The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   How Has IDW Developed Since I Dropped It? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=47861)

Konchadunga 06-21-2014 03:45 AM

How Has IDW Developed Since I Dropped It?
 
I'll give you a brief recap of my take on this. Back when the IDW series first debuted, I really was thrilled. For the first time, I had a TMNT series that didn't seem determined to ignore at least one of the incarnations that preceded it, and the thought of seeing new life breathed into characters I thought deserved more had me stoked.

The more I read, thought, the more I was underwhelmed. Sadly, the same derivative nature that had me intrigued at first ended up making the series too familiar. I already had a good grasp of who Slash, Krang, Baxter Stockman, and Casey Jones were, and too much time was spent closely retelling what has become broadly accepted as their key stories. Worse still, though, is that I feel that IDW almost never managed to make old characters interesting again. I do like what they did with the Fugitoid, and they handled Krang reasonably well by making him a serious menace who still has a cynical sense of humor; if not anywhere near one of the most memorable villains ever. However, the way they handled the Neutrinos--I will completely counter TMNT Entity on this one: I was thrilled to learn they'd be in this book, and couldn't wait to see their newfound fighting abilities, but I was just dumbfounded by the way they were written; Eastman et al made them so serious that they were in a big way even more ridiculous than their Fred Wolf counterparts. There is absolutely nothing brilliant about taking a silly thing seriously. That arc was also marred, once again, by being way too similar to Turtles in Space.

Then came The Secret History of the Foot Clan. I felt that arc was handled much better, but on the downside, there wasn't as much to screw up. The basic ninja and gangster crime drama is never the part of TMNT I'm big into, and even with aliens and magic thrown into the backstory (and an awesome scene of the real, human Oroku Saki killing whom I like to think was Ch'rel), it was something that felt basic to me.

That's not what convinced me to drop the book, though. No; that honor belongs to the Cityfall arc, and the news that Leonardo would be seduced away by questioning the no-kill policy in this series. I more-or-less tolerate heroes with such a policy, even in this book where it seems ridiculous, but I've long since lost any patience for stories that exist just to make strawmen of those who believe in killing for the greater good, and acting like they have no valid point. It was my original reason for boycotting all DC books, and then The New 52 sealed the deal.

So I ask whomever still reads this series: Taking my concerns into mind, as well as your own opinion if it's similar enough, has this book improved? Has it dropped "holier-than-thou" morality? Has it moved away from reviewing the past and started doing its own thing? Has it gotten better at characterization? How did it handle Rocksteady and Bebop? Please weigh in.

Veg 06-21-2014 04:07 AM

If you didnt like it then, you probably wont now.

Mutant Ninja Anole 06-21-2014 04:10 AM

Do you want straight up spoilers or more general answers?

I love the arc, and the whole 'no killing ever' thing was secondary to the larger themes going on IMHO but to explain in detail would obviously spoil City Fall and the subsequent stories.

Konchadunga 06-21-2014 04:15 AM

Can you tell me whether they definitively set the policy against killing in stone? I might not need to know anything else about CF. I'm more interested in where the series has gone afterward.

CyberCubed 06-21-2014 08:24 AM

I'm really not sure what to tell you. If you didn't enjoy those issues the writing hasn't changed much from then to now.

I think IDW has been almost consistently good, my only gripes being the obvious censorship from Nick that they have no control over, and perhaps some old characters becoming too one-dimensional like Krang in terms of personality.

But other than that its about what I expected out of a rebooted TMNT comic that borrows from all universes. Try not to compare it to Mirage, think about what Archie did for the OT characters, and this is the same.

Tazi 06-21-2014 08:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1287488)
I think IDW has been almost consistently good, my only gripes being the obvious censorship from Nick that they have no control over, and perhaps some old characters becoming too one-dimensional like Krang in terms of personality.

You should really read Utrom Empire, he is anything, but one-dimensional.

PizzaPower1985 06-21-2014 09:54 AM

I'm sorry that the original poster felt the need to drop this series. My own personal feeling is that this series is the strongest the TMNT has ever been as a concept, both as a narrative and in execution. It is a best of all previous incarnations approach with a few added twists like reincarnation that make this series the most fun I have ever had with the TMNT. There is the Ninja superhero action, the introspection, the fantastical Dimension X/ Sci-fi stuff and the odes to Japanese mythology... IMHO, it is everything someone could want in a TMNT book or story.

Mutant Ninja Anole 06-21-2014 10:59 AM

FTR, the tension about Leonardo not killing is certainly there but as it happens it seems less "No killing even in self defense" as "No execution style dispatching of your enemies." YMMV though.

Spoiler:
Big examples, it's Shredder chopping off the rival Savate ninja leader's head the same way he, his bros and Splinter were beheaded that basically snaps Leo out of his mind control. Later, a new villain taunts Leo to kill her, but he simply leaves her with a wound that will kill her if she doesn't leave to receive medical attention.

If that's too much, sorry to hear you're off the book because I personally find it great. But to each their own.

EDIT: Also, with regards to Bebop and Rocksteady, the short story is they are just as humorously dumb but more effective on account of being more genuinely vicious, giving the humor a darker edge, and just being so strong and durable that they just shrug off whatever is thrown at them. I like it.

Wentos 06-21-2014 05:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Konchadunga (Post 1287428)
That's not what convinced me to drop the book, though. No; that honor belongs to the Cityfall arc, and the news that Leonardo would be seduced away by questioning the no-kill policy in this series. I more-or-less tolerate heroes with such a policy, even in this book where it seems ridiculous, but I've long since lost any patience for stories that exist just to make strawmen of those who believe in killing for the greater good, and acting like they have no valid point. It was my original reason for boycotting all DC books, and then The New 52 sealed the deal.

Okay, first of all, none of what you're saying actually happened. Leonardo didn't turn bad because he questioned a "no-killing" policy, he turned bad because he was brainwashed by Shredder's flunky Kitsune.

Honestly, I'm baffled as to why you would think the turtles would be killers in the IDW comics. The turtles only killed their opponents in the Mirage comics, and even then it was pretty much exclusively the Foot Clan, who were too skilled to hold back on. The ONLY time in their entire 30 year history that they've ever gone out of their way to kill was to avenge Hamato Yoshi by dueling Shredder. And that was issue 1, volume 1.

And your argument about the IDW series being derivativ doesn't hold water either. You list Casey Jones, Slash, and Krang as examples, yet their origins and motivations are WILDLY different in their IDW incarnations than they were originally.

If you don't like the IDW comic, that's fine. But your reasoning as to why is total garbage.

TrickOrTreater 06-21-2014 06:11 PM

I'm not really sure what you're trying to say here.

That you would have liked these books more if these established characters were vastly different from how they've been portrayed before?

What's the point then? There's a very fine line in putting your own unique stamp on a character but keeping them as recognizable as possible and just reinventing said character out of whole cloth because reasons.

Kendamu 06-22-2014 12:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Konchadunga (Post 1287433)
Can you tell me whether they definitively set the policy against killing in stone? I might not need to know anything else about CF. I'm more interested in where the series has gone afterward.

Then pick up an issue and try it out again. There's nothing stopping you.

Redeemer 06-22-2014 12:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Konchadunga (Post 1287433)
Can you tell me whether they definitively set the policy against killing in stone? I might not need to know anything else about CF. I'm more interested in where the series has gone afterward.

I recall them killing in City Fall arc. Specifically when the foot invaded the Savante Ninja. Also poor victor became left handed all of a sudden. I was glad to see Nick Censorship look the other way. :lol:

Tazi 06-22-2014 09:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redeemer (Post 1288012)
Also poor victor became left handed all of a sudden.

Good thing he doesn't had to live like that for long... :trolleye:

The Big Bad 06-22-2014 05:04 PM

While my problems with the regular book are somewhat different from yours, Konchadunga, I would say from what I've read, the book hasn't changed, and if you didn't like it by "City Fall", you won't like where the book is at the moment. From my sporadic reading, it's the same as it ever was: the book feels overly committed to bringing back old characters because they're old characters. The current arc, for example, has the writers apparently turning Angel into this incarnation's version of Nobody, meaning they've put her in a super-suit that only resembles' Nobody's in the loosest sense of the word, and gives her abilities the original character never possessed. What's more, given that the entire point of the original character was that he was a cop, which Angel is not, there seems to be no point to the connection except to make people go “hey, I remember that guy!” and get nostalgia feels.

The "Turtles in Time" mini, however, is another story. While it still has some of the fundamental issues of the main book--all the places the turtles are visiting feel like they were chosen because they're places the turtles visited in other incarnations, and the world-building continues to be unacceptably incestuous, with the turtles now being indirectly responsible for the Triceratons' existence because of reasons--the first issue is super-fun in the way the regular series never is. It is totally unafraid of being silly and fun, and so it feels like a breath of fresh air, and I feel it has a lot to do with the fact that it has to tell a stand-alone story, and can't afford to worry about the future or use it as a crutch. The same goes for the Bebop and Rocksteady one-shot, which I found to be delightful.

CyberCubed 06-22-2014 05:22 PM

I really enjoy the series as a whole , but it's safe to say if you can't get into it by now than it's probably not for you.

One thing I do love about the series is the merging of characters. Angel and Nobody, Chet and Fugitoid, Casey's Dad and Hun. It reminds me of how Nick made Dogpound into Rahzar.

I personally don't like too many conflicting characters so I like when they become one and the same. I'm hoping Karai eventually becomes both Pimiko and Lotus Blossom at the same time by using different disguises or codenames on separate missions.

I also think Slash will become Tokka.

Konchadunga 06-22-2014 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wentos (Post 1287769)
Okay, first of all, none of what you're saying actually happened. Leonardo didn't turn bad because he questioned a "no-killing" policy, he turned bad because he was brainwashed by Shredder's flunky Kitsune.

I didn't read up to that point; so sue me.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wentos (Post 1287769)
Honestly, I'm baffled as to why you would think the turtles would be killers in the IDW comics. The turtles only killed their opponents in the Mirage comics, and even then it was pretty much exclusively the Foot Clan, who were too skilled to hold back on. The ONLY time in their entire 30 year history that they've ever gone out of their way to kill was to avenge Hamato Yoshi by dueling Shredder. And that was issue 1, volume 1.

Then let them kill only the Foot Clan here. It's one thing not to kill when you can avoid it, but when your own life is at risk, that's different.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wentos (Post 1287769)
And your argument about the IDW series being derivativ doesn't hold water either. You list Casey Jones, Slash, and Krang as examples, yet their origins and motivations are WILDLY different in their IDW incarnations than they were originally.

I probably should have used a different term. I don't mind those characters in themselves, and I like that they're varying up their mythologies, but I guess my problem is that the book tries so hard to bring so many characters back, that it has little time to focus on all of them. Changing up a character can work, but it's not like they can add a lot to them with the current style.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wentos (Post 1287769)
If you don't like the IDW comic, that's fine. But your reasoning as to why is total garbage.

No; it's not. Many have expressed the same thing.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1288430)
While my problems with the regular book are somewhat different from yours, Konchadunga, I would say from what I've read, the book hasn't changed, and if you didn't like it by "City Fall", you won't like where the book is at the moment. From my sporadic reading, it's the same as it ever was: the book feels overly committed to bringing back old characters because they're old characters. The current arc, for example, has the writers apparently turning Angel into this incarnation's version of Nobody, meaning they've put her in a super-suit that only resembles' Nobody's in the loosest sense of the word, and gives her abilities the original character never possessed. What's more, given that the entire point of the original character was that he was a cop, which Angel is not, there seems to be no point to the connection except to make people go “hey, I remember that guy!” and get nostalgia feels.

I heard about the Angel/Nobody thing, and that definitely irks me, too. I liked her as she was; except she needed to be a bit tougher before she came into the action.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1288430)

The "Turtles in Time" mini, however, is another story. While it still has some of the fundamental issues of the main book--all the places the turtles are visiting feel like they were chosen because they're places the turtles visited in other incarnations, and the world-building continues to be unacceptably incestuous, with the turtles now being indirectly responsible for the Triceratons' existence because of reasons--the first issue is super-fun in the way the regular series never is. It is totally unafraid of being silly and fun, and so it feels like a breath of fresh air, and I feel it has a lot to do with the fact that it has to tell a stand-alone story, and can't afford to worry about the future or use it as a crutch. The same goes for the Bebop and Rocksteady one-shot, which I found to be delightful.

Good to know I can read those without being too in the dark, then.

TomWaltz 06-23-2014 07:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Konchadunga (Post 1287428)
I'll give you a brief recap of my take on this. Back when the IDW series first debuted, I really was thrilled. For the first time, I had a TMNT series that didn't seem determined to ignore at least one of the incarnations that preceded it, and the thought of seeing new life breathed into characters I thought deserved more had me stoked.

The more I read, thought, the more I was underwhelmed. Sadly, the same derivative nature that had me intrigued at first ended up making the series too familiar. I already had a good grasp of who Slash, Krang, Baxter Stockman, and Casey Jones were, and too much time was spent closely retelling what has become broadly accepted as their key stories. Worse still, though, is that I feel that IDW almost never managed to make old characters interesting again. I do like what they did with the Fugitoid, and they handled Krang reasonably well by making him a serious menace who still has a cynical sense of humor; if not anywhere near one of the most memorable villains ever. However, the way they handled the Neutrinos--I will completely counter TMNT Entity on this one: I was thrilled to learn they'd be in this book, and couldn't wait to see their newfound fighting abilities, but I was just dumbfounded by the way they were written; Eastman et al made them so serious that they were in a big way even more ridiculous than their Fred Wolf counterparts. There is absolutely nothing brilliant about taking a silly thing seriously. That arc was also marred, once again, by being way too similar to Turtles in Space.

Then came The Secret History of the Foot Clan. I felt that arc was handled much better, but on the downside, there wasn't as much to screw up. The basic ninja and gangster crime drama is never the part of TMNT I'm big into, and even with aliens and magic thrown into the backstory (and an awesome scene of the real, human Oroku Saki killing whom I like to think was Ch'rel), it was something that felt basic to me.

That's not what convinced me to drop the book, though. No; that honor belongs to the Cityfall arc, and the news that Leonardo would be seduced away by questioning the no-kill policy in this series. I more-or-less tolerate heroes with such a policy, even in this book where it seems ridiculous, but I've long since lost any patience for stories that exist just to make strawmen of those who believe in killing for the greater good, and acting like they have no valid point. It was my original reason for boycotting all DC books, and then The New 52 sealed the deal.

So I ask whomever still reads this series: Taking my concerns into mind, as well as your own opinion if it's similar enough, has this book improved? Has it dropped "holier-than-thou" morality? Has it moved away from reviewing the past and started doing its own thing? Has it gotten better at characterization? How did it handle Rocksteady and Bebop? Please weigh in.

Oh, it just gets better and better, trust me -- and the writer grows more handsome and clever with each passing minute. In other words, the comic is like Shakespeare and the writer is like Brad Pitt. You can't go wrong!

:twink:

Talk soon…

Tom W.

Wentos 06-23-2014 07:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1288430)
the book feels overly committed to bringing back old characters because they're old characters. The current arc, for example, has the writers apparently turning Angel into this incarnation's version of Nobody, meaning they've put her in a super-suit that only resembles' Nobody's in the loosest sense of the word, and gives her abilities the original character never possessed. What's more, given that the entire point of the original character was that he was a cop, which Angel is not, there seems to be no point to the connection except to make people go “hey, I remember that guy!” and get nostalgia feels.

The "Turtles in Time" mini, however, is another story. While it still has some of the fundamental issues of the main book--all the places the turtles are visiting feel like they were chosen because they're places the turtles visited in other incarnations, and the world-building continues to be unacceptably incestuous, with the turtles now being indirectly responsible for the Triceratons' existence because of reasons--the first issue is super-fun in the way the regular series never is. It is totally unafraid of being silly and fun, and so it feels like a breath of fresh air, and I feel it has a lot to do with the fact that it has to tell a stand-alone story, and can't afford to worry about the future or use it as a crutch. The same goes for the Bebop and Rocksteady one-shot, which I found to be delightful.

This is the first piece of legitimate criticism in this thread, so I feel I ought to address it.

I don't really agree with your assertion that they're bringing back old characters just to do it, since you yourself admit that the IDW version of Nobody has almost no relation to the Nobody in the Mirage comics. I guess maybe you're arguing that if this character isn't like Mirage Nobody then they shouldn't be called Nobody at all, but then if they DID make IDW Nobody a carbon copy of Mirage Nobody, then fans would complain that the character was too derivative. You can't please everybody, but Kevin, Tom and Bobby balance things out the best they can.

You are totally right in saying that the IDW continuity is very intricate with a lot of overlap between characters. But while you seem to view it as a weakness, I view it as one of the book's greatest strengths. The various companion books that have been released over the course of the series have given Kevin, Tom and Bobby the unique ability to flesh out the setting and the characters of the universe they've created without sacrificing the forward momentum of the main narrative. Balancing plot progression with character development and world-building is not easy by any means, so the micros and minis are a great way to give the IDW-verse a larger context without making the main book feel stagnant.

Having said all that, there is a danger of revealing too much too quickly, and confining yourself to the pieces you've already laid on the table. In the long term this could become a problem, but it's worked out well so far, and I have faith that Bobby can keep the ever-expanding craziness straight.

Anyway. All of this is just to say that I understand and respect your viewpoint, but I don't share it.

Kendamu 06-24-2014 01:08 AM

Yeah, that is interesting. The complaint about Nobody is, "That's different and I don't like it." The complaint about other characters is, "More of the same and I don't like it."

CyberCubed 06-24-2014 05:37 PM

IDW TMNT is about everything I could have wanted from an, "Ultimate" TMNT series. Taking elements from every series along with new ideas has been very well done.

Is the series perfect? No. But I doubt the series would have been any better had Dark Horse gotten the license instead of IDW for example.

The Big Bad 06-24-2014 06:29 PM

Quote:

Yeah, that is interesting. The complaint about Nobody is, "That's different and I don't like it." The complaint about other characters is, "More of the same and I don't like it."
To a degree, yes: part of my problem is that many characters currently reside in that anti-Goldilocks zone where they're both too different and/or too similar. And yet no, because the solution, I feel, to characters like Nobody is not to make them more like their other selves, but to embrace that these are new concepts and just go whole-hog instead of retreating and going "hey, old concept!" in an attempt to make them more palatable.

To repeat: there is nothing to tie IDW Nobody to the character from the Mirage books and the 4Kids toon except for a name and costumes that share several elements. They could have called her something else or nothing at all, and I don't think many who like this development would have complained (at least unless the reason they like this development is because of the name, which case, consider my eyebrow raised in Spock-like manner). And yet, there the name is, which raises the question: why?

(There are several answers, the most satisfying being that they wanted to tie the name to her self-esteem issues. And by "satisfying" I mean "too literal and contrived by half".)

In any case, here we are. What does it add? A nod to an established character, for people who like that sort of thing. What does it add to our understanding about Nobody the cop? Nothing, since that's not the character we're getting. What does it take away? The opportunity to see Nobody the cop, at least anytime soon. I feel the whole thing would have felt more honest, daring, and interesting if they'd let it stand on its own without the name. I might not have liked it, but I'd at least feel it would have had more merit. And I feel that way about a whole bunch of characters, whose incarnations here tend to lose a lot of what made them interest without adding a whole lot.

Change in general is fine. The 4Kids cartoon's transformation of Karai into the Shredder's daughter is a huge change, one that fundamentally changes the character. And yet, I get it. It turns the character into the turtles' dark mirror--themselves, trained by the bad guy. Giving Hamato Yoshi a daughter? That's a fantastic change, because the idea that the turtles are Splinter's second attempt at raising a family is something I find inherently interesting, and was disappointed that Miwa turned out to be a baby when she was lost, because it cuts off a lot of that potential. I respect all of the liberties the original cartoon took with the source material, and, those the Archie book took with the original cartoon. I may not have liked them all, but there's a sense that the writers had the courage of their convictions. They didn't do things halfway. The IDW series on the other hand, specials notwithstanding, almost always feels halfway.

Mutant Ninja Anole 06-25-2014 09:13 AM

I really don't think I could disagree more, honestly. That they were able to take the SUPER COOL Neutrinos of the 1987 cartoon and make them legitimate freedom fighters, or the way they melded Krang into the Utroms, doesn't seem 'halfway' but blended quite well.

I don't really know about Nobody the cop but as is we get something to develop Angel, a character who at this point needs something new after being kicked off the Purple Dragons and trying and failing to fight Hun for the upteenth time. It also creates a new role for Harold and gives the Turtles a stronger ally in their upcoming conflict with the Foot. I'm not saying making a cop we haven't seen before in this universe wouldn't work, but here it takes a character we've already introduced and enhances them.

Tazi 06-25-2014 09:18 AM

...tho Kara would have been a much better choice. :roll:

TomWaltz 06-25-2014 01:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1290806)
To a degree, yes: part of my problem is that many characters currently reside in that anti-Goldilocks zone where they're both too different and/or too similar. And yet no, because the solution, I feel, to characters like Nobody is not to make them more like their other selves, but to embrace that these are new concepts and just go whole-hog instead of retreating and going "hey, old concept!" in an attempt to make them more palatable.

To repeat: there is nothing to tie IDW Nobody to the character from the Mirage books and the 4Kids toon except for a name and costumes that share several elements. They could have called her something else or nothing at all, and I don't think many who like this development would have complained (at least unless the reason they like this development is because of the name, which case, consider my eyebrow raised in Spock-like manner). And yet, there the name is, which raises the question: why?

(There are several answers, the most satisfying being that they wanted to tie the name to her self-esteem issues. And by "satisfying" I mean "too literal and contrived by half".)

In any case, here we are. What does it add? A nod to an established character, for people who like that sort of thing. What does it add to our understanding about Nobody the cop? Nothing, since that's not the character we're getting. What does it take away? The opportunity to see Nobody the cop, at least anytime soon. I feel the whole thing would have felt more honest, daring, and interesting if they'd let it stand on its own without the name. I might not have liked it, but I'd at least feel it would have had more merit. And I feel that way about a whole bunch of characters, whose incarnations here tend to lose a lot of what made them interest without adding a whole lot.

Change in general is fine. The 4Kids cartoon's transformation of Karai into the Shredder's daughter is a huge change, one that fundamentally changes the character. And yet, I get it. It turns the character into the turtles' dark mirror--themselves, trained by the bad guy. Giving Hamato Yoshi a daughter? That's a fantastic change, because the idea that the turtles are Splinter's second attempt at raising a family is something I find inherently interesting, and was disappointed that Miwa turned out to be a baby when she was lost, because it cuts off a lot of that potential. I respect all of the liberties the original cartoon took with the source material, and, those the Archie book took with the original cartoon. I may not have liked them all, but there's a sense that the writers had the courage of their convictions. They didn't do things halfway. The IDW series on the other hand, specials notwithstanding, almost always feels halfway.

Apparently I neither have courage nor conviction but I did recently save 15% on insurance with just a 15-minute phone call, so there's that.

:trazz:

Talk soon…

Tom W.

natecm 06-25-2014 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomWaltz (Post 1291422)
Apparently I neither have courage nor conviction but I did recently save 15% on insurance with just a 15-minute phone call, so there's that.

:trazz:

Talk soon…

Tom W.

And there's cake in the kitchen today! So that's awesome.

TomWaltz 06-25-2014 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by natecm (Post 1291477)
And there's cake in the kitchen today! So that's awesome.

I'm gonna eat a piece, too. But only halfway.

:tgrin:

Talk soon…

Tom W.

Wentos 06-26-2014 10:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1290806)
To a degree, yes: part of my problem is that many characters currently reside in that anti-Goldilocks zone where they're both too different and/or too similar. And yet no, because the solution, I feel, to characters like Nobody is not to make them more like their other selves, but to embrace that these are new concepts and just go whole-hog instead of retreating and going "hey, old concept!" in an attempt to make them more palatable.

To repeat: there is nothing to tie IDW Nobody to the character from the Mirage books and the 4Kids toon except for a name and costumes that share several elements. They could have called her something else or nothing at all, and I don't think many who like this development would have complained (at least unless the reason they like this development is because of the name, which case, consider my eyebrow raised in Spock-like manner). And yet, there the name is, which raises the question: why?

(There are several answers, the most satisfying being that they wanted to tie the name to her self-esteem issues. And by "satisfying" I mean "too literal and contrived by half".)

In any case, here we are. What does it add? A nod to an established character, for people who like that sort of thing. What does it add to our understanding about Nobody the cop? Nothing, since that's not the character we're getting. What does it take away? The opportunity to see Nobody the cop, at least anytime soon. I feel the whole thing would have felt more honest, daring, and interesting if they'd let it stand on its own without the name. I might not have liked it, but I'd at least feel it would have had more merit. And I feel that way about a whole bunch of characters, whose incarnations here tend to lose a lot of what made them interest without adding a whole lot.

Change in general is fine. The 4Kids cartoon's transformation of Karai into the Shredder's daughter is a huge change, one that fundamentally changes the character. And yet, I get it. It turns the character into the turtles' dark mirror--themselves, trained by the bad guy. Giving Hamato Yoshi a daughter? That's a fantastic change, because the idea that the turtles are Splinter's second attempt at raising a family is something I find inherently interesting, and was disappointed that Miwa turned out to be a baby when she was lost, because it cuts off a lot of that potential. I respect all of the liberties the original cartoon took with the source material, and, those the Archie book took with the original cartoon. I may not have liked them all, but there's a sense that the writers had the courage of their convictions. They didn't do things halfway. The IDW series on the other hand, specials notwithstanding, almost always feels halfway.

I really don't get why you're okay with the liberties the cartoons took with pre-existing characters like Karai, yet you hate every liberty the IDW comic has taken. It seems completely arbitrary to me, especially your complaint that the IDW comic is both too similar and too different. If you don't like the IDW comic that's fine, but your logic here makes no sense at all.

However, your accusation that the IDW comic doesn't differentiate itself enough from other iterations of the TMNT does warrant discussion. IMO the IDW comic has, as others have said before, set itself up as a sort of "Ultimate TMNT", a series that grabs from every facet of the TMNT franchise and introduces old elements in a new way. And this IMO is how IDW differentiates itself from other TMNT media.

Before the IDW comic started, most TMNT iterations had kept to themselves, coming up with their own supporting characters and status quos, independent of anything that had come before it. Even the Archie comic based on the 80's cartoon became its own unique thing before too long. There had never really been a TMNT comic (or movie, or cartoon) that was a conglomeration of all previous TMNT incarnations in an attempt to unify everything into a single cohesive whole. This is precisely what the IDW comic is attempting to do, to bring all these disparate elements together into one singular narrative. You could almost call it an attempt to be the definitive TMNT experience, though I doubt Kevin, Tom or Bobby would ever call it that.

I totally understand if you would prefer a TMNT comic that paves its own way and ignores the franchise's history. But you have to appreciate that IDW's approach to TMNT is unique, and in many ways was a long time coming. I mean come on, how did it take 25 years for Bebop and Rocksteady to show up in TMNT again?

ProphetofGanja 06-26-2014 06:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomWaltz (Post 1291525)
I'm gonna eat a piece, too. But only halfway.

:tgrin:

Talk soon…

Tom W.

So you CAN have your cake and eat it too!

CyberCubed 06-26-2014 11:06 PM

4kids did to the Mirage material the same thing IDW is doing to everything before it. Its adapting the old stuff and making it better in some cases while a few other areas fall short.

Of course 4kids had to deal with being a Saturday Morning cartoon so they couldn't handle the mature themes found in Mirage's City at War for example, but IDW doesn't have that problem.

I would like to see more personal moments for the Turtles, or more character driven moments. But hey, that's what the micros and specials are for, right? As long as we get the character driven moments somewhere its fine.

Lampy 06-26-2014 11:51 PM

Hahahaha. I love it when creators get involved and interact with their audience.

Wentos 06-27-2014 02:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1292470)
I would like to see more personal moments for the Turtles, or more character driven moments. But hey, that's what the micros and specials are for, right? As long as we get the character driven moments somewhere its fine.

Yeah, totally agreed. I would love more Turtle-centric microseries and miniseries. I know that the turtles are the focus of the main book, but the main book is very narrative-driven with a lot of balls in the air, while the companion books can slow down a bit and delve a little more into characterization.

That's why I'm so happy about Turtles in Time. It's the first turtle-centric companion book since the first four microseries issues. I love that we have this miniseries all by itself where the turtles are the stars, without the plot threads of the main book interrupting things.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:45 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.