The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   2 years later, how do you feel about the reincarnation origin? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=44013)

CyberCubed 08-07-2013 07:40 PM

2 years later, how do you feel about the reincarnation origin?
 
Believe it or not its already been 2 full years since the IDW run started back in summer of 2011. One of the most controversial aspects of IDW early on was the new origin story:

- The Turtles were previously human boys in their past life. Never before have the Turtles had anything to do with humans in any other series.

- The mutation immediately made the turtles into adult size, so the Turtles never had a 15 year childhood/training with Splinter in the sewers.

- Raphael never grew up alongside his brothers and wandered the streets for a year.

- April names the Turtles instead of Splinter


How do you feel about it now 2 years later? I feel Raphael wandering the streets alone and being a stranger to his brothers wasn't handled as well as it could have been. He was integrated back into the family a bit too fast and now it feels like he never lived apart from them in the first place.

The Big Bad 08-07-2013 07:56 PM

Another change to the pile you mentioned, Cybercubed.

- The turtles are now, in a manner of speaking, Splinter's biological children, instead of his adopted ones.

Plasticplayhouse 08-07-2013 08:01 PM

Doesn't bother me one bit. The idw tmnt team has really been putting their hearts into the book while being considerate to our feedback and they've been doing great things. I love the series thus far :)

Davin 08-07-2013 08:16 PM

It hasn't had a full 2 years to sink in for me as I just started catching up with the IDW series. It doesn't bother me too much though, I'm happy to have new tmnt comics to read.

Would I prefer they stuck with the old origin (mutated then trained over time), hell yes! But I am enjoying the mix of mirage, OT, and new elements for what they are.

Martin 08-07-2013 08:20 PM

1. I love the fact that they are reincarnated. It makes the whole ninja thing make sense and it gives a the overall story an unprecedented depth.

2.This is actually what I have more problems with since one of my favorite things about the turtles is that they grew up as a family, which lead to the creation of a unique and unbreakable bond between the four brothers. However, given the context in which the mutation takes place and the overall story, it was a necessary thing to keep things going. Bottom line, I prefer my turtles growing up in the sewers than the insta teenager (or whatever) that we got, but, since it was nicely presented and it payed off in the end, it doesn't really bother me.

3. This was another thing I had problems with (I even made a thread about it). I actually loved the concept of Raph being on his own for a while since I believed that his anger issues could be easily explained by it. It would have also presented a source of tension between him and his brothers since he basically developed in a completely different world than them, and had to learn how to survive by himself. That could have resulted in him having a different view on things. His fighting style and views on tactics could have also been affected by his life on the streets, thus creating a source of conflict between him and Leo.
Overall I feel that this was a very big missed opportunity since Raph could have ended up as a much more complex character.

4. I think it's cool since it gives the turtles a much deeper bond with april, which I believe is an important thing in this series.

I think that's all. I wrote all this from my phone so if something doesn't make sense, it's probably due to that.

Cowabunga Carl 08-07-2013 08:31 PM

Normally in a two year run we would have 24 comics, we have 43. 19 more then normal which is another year and seven months. There has been a lot that happened in that time and through those issues.

It has been a great run and over all it has been very enjoyable. The only thing that has bothered me is sometimes the art.

Powder 08-07-2013 08:56 PM

I like it. I'm not over the moon for it or anything, but it has definitely helped speed up character development, and helped make sense of a few small things that were left to suspension of disbelief in the past. It does it's job quite well. I suppose I am far more grateful for what happened as a result of it, rather than the idea of it alone. For example, with this origin we've gotten the long overdue doses of Japanese culture and ancestry, something I've always felt needed to be a significantly larger part of the TMNT comics. So for that I guess I dig it a lot... Hmm. It would be tiresome if more characters turned out to be reincarnated though.

Jester 08-07-2013 09:07 PM

It gets a lot done in a short amount of time...so...I guess it works.

My one big issue with it, is the point Big Bad brought up. It removes the whole "family by adoption" angle, which I always liked about the Turtles.

Donatello19 08-07-2013 09:38 PM

What the heck? I've never read the IDW comics at all, and those changes sound kind of weird (yet interesting as well)..especially the turtles already being humans and all.

Martin 08-07-2013 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donatello19 (Post 1136556)
What the heck? I've never read the IDW comics at all, and those changes sound kind of weird (yet interesting as well)..especially the turtles already being humans and all.

Then what are you doing here? Go grab yourself some copies and get caught up in the fun (:

Leo656 08-07-2013 10:08 PM

I'm a bit behind on it, and I'm still missing a few issues, but I can say none of the changes bother me as much as I expected them to. At first, it sounded like a bunch of horrible ideas, but most of them work well, they're just a little rushed out of necessity. Any of them could come across even better if more time was spent exploring each of them, but individually or on the whole, none of them really bother me. It's not "my" TMNT, the way I see it in my head, but it works.

There were worse ways they could have merged all the different versions of TMNT. One thing that's interesting to me is that both IDW and Nick are, in a sense, trying to present "Ultimate TMNT", in completely different ways, but both are pretty well-done for how they're approaching it in either case.

CyberCubed 08-07-2013 10:11 PM

Sadly its the only way "teenage" is proven in this title series.

The Turtles seemed to be teenagers as Yoshi's sons around the time they were killed, even if they looked like young 12-14 year olds around then. Otherwise their baby turtle forms wouldn't be teenagers as they were only mutated for one year.

The OT got away with this because well...the show wasn't built on logic. But its an interesting way of explaining why they're teenagers in IDW.

Kendamu 08-08-2013 02:43 AM

It's a pretty neat take! It doesn't bother me at all.

Andrew NDB 08-08-2013 02:47 AM

I'm supportive of the reincarnation angle as long as it's not abused beyond the Turtles and Splinter. In fact, I'd have probably preferred if it was strictly confined to Splinter himself, with him seeing (or wanting to, anyway) his lost sons in these four mutated Turtles he happens upon by chance, but whatever.

It brings sense to Splinter knowing martial arts and brings more gravitas to the conflict with Oroku Saki. It's more personal than ever, and it spans centuries now.

Master Splinter 08-08-2013 07:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1136673)
It's more personal than ever, and it spans centuries now.

And makes for some epic flashback scenes.

-ms

dkram230 08-08-2013 08:33 AM

I feel great about it

Mr._Mutant_Man 08-08-2013 08:45 AM

I like the new origin. I wasn't sold on the idea at first, but I thought issue #5 was well written and it changed my mind about any variations in the turtle's origin. Looking back at it now, if I wanted to read about the classic origin, I'd just pick up the Mirage books again. The best remakes keep the core idea while adding a few twists to keep the retelling from being pointless.

Jay $tarkiller 08-08-2013 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plasticplayhouse (Post 1136504)
Doesn't bother me one bit. The idw tmnt team has really been putting their hearts into the book while being considerate to our feedback and they've been doing great things. I love the series thus far :)

Exactly this..well articulated:tgrin: Love the series so far, only thing that annoys me, is the price of the jetpack variants. They're kind of expensive. But that's got nothing to do with Idw and their terrific job of giving us a great new take on our green team.

plastroncafe 08-08-2013 10:20 AM

I like it. It's new and yet works well within the framework of the story, and is in keeping with the spirit of the original.

As for the turtles immediately mutating into full size, well....that's original Mirage canon right there. It's original Mirage canon that often goes overlooked, even by Mirage itself as times, but still canon.

Redeemer 08-08-2013 10:40 AM

I agree with others that the best aspect of this incarnation is the fact that it gives the origin much more depth.
We still do not know how or why they were reborn, I am still thinking Krang, baxter/ TCRI or utroms have some sort of hand in their reincarnation.

MikeandRaph87 08-08-2013 10:56 AM

It works perfectly for Shredder and Splinter but not so for the turtles. It gives the Shredder/Splinter rivalry more depth like Nick making Shredder's step-daughter the biological daughter of Yoshi. I perfer the father/son-like realtionship without actually being biological father and sons. My opinion is still the same as it was when #5 hit the shelves. Unless a turtle commits murder this will remain the worst aspect of the IDW comic to me. Pet shop turtles being mutated is crazy enough but being reincarnated as pet shop turtles after being slaughtered by a ninja usruping a clan and happen to be brought to the same lab as their incarnated rat father? If Yoshi were to have taken to the fellow experiements as a father figure that is all that is needed for thier relationship. It will be nice if it was not touched on and we just keep getting action and fun storylines without it being involved.

DaVinci 08-08-2013 12:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1136815)
Pet shop turtles being mutated is crazy enough but being reincarnated as pet shop turtles after being slaughtered by a ninja usruping a clan and happen to be brought to the same lab as their incarnated rat father?

It's not a coincidence, though. It's destiny. They were brought together as a response to Yoshi's prayer and perhaps for a greater purpose as well.

Real beliefs about reincarnation already include destiny, since people who believe in it generally believe that how good or bad your life goes (and especially how it starts) is influenced by how good or bad a person you were in your previous life.

I think their new forms will somehow be important to defeating Shredder or some worse evil later on. It's all part of fate's plan.

In case you couldn't tell (:twink:), I like the reincarnation angle. Particularly since it brought us the Secret History of the Foot Clan.

Matches Malone 08-08-2013 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1136498)
How do you feel about it now 2 years later? I feel Raphael wandering the streets alone and being a stranger to his brothers wasn't handled as well as it could have been. He was integrated back into the family a bit too fast and now it feels like he never lived apart from them in the first place.

Kind of highlights the problem I have with the series. Every story arc has to wrap up neatly by the end of 4 issues and the status quo is restored (or in the case of the first story arc: established). Maybe this will change with CityFall, but I'm still waiting for some real creative risks to be taken outside of the origin. As of now, its real claim to fame in that regard is definitely the reincarnation angle.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1136578)
The OT got away with this because well...the show wasn't built on logic. But its an interesting way of explaining why they're teenagers in IDW.

Regarding the OT, I always figured it was logical enough (for this universe anyway) that the turtles simply acted and looked like teenagers to be called likewise.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1136673)
I'm supportive of the reincarnation angle as long as it's not abused beyond the Turtles and Splinter. In fact, I'd have probably preferred if it was strictly confined to Splinter himself, with him seeing (or wanting to, anyway) his lost sons in these four mutated Turtles he happens upon by chance, but whatever.

It brings sense to Splinter knowing martial arts and brings more gravitas to the conflict with Oroku Saki. It's more personal than ever, and it spans centuries now.

Pretty much my exact thoughts. Making them literally family is nowhere near as interesting to me, and even feels a little lazy to get the emotional punch when it needs it. An adopted family is far more fitting for a group of mutant outcasts who have to make their own family and home.

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1136802)
I like it. It's new and yet works well within the framework of the story, and is in keeping with the spirit of the original.

As for the turtles immediately mutating into full size, well....that's original Mirage canon right there. It's original Mirage canon that often goes overlooked, even by Mirage itself as times, but still canon.

I don't know about canon... In the first issue the turtles "reached their full size within a year," not immediately. And even that I think it was retconned early on starting with issue #9 where they now have a "pre-teenage" era.

TonySiegel 08-08-2013 01:38 PM

hopefully we have some flashback issues to flesh out the story of the turtles looking for Raph, and Raph's solo journey in the streets...

series is awesome, dont mind the reincarnation one bit...

has had some highs and lows from issue 1 til now...

pingclang 08-08-2013 03:46 PM

I love the new angle. It's a fresh take and I think eventually there will be more to it than we already know. IDW is really kicking it up with the series. None of the changes have bothered me because somehow, it all still feels familiar while completely new at the same time.

Joey Kamikaze 08-09-2013 05:33 AM

I never had an issue with the reincarnation plot. When I read #5 I thought it was a neat spin on the story, and I've enjoyed the subtle ways they've built on it since.

Every version of the mythos has played with the origin story a bit, and I don't think there's one "true" Turtles origin any more than I think there's one "true" telling of The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, for example. The IDW universe is exploring themes of destiny and, like TMNTA, doing more to tie the Turtles to the Japanese side of their origins. It's fun.

Tazi 08-09-2013 12:04 PM

I like this IDW origin, and it's getting better and better, when the story builds more and more stuff on it. SHotFC is a good example of that, and I think there's a lot more to come. I think the whole origin story is planned out by the authors a long ago, and it's stretched on this "50 issue saga", so we will see more interesting moments from the character's past life coming up later. For example, I don't think the turtles' and Splinter's reincarnation is just destiny or a coincidence. Well, it might be, but they might planned out some kind of twist related to their reincarnation, that they will reveal later.
I also think Kitsune is kind of using Shredder, and at the end of City Fall there will be a reveal about her motivations.

There are a few things however I don't like about this reincarnation, because they might be plot holes, or they're just unexplained, or I missed them:
- How does the Foot Clan get relocated to the States from Japan? When and why?
- Why does not Shredder knows where Kitsune is buried?
- To revive Shredder, it needed drops of a family relative's blood, so he was awakened by Karai's blood. What about Kitsune? They just opened the cascet and that's it? Why is she different?

ctt4lfecw 08-10-2013 10:24 PM

It's working for me just fine. Loving the series.

Nelson 08-11-2013 04:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1136802)
As for the turtles immediately mutating into full size, well....that's original Mirage canon right there. It's original Mirage canon that often goes overlooked, even by Mirage itself as times, but still canon.

Uh? I don't remember that from the Mirage comics. I thought they grew at the same pace as humans.

Toby Barrett 08-11-2013 05:11 PM

Nope. In issue 1, if you read it carefully, Splinter mentions in the span of a year they reach their current size at the time.

CyberCubed 08-11-2013 05:47 PM

Which they later retconned in the Turtle tot stories in Tales v. 2.

Toby Barrett 08-11-2013 06:02 PM

Well yea, but how many years did that take?

Nelson 08-11-2013 06:09 PM

Wow! How the hell did I miss (or forget) that bit?!

Thanks, guys.

snake 08-11-2013 06:38 PM

It's fine for me, I don't hate it, and I don't exactly like it.

Coola Yagami 08-11-2013 08:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1139403)
Which they later retconned in the Turtle tot stories in Tales v. 2.

Coulda taken place within that year though.

I like the reincarnation angle. It's interesting and I love little details like Leo's dreams of his mother or Mikey knowing how to read Japanese. The whole thing with Leo telling Splinter 'he is not his father' cuts a lot deeper because they really are father and son.

Eiko 08-11-2013 09:56 PM

love it really works well.

Luckyday 08-13-2013 01:42 PM

I thought it was a clever way of making Splinter Hamato Yoshi while still being 100% rat so to speak. I do miss them having grow to be teenagers but I understand. They already have history together so why bother? I like the connection with April and how it help build a reason for her to care about the turtles. I like the fact Raph was separate and makes a lot of sense. I kind of wish that they done the same thing to Donnie. He should have been separate as well. Maybe as a lab experiment that was treated kindly by follow scientists until Baxter Stockman came into the picture.

pingclang 08-13-2013 02:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Luckyday (Post 1140625)
I thought it was a clever way of making Splinter Hamato Yoshi while still being 100% rat so to speak. I do miss them having grow to be teenagers but I understand. They already have history together so why bother? I like the connection with April and in a why built a reason for April to care about the turtles. I like the fact Raph was separate and makes a lot of sense. I kind of wish that they done the same thing to Donnie. He should have been separate as well. Maybe as a lab experiment that was treated kindly by follow scientists until Baxter Stockman came into the picture just so.

Damn, that would have made for a great read. I loved Raph`s hobo angle, but that sounds just as awesome.

LittleBlueHero 08-13-2013 02:35 PM

Personally I think it adds a lot of depth to their history that was much needed.

It allows the writers another tool to utilize when telling the story and gives it some reasonable ground to stand on when trying to explain Ninjas in the present day.

It makes it feel like this is something that has been going on all around us for our entire lives, but we are just now discovering it.

Still digging it.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:26 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.