The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Chromium/foil covers? 3D covers? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=44712)

Andrew NDB 09-20-2013 12:20 PM

Chromium/foil covers? 3D covers?
 
A staple of the 90s, generally reserved for "special event" issues and #1s, now these kind of "gimmick" covers are starting to be seen more and more nowadays, even back at DC. Some are pretty cool, like the 3D bad guy covers on every DC book this month.

Do you think this is something IDW should experiment/invest in, as opposed to (or perhaps supplementing?) just a lot of entirely different covers?

DrSpengler 09-20-2013 12:29 PM

From what I understand with DC's recent hologram covers, they're very expensive to publish, and even at a price-hike of $5 per issue, don't recoup the cost of printing.

Any gimmick that takes a $4 comic (which is already ludicrously expensive for a comic) and makes it cost *more* just isn't worth it, in my opinion.

Maybe if the covers were optional variants as exclusives for hardcore collectors, I'd be down with that, as it doesn't affect me or my wallet. But a non-optional, price-increased gimmick cover would not sit well with me, no.

I was all over that stuff in the '90s when I was a kid (still own every X-Men: Fatal Attractions hologram card cover), but now I could do without it.

pingclang 09-20-2013 12:36 PM

Call me crazy but I just think that stuff is dumb. What's the point? I'm sure somebody likes it but it looks goofy to me and like was already said, it's a 90's thing. Do something new and interesting. Variants are getting sort of out of hand anyways.

Andrew NDB 09-20-2013 12:46 PM

They're purdy.

dkram230 09-20-2013 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1158986)
They're purdy.

I would love it. I don't buy the physical copies of any comics other than TMNT (I dabble in the Batmans and Supermans as digital downloads). But seeing these on the shelf at the comic store just made me want to grab one of each! I didn't, but I wanted to.

Rat_King 09-20-2013 09:04 PM

I had no clue DC was even doing this until I picked up this weeks haul. I was pleasantly surprised by it. I would enjoy getting TMNT specials like this. On a side note, my local comic shop told me DC apparently ran out of the lenticular covers and a lot of people didn't get them.

Jester 09-20-2013 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1158986)
They're purdy.

Like rainbow masks purdy? :P

Sabacooza 09-20-2013 09:52 PM

I saw they had one of these covers for Swamp Thing and I was thinking about getting it but then I thought what's the point really?

jbeeman85 09-30-2013 02:44 PM

It wouldn't surprise me if they did make 3d covers. The current Turtles series seems to have 20 covers per issue making it a rich man's game to be able to get them all.

Andrew NDB 09-30-2013 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1159133)
Like rainbow masks purdy? :P

No. No, not like rainbow masks purdy.

Crabfight 09-30-2013 06:00 PM

"Special issues"? Nah. For individual issue arcs it would feel forced to me (like the DC thing does). The way IDW (and all comic companies) try to promote each arc, I feel like it would be hard to convince me that this particular arc is any more special.

But for annuals? That'd be fine with me! Those issues are MEANT to be set apart from the rest and more significant. I wouldn't mind paying an extra buck or two in that case.

Leo656 09-30-2013 10:06 PM

I used to think they were neat, but having grown up and realized that money for comics doesn't fall from the sky, it's really just blatant gouging and fan-rape. "We can get away with it, so let's publish a bunch of incentives and double or triple the cover price." I'm guilty of it, I've bought plenty of variants, but other than a very rare few, I almost ALWAYS had buyer's remorse.

Superman #75, and some series' first issues, are the only time it's ever been justified. Just sell the variant cover itself as an individual piece of art for the same price, rather than make people buy the EXACT same book two to ten times over. More people would actually buy that, I think, because then the artwork wouldn't be a COMPLETE waste of money.

Some are nice, but by and large they're pointless. It's corporate greed, nothing more.

pingclang 10-02-2013 09:36 AM

Variants are just quick go to to get extra money from the same issue they printed that month. Yeah, some look great but at an average of 10 bucks a pop, no thanks. I used to get all the Captain America variants at my local shop and when his movie came out and they did a Cap cover for almost every Marvel book, I almost passed out at the pile handed to me and that ended my variant collecting. It's another reason the foil and chromium covers just annoy me. Something else to earn more from 1 issue with.

Plasticplayhouse 10-02-2013 09:46 AM

i like having one maybe two variant covers per issue, but that's about it. 3D or foil covers would be a pass for me. maybe one special 3D cover would be cool. maybe for the anniversary.

Redeemer 10-02-2013 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1158984)
From what I understand with DC's recent hologram covers, they're very expensive to publish, and even at a price-hike of $5 per issue, don't recoup the cost of printing.

Any gimmick that takes a $4 comic (which is already ludicrously expensive for a comic) and makes it cost *more* just isn't worth it, in my opinion.

Maybe if the covers were optional variants as exclusives for hardcore collectors, I'd be down with that, as it doesn't affect me or my wallet. But a non-optional, price-increased gimmick cover would not sit well with me, no.

Yeah I agree it would be too expensive to do. If TMNT had a bigger following like DC and Marvel then that would be one thing, but they simply do not have the numbers and on top of that everyone know Nick needs to get their cut.

Leo656 10-02-2013 12:22 PM

Yeah, I forgot to add that cost is a huge factor. There already is NO justification for regular comics costing $3-$5 as it is, as much as many full-sized magazines cost. I LOVE comic books, but the inflation in the last 15 years has been disgusting considering it took 50 years for the cost of a book to go from 10 cents to 75 cents. To $1.25 in 1990, then an overnight bump to $1.50 in 1993, and now 3 and 4 bucks on average, it's ridiculous. Especially since most of those new issues don't get sold (because they're too damn expensive, DUH) and end up in back issue bins, where they can, as always, be had for anywhere from a quarter to a buck. I'm seeing more and more brand new books end up in 50-cent bins within two months because nobody can even afford to collect anymore, it's f*cking insane. I went from getting 30 or so books a month to having to drop the hobby entirely once books went to a steady $3. I know I'm not the only one, either, as my local shop, one of the largest in my area, had to shut down within months of all DC and Marvel books hitting $3 a couple years ago. Too many people just can't justify the expense. I plan to one day start collecting almost weekly again, but for now I have to hit the shop once or twice a year and pick up all my back issues at bargain bin prices.

Anything that adds to the cost of books even one penny, or forces retailers to order three times as many books as they can sell just to get the chase or variant cover, is f*cking stupid and can in no way be justified. It's paper, ink, and f*cking staples. People can claim all they want that digital distribution is killing the industry, but I think that's BS because not every book/magazine/newspaper producer is going broke, a lot are doing just fine. The only thing that's hurting the comic industry is that they got greedy in the late-90s when they switched to higher-quality paper and ink. At one point they had to raise prices to cover the cost, but going up another quarter or 50 cents every three years isn't inflation, it's rape.

DrSpengler 10-02-2013 12:45 PM

Don't forget the decrease in page space dedicated to actual content. From 26 pages, to 24 pages, to 22 pages and now, in some cases, a scant 20 pages a month.

And the prices STILL keep going up.

I know we're entering tangent territory here, and I'm lobbing my frustrations at the nebulous "industry" and not IDW exclusively, but comics just aren't an impulse buy anymore.

I guess it was when Diamond monopolized distribution (how has this remained legal all these years?) and took comics from newsstands and spinner racks at 7-11 to the dungeonous caverns of direct market comic shops. All of a sudden they weren't something you grabbed at random while getting a Slurpee and a scratch off. Now you had to actively search them out in the 1 or 2 joints in the state that carried them, and then pay triple for the privilege.

Even worse is the "new wave" of writing, the "Bendis style" as I'm loathe to call it. The habit of decompressing storylines to the absolute breaking point and spreading a script that could have economically been told in 1 issue into a 6-issue "epic". With so called "witty banter" acting as page filler to keep the actual story from progressing and ensuring the author 6 paychecks instead of 1 for just the single idea.

It just seems every aspect of comics has turned to ravenously gouging the consumer base. Couple that with Big Two titles turning into relentless bloodsoaked rape-obsessed snuff tales and jeez, the hobby is about as fun as it is affordable.

I actually stick to kids and All Ages comics these days as they read, well, closer in spirit to the stuff I grew up with. Tighter story pacing, shorter arcs and actual wit instead of gratuitous shock value. I actually consider IDW's TMNT ongoing to be more of an "all ages" book, or at least something you'd rate at a PG. And I'm totally cool with that.

Aw jeez, I didn't mean to go on a freakin' rant, here.

Leo656 10-02-2013 01:02 PM

I like your style, Spengs. (I know I've said that before, but it bears repeating)

It breaks my heart because I f*cking love comics and comic collecting. I have to use profanity because I love it SO damn much my heart hurts just basking in the joy I've gotten my whole life from collecting and reading comics. For most of my adult life after high school, no matter how bad things were, the Wednesday night trip to MC Comics was the highlight of my week. I spent $200 or more a month, easy. I had it at the time, but also you got a lot more for your money back then. Income tax season, I'd drop an easy $100 just on back issues; now when I drop $100, the stack is depressingly shorter than it was just five years ago, and you're right, the books are getting shorter and the stories themselves are unnecessarily spread out a lot of times.

Case in point: One of the things that "forced" DC to go with the New 52 was the fact they gambled big on the "New Krypton" storyline and it didn't do well, but it didn't do well because it was WAY too long! I love almost every bit of the Superman lore, and *I* was sick of the story halfway through. NO ONE cares about Mon-El, or Nightwing and Flamebird, or Lucy Lane, enough to devote 6 months worth of issues to their sub-plots in what is ostensibly a story about Superman and Zod. THAT was why the story failed and why DC felt they had to turn their whole line into stuff resembling Image Comics circa 1994. They could have cut that year-long story by two-thirds, eliminating all the Superwoman, Nightwing/Flamebird, and Mon-El stuff, and told the main story the exact same way, and people wouldn't have gotten burned out on it. DC and Marvel have the "Fans will buy anything" mentality right now and they'll print whatever and however many they feel will sell. All the more reason I'm not in favor of these variant covers; if we buy them, they're gonna keep making them and charging us exponentially more for the privilege. :ohwell:

'S'OK, Spengs. I rant, too. We do it because we care, homie.

Andrew NDB 10-02-2013 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crabfight (Post 1162629)
"Special issues"?

Yeah. Let's say it's the issue where Shredder is killed, or #25 or #50 or #100. Or something.

jdangerc 10-02-2013 09:31 PM

In the 90's, I was all about Chrome and Hologram covers. Now, I could care less.

pingclang 10-03-2013 10:55 AM

In the area I live in there is zilch to do so our local comic shop is a haven, especially to us into stranger hobbies, and since the hike in price sales haven't changed much. I myself have to keep a set number of books because if I go over, I'm pulling money I shouldn't be. The problem is being made even worse when you factor in that Marvel has decided to print some of their books twice a month, I had to stop subbing to Avengers for that exact reason. Factor in variants such as what the original post was about and it goes from bad to stupid. The twice monthly books, the variant covers, they exist for one reason, we the fans are just that, FANS. Why do football teams put their logo on everything? It'll sell to the fans. Thats what the marketing strategy of comics is becoming, we give the fans the same books but with different covers, cheap and effective. We push to deliver more books, they'll subscribe and buy. Come on, Joe Quesada himself has talked about how Marvel doesn't care, the fans will buy it anyway. Chrome covers? More of that crap, no thanks.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:54 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.