The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   For someone who has the new color classics TPB vol. 6... (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=44764)

Andrew NDB 09-24-2013 11:01 AM

For someone who has the new color classics TPB vol. 6...
 
... could someone send me a scan of the big Renet reveal from the Savanti Juliet issue?

Thanks.

About the book, I perused it at the store... very well done. It's pretty awesome to see stuff like "Halls of Lost Legends" rendered in full color.

JoshDA7X 09-24-2013 04:49 PM

I'll try get it for you tomorrow unless someone beats me to it!

Crabfight 09-25-2013 08:09 AM

Yeah! This IDW reprint is my first time exposure to a lot of these stories, and I have to say, Volume 6 is probably my favorite release in the "Classics" run that IDW is doing. I loved Juliet's story and all the literary allusions made therein, as well as those made in the Lost Legends story. I really can't ever get enough Raph angst either, so the Lucindra story was pretty satisfying as well.

As for the main point of this thread, I don't have a scanner so I can't help you. Sorry! Looks like someone is already on it though...

Andrew NDB 09-25-2013 01:52 PM

I am still in need.

AleXviD 09-26-2013 12:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crabfight (Post 1160616)
I really can't ever get enough Raph angst either, so the Lucindra story was pretty satisfying as well.

Wait, wait! Classics Vol. 6 includes Lucindra story (#44), basically making it #42-44, despite most synopsis stating it would include #41-43, right? So, where would #41 go?

udp: Okay, I think that explains it.

Andrew NDB 09-27-2013 02:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AleXviD (Post 1160844)
Wait, wait! Classics Vol. 6 includes Lucindra story (#44), basically making it #42-44, despite most synopsis stating it would include #41-43, right? So, where would #41 go?

udp: Okay, I think that explains it.

I won't shed any tears for that story.

I still need a scan of that page, with Renet...

The Big Bad 10-22-2013 07:39 AM

Andrew, I got the volume last week: do you still need the scan? If so, do you just want the page where she first appears, or the whole scene?

You know, I'd be much more happy about these colored collections--it's the first time I'm reading many of these stories--if the colorists in charge weren't so intent in whitewashing however many major characters they can. April, at least, looks like she could conceivably be a woman of color here, but when comparing the newly-colored Lucindra to the version shown on the cover, it's clear that she's been made to be several shades lighter than she was initially conceived as. It's rather maddening.

CyberCubed 12-07-2013 08:40 PM

I just got this collection today, and its odd how Renet's hair was colored red instead of the usual blonde.

Also I never realized Loki from Thor was in TMNT.

wilddiverse 12-15-2013 05:24 AM


Powder 12-15-2013 05:38 AM

Please don't tell me they gave Renet caramel skin & brown hair.

CyberCubed 12-15-2013 10:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1188382)
Please don't tell me they gave Renet caramel skin & brown hair.

Her hair color is orange in the book. And she's white, that page just came up oddly.

The Big Bad 12-15-2013 07:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1188460)
Her hair color is orange in the book. And she's white, that page just came up oddly.

I beg to differ. My copy, at least, is perfectly consistent when it comes to her coloring, which is precisely the way seen in the scanned page.

And you know, after initially being rather aghast at this take on Renet--surely there's no confusion on what she's supposed to look like--I rather dig it. It really helps sell the idea that this is not Renet as the turtles once knew her. And if we're going to have whitewashing in the book then having it also work the other way around makes for a not-half-bad consolation prize.

Jester 12-15-2013 07:42 PM

Wait...who was whitewashed?

Cipher 12-15-2013 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1188594)
Wait...who was whitewashed?

Lucindra, more or less.

CyberCubed 12-15-2013 09:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1188610)
Lucindra, more or less.

Funny enough her brother was still black. Probably because his hair style looked like a young Will Smith.

The Big Bad 12-16-2013 05:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1188610)
Lucindra, more or less.

To illustrate:

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y1/...s2ecd1391.jpeg

Original comic book cover, which is actually reproduced in the collection.

http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y1/...ps811a77c2.jpg

Classics Vol. 6

Jester 12-16-2013 07:34 AM

Wow...that's pretty stupid. I only know her via Turtle Soup, and there...not so white.

DrSpengler 12-16-2013 08:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1188711)
Wow...that's pretty stupid. I only know her via Turtle Soup, and there...not so white.

Yeah, she was pretty tan in her Turtle Soup appearance.

Yeesh.

I don't think there was any malice involved in changing her skintone for these Classics reprints, I think it was just pure ignorance/lack of research. But still. Yeesh.

And Rick Arthur's pencils and inks don't seem to really benefit from that coloring job, either. Which actually brings me to a point on these Classics reprints in general. Black and white comic book art isn't like a coloring book. These aren't "empty" pencils and inks sitting around waiting to be colored. When the black and white medium is chosen by the artist at the beginning, then the entire aesthetic process is built around that medium. These stories are MEANT to be read in black and white and were constructed that way.

Going back to them and splashing color all over everything actively diminishes the artistic intent, to say nothing about completely reinterpreting mood and atmosphere. It's like colorizing a black and white film. It's not a good idea.

I worry about the inevitable reprints of "Souls Winter" as those were very clearly meant to be read in black and white; Zulli's pencils and inks would really suffer from being retroactively colored to appeal to a market that "doesn't like black and white".

Ted Turner would be proud.

CyberCubed 12-16-2013 12:20 PM

Well Lucindra has become a mixed race like Obama. Her brother is still black and her facial features are still black, so she is now mixed.

VaughnMichael 12-16-2013 12:40 PM

Wow yeah I'm glad to be skipping these, they're poorly done. :ohwell:

CyberCubed 12-16-2013 01:11 PM

I actually think the coloring is well done with the exception of those errors.

- Renet has orange hair in this issue, but to be fair this is an older and mature Renet from far in the future, so maybe she dyed her hair? Renet is blone in #46-47 with Shogun Chote.

- Lucindra is a minor character anyway that nobody really cares about, so she's not a big deal.

- Shark Shredder is tan in the Tales reprint, but that doesn't really bother me much.

- Shredder's all blue bodysuit is the biggest offender, but luckily you can just get the Ultimate Collections and ignore that.

Powder 12-16-2013 05:01 PM

It'd be one thing if a background character of no significance that went relatively unnoticed had their skin color change, but not one with a leading role in numerous stores. That's wholly unacceptable.

Jester 12-16-2013 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1188743)
Spoiler:
And Rick Arthur's pencils and inks don't seem to really benefit from that coloring job, either.
Which actually brings me to a point on these Classics reprints in general. Black and white comic book art isn't like a coloring book. These aren't "empty" pencils and inks sitting around waiting to be colored. When the black and white medium is chosen by the artist at the beginning, then the entire aesthetic process is built around that medium. These stories are MEANT to be read in black and white and were constructed that way.

Going back to them and splashing color all over everything actively diminishes the artistic intent, to say nothing about completely reinterpreting mood and atmosphere. It's like colorizing a black and white film. It's not a good idea.

Spoiler:
I worry about the inevitable reprints of "Souls Winter" as those were very clearly meant to be read in black and white; Zulli's pencils and inks would really suffer from being retroactively colored to appeal to a market that "doesn't like black and white".


Ted Turner would be proud.

Indeed. As the Ted Turner aside would indicate, it's like how ridiculous most old black and white movies look recolored.

Xav 12-16-2013 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1160341)
... could someone send me a scan of the big Renet reveal from the Savanti Juliet issue?

Thanks.

About the book, I perused it at the store... very well done. It's pretty awesome to see stuff like "Halls of Lost Legends" rendered in full color.

Why didn't you just buy the book yourself?

The Big Bad 12-16-2013 05:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1188743)
Yeah, she was pretty tan in her Turtle Soup appearance.

Yeesh.

I don't think there was any malice involved in changing her skintone for these Classics reprints, I think it was just pure ignorance/lack of research. But still. Yeesh.

Undoubtedly, given Digikore's other, non-skin related coloring weirdness. Still, I care less about what their intentions may have been than the fact it happened--it's harmful either way--and that the people who supposedly offer oversight, editors and such, didn't care enough about it to do anything about it. And frankly, if a colorist can't pay the barest amount of attention to what they're coloring--and it's not like Lucindra's race isn't entirely obvious from the details of the story even without the cover making it explicit--then they shouldn't be doing the job.

Heather Breckel 12-16-2013 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1188743)
Yeah, she was pretty tan in her Turtle Soup appearance.

Yeesh.

I don't think there was any malice involved in changing her skintone for these Classics reprints, I think it was just pure ignorance/lack of research. But still. Yeesh.

And Rick Arthur's pencils and inks don't seem to really benefit from that coloring job, either. Which actually brings me to a point on these Classics reprints in general. Black and white comic book art isn't like a coloring book. These aren't "empty" pencils and inks sitting around waiting to be colored. When the black and white medium is chosen by the artist at the beginning, then the entire aesthetic process is built around that medium. These stories are MEANT to be read in black and white and were constructed that way.

Going back to them and splashing color all over everything actively diminishes the artistic intent, to say nothing about completely reinterpreting mood and atmosphere. It's like colorizing a black and white film. It's not a good idea.

I worry about the inevitable reprints of "Souls Winter" as those were very clearly meant to be read in black and white; Zulli's pencils and inks would really suffer from being retroactively colored to appeal to a market that "doesn't like black and white".

Ted Turner would be proud.

Well, just because a comic is done in black and white initially doesn't mean it shouldn't be allowed to be colored. I understand that things like the gray toning don't translate as well when color is used. But I disagree that it ruins the intent of the art by adding color.

I haven't gotten to take a look yet at the color classics, so I can't really comment on how they look. But you have to understand that there still are a lot of people that won't read a comic if it doesn't have color, which is probably why IDW is doing it.

And I'm not saying this just because I'm a colorist and that's what I do for a living, I'm actually a pretty big fan of manga so I'm no stranger to BW comics. But I also understand that there is chunk of audience that is afraid to check out BW stuff. Bone, a comic which was done in black and white start to finish, got full color editions a while back to help pull in younger readers and it looked pretty awesome.

But to use something a bit more similar to TMNT for comparison, Akira actually got a colored edition years and years ago. Marvel released it long before manga really got popular in America and if I remember correctly, Otomo himself provided color guides

http://i.imgur.com/EkRIZXh.jpg

The results were actually pretty sweet.

Another tone heavy comic getting a color edition is Attack on Titan (this is actually happening in Japan, America isn't recoloring it), it's not out yet so I can't comment on how effective it is. There's also Sean Gordon Murphy, who's inks most definitely are not designed with a colorist in mind turn out amazing in both BW and color

http://i.imgur.com/lvj5I3h.jpg

(to my knowledge SGM doesn't usually like people coloring his work outside of people like Dave Stewart, who's a badass)

For TMNT, I don't think it was so much that the artists didn't want their work colored, it may have been more a case of "printing colored comics is crazy expensive, we're not doing color". That's why so many small press comics were in BW. Dave Sim sure as hell wasn't going to print phone book sized trades in color, that would have cost way too much.

I've done some BW comics myself. They're not in BW because I'm too lazy to color them or don't intend on them being colored, they're in BW because I don't want to pay twice as much to get a stack of books printed. If someone wanted to color my work, that would be okay with me if someone else is footing the printing costs haha.

DrSpengler 12-16-2013 08:03 PM

You raise good points, Heather, and the colorization of black and white comics can end up looking good, as you demonstrated.

But I look at this scenario and I see it in a manner similar to colorizing a black and white film. Whether it was by choice or by budgetary constraints, the work of art was produced with black and white release in mind, so every visual decision was made in those terms. An artist might have elected to ink or tone a scene completely differently had they had the foresight to know they were publishing in color.

I brought up the Ted Turner aside half-jokingly, but I think it bears a tinge of truth to the situation of colorizing something in order to give it a broader appeal. It's a very true statement and situation, as there are people out there who outright refuse to read a comic or watch a movie if it's in black and white (my older brother is one of those people), and colorizing something does indeed give it a greater reach in terms of accessibility.

But doing so also encroaches on the intent of the artist; they elected to produce the work in a certain medium and they should rightfully have a say in how others alter their work.

I'm picking up IDW's The Maxx: Maxximized reprints right now, those recolors of the original series, but I wouldn't be if Sam Kieth weren't overseeing the recoloring process. In this case, it's the original artist dictating how his work is being altered and I think that often leads to the better colorizations, as you pointed out.

In the case of Ted Turner colorizing films or, the third party studio IDW is outsourcing to colorize TMNT issues, it is a case where someone else is fundamentally changing someone else's work without their input or consent. The results can range from something as innocuous as Renet's hair color to something as distractingly wrong as Lucindra's skin tone, to say nothing of deeper concerns such as mood or even setting (the nonstop sunrises/sunsets in IDW's TMNT #1 color classic comes to mind). Not long ago, I did an article comparing and contrasting the many different colorizations of TMNT #1. Its alarming how many different ways colorists can interpret the same pages, resulting in wildly different moods. Only the original artist can tell you which is the "right" one; everyone else is just "guessing".

You do great work, Heather, and you know I respect you. And as a pro you could school me six ways 'til Sunday on the subject of color theory and technique; I dunno jack.

Really, it's more a concern with me in terms of integrity. We're looking at others making major changes to an artist's work, taking it from one medium and transferring it to another so that it might have broader appeal, and without the input of the original artist. That situation leaves me feeling a bit wary. At the very least, it would be more comforting if IDW was making the original black and white editions an option in some way or form (beyond just the Eastman/Laird issues in the Ultimate collections, I mean).

But that is sort of a Catch 22, as the only reason the issues are being colorized in the first place is because IDW does not believe the black and white versions will sell. So I guess it's a stalemate for the moment.

oldmanwinters 12-16-2013 08:13 PM

Most of the Mirages Tales of the TMNT Volume 2 would probably benefit greatly from color, since very few of those issues looked like there was a great deal of thought put into the B&W presentation. Those issues just look naked to me.

However, most of the Mirage Volume 1 stuff made very careful use of the tones and shading, and I haven't seen many of those issues improved through the application of color.

I do appreciate the effort on the Michelangelo one-shot, however. That book must have been very difficult to color.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:57 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.