The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT Archie Series Question(s)/Opinions (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=43997)

TonySiegel 08-06-2013 11:07 PM

TMNT Archie Series Question(s)/Opinions
 

Whats the difference between these two comics?

Where should I start with the Archie series?

Is the TMNT Adventures released by IDW worth it?

thanks peeps!

CyberCubed 08-06-2013 11:21 PM

The second #1 in your photos were a mini-series that adapted the first 5 episodes of the cartoon. It ended after 3 issues.

The other #1 is the start of the main Archie run. The first four issues are cartoon episode adaptions, the original stories start at #5.

darthsmozers 08-07-2013 11:51 AM

Pricewise you might be better off tracking down single issues (unless shipping costs get in the way). But, the first 5 volumes put out by IDW contains issues 1-20, they look nice on a shelf, and they intend to complete the whole series. Around issue 21 or so it starts to get really good, and by the 30's it really picks it up.

TonySiegel 08-08-2013 12:12 AM

thanks for the info peeps...

would definitely appreciate spoiler free reasons on why I would enjoy the archie series...

[currently reading ultimate collection volume 2 and entire run of IDW]

TigerClaw 08-08-2013 07:14 AM

The TMNT Archies Series is by far the best version of the Turtles in my opinion, It was very well written, had a lot of great characters, Ninjara in particular. :D

funatic 08-08-2013 10:49 AM

I wouldn't say its the best TMNT series, but its definitely one of the most consistent. Mirage titles jump in quality, artists, timeline, from issue to issue, so if you like to remain more grounded in a steadily developing plot, the adventure series is a good pick. Like others have said though, it doesn't really hit its stride until the early 20s, so it's a slow burn to the good stuff.

Oh, and in regard to your first question about the two #1s, read the 3 issue mini-series (starting with the 2nd cover pictured), before you read the other #1 (the start of the ongoing). Or you could just skip them all and start with #5 like I did - that's the original stuff.

beardcore84 08-08-2013 01:48 PM

Why are some of the adventure specials so hard to find??

Plasticplayhouse 08-08-2013 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TigerClaw (Post 1136734)
The TMNT Archies Series is by far the best version of the Turtles

i mean no disrespect to your oppinion, but i never thought i'd see the day when someone would say that.

i was into the mirage series and viewed it as the "real" ninja turtles comic. i skimmed through the first couple issues of the archie series that were always for sale at the corner store, but they never grew on me. i viewd the archie series as the "kiddy comic" back then. to be honest, i still pretty much have the same view of it, only with a little more respect.

there were about three or four of us (friends) who were fans of the mirage comic and i remember we had a small discussion while at the corner store one day about how we thought the archie series was bogus compared to the "real one".

Panda_Kahn_fan 08-08-2013 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plasticplayhouse (Post 1136896)
i mean no disrespect to your oppinion, but i never thought i'd see the day when someone would say that.

i was into the mirage series and viewed it as the "real" ninja turtles comic. i skimmed through the first couple issues of the archie series that were always for sale at the corner store, but they never grew on me. i viewd the archie series as the "kiddy comic" back then. to be honest, i still pretty much have the same view of it, only with a little more respect.

there were about three or four of us (friends) who were fans of the mirage comic and i remember we had a small discussion while at the corner store one day about how we thought the archie series was bogus compared to the "real one".

I, too like the Acrhie series better, and think it is the better, on the whole, or the two comics. Until IDW came along (now my favorite incarnation) Archie was my favorite TMNT comic series. But again, this is the opinion of 'best' focused through the lens of subjective taste. Not everyone thinks Mirage is he greatest TMNT of all time.

To be fair though, there were things I didn't like that Archie did. Didn't like the turnstone story, and Shredder should have remained a more constant threat (though not thier sole adversary)

Topsu 08-08-2013 02:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plasticplayhouse (Post 1136896)
i mean no disrespect to your oppinion, but i never thought i'd see the day when someone would say that.

I did say something about this on other thread, but I'll explain myself here. I think my location has to do with this, since Archie-comics was the only Turtlecomic released in magazine form here in Finland. There was couple of Mirage comics released in bookform in finnish, but I learned about those later. I grew on those comics, and they were awesome to me, much better than cartoon. I still think highly of them, they're holding up pretty well IMO.

I've read all the Mirage-stuff later, and I think that's great too. Both have their pros & cons, but I too consider Archie to be THE Turtle-comic.

Pterobat 08-08-2013 09:58 PM

I agree with starting post-cartoon adaptations with the Archie comic. A later storyline tries to tie the main story back with the cartoon adaptations in a small way (no spoilers), but the cartoon adaptations are poorly-written and poorly-drawn (except for Ken Mitchroney's artwork), though that's partly due to the limits of colouring and inking and not to the actual quality of the pencils.

Me, myself, I love the Archie Turtles comic. It's not as adult as the Mirage series, but it can deal with some pretty heavy stuff, and it's tremendous fun even *as* an adult. It's also fascinating to watch the series grow once it reaches its original material. It starts off as a more polished version of the Fred Wolf universe, but soon broadens the scope of its world and makes an ongoing storyline.

I love the kitchen sink we get, full of magic, time travel, mythology, aliens, the future, and so much more. Not all at once, of course, but there's a lot of story to choose from.

Sometimes the series has an infamous problem with environmentalist preaching and one of the villains is an evil corporate head, but, well, either you get used to this or you don't. It's a theme that's always there in the series, but becomes less ham-handed as time goes on.

CyberCubed 08-08-2013 10:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plasticplayhouse (Post 1136896)
i mean no disrespect to your oppinion, but i never thought i'd see the day when someone would say that.

i was into the mirage series and viewed it as the "real" ninja turtles comic. i skimmed through the first couple issues of the archie series that were always for sale at the corner store, but they never grew on me. i viewd the archie series as the "kiddy comic" back then. to be honest, i still pretty much have the same view of it, only with a little more respect.

there were about three or four of us (friends) who were fans of the mirage comic and i remember we had a small discussion while at the corner store one day about how we thought the archie series was bogus compared to the "real one".

Did you ever seriously read through it? The comic starts off as a kids comic in the beginning but overtime there's no difference between it and Mirage in terms of maturity.

As long as you don't mind a lot of mutants and talking animals you should enjoy it.

Leo656 08-09-2013 03:02 AM

When I was a kid most shops where I live didn't carry Mirage, while the Archie book was in every 7-11 and corner store. So if you grew up in central NJ in the late-80s/early-90s, and were talking to someone about "The TMNT comic book," you meant TMNT Adventures. I didn't fall into Mirage until I was 18, and while I like it (parts of it, anyway), having grown up on TNMTA I have a deeper appreciation for that series.

I liked the tone a lot more than the cartoon it was originally spun off from. In fact, at some point I remember finding myself re-reading issues of the Archie book more than re-watching episodes of the cartoon. I loved how it was a little more mature but still suitable for all ages. It definitely succeeded in growing into its own thing. It got really F'n preachy with the environmental stuff a few times, but to be fair, in 1990 that was all the rage for like 5 minutes, and TMNTA was an idea place to send out that kind of message, so it's forgivable in context. It's not like it was a bad message, but they delivered it in a very heavy-handed way. That, and the fact it didn't get a "real" ending, is the only thing I don't like about that series. I think it's an easy book for any TMNT fan to enjoy regardless of which incarnation they saw first, whereas I feel some Mirage and Image stuff to be a little obstructive for new readers.

They also were building up a nice little rogues gallery for the TMNT, also. I really liked Null as a villain and really wanted to see where they were going with him. I swear someone said in another thread once that they knew what his ultimate backstory was going to be; if anyone can clue me in either here on in PM I sure would appreciate it. I mean, Shredder was technically still their arch-villain, but Null was a straight-up evil bastard; showing off the image of Mondo and the Mutanimals suffering in Hell was a real prick thing to do.

I remember liking how TMNTA spent a lot of time on other world cultures and history; that was really welcome in a "kids book" at that time. They didn't have to put as much depth and substance into it as they did; I get how anyone who came to it after a long-term relationship with Mirage may feel like it's shallow, but it's a disservice to dismiss it as "just a kids book"; it has a lot going on.

Joey Kamikaze 08-09-2013 05:01 AM

I grew up reading TMNTA, and before the IDW version, it was my favorite version of the Turtles mythos. Having Murphy on as the writer for most of the run made the stories feel consistent and organic. One story-arc leads to the next, and for the most part even filler issues tie into the ongoing story and overall mythos, more like IDW than what I know of the original Mirage book, which I understand was mostly farmed out for filler stories between "Return to New York" and "City At War" (though I could be wrong).

Like others said, TMNTA starts as an adaptation of the Fred Wolf cartoon, but splinters into its own version of that universe with #5 of the ongoing. The first major story-arc, #6-13, is still somewhat "kiddy" but brings in some iconic characters in clever ways and eliminates Shredder and Krang as the primary antagonists, freeing the book up to tell more original stories. It's not the book at its best, but I'm damn fond of those early issues. Man Ray, Leatherhead, the Rat King, Wingnut and Screwloose, Cryin' Hound, Scumbug & Wyrm, it was a fun time for the book.

The second major story arc, #14-20, deals with fallout from #13 and the origins of more of the Mutanimals, as well as the battle against Null, "The Man Who Sold the World" (my favorite of Archie's original villains), and an alien insect armada, all of which is wrapped up in the original Mighty Mutanimals three-part miniseries. There's a fair amount of environmentalist posturing in there, no doubt, but this is the Turtles' first time outside New York and some of the stories are neat.

#21-27 are hit and miss as Murphy writes another "return of Shredder" story that also permanently boots Krang, Bebop and Rocksteady from the book, along with a few scattered filler issues, again with heavy-handed environmentalist messages. However, this is also when Chris Allen comes on doing art, and though the first few issues of Murphy/Allen are shaky, it doesn't take them long as a team to kick the book into high gear.

"Midnight Sun" (#28-30), where the Turtles, Splinter and April head to Japan, stands in my mind as the series' real turning point. That's where we meet Ninjara (who soon joins the team), and it's the beginning of a long trek across Asia and the Middle-East for the next ten issues, with some neat stories and (if memory serves) a focus on character development as the book matures and gradually takes on somewhat darker themes. Can't say I'm crazy about the Christopher Columbus issue, but there's another Stump wrestling story, Tattoo & Inky, and a nice epic cross-over with the short-lived Mutanimals book in #38-39. If you can find it, the Mutanimals book is mostly fun for its nine-issue run (except #8, which is just godawful and arguably has the Mutanimals playing eco-terrorists). The first April O'Neil miniseries released in this period is alright too.

After that you get into storylines like the fan-favorite Future Shark Trilogy (#42-44), which introduces you to TMNTA's flooded future, where the polar ice caps have melted and most of New York is underwater; the Black Hole Trilogy (#48-50), which is... meh; and eventually "Terracide," which is neat but depressing--and that leads into a whole storyline about the Turtles being exposed to the public and the fallout of such. By then the book has taken on its own mythic feel. Even though there was supposed to be more to the story, the ending of #70, Murphy's last issue, feels in retrospect like a bitter-sweet callback to the advice Future Raph gave to his younger self back in the FST.

Now, as to the seasonal specials and other miniseries, they're hit and miss. You're not missing much if you skip the seasonal specials entirely. "Donatello & Leatherhead" is oddball but fun, and I love the improved bo Don invents for the story. The Merdude stories are... meh. I have to admit I never read the May East books (another April miniseries) but I hear mixed things. None of the side-stories do much to tie into or advance the main story so they're all skippable from that perspective.

TL;DR: Raphael's all-black wrestling costume is awesome.

TonySiegel 08-09-2013 11:54 AM

hopefully will find time someday to trek through the archie series...

loving the responses appreciate the discussion and feedback...

CyberCubed 08-09-2013 11:57 AM

I'm surprised some of you never read it back in the day. The series was quite popular.

Chuck 08-09-2013 12:49 PM

I love the Archie series, when I first started reading it I was a little kid and the series became more mature as I got older. I was embarrassed to buy Archie at the comic store when I was in the 8th grade, It was the black hole trilogy and I remember loving the story and a friend of mine wouldn't read it because he said it was for kids, I stored my Archie series in my bottom drawer with my Mutanimals so my friend wouldn't see my collection. It wasn't util the internet that I could find fellow Archie turtle fans and not feel so alone lol. I never understood Mirage when I was a kid but thought the art was great and it wasn't until high school that I really appreciated the stories. Mirage can't be beat but I think Archie is a great read and had the best Villians ever.

Joey Kamikaze 08-09-2013 07:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1137654)
I'm surprised some of you never read it back in the day. The series was quite popular.

I've only met 3 other people in real life who read the Archie line. One in grade school, one in Cub Scouts, the other is the waitress I work with. Everyone else I know who read TMNT read the Mirage book. It's weird.

Heck, when the IDW relaunch happened and I started paying attention to the fan community again, I was surprised by how many other people on the net actually remembered TMNTA. Seeing other people mention the Archie books in the IDW letter column was bizarre. For years I felt like the only one who knew it existed.

Cipher 08-09-2013 08:35 PM

TMNT Adventures (reprinted in the numbered IDW trades as well as their "100-Page Spectacular," which contains the first three-issue mini-series and is still available) is definitely worth reading through if:

1) You were a Turtles fan during the '90s fad or enjoy the Fred Wolf/Playmates universe and aesthetic.

2) You've already read the Mirage series.

All others need not apply. It's great for what it is, and if you're a Turtles fan looking for more material, I'd absolutely recommend it. It's a wonderfully creative series that really takes the Playmates version of TMNT and runs with it, and it delivers some reasonably smart, compelling and suspenseful stories, especially later in its run. Before the 4Kids show and IDW, it was also probably the single most coherent, tightly serialized version of Turtles.

That all said, it's still squarely for kids, and it shows (despite being a very commendable kids' book). Without having been one during that time yourself, I imagine it'd be a much rougher read. Certainly, it's hard to recommend over the Mirage series, which, despite a rough start itself, becomes amazing down the line and is easily recommendable to adult readers, even non-Turtles fans.

Adventures is fun. But I'd say you have to approach it with the right mindset and already be a Turtles fan to make it worth it.

50centinchange 09-17-2013 01:55 PM

I always really liked the Archie series and to this day they are extremely hard for me to find. There are some of the later issues that I have never personally seen.

While it is a bit more cartoon oriented, there is some depth to it, particularly as the series goes along. The arcs with the future Turtles in particular have a much heavier tone to them than the first half of the series run.

Heather Breckel 09-17-2013 05:59 PM

I grew up on the Archie series and didn't read any of the Mirage books until shortly after I got to work on the IDW micro series. So because of that, the series is pretty near and dear to my heart. As others have said, it does have one significant advantage over Mirage, and that was that the issues were actually consistent.

I recently re-read all of the Archie issues and I still enjoyed them a lot as an adult. The first issues are definitely campy, but I really liked the direction it took once they got into the whole big alien invasion/Cuddly the Cowlick arc. It's probably because I grew up with it, but I do prefer it slightly over Mirage. When Mirage has a consistent and ongoing storyline, it blows Archie out of the water by far, but I had a hard time with a lot of the random artist/random story issues.

Manga was the big thing I read growing up, so I lean more towards books with an ongoing storyline.

Darth Knuckles 09-18-2013 01:53 PM

I did grow up reading the Archie TMNT Adventures Comics so they are also a near and dear part of my childhood. I was a huge fan of the Original Cartoon first but the Archie TMNT Comics were my very first comic series that I read regularly.

I just this year started reading the Mirage Comics and I thought they'd be good....but the first twelve issues plus the five micro-series are DARN good! So I'm going to continue reading the Mirage Comics and after I do that, I'm going to go back and read the Archie series and compare them now after I've read them both back to back.

Panda_Kahn_fan 09-19-2013 12:50 AM

I agree with these points,Archie did deal with some mature themes and ideas with character relationships; the only thing Mirage had over Archie was the ability to show more blood and violence and spell out more mature themes instead of just implying them. And that does NOT make a comic 'better' or 'more mature'. :roll:

jbeeman85 09-19-2013 01:17 PM

When reading the Archie series again just recently I had forgotten how much environmental issues were brought up in the series. I guess it was a way to make kids think about being wasteful and doing things to destroy the environment.

The later issues of this series are pretty hard to find while earlier issues seem to be pretty cheap. I still can't seem to find the Adventure Specials #10, and #11 available anywhere.

50centinchange 09-19-2013 05:14 PM

It does amaze me too, I still need the really late issues and they just never seem to pop up anywhere.

Leo656 09-19-2013 11:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jbeeman85 (Post 1158512)
When reading the Archie series again just recently I had forgotten how much environmental issues were brought up in the series. I guess it was a way to make kids think about being wasteful and doing things to destroy the environment.

That sh*t was eeeeeeeeverywhere in 1989-1991. It wasn't just TMNTA, but that book was an ideal vehicle for it because kids were huge into TMNT and the Turtles and many of their cohorts, being animals, were perfect characters to espouse a "clean Earth/preserve nature" message.

I dug it when I was 8; I remember teachers making all the kids do Earth Day posters and having them pester their parents about recycling. Over by me we even had an Earth Day Fair for 2 or 3 years. Funny story, one year at the Earth Day Fair I won 3 goldfish in one of those "toss the ping-pong ball into the fishbowl" games, then got another goldfish with the fishbowl we bought, so I named them after the Turtles. They lasted 6 days. :ohwell:

Then by like '93 nobody cared anymore and hasn't since; we all kinda know the planet is f*cked and stopped making posters and having recycling drives pretending kids harassing their parents would fix anything. :lol: But the TMNTA book was a definite product of its times, thus the preachy environmental message. It was heavy-handed, and sometimes annoying, but it did come from a good place.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:24 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.