The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Do you consider the Archie TMNT series obscure to the fandom? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=48213)

CyberCubed 07-14-2014 10:31 PM

Do you consider the Archie TMNT series obscure to the fandom?
 
Back in the 90's the Archie comics were the best selling TMNT comics and went on for nearly a decade. However that was over 20 years ago, and anyone who wasn't a kid in the early 90's wouldn't have known about this series until years later.

Do you consider the Archie TMNT comics obscure to the fandom? Everyone knows about the 3 cartoons, the movies, the original Mirage comics and now the current IDW series.

But the Archie TMNT series, outside of us old-school 90's fans who grew up with it, tends to be the most overlooked or forgotten TMNT series. Even Next Mutation as disliked as it is is more often mentioned. Even with IDW reprinting the series in trades it seems like many people aren't buying the volumes.

What do you think?

Metropoliskid41 07-14-2014 10:59 PM

Comics will always loose, especially with the current Diamond distribution system, in a battle of exposure with TV or movies. Look at all of these box office successes that Marvel studios is having, they don't even come close to seeing even half of the people that went and saw Avengers buying an Avengers comics. Almost every one in the US has access to a television set, not everyone out there has a local comic shop. I think I only have 2 comic shops within a 75 mile radius of me.

So as far as a "forgotten" part of the franchise, I honestly think if such a thing exists, that would have to be the Image run. It certainly has its fans and followers, but it is so much different than everything else, I think it has been forgotten or escaped the eye of the general TMNT public. Archie spun out of the OT, and while it clearly went in its own unique direction and became its own entity, it still was similar in look to the OT. So it will always have that tie-in with fans. The current reprints help. Obviously the original Mirage run cannot be forgotten. That leaves Image, a volume that hasn't been collected and readily available (and with all of the creator owned characters that appeared in it, I don't know how complete IDW's planned collecting of this series will be) I don't know when people will be able to get their hands on it. The single issues themselves will cost you an arm and a leg. With no widespread exposure like a movie or TV show that ties into or portrays the Image run, and limited availability, I think it suffers (or is most likely to suffer) from being overlooked or forgotten if that is an issue at all with any of the faucets of the tmnt franchise.

I don't necessarily agree that any part of the TMNT franchise suffers from this problem, but if it did I would think that the Image run would be the most likely victim.

Newton Gimmick 07-14-2014 11:55 PM

Image is very obscure to most. Perhaps the most.

Then again, the RPG stuff may be the most obscure. But I guess that's not necessarily the same thing.

Honestly, IDW is probably more obscure than the Archie stuff on pure numbers alone. The comic market is way smaller these days. Archie had a run in the heyday of comics and is being reprinted now. Purely on numbers, Archie probably has seen more eyeballs.

But yeah, the Archie stuff is definitely one of the more obscure parts of the brand. Plenty of people who would consider themselves pretty hardcore TMNT fans, have likely never read an issue or more than one or two.

But TMNT is a property that has so many threads and vines out there, that you end up with people who connected to various little things and not others. Archie is more available now than it has been in 20 years or so, but it's exposure is still going to be limited. 90% of the fandom is generated on the current cartoon (during any given period) and everything else is slicing up that last 10%. Archie had a bigger bite in the 90s, but they're still part of the same 10% they've always been. They just occupy less of it.

wilddiverse 07-15-2014 12:03 AM

Or Dreamwave? UK Hero Turtles? Newspaper comic strip? There's plenty more obscure than the Archie series...

And honestly who the hell is "the fandom"? How is that vague term broken down and measured to know what "the fandom" is aware of?

Newton Gimmick 07-15-2014 12:06 AM

Oh yeah, let's not forget Volume 4. That may be more obscure than the Image stuff.

Plenty of obscurity to go around!

Joey Kamikaze 07-15-2014 12:42 AM

I'd say the TMNTA-only stuff is pretty obscure in the mainstream. If you're talking Turtles with the average person, there's a way better chance s/he is going to know Shredder and Krang than Null and Maligna. Speaking from personal experience, I only ever met a couple other people who read TMNTA, and that was in elementary school. But I grew up in a small town so it could be a matter of sample size.

Volume one of the Mirage book and the cartoons, games and movies seem the most well-known versions of the Turtles. Everything from Mirage vol 2 onward and the other comics seem more obscure, yeah, at least if you're talking the population at large. If you're talking TMNT fans specifically, I think TMNTA has been mostly ignored by anyone who didn't grow up reading it, but there are obviously plenty of die-hards if the letter column in IDW and the many calls for "The Forever War" are any indication.

Metropoliskid41 07-15-2014 05:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wilddiverse (Post 1303568)
Or Dreamwave? UK Hero Turtles? Newspaper comic strip? There's plenty more obscure than the Archie series...

And honestly who the hell is "the fandom"? How is that vague term broken down and measured to know what "the fandom" is aware of?

Definitely the Newspaper strip, there is not a whole lot of information out there on it. I'm really hoping IDW collects it and releases it like they have with the Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman newspaper strips.

pingclang 07-15-2014 06:45 AM

I wouldnt call it obscure. A lot of info on it is out there and people still reference it.If it was obscure it wouldnt be nearly as easy to find out about. It is sad not as many folks like it. Ive only read up to the idw trades and man is it good.

CyberCubed 07-15-2014 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wilddiverse (Post 1303568)
Or Dreamwave? UK Hero Turtles? Newspaper comic strip? There's plenty more obscure than the Archie series...

And honestly who the hell is "the fandom"? How is that vague term broken down and measured to know what "the fandom" is aware of?

That stuff is all minor to begin with though. I'm talking about an aspect of the TMNT franchise that was huge and went on for nearly a decade. It seems the only people who ever talk about Archie is those of us 90's kids who grew up with it. Kids who got into the TMNT franchise later on or simply never got the comic in the 90's don't really seem to care about it much.

I honestly wonder how much IDW's Archie trades are selling.

TigerClaw 07-15-2014 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1303516)
Back in the 90's the Archie comics were the best selling TMNT comics and went on for nearly a decade. However that was over 20 years ago, and anyone who wasn't a kid in the early 90's wouldn't have known about this series until years later.

Do you consider the Archie TMNT comics obscure to the fandom? Everyone knows about the 3 cartoons, the movies, the original Mirage comics and now the current IDW series.

But the Archie TMNT series, outside of us old-school 90's fans who grew up with it, tends to be the most overlooked or forgotten TMNT series. Even Next Mutation as disliked as it is is more often mentioned. Even with IDW reprinting the series in trades it seems like many people aren't buying the volumes.

What do you think?

I don't think the Archies TMNT Comics were obscured, They were very well thought out.

It was loosely based on the animated series, But going a different direction.

I identify with this comic series more then the original black and white ones from Mirage.

Powder 07-15-2014 11:38 AM

You definitely don't understand the point of this thread.

TigerClaw 07-15-2014 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1303822)
You definitely don't understand the point of this thread.

well, the point of the thread was, is the comic obscured to the fandom?

And me being a part of it, Its not to me. :)

miru 07-15-2014 06:29 PM

Yeah, I feel it's pretty obscure. Probably the second most obscure major TMNT incarnation to Image. It's mostly known outside the fandom because of Armaggon, Ninjara, and most of the Mutanimals (except those two Captain Planet rejects).

TigerClaw 07-15-2014 07:09 PM

I remembered the Archies Series comic because, It was the comic that first introduced us to Mondo Gecko before the cartoon did.

MikeandRaph87 07-15-2014 07:18 PM

No, its a much beloved comic of 80s' and 90s' kids and got many of us such as myself into comics. Its rare that its looked too for inspiration especially as time passes but DW's seven issue run is the obscure one since it barely got off the ground before the publisher fell into bankruptcy. Its not loved like Archie or controversial and disliked such as Image. Its just there.

Newton Gimmick 07-15-2014 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TigerClaw (Post 1303791)
I don't think the Archies TMNT Comics were obscured, They were very well thought out.

http://i61.tinypic.com/2lt4l7b.jpg

Jester 07-15-2014 10:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Newton Gimmick (Post 1304209)

http://annscookbook.com/wp-content/u...I_Love_You.gif

MikeandRaph87 07-15-2014 10:07 PM

http://assets.diylol.com/hfs/6b6/205...1329008464.jpg

Bry 07-15-2014 11:34 PM

Well, there are lots of levels of "obscure", especially in this fandom. I think a lot of current fans grew up with that comic (and personally speaking, issue 13 really helped get me hooked for life), but I think most non-Mirage comic series will be easily overshadowed by the mainstream versions like the cartoons and the movies. Most of the general public probably aren't even aware it existed... but then again, it's very possible that much of the general public aren't aware the Mirage comics existed either - or much of anything past the '87 cartoon and original movies that made up "Turtlemania", really.

TMNTA it ran for 72 issues over 7 years. That's nothing to scoff at. It had a good run and I think it made an impact - not the biggest, but not the smallest. Respectable.

Darthknuxward 08-07-2014 09:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1303776)
That stuff is all minor to begin with though. I'm talking about an aspect of the TMNT franchise that was huge and went on for nearly a decade. It seems the only people who ever talk about Archie is those of us 90's kids who grew up with it. Kids who got into the TMNT franchise later on or simply never got the comic in the 90's don't really seem to care about it much.

I honestly wonder how much IDW's Archie trades are selling.

I wasn't old enough to grow up with it and it's one of my favorite TMNT universes.

MogwaiNinja89 08-10-2014 03:42 PM

I'd say it's obscure in the way you don't see it mentioned often. I hear Image mentioned more than Archie.

Andrew NDB 08-12-2014 11:55 AM

Maybe it's not talked about as much as other universes (maybe because it's not that unique and sort of gets lumped in with the Fred Wolf stuff) but the Archie series was selling 150,000 copies month in, month out for a long time... many times more than the sort of numbers that Mirage, Dreamwave, or IDW ever pulled.

Tazi 08-12-2014 12:11 PM

Dunno, so far it seemd to me that the major part of people who have ever read TMNT were the readers of Archie...
Archie got into a lot of countries thanks to the FW series. Unfortunately, Mirage not. :ohwell:

CyberCubed 08-12-2014 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1330814)
Maybe it's not talked about as much as other universes (maybe because it's not that unique and sort of gets lumped in with the Fred Wolf stuff) but the Archie series was selling 150,000 copies month in, month out for a long time... many times more than the sort of numbers that Mirage, Dreamwave, or IDW ever pulled.

True but that's for 90's era fans. Seems like people who got into TMNT during the 2000's never heard of Archie.

Andrew NDB 08-12-2014 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1330838)
True but that's for 90's era fans. Seems like people who got into TMNT during the 2000's never heard of Archie.

Why would they?

zodiac brave 08-12-2014 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1330845)
Why would they?

if they got really into the franchise, they might dig deeper into it.

you know, to further explore the thing they like?

tfranzone 08-18-2014 12:45 PM

like you stated, as a kid born in the 80s/grew up in the 90s... i always enjoyed the archie tmnt adventures series.. but it def. isnt mentioned as much as other.

But even with people who are fans of it..In terms of sales, they dont do themselves any favors,IMO. I havent bought the idw trades bc price wise they arent too accomodating. You get like 3-5 issues for $15 a trade.. and at 70+ issues, im not going to spend that kind of money for them. They arent even reprinted that nicely (but thats secondary to price for me). its over $250 in trades to collect them and they would probably be at like 20 volumes.. since 8 being released this week only covers like up to issue number 30 or so.

My hope is that IDW makes some sort of omnibus or at least deluxe versions of these collecting like 10-15 issues at a time for something like $25 a piece. Maybe they'd sell more. I know I'd be more willing to spring for that. But, maybe they will never do this if they think the popularity is already low. I guess just as sometimes you can easily capitalize on a franchise, there also has to be installments that dont do well sales wise due to the amount of other things to put your fandom and money towards.

Panda_Kahn_fan 08-19-2014 12:14 AM

I always did love the Archie characters, and how serious it was comapred to the OT. If the Ot had taken itself this seriously pre-red sky, I would look back on it with far more than fond nostalgia! I really don't think it's obscure to older TMNT fans! :)

neatoman 08-19-2014 06:44 AM

Obscure? Well the cartoon is more well known but TV shows and movies will always be more easily accessible to a large audience anyway.

In the actual fandom, like the people who are really into TMNT and want their fix, it's not obscure because it's not that hard to come by. And most of the people who grew up on the cartoons (the Fred Wolf kids are about 26-36 now and the 4Kids kids are teenagers or older now, 13-22 I'd say) most likely didn't bother check out much else in the franchise after they grew up.

TigerClaw 08-19-2014 07:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1335856)
Obscure? Well the cartoon is more well known but TV shows and movies will always be more easily accessible to a large audience anyway.

In the actual fandom, like the people who are really into TMNT and want their fix, it's not obscure because it's not that hard to come by. And most of the people who grew up on the cartoons (the Fred Wolf kids are about 26-36 now and the 4Kids kids are teenagers or older now, 13-22 I'd say) most likely didn't bother check out much else in the franchise after they grew up.

Let's not forget the fans who are now in there 40s, I was only 14 years old when the Fred Wolf debut in 1987.

neatoman 08-19-2014 07:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TigerClaw (Post 1335868)
Let's not forget the fans who are now in there 40s, I was only 14 years old when the Fred Wolf debut in 1987.

Huh, So am I to assume you started with the Mirage comics then?

TigerClaw 08-19-2014 07:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1335871)
Huh, So am I to assume you started with the Mirage comics then?

Well, I got into it via the Fred Wolf series, Then started reading the Archies Series comics, when I found them in a comic book section at Walgreens.

I tried to read the Mirage Comics, But wasn't too into them, Because they weren't like the Archies series comics, I was very picky.

I have fond memories reading the Archies Series comics because, They were close to the cartoon, Yet go in a separate direction, And I loved how they did the Characters better then the Cartoon did.

neatoman 08-19-2014 07:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TigerClaw (Post 1335882)
Well, I got into it via the Fred Wolf series, Then started Reading the Archies Series comics when I found them in a comic book section at Walgreens.

I tried to read the Mirage Comics, But wasn't too into them, Because they weren't like the Archies series comics, I was very picky.

What was it about the the Fred Wolf cartoon that appealed to you? I did not watch any of the the Fred Wolf cartoon until I was about 14 myself and found it to be a little too much about about pizza and puns rather than anything substantial like story, character development or production values.

TigerClaw 08-19-2014 08:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1335887)
What was it about the the Fred Wolf cartoon that appealed to you? I did not watch any of the the Fred Wolf cartoon until I was about 14 myself and found it to be a little too much about about pizza and puns rather than anything substantial like story, character development or production values.

I enjoyed the Fred Wolf cartoon cause it was fun, When I read the comics that were loosely based on it, It told stories and had character development that the series couldn't do in a half hour.

For example, Mondo Gecko was a lot more developed as a character in the Comics, Then he was on the animated series, Who only appeared on 2 episodes.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:36 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.