The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Who else thinks IDW shredder is a horrible leader and kind of a idiot (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=43652)

PApagreg 07-17-2013 05:52 PM

Who else thinks IDW shredder is a horrible leader and kind of a idiot
 
I mean he does some eye brow raising things but after that alopex incident I kind of think he is a idiot

Irishmile 07-17-2013 05:54 PM

Didn't you already start a thread to talk about this?

CyberCubed 07-17-2013 06:03 PM

All comic book villains are slightly insane. That's why we like them because they're a little nonsensical.

So if you think IDW Shredder is a horrible leader, then they've wrote him successfully.

Rhio2k 07-17-2013 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PApagreg (Post 1124535)
I mean he does some eye brow raising things but after that alopex incident I kind of think he is a idiot


Yeah, Shredder dun goofed. BADLY, in this case.

Toby Barrett 07-17-2013 08:22 PM

http://imageshack.us/a/img585/7806/anecuw.gif

Rat_King 07-17-2013 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1124542)
All comic book villains are slightly insane. That's why we like them because they're a little nonsensical.

So if you think IDW Shredder is a horrible leader, then they've wrote him successfully.

I completely agree. That's the point of a character who is hell bent on ruling merely for the power and to have everyone under his boot. It isn't necessarily cunning that gets them through as much as it's ruthlessness.

Redeemer 07-17-2013 09:24 PM

I think this has been blown entirely out of propotion, all because a couple of his minions are think about betraying him..... At least he doesn't get defeated by the same opponent over 100 times!!! or dies in the first fight.....

ToTheNines 07-17-2013 09:32 PM

I think the IDW team is clearly setting Shredder up for an epic downfall. I just hope he stays dead once they do it to him.

Weapons@theready 07-17-2013 10:10 PM

I love this incarnation of the Shredder, he's a ruthless bad ass who is going to do a bunch of crazy **** to get his people in line even if that means pissing them off along the way. Will it ultimately lead to his down fall? Of course, but its the character flaws that make people fall in love with the character

Mr_riddler 07-18-2013 06:28 AM

The IDW Shredder is making mortal enemies too quickly.

-Krang wants him dead.
-The Savete Ninja wants him dead
-Karai maybe wants him dead.
-Alopex wants him dead.

Is just a matter of time, he's going to fall for his own weight.

shredder orokusaki 07-18-2013 06:47 AM

Those fools who want me dead will be the first to die! No one can kill me!!

Toby Barrett 07-18-2013 09:16 AM

Go back to bed kid.

Powder 07-18-2013 01:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shredder orokusaki (Post 1124759)
Those fools who want me dead will be the first to die! No one can kill me!!

Can we still try? Because, you know, I'd like to hit you a few good times.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 07-18-2013 05:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr_riddler (Post 1124754)
The IDW Shredder is making mortal enemies too quickly.

-Krang wants him dead.
-The Savete Ninja wants him dead
-Karai maybe wants him dead.
-Alopex wants him dead.

Is just a matter of time, he's going to fall for his own weight.

I don't think Karai wants him dead, but you left Splinter and the TMNT off the list. They want him dead, obviously. Except Michelangelo. And now Leonardo.

Vi11AiN6 07-18-2013 07:51 PM

How is he an idiot? He's immortal as far as IDW has explained it.
He's an a$$hole that's for sure. He duped Krang's dad, he rules Kitsune, he has an army doing his bidding, he has Leo on his side.
How does all that make him an idiot.

PApagreg 07-18-2013 07:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vi11AiN6 (Post 1125112)
How is he an idiot? He's immortal as far as IDW has explained it.
He's an a$$hole that's for sure. He duped Krang's dad, he rules Kitsune, he has an army doing his bidding, he has Leo on his side.
How does all that make him an idiot.

Read Alopex micro

Mr_riddler 07-19-2013 03:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ***The One True Shredder*** (Post 1125020)
I don't think Karai wants him dead, but you left Splinter and the TMNT off the list. They want him dead, obviously. Except Michelangelo. And now Leonardo.

They had his chance and they blew it. The "Father's safety is our priority" thing, was a bad move, that act of "mercy" will have severe consequences for the team. Killing the Shredder and get his revenge is not the priority of this version of the TMNT, i guess.

And Karai... well, remember his "confrontation" with Shredder in the number 13. And if you mix the jealousy when she witnesses to Leonardo as a the second-in-command of the Foot clan. That's a dangerous combination.

corvus 07-19-2013 12:06 PM

He's winning pretty hard at the moment. The whole arch is about him becoming a bigger threat. Karai doesn't want him dead, why do people keep saying that? Krang wants every human on earth dead. I think shredder can handle the Savate, I'd like to see him challenge Victor to a one on one duel. The turtles are his biggest threat and judging by everything that's been announced at Comic-Con he'll handle them pretty well.

Tazi 07-20-2013 09:27 AM

two things:
- In #23 Hob knows where the foot hideout is.
- Alopex is planning to betray Shredder.

it's not too hard to fit these two "puzzle pieces" together... ;)

And Shredder is probably not that stupid, and very likely already figured out that, the turtles will be coming, and he just used Alopex's betrayal as the part of his plan. Since Bobby said "the Shredder will play it like a giant game of chess", I think this will be the way. :)

corvus 07-20-2013 11:57 AM

I don't think Alopex is a threat to him. He could kill her quite easily.

The Big Bad 07-20-2013 02:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vi11AiN6 (Post 1125112)
How is he an idiot? He's immortal as far as IDW has explained it.
He's an a$$hole that's for sure. He duped Krang's dad, he rules Kitsune, he has an army doing his bidding, he has Leo on his side.
How does all that make him an idiot.

Personally, what most makes me doubt his competence is his zeal in recruiting Leo--not as a soldier or even an assassin, but specifically as his successor. I can tell why Waltz has chosen this as a story--it's certainly dramatic--but the whole thing has so many logistical problems that it casts doubt on anything the Shredder does.

I mean, in the end, the Shredder's role as leader of the Foot is, from what we can assume, an administrative one. He sets the agenda and keeps its various factions working. It is not a job that necessarily requires physical prowess--it's a bonus if you have it, but one can, in theory, be in a wheelchair and still run the Foot Clan.

Now, Leo may be very good at what he does, but what he does bears little relation to what he'd be doing as head of the Foot. He is at best a squad leader or an operative doing the sort of mission Karai did in "Hun on the Run", but not a leader, at least not without extensive grooming, the sort that one could theoretically give to lots of people who don't require brainwashing.

Then there's the actual minuses, mostly centered around the fact that bringing Leo in is really bad politics, and a major disincentive for the Foot rank and file. Imagine Foot Soldier Hakeem Hitaki, who's been serving the Clan faithfully for five years, hoping for his shot at a top spot, suddenly realizing that no, the Shredder doesn't care about that, and will not only give those spots to outsiders, but he'll give them to the very people they've been fighting for months. It's an incredibly easy way to breed dissatisfaction among his subordinates.

And basically, it's another example of what his overall problem seems to be, that he doesn't seem to give a crap about his subordinates, and thinks that their fear of him will be enough to keep them in line forever, or that he'll be able to contain any disruptions that arise.

And while that storytelling tack worked on the 2003 cartoon, it did so because we unambiguously knew why people like Karai and Hun were loyal to the Shredder--not only did he unambiguously make their lives better and made them better people, his presence is far better than the alternative (a city at war)--but there's little of the sort here. When even Alopex, who has a reason to feel grateful to the guy, wants to kill him, it makes me wonder why his people keep him around. I mean, what have Karai and the other Foot Clan members gained since his resurrection that they couldn't have obtained before?

Plasticplayhouse 07-20-2013 06:23 PM

Shreds is a super ninja that is also imortal. I don't think he gives a **** about anything. He seems to enjoy the chase as much a the kill.

Coola Yagami 07-20-2013 06:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1126549)
Personally, what most makes me doubt his competence is his zeal in recruiting Leo--not as a soldier or even an assassin, but specifically as his successor. I can tell why Waltz has chosen this as a story--it's certainly dramatic--but the whole thing has so many logistical problems that it casts doubt on anything the Shredder does.

I mean, in the end, the Shredder's role as leader of the Foot is, from what we can assume, an administrative one. He sets the agenda and keeps its various factions working. It is not a job that necessarily requires physical prowess--it's a bonus if you have it, but one can, in theory, be in a wheelchair and still run the Foot Clan.

Now, Leo may be very good at what he does, but what he does bears little relation to what he'd be doing as head of the Foot. He is at best a squad leader or an operative doing the sort of mission Karai did in "Hun on the Run", but not a leader, at least not without extensive grooming, the sort that one could theoretically give to lots of people who don't require brainwashing.

Then there's the actual minuses, mostly centered around the fact that bringing Leo in is really bad politics, and a major disincentive for the Foot rank and file. Imagine Foot Soldier Hakeem Hitaki, who's been serving the Clan faithfully for five years, hoping for his shot at a top spot, suddenly realizing that no, the Shredder doesn't care about that, and will not only give those spots to outsiders, but he'll give them to the very people they've been fighting for months. It's an incredibly easy way to breed dissatisfaction among his subordinates.

And basically, it's another example of what his overall problem seems to be, that he doesn't seem to give a crap about his subordinates, and thinks that their fear of him will be enough to keep them in line forever, or that he'll be able to contain any disruptions that arise.

And while that storytelling tack worked on the 2003 cartoon, it did so because we unambiguously knew why people like Karai and Hun were loyal to the Shredder--not only did he unambiguously make their lives better and made them better people, his presence is far better than the alternative (a city at war)--but there's little of the sort here. When even Alopex, who has a reason to feel grateful to the guy, wants to kill him, it makes me wonder why his people keep him around. I mean, what have Karai and the other Foot Clan members gained since his resurrection that they couldn't have obtained before?

I hope they dig deep into why they even bothered to revive him in the first place. Were the Foot seriously losing against the Savate and Karai was looking for some sort of advantage?

Krang100 08-01-2013 07:20 PM

In this continuity, Shredder was too violent and evil who even kills his own father. Even Krang has respect for his own father.

This Shredder is better skilled than his Mirage Comics counterpart who was killed in the first issue, he accepts the challenge and was killed. Here, Splinter has a hard fight with Shredder. In this continuty he tries to make the things in his favor, a example, he convinces Leo to join in his side, the Mirage Comics only fight to death.

Raphaeline 08-01-2013 09:00 PM

Maybe it's because he wants Karai to realize that she needs to train even more? he wants to make her jealous of Leo, so she sees him as a rival and tries to get more mature and more skilled, like some kind of motivation?

That's what I thought the Shredder was doing in fact, but maybe I'm wrong.

Maybe he thought Karai was too confident and he wanted to show her that she still needs to improve, and if she doesn't someone else would take her place.

Joey Kamikaze 08-09-2013 05:56 AM

(Thread necromancy because I've been lurking and waiting for my account to be activated!)

You can argue that Shredder is making bad decisions, but that doesn't mean he's being written poorly. It actually means he's being written well. If you look at past incarnations of Shredder, hubris is one of his defining traits. We're talking about a character who, in the original Mirage universe, got cocky and died in his first battle with the Turtle clan. Then he came back, won against them once in a surprise attack, then got ganked again. The Fred Wolf version of Shredder is more comical, but he's arguably no more inept a villain than the Mirage version; at least he survives. The Archie Shredder, too, consistently over-estimates his own skill and cunning and under-estimates his opponents, and in the long run isn't one of the series' major threats despite how iconic he is as a character. I'm not too familiar with the 2k3 universe or the new animated show, so I can't speak to Shredder in those stories, but the "classic" Shredders certainly share some major character flaws, even if each version expresses them differently.

The IDW Shredder is already my favorite incarnation of Oroku Saki, and he's easily the most badass I've ever seen the character, but there's no doubt he's setting himself up for a fall later on, and that's totally consistent with Shredder as a character. Donatello does machines, Raphael is a hothead, Splinter does his best to be wise and zen, and Shredder comes on strong and then shoots himself in the foot. That's who these characters are. And in Shredder's case, it's very satisfying to watch.

Tazi 08-09-2013 11:42 AM

Archie Shredder actually started to became more interesting later. There was a story where he could totally kill Splinter, but let him go, because he paid back the turtles, that they saved him from Krang's mind-overtake. So he showed some honor.
Shredder's desert outfit was cool from that story btw.

On the topic: I think Shredder might lose Alopex and Karai at the end of City Fall (and later Kitsune... maybe. or not.), but he will have Bebop & Rocksteady for Alopex's replacement, and probably, Hun too as a second in command.

I wonder if Foot Elite or Tatsu will show up later on the side of Shredder... Actually, that would make sense if Tatsu would be the trainer of the Elite, he was a trainer kinda guy, in Movie 1 anyway.

Joey Kamikaze 08-09-2013 08:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tazi (Post 1137647)
Archie Shredder actually started to became more interesting later. There was a story where he could totally kill Splinter, but let him go, because he paid back the turtles, that they saved him from Krang's mind-overtake. So he showed some honor.
Shredder's desert outfit was cool from that story btw.

On the topic: I think Shredder might lose Alopex and Karai at the end of City Fall (and later Kitsune... maybe. or not.), but he will have Bebop & Rocksteady for Alopex's replacement, and probably, Hun too as a second in command.

I wonder if Foot Elite or Tatsu will show up later on the side of Shredder... Actually, that would make sense if Tatsu would be the trainer of the Elite, he was a trainer kinda guy, in Movie 1 anyway.

Heck yeah, #36, when Shredder "wins" but lets the Turtles go in thanks for saving his butt in #25, was great. That kind of internal consistency and long-term character development was part of why I love the Archie series.

I'm still wondering if the Dan Duncan cover to IDW #9 is supposed to be a homage to TMNTA #36's cover. My brain immediately made the connection, but that could just be me on a nostalgia kick.

And I totally agree that Shredder is in for some back-stabbings. As much as I expect Alopex and Karai will betray him down the line, it's Kitsune I think Shredder should be watching. I get the feeling Kitsune sees Shredder more as her pawn, and she's probably using him as part of her own agenda. If he keeps trying to boss her around, it's probably just a matter of time before she teaches him why you shouldn't mess with witches.

Cipher 08-09-2013 08:55 PM

IDW's Shredder is a Saturday morning cartoon supervillain. All his other problems are secondary to that.

CyberCubed 08-09-2013 09:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1138096)
IDW's Shredder is a Saturday morning cartoon supervillain. All his other problems are secondary to that.

And so is Krang, Baxter, and Old Hob. I remember saying the IDW series feels like a new TMNT cartoon rather than a comic along the lines of Mirage.

pingclang 08-10-2013 07:54 AM

I don't think this Shredder is an idiot, I just think he has a plan that's too convoluted. He's pulling little pieces from every where to make his plot and plan that I can't figure out, myself. Maybe I don't see everything, though.

The Big Bad 08-10-2013 09:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1137509)
(Thread necromancy because I've been lurking and waiting for my account to be activated!)

You can argue that Shredder is making bad decisions, but that doesn't mean he's being written poorly. It actually means he's being written well. If you look at past incarnations of Shredder, hubris is one of his defining traits. We're talking about a character who, in the original Mirage universe, got cocky and died in his first battle with the Turtle clan. Then he came back, won against them once in a surprise attack, then got ganked again. The Fred Wolf version of Shredder is more comical, but he's arguably no more inept a villain than the Mirage version; at least he survives. The Archie Shredder, too, consistently over-estimates his own skill and cunning and under-estimates his opponents, and in the long run isn't one of the series' major threats despite how iconic he is as a character. I'm not too familiar with the 2k3 universe or the new animated show, so I can't speak to Shredder in those stories, but the "classic" Shredders certainly share some major character flaws, even if each version expresses them differently.

The IDW Shredder is already my favorite incarnation of Oroku Saki, and he's easily the most badass I've ever seen the character, but there's no doubt he's setting himself up for a fall later on, and that's totally consistent with Shredder as a character. Donatello does machines, Raphael is a hothead, Splinter does his best to be wise and zen, and Shredder comes on strong and then shoots himself in the foot. That's who these characters are. And in Shredder's case, it's very satisfying to watch.

I dunno--is it possible to write him this way? Sure. Is this what the IDW book is doing? I'm not that sure. That sort of approach to villains usually requires more emphasis on internal politics than the book has been comfortable giving us. Which reminds me: how was the bit about the Foot defectors in the Alopex mini handled? That's the sort of thing I'd like to see more of, depending on how it's played.

Keldor1578 08-11-2013 04:51 PM

The Shredder got his ass handed to him by the turtles in IDW
 
How do you feel about the turtles kicking Shredder's ass in issue 12 of IDW., I don't know if i can buy him as threat to the turtles.

CyberCubed 08-11-2013 04:56 PM

He's fought them again since then and nearly defeated Splinter the second time around. He also nearly killed Casey.

I think the reason they had the Turtles beat him the first time was to mirror Mirage #1 where the Turtles take out Shredder the first time. Only thing is back then it was because Shredder died in the first issue, but in IDW he was going to be recurring so it probably wasn't as good an idea.

They seem to have acknowledged that though since Shredder is much more of a threat in Cityfall.

Toby Barrett 08-11-2013 04:56 PM

What a wonderful, thought provoking topic.

Powder 08-11-2013 07:21 PM

http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=43652


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:51 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.