person at some point. |
Why does sexuality need to be added?
Point is there's a TON of metaphors in this series that doesn't need to be spelled out! I mean do we need to worry if Casey and April are putting ads on craiglist? Does Aloplex service Shredder sexually? Does Splinter masturbate? Donnie is a computer wiz, what's hos porn collection like? Has Karai been in a Cosplay Bukkake video?!?!? Why would those things need to be on the surface of a comic book about a cartoon/comic owned by Nick? |
Interesting, am I the only one on this forum who doesn't have any gay family members? I don't even know anyone in real life that is gay (at least, they haven't said anything), so my only exposure is on TV and the news.
People assume others are straight because well....that's the default. |
I'm done with this thread. If a talented writer cones along and makes a situation or charachter relevant about sexuality so be it!
However The series is doing enought alone. I find the conversation between Fugitoid and Donatello to be far more thought provoking than someone being gay. If a character is gay I don't care honestly. What I care about is how well it's written into the story! |
Quote:
Because they've already established it for several major characters? Quote:
Notice, again, how we've confirmed several characters' sexuality already with absolutely no need for details as to their sex lives. Showing only the romantic side of love is a trope as old as time. When a character is dating/kissing/married to someone who's the opposite gender, that's a display of heterosexuality. When a character is dating/kissing/married to someone of the same gender, that's a display of homosexuality. There's no reason to go into the bedroom either way. If you want an example of another IDW title getting this totally right, look to their (unfortunately mediocre) Godzilla ongoing. One of the members of the main team is gay, which we know because in the first issue a monster interrupts his wedding to another man. Nothing about it is made to be a big deal from there; his character would play exactly the same were he getting married to a woman. He's just gay because, hey, some people are, and it's cool to see that represented in fiction alongside straight characters. Quote:
1) The Nick cartoon and IDW series are targeting different age groups and so far Nick has shown themselves to be okay with that. And 2) Hopefully Nick isn't a bigoted company. We need to get over the idea that featuring a gay character is in any way controversial, when it's just how some people are. Unless you're growing up in backwoods Alabama, you will meet openly gay people in your life. I hate to go down this route, because it's a gross oversimplification, but prior to the 1950s (at the very earliest), it would've been controversial or taboo for any media, especially something aimed at children, to feature a positive or casual portrayal of a non-white character. Thankfully people got over that, because, hey, you'll meet plenty of non-white people in your life and it doesn't have to be a huge statement to reflect that in fiction. Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
But then again all these people I knew had girlfriends and such, so there's that too. |
Quote:
Spoiler:
|
I wonder why The Big Bad is always thinking of this stuff. In the Nick section he kept bringing up feminism and how April wasn't portrayed as a positive lead since she was Don's love interest. And now he's talking about the lack of gay/lesbian characters.
He's dangerously hovering over the line where he's accusing things of being phobic just because he doesn't see something represented. About 20-30 years ago people did the same thing with the lack of black characters on TV. The show would introduce "a token black guy" to the main cast just to keep people from accusing the shows producers from being racist. Now black people are so common on every TV show that people have moved on from them to gay/lesbian characters and feminism. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
In all The Big Bad's posts, I don't think I've ever once seen an accusation that the creative teams are actively trying to malign any groups, and I think he (she?) has actually gone out of his or her way to say the opposite. It's important to think about these things specifically because it's so easy to unintentionally fall into problematic patterns. As for being cautious to avoid tokenism, that's certainly valid, as it actually hurts progress under the guise of helping. Conversely, though, there are a fair number of people who use that logic to avoid doing anything. "Oh, you can't push for the addition of such and such type of character because that's just adding a token," when, in fact, you can add diverse characters simply for the sake of adding them -- because the things that separate us are traits like any other traits, because it's simply an accurate representation of life to do so, and because that's how, over time, you normalize these differences. It should strike you just from re-reading your own post, but the very reason we no longer have the issue with non-whites in media we did "20-30 years ago" is precisely because people spoke up and became conscious of under-representation. And sure, we endured some ugly tokenism and stereotypes along the way, but the end result is that it's no longer novel to show non-whites in media and, frankly, it's expected. It'd be great if we could have the same for gay characters in less time than that. |
Quote:
I don't think we'll ever see a Disney movie where the princess is a lesbian and falls in love with another girl instead of "prince charming." Is it because Disney is homophobic? No, of course not. Its just probably not something they ever think about. |
Quote:
Also, Disney hardly needs to be used as the yardstick for progressiveness. |
Never have I read an issue of the IDW TMNT series and thought, "you know what this is missing? A homosexual character." I can't see them placing an LGBT character in this storyline without it feeling a bit forced. I would agree with some others that sexuality isn't really explored at all in TMNT. There is no need for it IMO.
|
Quote:
Spoiler:
Quote:
Quote:
Now, about IDW, I also like it the way it is. There's no need to bring in more sexuality, and make it focus more about relationships, if it stays like that how it is now, I'll be happy with that. But if they have a good idea about a storyline, and that involves lovetriangles, or Stockman being a closet homosexual, or anything, I would enjoy that too. But I'm guessing that IDW won't go too far in these topics anyway... |
Even if IDW were interested in inserting more sexuality into the Turtles book, I'm fairly certain Nickelodeon would nuke that from orbit.
|
TMNT is a franchise. They're going to be very careful how they proceed here. Years back, a movie based on the Authority was a nonstarter at WB because the characters based on Superman and Batman were involved. X-Men toys were removed from a box store (the name wasn't given) when Northstar came out. And a major toy company who will remain nameless had screenwriter contracts forbidding gay characters in the script. Now, things have changed since that. The "loving vs Virginia" parallel is often used in franchise fare for instance. Dumbledore's outing didn't hurt potter's box office. And it could be that Kevin Keller over at Archie breaks the same ground Valerie Brown did with Josie and the Pussycats (Hanna-barbera tried to change her race for the cartoon). And that brings us to Viacom. I don't think it's any accident that Jet, Bumi and Zhao were in the Avatar toyline.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Yes, there are pitfalls involved with writing gay characters, just as there are pitfalls involved in writing any character but white men (who get the privilege of not being seen as representatives of their particular group, but as individuals). However, not representing them at all is never the answer; representing many of them are. To put it in more TMNT-centric ways. Bebop in the original TMNT cartoon is an incredibly problematic character. As the only African American character in the regular cast until Carter, he reinforces stereotypes that portray them as essentially thuggish, stupid, and servile. However, if you were to take that same character and place him, without alteration, in the 2003, most of the problems go away, because that series also has black people who are smart (Baxter Stockman), who are heroic (Silver Sentry, Faraji), or are treated sympathetically regardless of being their low social standing (Angel, although it's worth wondering if that same narrative would have worked if she were a man). The same holds true for queer characters: the more of them you have, the more stories you can tell with them. Quote:
I write because as someone who loves the TMNT—and I think I have more than enough blogposts to prove it—I think it would be a disservice to it if I didn't note when it's problematic. I write about it because people still, with no malice aforethought, say things like “straight is the default”--which has the necessary corollary that not-straight is therefore abnormal or deviant, and I don't think I need to explain the problems with that—and people need to hear just why its harmful and incorrect. I write about it because people still believe that being inclusive is somehow incompatible with telling great stories and/or the sort of stories the series has always told. It's not, I can and have proven it, and will continue to prove it until people stop using this argument to justify exclusion. I write about it because I know the comic book creators frequent these boards, and live in the hope that the reason why they haven't included queer characters yet is because it never occurred to them to do so, or were somehow afraid to. If that's the case, I want to let them know that hey, it's something that they can do, that there's an audience for it, and that it's easier than they may think it is. If, it turns out that Nick is behind the book's lack of gay characters, then I'll know to turn my disappointment towards them. And if it turns out that they can include them but won't, I'd like to know why. I write about it because I know several female, gay, bi, and/or trans* TMNT fans, and I think they deserve to have themselves represented in the work that they love. And no, I don't have a problem with people who aren't aware of the issues. They're guilty of nothing but living in a very crappy society that constantly sends out very crappy messages. People who don't see the problems and then go on to claim that because they don't see the problems other, less privileged people see, they must not exist? People who claim they don't have a problem with a group but then argue for their exclusion? People who argue that TMNT is important, but then claim it's problematic elements don't matter because suddenly, it's just a comic book/cartoon/movie? Yup, them I have a problem with. Quote:
And yes, this. |
Here we go...
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
If you're worried about exploring sexuality, see what Cipher wrote. It doesn't need to happen. Casey thinks April is cute. It's not a meditation and exploration on the plights of the heterosexual lifestyle. Why can't the same happen with a gay/bi character? |
A simple line as they did in the ParaNorman movie would be enough, or using Mikey's pizza guy friend as an example, having him getting comforted by his boyfriend that he struggles with the after effects of being attacked by a 7-8 foot tall turtle-man.
Not every gay character needs to be a sitcom stereotype with a pink feather bola, as it seems many fears. |
The Big Bad, when did these things start to become an issue for you? I don't remember you making posts like this back on Toonzone 10 years ago when we were back in 2003-2005.
Now I realize we were all a lot younger back then (it was 10 years ago after all), but I never remember you analyzing TMNT 2k3, Justice League, X-men Evolution and all the other shows that were airing at the time like this. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:24 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.