![]() |
Why the Turtles are Ugly: A Theory
I just read through a separate thread about the new World Cup commercials. Despite the fact that it was MEANT to be a thread devoted to new footage of the movie, it quickly de-evolved into a discussion about the new Turtle design. While some were commenting about the Turtles new wardrobe, most people began bashing the Turtles physical appearances.
It's the same debate everyone's been having since we first saw that Mikey Halloween costume and those maquettes: Those who are FOR the design say the boys have taken on more human features because it's the only way to take full advantage of CGI; More human = better facial expressions. Those who are AGAINST the new designs say that the Turtles new faces (and to a degree, their body proportions) are unsettling and disturbing; that the use of CGI is a poor substitute for Jim Henson's puppet suits and they shouldn't have messed with a good thing. I for one LOVE the new look...but the reason why has nothing to do with my interest in the technological advances of filmmaking. Ironically, I love the look for the same reason the haters DON'T. I love them BECAUSE they're ugly. All of the haters are right about their faces. The tiny eyes, the flared nostrils, the smaller lips and teeth. It's weird and unsettling and so different from the Turtles we grew up with: From Mirage to Nick, these Turtles are so warped from what we expected that it's caused many of us to bash on the movie even more than we did when we found out Bay was producing it. And that's just the faces! Their bulked-up, hunchbacked bodies are also very creepy. Most people theories about why the Turtles have changed so drastically hinge on a few key opinions: Bay kept wanting to PUSH IT TO THE MAX. They wanted to sell toys. They wanted to push the technology. Or, they did it just because they could...to get a rise out of us long time fans. But here's my theory, something I haven't heard mentioned before (and if it has been, sorry if this post is redundant...I didn't feel like digging through pages of pages of posts to see if I was being unoriginal). The new Turtles are ugly because they're monsters. There. That's it. Everyone who hates the new look can stop wondering. What we have all forgotten about the Turtles is that they are all freaks of science (or sci-fi). They're not supposed to be cute and cuddly...they're mutants! They live in the sewer with their equally creepy giant rat dad! And they KNOW they're not supposed to be seen by the public for this very reason, hence all the trenchcoats and bald fat guy masks. One could argue that they secrecy has more to do with the Ninja code, but I don't buy it. The Turtles and Splinter have always known they were monsters. Monsters with a purpose, with a goal to fight evil at every turn, but monsters nonetheless. But we, as fans, have FORGOTTEN this very key point. We love the Turtles because they're fun-loving teens who eat pizza and always save the day. They laugh and joke and goof off, they watch TV and play videogames and read comics. They have unrequited crushes on redheads. They sometimes hate that their dad is so strict and controlling. In short, we love the Turtles because deep down, they're just like us (minus all the ninja stuff, of course). And after spending so many years with these guys in their various incarnations, it's hard to see them as the physical monsters they really are. And I think Liebesman and company wanted to remind us of that. Is it because they want us to fear and be disgusted by the Turtles? Yes...but only until we get to know them again. From the first trailer, we know that April's initial reaction to the boys is shock (so much so that she faints). I'm sure the very next scene is her waking up in the sewer lair and freaking out again: These hideous giant reptiles have kidnapped me and now I'm going to die. We all know that's not how it's going to turn out. No, she's going to slowly get to know the Turtles for who they really are on the inside. Not just mutants, not just ninjas, not just turtles...teens. Teens whom she will grow to trust and love and respect. And she will extend this trust and love and respect to their father as well. I thought of this theory after the second trailer came out. Suddenly, after spending just 2 minutes and 43 seconds with these monsters, many of us realized that they were still the same guys we all grew up with. Those who initially boycotted the movies now decided to give it a shot. Those who were already excited for the film exploded in joy. Though ugly, though unsettling, though monsterous, they are still the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Sorry for the long post, but I just had to get that off my chest. To those of you who got through this, thanks for reading. -Jonaas |
Can we put a ban on the word haters?
As one who is often referred to as a "hater", I think I speak for everyone "against" the designs when I say that we don't take issue with ugly, just this version of ugly. I'm all for the turtles being grotesque & beastly, or even a bit of uncanny valley, but for me, that brings to mind the work of Zulli, Farley, characters like Tokka, Slash, not lips & noses (though those features can be done justice, a lot of us agree on that point when it comes to the designs of "Out Of The Shadows"). At any rate, this kinda stuff has been discussed to death, no "new" perspective is going to change how anyone feels. Folks on either side of this issue are very passionate & firm in their stance. I imagine this is just going to drum up more beef between the sides (who, I think, lately, have been getting along better). |
Quote:
I was first a fan of the OT and the Archie Comics. The very first Mirage Comic I ever read was a Zulli comic in 1991. While initially freaked out by how they looked (NO BANDANNAS?!) I grew to love the look and when we first got a peek of the new designs, my memory harkened back to Zulli's take. And I'm not trying to change anyone's mind here, but I am trying to share my perspective. Also, whether it's been discussed to death or not is not the issue: if it's something that people don't feel like reading about, they don't have to. |
Just a preemptive call for civility...because it seems like a necessity in most threads now-a-days.
|
Quote:
|
Just to be clear, I didn't think you were trying to be rude or biased. I'm just sick of that word. :trazz:
|
Quote:
|
Nice insight.
People are mainly complaining about the ugly faces for Michelangelo, Donatello, and slighty Raphael. Leo is the only turtle with a decent face. I mean look at it! http://www.spotlightreport.net/wp-co...14-600x350.jpg He is like Brad Pitt. I think the TMNT Movie Facebook page chose Leonardo as their profile picture because he was the only one that looked decent instead of a hideous freak. While Michelangelo is like a cross between Shrek and Sloth from the Goonies. Donatello looks like a cross between a fish and rabbit, the unattractive type of rabbit. Raphael looks somewhat decent, he mainly resembles Azog from the Hobbit. I think there would be less of a backlash from the fans if they just stayed with the face that Leo had and only made slight alterations. Leonardo barely looks humanoid and looks similar to the other TMNT designs, just with nostrils. Leo's face is the right mixture of mutant and humanoid features. They just screwed up on the others. |
I don't mind grotesque or "ugly" ninja Turtles, but. I personally don't find the PD Turtles that, just poorly designed. As Powder exampled Zulli's TMNT design is a perfect example on monstrous Ninja Turtles done good, and the OotS game did a great job on designing a semi-realistic take on the classic (Nick) Turtle designs.
The PD Turtles do have some good stuff on them, the textures are very nice, their hands and feet are beautifully modeled and animated. They have greatly improved the faces on all four turtles, but. I feel they could have fixed them even more. But, I really can not stand their bodies. It's not just the face that look too human, but their bodies are shaped like the atypical powerhouse bodybuilder with the triangular body shape, broad shoulders narrow hips, buff muscles. The 90's superhero body, or a big wrestler like Cena. And I don't fancy that. If others do, kudos to them, but for me the appeal of the TMNT design is that they are turtles, humanoids, but turtle humaniods not human turtleoids. The shell on the PD turtles looks like an after thought, like it's just mandatory because the turtles have shells. The shell bridges are removed for some strange design reason, the plastron is shaped like a sexy hunks muscled out torso, even showing the V line down their abdomen. And the Carapace don't look like it's an actual part of the turtle, it's huge and bulky and looks like it'll tear right off their skin as it can't be connected like it's supposed to be on a turtle. Short. They just don't look like proper Ninja Turtles designs to me as a lot of the things that appealed to me is gone. |
But what's really at stake here? Nothing. Unless you bet big money on if the Turtles in this movie would look like the Jim Henson film. The last time I watched TMNT other than the old series was Turtles Forever then the TMNT animated flick and my reaction to those were simply "That's good". I didn't put it over like I would have if I was still 5 years old, marking out to anything and everything TMNT.
I remember when I was a kid the local Walgreen's put an ad in the paper saying come see Michelangelo of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles so I begged my Mom to go, we got there and it was one of those goofy big foam suits that looked more like a football mascot but I still ate it up. With anything there is bound to be disappointment. Look at the X-Men franchise. I absolutely cannot stand them but here they are going 7 movies deep. Has anyone protested Fox for having the rights to these movies? None of the characters look like their comic book counterparts but enough people go and see them enough to warrant sequels. At this point I'm just happy that there is a Turtles film coming out. I'm not expecting much and I don't really mind the designs. I don't care to sit on the internets and nitpick every little thing to death which I might have done that years ago but not anymore. If this movie came out a years ago I might have headed right to Michael Bay's house with pitchforks and an angry mob but with time I have grown to like his movies. If the movie sucks then so be it. The fandom will still be going strong with another season of the Nick series, IDW Comic. |
As much as I love these designs, I've never thought designs were that important. I don't like what Man of Steel did with the Superman costume. Batman movies have never had a costume I've liked. Ironman has at least two new suits every movie, so if you like one, it's already gone. And like UGH said, the X-Men costumes look aweful (save First Class). I just never considered these things more than minor, minor aspects of the film. It really doesn't seem important enough to get bent out of shape over...
|
I don't think anything in this movie is worthy enough to get into fights and possibly get banned or suspended over. People are quickly to jump to conclusions when we have yet to see a full scene of this movie yet.
Things people have Nitpicked so far Leo doing a flip and landing loudly on the roof being not ninja like. This was after Raph pulled April onto the roof for taking a picture of the four, the gig was up, why should he approach in a stealthy way? The Turtles not doing karate or martial arts. I think they are saving the fights for us to be entertained but Mikey's kick looked cool Shredder being a white guy. What's the big idea? Shredder is just a mantle and ultimately just a title. There have been numerous people to be the Shredder. There has been a Demon Shredder. A Dragon Shredder. A Human Shredder. A Clone Shredder that turned into a Shark/Human hybrid. An Android Shredder. 2 Women Shredders. Hell if one of us lived in the Turtleverse and put the armor on we too would become The Shredder. At least they have the guy who's lurking in the shadows in this movie that resembles the Nick TMNT Shredder. The Turtles being an exaggerated 7 foot tall. The Turtles wearing flair. We really don't know the reason for their choice of clothes. April's not naturally red headed The first April I saw had Curly black hair and wore a blue jumpsuit its not a big deal is it? I personally wanted to see Jane Levy as April. Because shes fabulous and I have a mad celebrity crush on her. The Foot using guns. *clears throat* http://38.media.tumblr.com/50465ab4f...mnmyo1_500.jpg http://www.figurerealm.com/userimage...00/12421-1.jpg http://www.adventuresinpoortaste.com...12/08/0031.jpg http://www.adventuresinpoortaste.com...12/12/0026.jpg https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/i...8z6Fo6tXkJxJV_ http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-XSbuluEJrI...s1600/14-2.jpg Guns were everywhere! |
The fact that the turtles are bigger and uglier makes me love this movie even more.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I'd rather this movie flopped and have no movie series for a decade than have Bay's vision for the franchise forced on us. A lot of the problems with this movie can't be fixed or improved with sequels like most film series. |
This is not going to get 5 movies. There is no way that is gonna happen.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Very thought provoking. You may be right on track with the intentions behind their design decisions. I've read all the arguments about how the new designs help facilitate expression and their ability to emote, but I like your idea more. The new look of the turtles show without a doubt that they are indeed mutants that must hide in the shadows and sneak off into the night. I like your perspective on this.
|
Quote:
Anyway. As a counterpoint, I feel like I made my case really thoroughly in the other thread, so I'll just link to that. The only thing I can really add is, considering they went more "humanoid" with their look in this movie, if anything they look less like monsters. They're big and ugly, that much is true. And they may have been cuter-looking before, but they were also more inhuman-looking at the same time. When you look at the new designs, you can see the human features. I really think that takes away from the concept on a basic design level. And I think they've always looked like that for a very good reason - the Turtles being small and sorta cute is part of the appeal, because you don't expect them to be as deadly as they are. It's something that been used to great effect, and you totally lose that when you turn them into giant, hulking monsters. Quote:
http://media1.giphy.com/media/vJuQAOM5EKGNa/giphy.gif |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I came up with this theory in that thread you mentioned.
Quote:
It's highly likely that the development from fear to acceptance in this movie is going to be 3 lines of dialogue so they took this tremendously long detour for nothing. |
For mutants, they look amazing. Don't think they look ugly. Different, but not ugly
|
Quote:
Opinions and all that, though personally I don't agree, and for a big reason of: Quote:
The Turtles have always been in a weird spot. They shouldn't feel quite like humans, nor animals, but at the same time should feel like people. Beings we can connect with, who feel like just another person but aren't quite us. A brother from another species mother. If they're "monsters"... we lose that. They're so much closer to us than most other "superhero" types are capable of being... It would be hard to connect with a character that has super powers we can never have. These guys how ever have no more super powers than we have. Maybe they are stronger, but their abilities come down to skill and training, and via an art that has it's real life equivalents that isn't entirely out of reach for real people. (Most of us would simply lack the actual reason to use it.) If they're over powered "monsters"... then it's like some part of them is just kinda.. gone. There really isn't any reason that they couldn't have kept at least some degree of physical appeal other than simply choosing not to. MY theory... this is clearly a very youthful, 21st century masculine take on it. I believe the reasons they made them big and creepy looking is not too far off from the same reasons why many young male MMO game players, like on WoW, gravitate toward playing the creepier looking "bad" side. Because in the limited mentality of our society being a fugly monster that's possibly on steroids equals being cooler, more badass, more masculine. The 21st century does not believe you can be a badass and do it while being half decent looking. I don't need them to look completely like the old style, nor do they need to be 100% adorable... but for christ sake, someone make some cuteagen for these guys, even just a light dab of it would do wonders. My fake theory: they made them that way to help fend off the fangirls. Edit: I suppose it also comes down to them having a very wide, mixed audience. I mean, a lot of media has a very specific gender/age target and while companies like Nick might AIM for that, these guys as a whole appeal to so many and probably for different reasons/aspects of them and really none of it is "wrong." Not really any reason it's wrong for someone to prefer them creepy, nor is it wrong to prefer them on the cuter side... but it needs to be understood and ok that if it leans too far to one of those sides (or some other side entirely) it's going to be a let down for some people but it's not wrong of them to feel that way... Quote:
Quote:
Don't call me a "hater" for not likely their model facial choices and I won't refer those who are in love with it as "screen humpers." Quote:
|
Ironically enough if you look at the PD Turtles and then refer to Zulli's "monstrous" versions from Mirage Vol.1 you can see a huge resemblance in both. I even think that when the creative team behind the new look was studying reference materials they more than likely ran into Zulli's work and it became the inspiration for their designs. He even went as far as putting human lips on them at times.
|
I just think they aren't designed that great. They're less turtles mutated into humanoid forms and more human/turtle hybrids.
Like someone else said, it's not just the face. I hate the lack of actual plastron and it's just sculpted conveniently into the shape of muscular physique leading down to the v line towards the groin. The lack of a connection from plastron to shell and the shells look like they're just glued to their backs and in some images look like they're going to fall off (Don had a pic that REALLY looked like the shell wasn't connected from the shoulder blade area of his back upwards. And then their shells almost reach the top of their heads. There's just a lot "not turtle" about the design to me. Turtle/human hybrids. |
Quote:
|
They may not target every demographic equally, but I don't think anyone selling anything would try to "fend off" anyone.
EDIT: I see the turtle's appearance like, Turtle -----|----- Human Is there only one correct position of that slider? Because when fan art pushes that slider to left, people around here eat it up. |
Making the turtles cute and cuddly (a la Nickelodeon) is a quick and easy way to endear audiences to them. I admit to being a bit shocked by these new 'ugly' turtles when I first saw the pictures / trailers, but I quite like the idea that they are monstrous in appearance, as they would be to us humans if this was real life. In addition, it means that to win over audiences they will need to appeal to a deeper aspect of us, beyond the slightly superficial attraction to 'cuteness'. Strong characterisation, emotive CGI animation etc. If handled well, the ugliness should cease to be a factor. I stress the word 'if'..... :)
|
Well, technically I meant in terms of saving the Turtles from fangirls... lol Although trying to target a demographic specifically would be a crying shame and would have to say/agree that there, at least so far hints, is a fairly clear lack of much estrogen on the design team. Dunno if they'd be doing it on purpose necessarily, but maybe it's just very limited minds who don't have the ability to do anything else... Get some more women involved and some might end up surprised by a "Michael Bay film" for once. :P (Personally the overused formula for making movies that 20-year-old guys will go see is getting kind of stale out of Hollywood.)
|
There are so many Tmnt 2k14 fangirls on Tumblr, that it's impossible to count them all lol
|
Quote:
There is a cuteness factor that the Nick cartoon wields deftly. It doesn't take long on tumblr see that. From what I'm hearing here, it's not present in this movie. But I don't see either look as cute or ugly... |
Quote:
|
I think this brings up an interesting point that there's a certain divide with fans. To many people who like the Fred Wolf show think the movie should be light and outlandish whereas those who skewer more Mirage end would prefer a dark and realistic movie.
I don't think it's impossible to strike a balance that pleases everyone. Certainly the best example is the 1990 movie and to this day it still baffles me that when it comes to how to approach a movie they've ignored the one movie undeniably worked. I think they've gone about striking the balance in their own "Michael bay" way and failed hence why no one can really make up their minds what this movie is. The designs are just a sign of that, I don't think anyone purposefully set out to make them ugly but they've taken what is a fine idea that mutated turtles wouldn't be ultra cute and cuddly but gone for overly hulking monster look but with friendly human faces. I don't think it crossed their minds this would look weird to people hence Bay-Mikey's nose was front and center all the initial promo. That's been the process throughout the entire creation of this movie. They've been ultra stoked about something until severe backlash which leaves them confused. They've made changed to please fans - even while shooting on set and yet I don't think they've ever gotten why these approaches were wrong to begin with - hence why I have little faith they can fix them. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:03 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.