The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Nick influences (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=46928)

electric_sheep 04-06-2014 07:07 AM

Nick influences
 
I am not a biggest fan of Nick cartoon, but i don't mind it that much, until it starts letting it's roots into the comics.
Any of you guys have the same problem with this?
Look at this

And now look at this


They completely changed the designs to fit the cartoon, right down to Donatello's gap tooth. They even changed Mikey to fit the personality of the cartoon, and that's just wrong. I don't blame the artists, i blame Nickelodeon for pushing it on them.
Old turtles looked badass, new turtles look goofy...

chrisdude 04-06-2014 07:29 AM

They gave Donnie a tooth gap? I didn't even notice that, myself...

But it's a comic. Every artist who draws for the series makes the turtles look entirely different. That first pic is from the original artist, who went off to do something else. When Eastman draws, they look like Mirage. Santolouco's new style is my favorite, though.

Tazi 04-06-2014 07:32 AM

I'm guessing I don't have to mentoin artists renditions, cuz you already know about that. I think that's all, not Nick's influence or anything. Campbell drew the turtles like that before Viacom even bought TMNT, and Santoloucu is inspired by Campbell. They still kinda not the same. Don doesn't have the huge gap, Mikey doesn't have freckles, Raph has no crack on his shell. Santolouco's turtles now have the bondage/kneepads that Ross added in Northampton arc, that's different from Nick.

http://p.twimg.com/A3-FYt6CIAAupJt.jpg

They're still different enough, at least to me.

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blo...ver-A_rich.jpg

Powder 04-06-2014 07:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by electric_sheep (Post 1244171)
I don't blame the artists, i blame Nickelodeon for pushing it on them.

Well, you're ignorant for that, then. The creative team itself obviously leans in favor of certain cartoon based design elements. Mateus wanted his turtles to be Nick styled, and Tom wanted the rainbow masks. Has nothing to do with the higher ups. As for anyones work being goofy, art is subjective, you just happen to dislike Santoloucos, apparently.

I like the Nick designs, & I like these Nick inspired designs. A little brand unification is good, I think. It's what sets apart the Mirage & Viacom eras.

electric_sheep 04-06-2014 07:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrisdude (Post 1244173)
They gave Donnie a tooth gap? I didn't even notice that, myself...

But it's a comic. Every artist who draws for the series makes the turtles look entirely different. That first pic is from the original artist, who went off to do something else. When Eastman draws, they look like Mirage. Santolouco's new style is my favorite, though.

The art is beautiful, it's just the turtle designs. With every issue they add more from the cartoon, slowly almost unnoticeable until you go back and read a couple issue back. Yeah Donnie now has gap tooth and Mikey is more goofy than laid back like he was when the comics started...

Powder 04-06-2014 07:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by electric_sheep (Post 1244176)
Mikey is more goofy than laid back like he was when the comics started...

Hardly. It's the complete opposite.

I swear to God, users like you, I can't tell if you're just ridiculously biased or just trying to bait people.

electric_sheep 04-06-2014 07:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tazi (Post 1244174)
I'm guessing I don't have to mentoin artists renditions, cuz you already know about that. I think that's all, not Nick's influence or anything. Campbell drew the turtles like that before Viacom even bought TMNT, and Santoloucu is inspired by Campbell. They still kinda not the same. Don doesn't have the huge gap, Mikey doesn't have freckles, Raph has no crack on his shell. Santolouco's turtles now have the bondage/kneepads that Ross added in Northampton arc, that's different from Nick.

http://p.twimg.com/A3-FYt6CIAAupJt.jpg

They're still different enough, at least to me.

http://www.tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/blo...ver-A_rich.jpg

Gap and freckles wouldn't bother me that much, i am talking about the whole body design, Their arms and legs look exactly in the cartoon. I get artist rendition and all that, but they should at least try to keep a little of the old continuity look..

Quote:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1244177)
Hardly. It's the complete opposite.

I swear to God, users like you, I can't tell if you're just ridiculously biased or just trying to bait people.


Probably a mixture of both.

chrisdude 04-06-2014 07:54 AM

I get it. I loved the Waltz' art from the beginning, and when the parade of artists came through, I was really afraid of them landing on someone, er... gross. It was unnerving, realizing that the turtles didn't really have a style, as a series, and it was completely up to the artist. I'm just glad they landed on someone I like...

Powder 04-06-2014 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrisdude (Post 1244179)
It was unnerving, realizing that the turtles didn't really have a style, as a series, and it was completely up to the artist.

How? It's pretty much allllllways been that way. Guest era, Tales, Jim's art changing radically throughout the years, Mirage in-house artists taking turns, etc.

Tazi 04-06-2014 09:18 AM

Besides, when i first saw the nick designs, I had the impression that they're really similar tő Lawson's more recent designs, then any other animated/movie variations so far. Főr example 4kids turtles are much more 'alienated' from that, they look like they were done by the same guy who did xmen evo. (i actually like both xmen evo and 4kids, just saying how different they were)

Donatello19 04-06-2014 10:59 AM

There's no problem with these designs, really...I think they look great. And they're still different enough from the Nick turtles...it's understandable that they're doing this, it could bring in a lot more readers. Kids that like the Nick cartoon could see these, and then want to start reading them.

Technogeek29 04-06-2014 11:35 AM

Quote:

Mikey is more goofy than laid back like he was when the comics started...
Not really IDW Mikey has started out being pretty laid back but not overly optimistic as most Michelangelo's. He didn't want to believe Raph was alive or that he was dead. He is open minded about their reincarnation, but I he doesn't seem to really care if its true or not. And unlike most of the newer incarnations he doesn't tolerate his brothers crap when they bicker and has called them out on it several times.

Sophie Campbell 04-06-2014 11:49 AM

this all basically boils down to "i like this artist better than that artist" which is fine, we all think like that, i sure have my favorite Turtle renditions and other artists' Turtles that i hate, but you're couching it in something you don't fully understand, which is how things operate behind the scenes and how art, as a process and concept, works.

i can't speak for any of the other artists, but there's been little to no involvement by Nickelodeon in how i draw the Turtles (other than me not drawing tails on the Turtles but i can do that all i want in my fanart, no big deal). in fact there's sometimes concern if they look TOO much like the cartoon, not the other way around. i actually can't believe how little involvement they have, which is awesome for me, of course. no complaints here! XD

Powder's right that it's always been this way, too, not just in TMNT comics but ALL serialized monthly comics are like this. sure, there are some where they bring on artists to imitate the main style so everything has a consistent look over many different artists, but do you really want TMNT comics like that? that sounds really depressing to me.

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrisdude (Post 1244179)
I get it. I loved the Waltz' art from the beginning, and when the parade of artists came through, I was really afraid of them landing on someone, er... gross. It was unnerving, realizing that the turtles didn't really have a style, as a series, and it was completely up to the artist. I'm just glad they landed on someone I like...

it's Duncan by the way, not Waltz. ;) this actually kind of upsets me. let me get this straight, you'd rather the Turtles' look be decided upon by the copyright-holder, the suits, so to speak, than the people actually drawing the characters? you'd rather it be dictated by the company, by people who frankly don't give a crap WHAT the Turtles look like as long as it's "brand consistent" so they can sell toys, than decided by the people who actually love these characters just like you do, like me, Mateus, and everyone else who has worked on the IDW series?

finally, when you take into account how Nickelodeon operates behind the scenes, this is just how art itself works. you can't compare two very different artists and try to directly contrast differences in character design. sure, you might be able to make a point if you took the entire range of artists and pointed out how later people like Mateus and myself draw the Turtles in a way more similar to the cartoon than the people earlier on, like Dan and Andy, so maybe Nick or IDW is specifically bringing on artists who draw in a certain way. but it could equally be that the Nick show is simply super influential, like any new TMNT incarnation tends to be, whether you like them or not the Nick Turtles have really strong designs, or maybe that as a group TMNT artists might influence each other, or just MAYBE that some artists might want to incorporate Nick show elements because they like them and that's it? so anyway, i'm kind of rambling here now, but basically my point is that how artistic influence works isn't as how you're making it out it to work. it's just not that simple as evil Nickelodeon coming in and making us all draw a certain way.

and if they DID tell us to draw a certain way, why would they do it in such a half-hearted way? like Mateus's Turtles and my Turtles KINDA look like the Nick Turtles but they're obviously, clearly different, if Viacom really cared about brand consistency, why would they go "ehh, they KINDA look like the cartoon Turtles, that's good enough. whatever." and why would they let IDW continue to hire Andy or Kevin, whose Turtles are about as far from the Nick Turtles as you can get?

anyway, i'm totally ranting now, haha. XD if Bobby shows up he'll be mad i'm typing all this instead of working on Turtles in Time layouts.

Lampy 04-06-2014 11:56 AM

There was a bunch of discussions about this a while back in which several posters and I expressed concern over just how much influence nickelodeon has over this comic. Would the higher ups just snap their finger and say, "gap tooth, varying heights, goofy-looking" and just how fast IDW would react to that request, but in a more broader sense (i.e. story, characteristics, etc.) However, looking back on it now, we really had nothing to be concerned about as that's clearly not the case. The depictions of Mateus' turtles are clearly nick-inspired. But that's as far as the similarities go.
The first releases in the SHotFC mini-series did take me aback. But it's clear that Mateus' designs are improving the more he draws them. I still prefer Dan Duncan's early turtles, but Mateus' turtles (nick design inspirations and all) are definitely not a problem. Each artist has their own special rendition.

EDIT: All versions of the Turtles in all media change designs at some point. Mirage, in particular, had a ton of guest artists. Both OT and 4Kids eventually had design changes. Movie turtles had design changes. As a TMNT fan, you'd think the carousel of artists wouldn't bother you so much. I say go with it, enjoy the art. They're killing it in the best way possible (gathering ideas from all incarnations left and right). And if nothing else for you, at least the story is great.

Cipher 04-06-2014 02:40 PM

I was going to say (before Ross popped in to confirm), we're likely seeing some (some) elements of the Nick designs simply because they're strong designs -- among the best the franchise has ever seen in terms of simplicity and communication of character.

Personally, I could go for reducing those influences just a bit, not because I don't care for them, but to further distinguish the comic from other material (basically the opposite of what Powder said he leans toward). It sounds like that might be something both IDW and Nick are trying to stay aware of as well?

Things like the no-kill rule, the lack of material requiring "13+" stickers on IDW's original content, etc., appear to be safety measures in the event young fans of the cartoon stumble across the comics, but there's still content in there that skews well older than the Nick crowd, and there's probably a desire to separate them from IDW's own Nick-based series too. I'm sure, given their different target demographics, everyone wants to keep them separate. So, yeah, to a certain level, the more differentiation the better.

But I don't think we've had anything yet that's ridden the line too closely. The artists are just picking elements of other designs they like, and for the most part they're elements that work well.

Coola Yagami 04-06-2014 02:57 PM

It's still different enough in tone. Shredder talks but the big talk in the cartoon kiddy show..... but we don't see him actually impale Casey or slice a rival gang member's arm off. Nor will they ever show Leo yank a star out of an enemy's neck and say they can either leave to get medical attention or stay and fight and die from bleeding out.

CyberCubed 04-06-2014 03:28 PM

Bobby already said they were told not to use any of the Nick created characters in IDW.

So we won't be seeing Dogpound, Fishface, Spiderbitez, etc.

They can probably use Rahzar though, since he was an already existing character before Dogpound turned into him.

Joey Kamikaze 04-06-2014 04:06 PM

Gonna call BS on Mikey changing too. I just did a full re-read recently and if you read the Mikey micro... well, he's Mikey and he's always been Mikey in IDW. I wrote up a piece on the first year of IDW, where I talk in part about how each of the micros show off the bros' personalities, and these are the images I chose to show off Mikey's personality in that issue:



Then keep in mind that's the seventh issue in IDW chronology. Mikey's always been the goofy, lovable emotional center of the family since IDW began. Little bits like him being the one to calm Raph down later in "City Fall" or getting the family together in "Northampton," while still being a "party dude" at heart, are totally consistent with his role as a character.

chrisdude 04-06-2014 05:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ross Campbell (Post 1244250)
it's Duncan by the way, not Waltz. ;) this actually kind of upsets me. let me get this straight, you'd rather the Turtles' look be decided upon by the copyright-holder, the suits, so to speak, than the people actually drawing the characters? you'd rather it be dictated by the company, by people who frankly don't give a crap WHAT the Turtles look like as long as it's "brand consistent" so they can sell toys, than decided by the people who actually love these characters just like you do, like me, Mateus, and everyone else who has worked on the IDW series?

One of my first impressions of the comic, when I picked up the first trade, was, "Wow, these turtles look cool." Duncan (Sorry about that) came up with a way for the turtles to look. I liked it, and it just went away. I guess details about a character's appearance just aren't canon. That weirds me out. I'm fairly new to comics, and this must happen more than I've seen, but it's tough thing for me to wrap my head around...

Technogeek29 04-06-2014 05:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chrisdude (Post 1244379)
One of my first impressions of the comic, when I picked up the first trade, was, "Wow, these turtles look cool." Duncan (Sorry about that) came up with a way for the turtles to look. I liked it, and it just went away. I guess details about a character's appearance just aren't canon. That weirds me out. I'm fairly new to comics, and this must happen more than I've seen, but it's tough thing for me to wrap my head around...

DC will really not be your cup of tea. While not as often as say IDW they often change writers with their artist and will make you feel like your reading a different book each time.

Cipher 04-06-2014 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Technogeek29 (Post 1244381)
DC will really not be your cup of tea. While not as often as say IDW they often change writers with their artist and will make you feel like your reading a different book each time.

As someone who reads a fair amount of DC, I actually find the artist changes at IDW more jarring.

Not that either really bother me, but IDW tends to allow for far more deviation than does DC or Marvel. Mostly I'm thinking in terms of character models. DC's are fairly locked in, whereas IDW artists have the freedom to change characters drastically. (See the fact that the Turtles belts, masks, etc. change radically with each new penciller.)

Honestly, I could go for certain details being more consistent between artists at IDW. The approach is currently uneven, which can take you out of the story. For example, receiving the colored masks, April's haircut, etc., are in-story elements that are kept consistent between artists. But things like major details of the Turtles' gear, Casey's mask (which has resulted in at least one botched plot point), and more are left completely to the discretion of each new penciller. I think most readers are inclined to take things that aren't endemic to an artist's style as being literal, in-story changes; at the very least that's my natural interpretation when it comes to sequential art. But IDW's approach to that seems to be rather arbitrary. Some things are, other things that seem like they'd be right along the same lines aren't.

So, uh, per Bobby's request on his latest podcast appearance, this is a respectful but legitimate criticism. It can make for an awkward reading experience, especially when revisiting large chunks of the series. It breaks immersion quite a bit.

LeotheLateBloomer 04-08-2014 11:03 AM

From what it looks like, IDW doesn't seem to know what type of design they want to settle for.

DoctorFacilier 04-19-2014 02:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeotheLateBloomer (Post 1245217)
From what it looks like, IDW doesn't seem to know what type of design they want to settle for.

Turtles having no ankles and skinny arms bugs me, it doesn't fit with the rest of designs. Hope they ditch the whole Nick turtles in the future and bring something closer to the first issues in.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.