The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Mateus santolouco returns!!! (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=46433)

gundamric 02-28-2014 05:43 PM

Mateus santolouco returns!!!
 
Hi guys just wanted to know every bodies thoughts on the return of mateus to the tmnt regular run which do you prefer Andy Kuhn, Dan Duncan, mateus santolouco or Ross Campbell also state the reasons why and what are your favorite panels, pages or covers from each artist thanks everybody cowabunga

CyberCubed 02-28-2014 05:49 PM

Eh I thought it was known for a while that he returns after the current arc.

I like all the artists so far.

gundamric 02-28-2014 05:56 PM

Yeah I think I was little late finding out just wanted to get every bodies thoughts on the artists

spookycookies 02-28-2014 07:34 PM

ever since Secret History of The Foot he has been my favorite TMNT artist. I'm glad he'll be back and I can't wait to see what he has in store for us with the rest of the IDW crew.

gundamric 02-28-2014 08:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spookycookies (Post 1220571)
ever since Secret History of The Foot he has been my favorite TMNT artist. I'm glad he'll be back and I can't wait to see what he has in store for us with the rest of the IDW crew.

Have to agree the secret history of foot clan is what sold me on his artwork the way each turtle looks unique not just by bandannas but height physical aspect like muscles and their face you can just see Raphael is always mad and his stocky and Leo is always calm and calculating don is curios and mike well he's mike can't wait to see what his metal head looks like

Jeff 02-28-2014 09:06 PM

as far as regular artists on this series go, in order Mateus is at the top, followed VERY closely by Ross Campbell, then I'd say Duncan is in third, Bates fourth, and Andy Kuhn a very far off fifth. If we're counting Eastman because of issue 21 and the annual, honestly, id put him between campbell and duncan, and i LOVE Eastman.

gundamric 02-28-2014 11:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeff (Post 1220629)
as far as regular artists on this series go, in order Mateus is at the top, followed VERY closely by Ross Campbell, then I'd say Duncan is in third, Bates fourth, and Andy Kuhn a very far off fifth. If we're counting Eastman because of issue 21 and the annual, honestly, id put him between campbell and duncan, and i LOVE Eastman.

That's a good list but I have to say if we are counting in eastman he would be at the top for me along with Peter laird I'm happy that they worked together on the 30th anniversary issue cover hopefully that's a sign of more good things to come love the way Peter draws the turtles along with mike dooney as well

Redeemer 02-28-2014 11:27 PM

Mateus is my favorite artist hands down followed by Dan Duncan. I like Ross, but He makes the Turtles look lie Prebubesent girls at times :lol:
Andy Kung's buck teeth turtles make me feel like a hick :lol:
I just never cared for Eastman's art......:ohwell:
He is actually my least favorite.

BabyTurtles 03-01-2014 12:00 AM

I'm gonna miss Ross T^T

but Mateus is a great artist also~ he's my second fav ^_^

Toby Barrett 03-01-2014 06:38 AM

It does look like he's going to stop drawing the turtles with those stupid-ass masks he drew in SHotFC and City Fall, so that's good at least.

Dirty Blond 03-01-2014 09:31 AM

His Shredder is one of my all-time favorite renditions of the character.

Venom 03-01-2014 05:37 PM

I adore Mateus's artwork, but I don't dig the round, "bubble head" he gives the Turtles.

coreyrc87 03-01-2014 06:36 PM

I can hardly wait for Santolouco's return - his work is my favorite.

Redeemer 03-01-2014 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 1220997)
I adore Mateus's artwork, but I don't dig the round, "bubble head" he gives the Turtles.

How would you describe the heads Ross Gives TMNT???

Plasticplayhouse 03-01-2014 09:50 PM

With Ross wrapping up his stint, I'm happy to have Mateus back.I love both of their styles and the different dynamic each brings. Hopefully we'll see Ross again in the future.

Powder 03-02-2014 02:38 PM

I absolutely adore his work and I'm happy to have more of it, but ultimately, I prefer a more indie look for turtle books, personally. A little more stripped down, if you will.

Redeemer 03-02-2014 02:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plasticplayhouse (Post 1221114)
With Ross wrapping up his stint, I'm happy to have Mateus back.I love both of their styles and the different dynamic each brings. Hopefully we'll see Ross again in the future.

I noticed this as well.
Ross' art tends to bring out more emotion and sympathy during the dramatic or emotional scene.
Mateus' art makes the story and scenes pop during action scenes, especially action scenes. Also Mateus' art keeps is way more intense and plays well during the climatic scenes.

TMNTChris1980 03-02-2014 04:16 PM

Yeah, Ross' art is so amazing, he really captures the youthful look and emotions of the TMNT. Mateus' stuff is amazing too.

Icegaze 03-02-2014 04:35 PM

Santolouco is my absolute favourite TMNT artist at the moment. I enjoyed volumes 22 to 28 so much. And Secret History of the Foot clan was epic too. Just check out the cover for volume 34: http://santolouco.deviantart.com/art...over-435229978
Can't wait for volume 33 to begin! And I hope he stays for over 10 successive volumes.

If I had to rank in order of preference:
1. Mateus Santolouco
2. Dan Duncan
3. Cory Smith (Karai Micro Series)
4. Ross Campbell (his art used to be my favourite but the more I compare it to Santolouco's City Fall masterpiece, the more Ross' turtles look like too cute for the gritty tone of this series)
5. Ben Bates (Bebop & Rocksteady Micro series)

I am not a fan of either Eastman's or Kuhn's art styles.

coreyrc87 03-02-2014 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Icegaze (Post 1221549)
3. Cory Smith (Karai Micro Series)
5. Ben Bates (Bebop & Rocksteady Micro series)

Ah - I completely forgot about Smith and Bates! Love their work too.

DONATELLO DUZMACHINES 03-03-2014 05:25 PM

Mateus is my fav artist on this book so Im happy to see him return, but I'm also really enjoying Ross' s work.
Spoiler:
Cant wait to see Mateus' s design for Metalhead

Venom 03-04-2014 11:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redeemer (Post 1221038)
How would you describe the heads Ross Gives TMNT???

An adaptation of Mateus's artwork for the sake of consistency.

Personally, I loved Ross's Mirage work and his Dark Horse designs the best, mainly because of the heads, because the man can still draw beautifully.

Redeemer 03-04-2014 11:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 1222413)
An adaptation of Mateus's artwork for the sake of consistency.

Personally, I loved Ross's Mirage work and his Dark Horse designs the best, mainly because of the heads, because the man can still draw beautifully.

Even in the recent Leonardo Micro and his Fan comic have those bubble shaped heads. His Leonardo Micro came out before any Tmnt comic Mateus' came out.

ProphetofGanja 03-08-2014 11:33 AM

I'm just curious what the name of the next arc will be. It seems to be vaguely similar to the "Return to New York" storyline, but I know IDW will do something totally unique.

can't wait to see Metalhead!

Turns 03-08-2014 06:53 PM

Of the artists who have contributed to the regular title this is how I would rank them.

1. Mateus Santolouco
2. Dan Duncan
3. Kevin Eastman
4. Ross Campbell
5. Ben Bates
6. Andy Khun

Candy Kappa 03-08-2014 07:00 PM

Ross is my #1 without an doubt. After that it's a toss up between Mateus, Ben and Andy, although I think maybe Mateus would get on the #2 spot, but it's really depending on what my mood is in for.

nimajneb 03-09-2014 01:43 AM

We knew for ages he was taking a break after city fall.
I love Santolouco's art, his rendition of the turtles really is my favourite (his art is my icon picture!) but he nails environments too as well as characters.
Really gets the movement spot on in his art, I hope he stays with the property for a long time.

arkangel 03-09-2014 05:06 AM

Santolouco is arguably the best of the bunch and probably by a fairly good margin, but there is just something about Ross Campbell's work that draws me in. Like Eastman, it has a uniqueness that stands out and is unmistakable.

Dan Duncan, Ben Bates, and Andy Kuhn are all good artists as well, but I find their work more generic and Dan seems to have a flair for the hydrocephalic that takes away from what is usually decent work, imho. I'm sometimes waiting for a turtle head to burst.

SwiftNinjaFox 03-09-2014 11:18 AM

What issue will Santolouco return with? Is 33 his return? (I'm assuming yes?)

Just re-read Secret History of the Foot Clan and I'm really looking forward to his return.....though I wouldn't mind him changing how he handles their masks. Judging from his cover for #33, perhaps he will be. :)

Thoughtmirror 03-09-2014 11:27 AM

I do believe that Mateus Santolouco was the very person who made me become even more addicted to the IDW Tmnt comic series. He doesn't make them look blockish or too big in my opinon. I've liked quite a few artists as of late, but he stands out among the rest. I hope he continues for a long while.

AquaParade 03-09-2014 03:40 PM

I've been rooting for Santolouco to get the ongoing-series job since his debut in issue #5. Really glad to have him although I agree that he has taken the mask's a little too far.

I'd like to voice my love for Andy Kuhns work. I'd still rank Santolouco, Eastman and Duncan above him when it comes to personal taste, but I think he has a really great style even if the teeth are a bit too much sometimes.

Redeemer 03-09-2014 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turns (Post 1224635)
Of the artists who have contributed to the regular title this is how I would rank them.

1. Mateus Santolouco
2. Dan Duncan
3. Kevin Eastman
4. Ross Campbell
5. Ben Bates
6. Andy Khun

I would place Ben Bates as 3. and I would drop Eastman to the bottom of that list. I really just don't like Eastman's art.

gundamric 03-09-2014 07:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thoughtmirror (Post 1224935)
I do believe that Mateus Santolouco was the very person who made me become even more addicted to the IDW Tmnt comic series. He doesn't make them look blockish or too big in my opinon. I've liked quite a few artists as of late, but he stands out among the rest. I hope he continues for a long while.

I hear you man he is very passionate about working on tint books he is a huge fan himself always helps when a fan does the artwork also he wrote and illustrated secret history of the foot clan that tells you how involved he is with the series also I read on the letter to the editor he's on board confirmed all the way to issue 50 at least :)

liugeaux 03-10-2014 09:16 AM

Well, if we are making lists.

1. Ben Bates
2. Mateus Santolouco
3. Ross Campbell
4. Dan Duncan
5. Kevin Eastman
6. Andy Khun

Ben Bates is amazing! I'm not a huge fan of Duncan or Eastman's work in the series, and Kuhn's art in the Utrom Empire has been much better than his Sins of the Father run.

Rooish 03-18-2014 05:43 PM

I think his art is the most professional looking; however I ****ing hate the flanderization of Mikey (scrawny with buck teeth) and Don (scrawny with egg head). It practically ruins the art for me.

My favourite artists are Bates and Duncan and Ross. Kuhn had a very interesting style and his covers are great but the rest is too sketchy. I'm not a huge fan of Eastman's style--at least in how he draws humans.

SDCC 03-19-2014 09:31 AM

Ooooo I love a list. Going by those who have worked on the main title (hopefully not forgetting anyone).

1. Mateus Santolouco - Great art and a great guy (Did an interview with him). The Daddy. SHOTFC is awesome, and he liked putting Mikey in hats, which amused me no end.

2. Ross Campbell - A close second. Really enjoy his expressive faces. I'd be happy if they just rotated these two.

3. Dan Duncan - Kicked things off well and part of the reason I got into this series.

4. Ben Bates - Wasn't so sure about the arc, but his art kept me on-board.

5. Andy Khun - Great Utroms in Utrom Empire, but I'm not keen on his humans generally. His turtles are average.

6. Kevin Eastman - He may be the creator, but I found the annual to be a mess that was really hard to follow.

DrSpengler 03-19-2014 09:51 AM

Well, if we're doing lists, I guess I'll play too. Of the artists to work on the ongoing.

1: Santolouco (There's so much vicious energy in his work that it practically leaps off the page. It's dynamic and lavish; the kind of labor-intensive pencils you rarely see in a monthly title. And while I don't like all of the design aesthetics, I appreciate any artist willing to diversify the Turtles on a visual level)

2: Campbell (Honestly, he'd be tied for first place if it weren't for a few minor grievances. I love his "cute" style, but at times it alters characters in ways I don't appreciate, such as overly feminizing Alopex right at the narrative point where she transitioned from "bad" to "good". But he toggles back and forth between action and softer atmosphere in a way no other artist at IDW does)

3: Bates (I was surprised at how divisive his work was, but for me there was never any question that he ranked near the top. His style is cartoonish in a way they others aren't and puts a spotlight on the humor of the characters, but I'm a guy who doesn't think TMNT has to be "serious business" all the time. I welcome some visual levity. His action layouts were great and everyone has a lot of personality to them.)

4: Duncan (He got the ball rolling at a time when the book was trying to find its legs and informed the look of the series from the beginning. His style wasn't lavish and maybe a little muddy but it was competent, dynamic and he very rarely took shortcuts. But Duncan's best strength was something all the other artists on the ongoing have lacked. He NEVER needed a fill-in or alternate to give him lead time. He produced 12 consecutive issues and got them out on time with no one picking up the slack. And for the most part, they all looked great. That's a skill you see less and less of in the industry today and one worth appreciating.)

5: Eastman (Look, Eastman's style is classic; I'm not saying otherwise. It's more that his storytelling style is monotonous. All he does is "flying by the seat of your pants running battles". That's all he's EVER done. He has the formula down to a science, but you will NEVER get anything fresh or different from him. It will always, ALWAYS be "flying by the seat of your pants running battles" and I'm just a little bored with them.)

6: Kuhn (When I rank Kuhn at the bottom, it seems like I hate him, but I don't. There isn't an artist on the ongoing that I dislike. Kuhn's layouts and inking are top notch and over in Utrom Empire he has been drawing the most expressive Utroms I've ever seen. His Triceratons are great, his Baxter is menacing, his Fugitoid is sympathetic. Everyone and everything is GREAT... but his Turtles. He draws them as gargantuan, thuggish tanks as wide as they are tall. He gives them these massive cheekbones and dopish grins. He doesn't diversify them visually in any way. He just draws lousy Turtles and even though everything ELSE is wonderful... this is a book called "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" and if you can't draw aesthetically pleasing Turtles then that IS a big problem. I like that he's found his niche on other TMNT books, like the Villain Micros and Utrom Empire that feature non-Turtle characters, but his run on the ongoing was me least favorite, artistically.)

mgambino 03-19-2014 09:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1230196)
Well, if we're doing lists, I guess I'll play too. Of the artists to work on the ongoing.

1: Santolouco (There's so much vicious energy in his work that it practically leaps off the page. It's dynamic and lavish; the kind of labor-intensive pencils you rarely see in a monthly title. And while I don't like all of the design aesthetics, I appreciate any artist willing to diversify the Turtles on a visual level)

2: Campbell (Honestly, he'd be tied for first place if it weren't for a few minor grievances. I love his "cute" style, but at times it alters characters in ways I don't appreciate, such as overly feminizing Alopex right at the narrative point where she transitioned from "bad" to "good". But he toggles back and forth between action and softer atmosphere in a way no other artist at IDW does)

3: Bates (I was surprised at how divisive his work was, but for me there was never any question that he ranked near the top. His style is cartoonish in a way they others aren't and puts a spotlight on the humor of the characters, but I'm a guy who doesn't think TMNT has to be "serious business" all the time. I welcome some visual levity. His action layouts were great and everyone has a lot of personality to them.)

4: Duncan (He got the ball rolling at a time when the book was trying to find its legs and informed the look of the series from the beginning. His style wasn't lavish and maybe a little muddy but it was competent, dynamic and he very rarely took shortcuts. But Duncan's best strength was something all the other artists on the ongoing have lacked. He NEVER needed a fill-in or alternate to give him lead time. He produced 12 consecutive issues and got them out on time with no one picking up the slack. And for the most part, they all looked great. That's a skill you see less and less of in the industry today and one worth appreciating.)

5: Eastman (Look, Eastman's style is classic; I'm not saying otherwise. It's more that his storytelling style is monotonous. All he does is "flying by the seat of your pants running battles". That's all he's EVER done. He has the formula down to a science, but you will NEVER get anything fresh or different from him. It will always, ALWAYS be "flying by the seat of your pants running battles" and I'm just a little bored with them.)

6: Kuhn (When I rank Kuhn at the bottom, it seems like I hate him, but I don't. There isn't an artist on the ongoing that I dislike. Kuhn's layouts and inking are top notch and over in Utrom Empire he has been drawing the most expressive Utroms I've ever seen. His Triceratons are great, his Baxter is menacing, his Fugitoid is sympathetic. Everyone and everything is GREAT... but his Turtles. He draws them as gargantuan, thuggish tanks as wide as they are tall. He gives them these massive cheekbones and dopish grins. He doesn't diversify them visually in any way. He just draws lousy Turtles and even though everything ELSE is wonderful... this is a book called "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" and if you can't draw aesthetically pleasing Turtles then that IS a big problem. I like that he's found his niche on other TMNT books, like the Villain Micros and Utrom Empire that feature non-Turtle characters, but his run on the ongoing was me least favorite, artistically.)

Pretty telling about about the high quality of the artists that Kuhn could be viewed as one of the worst to work on the book.

DrSpengler 03-19-2014 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgambino (Post 1230198)
Pretty telling about about the high quality of the artists that Kuhn could be viewed as one of the worst to work on the book.

EXACTLY. Kuhn is a superb artist in his own right with just a few aesthetic choices that don't appeal to me. He is highly competent in all the fundamentals and by no means a poor artist. My ranking for him is merely a matter of subjective opinion.

So far as the ongoing is concerned, IDW has yet to hire an objectively bad artist or anything even close to that.

SDCC 03-19-2014 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1230200)
EXACTLY. Kuhn is a superb artist in his own right with just a few aesthetic choices that don't appeal to me. He is highly competent in all the fundamentals and by no means a poor artist. My ranking for him is merely a matter of subjective opinion.

So far as the ongoing is concerned, IDW has yet to hire an objectively bad artist or anything even close to that.

This! A thousand times this.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.