The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   OT characters in IDW; What do you think now? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=45923)

Panda_Kahn_fan 01-17-2014 03:34 PM

OT characters in IDW; What do you think now?
 
Okay, seeing we are now three years into the comic, I want to ask everyone what they think of bringing more OT characters into this comic series, based on what we've already seen. So far, IDW has a decent track record;

Krang- poweful and intimidating warlord, made destructive war the planet Neutrino, is responsible for the Death of Honeycutt's family, has a complex and interesting motivation/backstory of wanting to save his race, and actually DEFEATED the turtles by managing to carry out his primary goal- capturing the fugitoid- a feat the Triceritons and federation failed to do back in Mirage. A far cry from the OT's burbling housewife bickering with shredder brain.

Bebop and Rocksteady- While still both dumb and lost to Raph pre-mutation, these to cleaned house against those thugs the foot were trying to negotiate with, then turned around and KILLED at least a dozen highly trained foot ninja without breaking a sweat. Then they turned the tide at the Cityfall battle, which helped casue the turtles to flee, shook off showers of bullets like were nothing, and it took a freakin' GRENADE to even slow these punks down enough for the turtles to get away. These two brezerkers are like steam rollers with the controls stuck on forward- and possibly two of the most powerful henchmen the foot's had in ANY continuity.

The neitrinos- Compenent and capable fighters who stood against Krang's tryanny, these cool catsare a far cry from the goofy hippies from the 80's. I actually felt for them when Krang took the royal family hostage.

There are now versions of these characters that I would LOVE to see in others turtles media, and would be disappointed if they didn't. Is there still any concerns about Fred Wolf characters showing up again? Any you'd like to see in particular from here on out? :D

Powder 01-17-2014 03:44 PM

Krang's cool, albeit a little plain. I miss his wit. B&R kick major ass. I was not looking forward to their inclusion but they feel like they came straight out of a Troma movie, so I love 'em. Bloodthirsty scumbbags, haha. The Neutrinos, however, I could do without. While many people dislike those guys from the original toon, the charm that did make them likable to some, was their personality. & IDW did away with that, more or less, so they really could have been any other rebellious characters. Overall, I'm fine with them bringing in OT characters, but not in too high a volume. There's a ton of universes to pull from, and they shouldn't rely too heavily on that one just for nostalgic purposes or whatever.

CyberCubed 01-17-2014 04:12 PM

Krang is the only one I'm disappointed with for the same reasons as Powder. He's also too much like Ch'rell now.

Krang really needs that sarcasm and humor to make him feel like Krang. Without it he's just another generic alien warlord.

turtlefanforever 01-17-2014 04:39 PM

What do I think now?!
 
More! Not enough. More

Coola Yagami 01-17-2014 08:53 PM

No love for Slash?

The thing about Krang is that, putting him in a more serious light basically turns him into Chrell. That's basically what he was in the Archie comics. He was only joking and bitching at Shredder in the cartoon-adapted issues.

Powder 01-17-2014 08:56 PM

I really like what they're doing with Slash in this book, though I'm not huge on his design. But maybe now that he's got Leo's gear that'll change.

MikeandRaph87 01-17-2014 09:26 PM

Surpringly,I am on the same page with Powder on both the Slash degin and Krang lacking his wit. While Krang has been built up as a big bad and is a legitmate huge threat I wonder if he will be allowed to crack a oneliner even in the vile sense. I feel the character can use it. I

know we are now moving away from those centric to the '87 cartoon being incorporated though I do wonder how much of an influence that the '87 cartoon will have on both Rat King and Leatherhead. I always felt them to be the best within the original cartoon. Leatherhead's most likely not ever going to have that awesome accent and speech pattern but I would like to see him updated as a villain but will it happen. Rat King finally got a nice origin in the Nicktoon but his design sucks unless its the one that was pretty much the same in Mirage/1987 cartoon/
Archie's Adventures/Playmates figure 1989.

DrSpengler 01-18-2014 10:29 AM

I like them.

I do understand some grievances, certainly, as a few characters only superficial reflect their '80s counterparts and that invites the "why bother?" criticism. I get that, I do. The Neutrinos are NOTHING like their '80s counterparts in terms of personality, only bringing over the visuals and the "rebels against Krang" angle.

But I don't think any characters have been a wholesale example of "name applied to someone totally different" there are still elements in terms of back story and role that reflect their original incarnations, just molded to fit this new universe.

I also think it was something the writers gradually got the hang of; determining character elements to keep and what elements to discard in the transition. They definitely perfected the formula with Bebop and Rocksteady, who have all the humor and low brain cell count of their predecessors, but their boosted power levels make them a genuine threat and don't diminish them to useless comic relief (and keep in mind, there is a difference between "comic relief" and "USELESS comic relief").

Slash is kind of a fusion of Tokka and the namesake, which was a strange choice, but I can see why they'd consider two Evil Turtles to be redundant and elected to combine the characters. So Slash looks like Tokka and shares his meager intellect, but wears Slash's black bandana and boasts his name. (I do hope Slash gets a intellect boost, though, as dumb-as-rocks characters can be a little boring).

Krang, I like, though I concede that without the sense of humor he does actually seem bland in comparison to his original incarnation. I think the real issue is that the humor in the old Fred Wolf character came as one half of a comedy duo. Without Shredder to work off of, he really wasn't all that funny. Being the big evil overlord, General Krang doesn't have a partner or a lackey to bounce wit off of. I was kind of hoping Baxter Stockman might fill that role a bit, and there was an element of antagonistic humor between them in Baxter's Villain Micro. But I guess we'll see.

Personally, I've wanted to see new versions of the '80s characters for years now, so I'm perfectly fine. Between the IDW comic and the Nickelodeon cartoon, we've actually got a VARIETY of new interpretations of '80s characters. SO even if someone doesn't dig IDW's Slash, they may like Nick's. Or if they aren't big on Kraang Prime, they might think General Krang is pretty sweet.

I'm all for it. I may not be hot on EVERY character revival in the comics, but that's just the reality of things. But the ones I DO like, I think are really cool.

The Big Bad 01-18-2014 12:02 PM

Not a fan, at least when it comes to the ones I've seen. They fail both parts of my personal test for successful adaptations.

1) Do they capture the spirit of the original characters?

And more importantly...

2) Would these characters be at all appealing if they'd been all-new?

When it comes to Krang and the Neutrinos, the answer is "no" and "no".

I'm interested in eventually seeing how they did with Bebop and Rocksteady, though.

CyberCubed 01-18-2014 12:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1197396)

Krang, I like, though I concede that without the sense of humor he does actually seem bland in comparison to his original incarnation. I think the real issue is that the humor in the old Fred Wolf character came as one half of a comedy duo. Without Shredder to work off of, he really wasn't all that funny. Being the big evil overlord, General Krang doesn't have a partner or a lackey to bounce wit off of. I was kind of hoping Baxter Stockman might fill that role a bit, and there was an element of antagonistic humor between them in Baxter's Villain Micro. But I guess we'll see.

Krang is definitely the character that needs a bit of a "personality boost" in the comic, as he really does just feel like a generic alien warlord at times.

Nick gave their Kraang funny speech patterns to make them memorable alongside original Fred Wolf Krang. But IDW's Krang feels the less interesting of the 3.

Also Archie Krang was still funny. He didn't appear all that much but Murphy managed to keep the spirit of Fred Wolf Krang in him that he felt like the same character. Archie Krang is how IDW Krang should be, honestly.

Cipher 01-18-2014 08:31 PM

It's all over the place. The IDW series occasionally hits updates I really enjoy, both for the nostalgia and because there's a genuinely good underlying concept to mine, but other times provides absolutely cringe-worthy references for references' sake that impede enjoyment.

Bebop and Rocksteady are great. I had some initial misgivings here, but they're an interesting dynamic and -- and this is really key -- if you didn't know they were lifted from the Fred Wolf era you might be convinced they were original elements of this series. Totally works. Aces.

Krang is bland stereotype. Stereotypical goals. No distinct voice. Cliched backstory (which is the most character we've seen from him). He's there to be a villain, but even elements like his being a tiny brain-like-creature in a conqueror's visage is given little focus and relies on foreknowledge of Krang for explanation. Totally salvageable, but everything about him relies on the impact of him being Krang (who you know and love) rather than anything he's done as a unique character. They need to do more distinguish him.

The Neutrinos are an absolute low-point for the IDW series and everything about their inclusion is ill-conceived.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1197428)
Not a fan, at least when it comes to the ones I've seen. They fail both parts of my personal test for successful adaptations.

1) Do they capture the spirit of the original characters?

And more importantly...

2) Would these characters be at all appealing if they'd been all-new?

When it comes to Krang and the Neutrinos, the answer is "no" and "no".

I'm interested in eventually seeing how they did with Bebop and Rocksteady, though.

We are on all the same pages.

MsMarvelDuckie 01-18-2014 09:14 PM

I may be in the minority, but I have loved all of them so far. I do admittedly miss Krang's dark humor, but perhaps if he ever teams up with Shredder, that will come out a bit more. I saw hints of it Baxter's micro, as some noted earlier, but I'd love to see more of it. I actually like the darker and more threatening direction they took with him, and the more serious and competent Neutrinos were an interesting take, as well. As much as I liked their original incarnations, sometimes they came off as a little over-the-top and clichéd. I actually giggled when I saw Princess Trib kiss Mikey right in front of Kala, who was always his crush in the OT! It was just so ironic and funny.

Panda_Kahn_fan 01-18-2014 10:43 PM

Thanks for your opinions, guys. I wasn't including Slash because; a.) he was an Archie charcter too, and not just fred wolf, and 2.) there were few complaints about him. And yes, Krang needs some of his sense of humor back.

And yes, Bebop and Rockstady have blown ALL doubts about them out of the water. These two are not just nostalgia rehashes, but have proven themselves worthy of Mirage-level turtles fiction, while staying true to the spirit of thier OT selves. They stayed stupid idiots, but also had the layer of being powerful, destructive psychos who revel in death and carnage and destruction. As it stands right now, thier confirmed kill count of foot ninja actually stands higher than all four turtles combined

Icegaze 01-19-2014 04:59 AM

In order of personal preference, I'd say:
1 & 2. Bebop & Rocksteady: Fantastic translation into a more serious tone
3. Krang: Love the seriousness that makes him more like Ch'rell than the 80s Krang
4. The Neutrinos: Just like what OP said
5. Slash: Reminds me too much of Tokka but I will keep an open mind as things might change as the story progresses.

Candy Kappa 01-19-2014 06:32 AM

Besides Krang lack of wittyness, I'm quite pleased with the characters used from the FW.

Coola Yagami 01-19-2014 07:10 PM

Krang needs more personality, but being funny isn't one of them, or it ruins his 'bad-ass overlord' status. Krang can't joke with Baxter cause he'd have him executed if he joked back. Shredder is super serious too in this version. They'd plan to backstab each other, but they won't trade off quips and insults. One joke and it's war between them.

This Krang just isn't the kind of character to be made into a funny one. It would ruin the serious tone he has established.

Powder 01-19-2014 08:24 PM

That's total nonsense. Plenty of dictators, serial killers, and other generally evil figures had a sense of humor. Hitler loved playing with dogs, blowing bubbles, doing goofy photoshoots, I imagine he cracked a few jokes to/at his peers. Besides, making jokes doesn't require banter. He could just have a twisted view of the world around him, getting pleasure from horrible things & being cruel. Krang could mock Baxter or his underlings, make sick jokes about genocide, whatever. Nobody is saying Shredder should be like his OT self, but Krang should, at least to some extent, considering that is his source universe. Krang without humor would be like Raph without attitude.

Cipher 01-19-2014 08:39 PM

For the record, I don't even particularly care if Krang has a sense of humor. I just want him to have some voice/personality other than generic villainy.

Coola Yagami 01-19-2014 08:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1197900)
That's total nonsense. Plenty of dictators, serial killers, and other generally evil figures had a sense of humor. Hitler loved playing with dogs, blowing bubbles, doing goofy photoshoots, I imagine he cracked a few jokes to/at his peers. Besides, making jokes doesn't require banter. He could just have a twisted view of the world around him, getting pleasure from horrible things & being cruel. Krang could mock Baxter or his underlings, make sick jokes about genocide, whatever. Nobody is saying Shredder should be like his OT self, but Krang should, at least to some extent, considering that is his source universe. Krang without humor would be like Raph without attitude.

The challenge would be making Krang have some snark and witty dark humor without it suddenly being OOC for him this far into the game.

Technogeek29 01-19-2014 08:55 PM

He does seem to make snide remarks around Stockman. One example is when Stockman is chewing out Hob and Krang replies "Is this what you call, in good hands Stockman?" Or how he made a joke about Stockman's plans always backfiring. He seems to still be a sadist like the Archie version finding amusement in the displeasure of others

CyberCubed 01-19-2014 09:34 PM

I want Krang to crack jokes and use more sarcasm and wit. I'd also love to see him watching American soap operas.

Powder 01-19-2014 09:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 1197906)
The challenge would be making Krang have some snark and witty dark humor without it suddenly being OOC for him this far into the game.

We're really not the far in, though... & besides, new situations allow different glimpses of a character. Plus it's not like it would be over the top, just slide a little in there subtly.

Coola Yagami 01-20-2014 12:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1197930)
I want Krang to crack jokes and use more sarcasm and wit. I'd also love to see him watching American soap operas.

..... No.... The way Powder said it makes more sense.... Let's not throw his bad-ass take-no-crap alien warlord personality out the window either.

Candy Kappa 01-20-2014 01:59 AM

I think Krang could easily be written a bit more snarky over time, when the Utrom race are getting more stabile. Remember he got his entire race bottled up, near extinction. Dudes got some pressure at the moment.

liugeaux 01-20-2014 01:42 PM

Well, here's mine.

Slash, I really hate his design, I've never liked Tokka and I really miss the more toned down design of the Archie Slash. I don't know what they could really do with his character now, he's basically just a giant turtle monster. Honestly, I think his character would be more useful had he actually died at the end of Sins of the Father. The accidental death of Slash could have been an ongoing point of strife for the Turtles much like Uncle Ben is to Peter Parker.

I like Krang, and the Krang micro does a good job of propping up an otherwise generic one dimensional character, but he does need some more meat to him. This coming from someone that never really liked him in the original show. I don't miss his humor, so the more like Ch'rell the better.

Bebop and Rocksteady were the ones I was most worried about about. Their slapstick baffoonery in the cartoon, seemed the least likely to fit in with the IDW tone, but I really like the angle they took with them. Sure they are dumb and powerful, but most of all they are loyal, when they have absolutely no reason to be. With nearly everyone turning on the Shredder, these two were a breath of fresh-air.

The Neutrinos, their inclusion was a turning point in the series for me. It proved that NOTHING is off limits, and it excites me to this day. I know they are totally different, but the "why bother?" criticism seems dumb to me. I'd rather the team bend an old under-used character to the needs to their story than create a new one. This series has done a great job re-purposing the past, and that's what I want, reinterpretations of old characters. Sure, I love Hob and Alopex, but it took alot of time to get me on board with them.

With that said, the Utrom Empire Series looks to have all kinds of call-backs...I really can't wait.

CyberCubed 01-20-2014 02:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by liugeaux (Post 1198138)
I like Krang, and the Krang micro does a good job of propping up an otherwise generic one dimensional character, but he does need some more meat to him. This coming from someone that never really liked him in the original show. I don't miss his humor, so the more like Ch'rell the better.

The original Krang was one of the funniest and most entertaining characters in the franchise history. Ch'rell outside of the Shredder suit was bland, just like General Krang. Don't see why you would prefer generic supervillainy blandness over funny and entertaining.

Icegaze 01-20-2014 02:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1198157)
The original Krang was one of the funniest and most entertaining characters in the franchise history. Ch'rell outside of the Shredder suit was bland, just like General Krang. Don't see why you would prefer generic supervillainy blandness over funny and entertaining.

Well, I for one agree with liugeaux; this Krang is a far better villain that the OT Krang, who I never liked, even as an 80-90s kid who grew up on the cartoon series before even knowing about the existence of the source material (comics) till a decade or so later.

Ch'rell was also a superb villain. I guess I prefer to take a villain seriously, for him/her to look and sound always like a threat. I don't want to sympathize or get attached to a villain emotionally. Don't want them to be funny or goofy. I want terror and destruction! This doesn't mean they are "one dimensional" either.

Tazi 01-20-2014 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1198157)
Ch'rell outside of the Shredder suit was bland, just like General Krang.

Except Krang has real goals unlike Ch'rell, and the dynamics between Krang and Baxter is great, and a lot like in FW, except it's not as sitcom as Shredder/Krang was.

In the IDW context, are you seriously want him to be like in OT?

They should start it with giving him multiple contradicting origin stories... :lol:

CyberCubed 01-20-2014 03:39 PM

But as said its generic supervillainy. Replace General Krang with Lord Dregg and you'd have the same exact character.

OT Krang was loved for a reason, not because of childhood nostalgia, but because he was an actually good and funny character.

Andrew NDB 01-20-2014 04:03 PM

I don't think much of the OT characters at IDW at all. Krang himself isn't too hard to swallow, though, I guess, but doesn't quite seem fully realized yet.

I'd rather IDW do more in the way of wholly original characters and make them shine and have the IDW comic stand out from what, say, the Nicktoon is doing.

Panda_Kahn_fan 01-21-2014 11:07 AM

Not every likes the OT characters, or how they are all being potrayed, and that's cool. Hopefully though, there are enough original characters (Old Hob, Kitsune, Antonio, Woody, Alopex, etc.) Mirage characters (Fugitoid, Triceritons, Renet), and 4kids characters (Hun, Angel, and this 'Shredder's Daughter' version of Karai we have here) to offset things with the OT ones. We have a nice mix here to keep things interesting. :D

Tazi 01-21-2014 11:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1198183)
But as said its generic supervillainy. Replace General Krang with Lord Dregg and you'd have the same exact character.

Dregg is kinda not the same. Or at least as much as I know about Dregg, he was never a hero and a savior to his kind. Krang's main goal is to save his race, and make a new home for them, plus he can actually win against the turtles.

Quote:

OT Krang was loved for a reason, not because of childhood nostalgia, but because he was an actually good and funny character.
Don't get me wrong I love OT Krang, I'm even okay with giving him some funny moments in IDW.... but OT was more about jokes and funny stuff, then deep characters and big dosage of action, a funny Krang worked well with the tone of the show, but the same Krang would never work in IDW. Well, unless they make him into a "comic relief villain" or something, with having much less role than being the emperor of the Utrom race.

Besides, IDW Krang shares a lot with Archie Krang, in tone too, so it wasn't just from FW to IDW, it had same changes already in between.

liugeaux 01-23-2014 05:51 PM

For the record, cracking jokes doesn't equal character depth. The only thing I really liked about the original Krang was his voice. I liked the absolute power hungry aspect of Ch'rell in 2k3 show, but the purpose driven Krang we have in the IDW series is really where the character should be going. However, I really want the IDW Krang to be more ruthless than he already is. I would love for him to off Baxter, or forcibly mutate him.

Panda_Kahn_fan 01-25-2014 07:07 AM

Awesome guys, I can agree with the general opinion here; Bebop and Rocksteady were handled well, Krang is good but could use some improvement, and the use of the Neuotrinoes were mixed feelings (though I did like the handling of fugitoid). Well, I hope whoever we see next from the OT are handled as well as Bebop and Rocksteady were. Personally, I hope we might get a few like Groudchuck and Dirtbag on old hob's team, or Maybe some good mutants like mondo Gecko or Mona Lisa from the mutagen April stole Anyways, Thanks guys! :D

CyberCubed 01-25-2014 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by liugeaux (Post 1199895)
For the record, cracking jokes doesn't equal character depth. The only thing I really liked about the original Krang was his voice. I liked the absolute power hungry aspect of Ch'rell in 2k3 show, but the purpose driven Krang we have in the IDW series is really where the character should be going. However, I really want the IDW Krang to be more ruthless than he already is. I would love for him to off Baxter, or forcibly mutate him.

OT Krang had an actual character. IDW Krang only has brief glimpses of it, and its mostly just backstory. Most of the time IDW Krang just spouts generic evil warlord threats and orders.

Tazi 01-25-2014 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1200695)
OT Krang had an actual character.

Time to explain that, huh?

Quote:

IDW Krang only has brief glimpses of it, and its mostly just backstory. Most of the time IDW Krang just spouts generic evil warlord threats and orders.
That's what OT Krang did, accompanied with hilarious dialogues with his henchman. (yes, that includes Shredder)
IDW Krang is already a lot more then that. And what's this "it's just backstory, so it doesn't counts" thing? How is the backstory a seperate part of everything else?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:44 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.