|
Alan Moore's The Killing Joke
Loved this one since junior high and always been one of my favorites.
One of Moore's best stories even if Moore himself doesn't like it, i thought it was a great take on Joker's past and present. |
I've actually never read it
Wait Why are you looking at me like that? :shifty: :tcouch: |
Grant Morrison recently brought this back into the limelight when he revealed that he interpreted the ending as Batman killing The Joker...the very same conclusion I came to after reading it as a kid.
Too bad it's long-term impact has finally been nullified what with Barbera running around as Batgirl again. God I miss Oracle. |
It's great but my favorite has to be Year One, it's the purest batman story ever written.
|
Quote:
Quote:
Killing Joke was supposable suppose to be the last Joker story supposably. Frank Miller kind of screwed the pooch on that one. :lol: |
I'm a decently big Batman fan, but I've never had any interest in reading it, mostly because it's only available in collected-edition-priced hardcovers.
It just sounds really ... trite. I can see why Moore would have looked less favorably on it later years. I love Watchmen to bits, but most of his commercial superhero work isn't that layered or successful. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
But I'm also capable of making the judgement that I don't want to pay the prices it goes for based on previews and endless summaries I've read. |
Quote:
https://m.comixology.com/Batman-The-...al-comic/48363 Don't see anything absurd about that, it's longer than a normal comic, pretty normal. |
I LOVE The Killing Joke, its one of my favorite Batman stories. I recommend this to everyone who asks me what comics they should read.
|
It's a great read and I Don't even remember if I still have it. But to me that just shows what a twisted individual the Joker is, torturing Gordon and maiming Barbara, just to prove a point. The long Halloween is still my fave Batman story though.
|
It's great. Moore's just one of those guys who over-analyzes his own work. And I don't think it's *that* over-priced if you know where to look. I swear I've seen later print copies for like $5. I'm pretty sure it's just the original first-print that's expensive.
I mean, at the end of the day, it probably can't live up to anyone's mental picture after a decade or more of reading *about* it once that person actually reads it, but what makes it so great is, it's THE definitive Joker story. It's literally the only Joker story anyone would ever need to read in their entire lives. The most epic, the one with the most long-term impact to the overall mythos? Maybe, maybe not. But it's the only one that is, in and of itself, entirely *essential*. A person could know literally nothing about The Joker, and this one self-contained story tells you everything. It's a great character piece, and since then it's almost become more prominent in how much of the Joker material since then has come to rely on it in various ways. As far as different interpretations of the ending, well... Spoiler:
|
Guess I'm gonna have to break the trade I have out again and give it another read.
|
I loved the book. I just don't like the ending. I'm a purist when it comes to the "no-killing" code of Batman. I think it's a really important part of the character and blah, blah, blah.
I understand what Moore was getting at. The Joker won. He just. . . broke Batman instead of Gordon. Awesome book, either way. |
Quote:
“You had a bad day once, am I right? I know I am. I can tell you had a bad day and everything changed. Why else would you dress up like a flying rat?” |
The ending is left to the reader's interpretation, but it has been noted that Moore meant for Batman to kill the Joker.
The Killing Joke was never meant to be canon, it was originally meant to be an Elseworlds story. But parts of it did become canon, such as Barbara becoming crippled. So officially, Bats didn't kill Joker at the end. Yet, if you look at the last few panels it shows the Joker laughing, panel by panel his laughter is coming down, until it suddenly stops. Batman's hands were shown around the Joker's neck before this. So, it's still possible to come to the conclusion that the Joker finally pushed Batman too far and cracked him. |
Again, I can see why it can be *interpreted* that way, but just curious: Where's your source to confirm that Joker did indeed die at the end? Because literally every time I've ever read anything about it, nobody's ever heard Moore himself say so. And like I said before, since he so often publicly dissects his own work, I think he would have said something about it by now.
If he has confirmed it, great. But again, just curious... is there a source, or just "well, that's what it seems like happened"? Because when it comes to any of Alan Moore's stuff, if he doesn't flat-out say so, I don't buy it. |
Huh, I was unaware of this theory until now.
From what I can tell, this misconception comes from the book "And the Universe so Big: Understanding Batman: The Killing Joke" and popularised by a podcast interview with Grant Morrision, however since niether didn’t work on the book it’s nothing more than fan speculation. Also, Batman’s hands are clearly not around the Joker’s neck. Not to mention nowhere in the original script is this mentioned. I think it’s an interesting way to look at the ending, but I don’t think it should be treated as fact. |
Yeah, like I said, Alan Moore loves to talk about his stuff. Almost 30 years, and he never said, "And nobody even noticed where I killed The Joker..."
Some people are mysterious and some people are wide open. Moore doesn't even like Killing Joke, so he'd have no reason not to "spoil" the "hidden ending". Unless he himself says so, I'm saying it's not true. He of all people would have said so, were it true. Just an interesting alternative reading/interpretation. |
Quote:
I'll have to re-read The Killing Joke sometime. Alan Moore's run on Swamp Thing was awesome too. If you haven't read it yet, track it down. Even the "filler" stories are memorable. |
I have an extra copy of the first edition is anyone is looking for it, just let me know.
|
It's an awesome story. The recolored version sucks aside from the funhouse scene though.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:34 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.