![]() |
What do you do when your comic collection grows too large?
So about a year ago I decided to switch over to IDW's trades so I sold all the single IDW issues on ebay and then re-bought the series through the trade collections. I don't regret it because IDW's trades are pretty good and its easier to store the books than the single issues.
However I still have all my old Mirage and Archie issues, and since I have 95% of all the comics released...my collection is fairly large. I have been buying the collections of the old Mirage books, and was considering getting rid of the old single issues, but I'm not sure. Is there sentimental value in keeping old comics? The old Mirage issues paper feels like the ink almost rubs off on your hands, and the paper quality has deteriorated over 25 years. Meanwhile IDW collects all the same issues (albeit some only in color), and they're easier to store. What do you do, for TMNT or otherwise when your comic collection grows too large? |
Get a bigger place to live :D
|
I've been contemplating this too. I too wonder if I should just keep the trades of the Mirage collected stuff and stay with the single issues after the collected book 7 trade. Then I've been dumping the access junk from my comic book hey days, like Wizard magazine, Hero Illustrated, Overstreet Fan mag, Cinescape mag. I mean the stuff is old now and it has no purpose. So I've been recycling these mags. Previews catalogs as well. Has anyone else done this too? Its just you can't hang on to that stuff and let anything comic book related almost consume your life. You have to draw the line. Comics stores are also so stingy now about buying peoples collections.
|
I think a focused collection is the answer. In the '80s/'90s, I tried to collect every single TMNT comic book appearance. Now I've limited it to mirage vol. 1, 2 and 4, and IDW Eastman covers only, along with some one-shots like Turtlemania and Micro-Series.
I do see the allure in owning the original issues. There is just something about owning the first printing. For TMNT volume 1, I feel the series isn't complete unless the reprints are all in the collection too. This is because most of the volume 1 reprints have new covers and new backup stories. To me, the collected volumes are very cool, but you can't get the original experience unless you read the original comics in all their ink-rubbing-off-on-your-fingers glory. |
I'm preparing to move in a few months so I finally made it a point to catalog my entire comic collection. Total collection of floppies only runs just over 2k, with another 300+ in trades and graphic novels.
Not all of those are coming with me when I relocate. Basically anything that isn't an ongoing or TMNT related is going to have to find a new home, and soon. I'm considering selling what I can and then donating the rest. You can apparently even donate comics to the Troops. One thing that I really hope I don't have to do is toss them out or recycle them, that'd just break my heart. |
I stack a few of them together and start slapping people with them so that they can try to guess how many issues I have
|
I had to move most of everything I own into storage a few years ago, comics and otherwise. Not the ideal solution by any means, but I used to work there so at least I get an okay rate. Apparently lots of people go that route with their collections, but you need to make sure they're packed well and it's kind of a hassle to check in on your stuff periodically.
I'm planning on getting at least most of my comics out of storage soon, though. I prefer to keep them close by. |
Quote:
|
Believe me dude, it's very easy to amass a large comic collection in a matter of a couple years.
I've been thinking of downsizing my collection due to having several long boxes of non-Turtle comics. |
Quote:
Counting only the major stuff, what got me that far was: Spoiler:
That's not bothering to list various mini-series and Marvel books I ended up owning but don't really "collect" as such. Oh, and the "adult" comics. There's a couple hundred of those in there, too. It all adds up really quick. It's super easy to find yourself with thousands of books before you know it when you get The Frenzy. I didn't buy anything for a couple years from about 1996 to 2001, and once I got back into DC again, I started reading everything, especially when Infinite Crisis and Final Crisis were about to hit. Oh, man, forget about it, I was reading every single book they put out, for a while. By the by, never, ever let anyone try and tell you that there's ANY other way to read "Infinite Crisis" besides as a giant stack of 90-100 interconnected issues spanning the entire DC line. That is the "Proper" way to experience it, and oh my GOD, is it glorious. :lol: I only quit when we took a big financial hit a few years ago. I have every intention of picking up again one of these days, and it'll probably be like 2002 all over again, getting caught up with all that I missed. It didn't hurt that I didn't have any internet for a lot of that time period, so I had a lot of time to actually read everything I bought, and reading more in turn always led to buying more, because I'd constantly find out about stuff I missed. Sometimes I'd read about something like Teen Titans "The Judas Contract" in Wizard, and just run out the same day to pick up the back issues. I miss it. But yeah, I think I started "serious" collecting in 2001, already owning about 500+ issues of Superman, Batman, TMNT and Sonic books, but I hit 2,000 inside a few months. Those $5 grab bags get ya, man. :lol: "That one might have that last issue of Secret Wars I need! Ahh, darn, it's full of Wonder Man." :P |
I have a small, inexpensive storage bin where I keep a longbox of TMNT stuff and other odds and ends. My problem is that I own too many trade paperbacks. I buy two copies of a certain Marvel series every month (one to read, one to save) but only because that series relaunched this year. My collection of floppies is much, much smaller than my volume of trade paperbacks.
I will probably use eBay or Amazon soon to whittle my collection down; I've just been lazy about it recently. |
Oh man, if only I had to worry about JUST having Turtles comics... I have everything Superman (all titles)/Flash/Green Lantern thats come out since 1980... All the Turtles books, at least one printing each (more of each IDW) [no Image #23 YET], a ton of HCs, trades and the like... Right now my old room at my parents is still full of books, about 20 long boxes, 6 or 8 short boxes and at least half a dozen random other types of boxes that would safely hold comics... Then where I'm staying right now I have 1 long box, four short boxes, 8 diamond boxes with the comics standing up in them, bagged; about 10 medium priority boxes full (a month of books in each, roughly); and then some of those neat plastic totes from walmart that hold comics/hcs/trades/novels nicely... There there are at least three different stacks of oversized books hanging out and a small stack next to the bed that needs to be read. I've never counted, but I'd guess somewhere around 10K comics now, and I seriously need to sort them and reorganize. The only collection thats all together is Turtles and I'm sure there's a few books scattered throughout the long boxes that needs to be moved.
Its difficult to want to part with them... Like others above have said, it doesn't take long to get stacked up... Plus I have a medical condition that limits my energy and reading doesn't take a lot of energy so I do a lot of it. |
Quote:
How often do you serious re-read your collection? I can't imagine ever going back to 10,000 comics. |
I sell off single issues for trades with everything but Mirage, which I don't mind keeping a singles collection of.
I am starting to hit the point where I have too many trades, but as I'm starting grad school next year, they're staying boxed up with the 'rents for now. I'll have to deal with them somehow or sell them off when I'm more permanently settled. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Ms Marvel Unwritten Chew Atomic Robo Hawkeye Lumberjanes Buffy the Vampire Slayer Saga Sex Criminals Mouse Guard And those are just the ongoings |
After amassing a collection of thousands of comics over the course of 20+ years, I decided a few years ago to limit myself to completing runs of TMNT (vol 1, 2 and 4 with all variants and reprints), Incredible Hulk #1-474, and the Amazing Spider-man #1-441. I also allow myself 1 long box of "random other stuff".
I've been in the process of "trimming the fat", and putting the money back into my focused runs. Because of this, I just recently completed all 3 runs sans Amazing Spider-man #1 and Incredible Hulk #1. Those are just way out of my league. So I trimmed my collection by about half, from 12 long boxes to 6 long boxes. I've thought about limiting my Spider-man and Hulk collections to only Silver Age + keys to free even more space, but I haven't gone there yet. |
Quote:
And there's absolutely zero chance I'd get back anywhere near what I paid into it, anyways, because comics depreciate super fast and almost nothing I own is rare or expensive. I'd honestly be lucky to get a buck or two a book, which sounds like a lot, but considering I most likely spent two to three times that much, it doesn't justify it to me. Selling it piecemeal would take centuries, and selling it as a lot would be impossible (and I'd get raped, probably a quarter a book if I was lucky). Just not interested in ever getting rid of 'em. Even my wife agrees that even if we were super hard-up it would be a real shame to get rid of all that stuff after we went through so much time getting it. The depression and feeling of loss would be greater than money could fix. It's pretty much never even been an option. I mean, lots of people have money, but how many people have that many F'n comics? |
Trades. Sold off my entire run except my #1 print. Every fan should own one!
|
I'm glad I never got into Marvel or DC comics, I don't know what I would do with piles and piles of comics littering my closet or bedroom or whereever.
|
I don't have anywhere near the amount that some are mentioning but I have been thinking of selling off a lot of stuff that I don't feel like I need to keep in order to use the money for turtles related stuff Id want. Problem is you don't really get a lot for reselling comics typically. Especially newer ones. I'd like to limit my collecting to only turtles and deadpool but it's tougher than it sounds. For me at least.
|
What about comics unlikely to be released as trades, like Las Tortugas Ninjas?
|
Until recently I had 12 long boxes full of comics and more trades than I had bookshelves to store them all.
I decided that if I hadn't read or even looked at the books in years then I wasn't getting any use out of them and to just let them go. I sold a few runs that were worth the effort on eBay (like a complete Flynn/Yardley Sonic the Hedgehog run up through World's Collide) but the majority were 90s comics and were subsequently worth less than toilet paper. I donated nearly all of them to a local comic shop, a local library and a friend of a friend who specifically wanted kids comics to give to his son. And... I don't miss any of them. They took up tons of space, were a pain to move, grew and grew and grew, but now that they're gone I don't feel any loss. They were just STUFF that I accumulated because I had a collector's mentality and I've been trying to eliminate that. I kept all my TMNT comics, of course, because I use them for reference for my site and I enjoy rereading them on a regular basis. Kept a few runs that I also enjoy rereading, things like Jason Aaron's Ghost Rider and Flynn's Mega Man and Burnham's Ghostbusters. Got it down to 4 long boxes and even those are mostly only half full. |
Quote:
In all seriousness, though, you're missing out, man. No movie or cartoon is ever going to be able to do as good a job with Batman or Superman or any of them as the books do. At best they're just streamlined, but even the best adaptations I've seen far fall short of the originals. There just isn't any comparison. The Batman and Justice League stuff comes closest, but it's still not the same, or anywhere near as good. |
Quote:
... OH wait... |
I have a room pretty much dedicated to comics, anime, toys/collectibles, etc. That's my solution. Yet it still spills out into other parts of the house.
|
Quote:
Out of 75 years of Batman comics, how much of it is relevant? The comics have even rebooted countless times, the older stories are too cheesy and the newer stuff suffers from bad plotlines and characters constantly changing depending on who the writing team is. Does Batman really need 4 Robin's, especially with two of them dying and coming back to life? The cartoons gave us Dick and Tim, and that's all you really need. Superman:TAS and Justice League covered 75 years of Superman while doing the good parts and leaving out all the nonsense. TMNT is the only exception to this as the cartoons do their own thing from Mirage or IDW, which is why I had to get into the comics in the 90's when all I read was Archie at the time. |
None of that's really true at all, though. You don't know what's good or bad from Batman unless you read it, and the best stories like Killing Joke and Death in the Family have zero chance of ever being adapted into anything good because they're too dark. And very few of Superman's adaptations have matched the best of the comics. As good as that entire cartoon series was, it's still not as good as even *just* the two years where John Byrne and Marv Wolfman were writing it. Only "Public Enemies" really came close to matching the books, and even then, it wasn't "better" so much as just shorter. Too short, really, in that there were quite a few important parts the movie left out because they weren't immediately relevant to *that* story, but played out in a big way later in the comics. And don't even get me started on the "Death of Superman" cartoon, the First and Worst of the DC animated features. They really butchered that one to hell. Not even "streamlined", just flat-out ruined it, because the storyline was too big for a 90-minute cartoon.
And that's essentially the problem. There's too much story in comics for them to be whittled down into bite-sized chunks without losing a ton of what makes the stories work on more than a superficial level. The nature of comics is telling stories that play out over years, with inter-connecting plot threads, character arcs, and that's what separates them from every other form of storytelling. You can take the basic story, strip it down to the bare bones, repackage it, and say it's just as good, but it's not. It's like saying Easy Mac is just as good, or better, than making Kraft Mac N Cheese the "hard" way. It's not as good, and it's not the same thing, it just looks like it on the surface. Not that the cartoons etc. are "bad" - lots of 'em are pretty good - but I've yet to see any that are *preferable* to the source material. There will never be a Batman story in film or animation that has the emotional impact of Killing Joke or Death in the Family. It is impossible for that to happen. They're hamstrung by the need to keep things brief and not too "deep" or "dark". So often, the "characters" aren't even characters, they're action figures. It's just a completely different kind of storytelling. And you simply can't "get it" if you're not involved in it. A lot of the "nonsense" that gets cut is actually a lot better than what they actually bother to adapt, believe it or not. Then again, you wouldn't know. |
I second the idea that more people should read superhero comics. They're really fun!
Well, sometimes they're terrible and frustrating. But then you find another that's fun and all is forgiven. |
That really is the way of it, isn't it?
No matter how craptastic they get, something will always pull you back in. Superhero comics are a hell of a drug. |
Quote:
I don't wanna bitch about it much, but really... there are a lot of cool stuff out there, not just the big two publishers, and I'd wish people get into other stuff then Hulks in all the colors of the rainbow. |
Quote:
Would you believe... I actually understood every bit of it? :lol: That right there, is proof positive that a person reads too many f*cking comics. "If you understand exactly what Grant Morrison is trying to say in his work, without needing either multiple read-throughs OR a wiki to help you understand it... and further, actually LIKE it... then you have the Meta-Gene. Your super-power is the ability to make sense of esoteric acid-flashbacks masquerading as super-hero stories." :lol: I really liked it. That's so messed up. I don't even see how anyone else could even finish it. But I really liked it. Tazi: A big issue there is, the entire medium was more or less created for super-hero stories, and though it got away from it briefly a few times, it always comes back to that and always will. You can get "other" kinds of stories anywhere, but super-heroes - until fairly recently - were more or less "only" for comic books, and comic books were "only" for super-heroes. And let's face it: Nobody's ever going to come up with another character to eclipse Batman, Superman, etc. The closest anyone ever comes, is an "original" character that's still very heavily influenced by those iconic ones, because everyone's already conditioned to think, "Okay, iconic do-gooder guy is this brand's 'Superman', their brooding loner is their 'Batman'..." etc. etc. The archetypes have already been established, so it's like, "Well, I could read this book that's about a character sorta like Batman... or, I could just read Batman." It's almost impossible to create new characters in comics anymore that can make a lasting impact, we already have tons of good ones. And it's tough to do anything "new" and "different" in a niche genre like comic books, anyway, where people are very specific about what they like and dislike. People buy super-heroes, so they get more of them. And again, that's mostly because you can find romance, crime, drama or western stories literally everywhere. Until recently, if you wanted to see one guy punch another guy into the sun, you'd only get that in comics. Can't blame 'em for sticking with what brought everyone to the dance, y'know? |
We're glad you're realizing that now, Leo.
Because this entire forum has been an intervention. And recognizing you have a problem is the first step towards overcoming it. :D |
Quote:
I think the reason I'm drawn to superhero comics, though, is the same reason I'm drawn to certain movie genres, even though I'm a total literary snob when it comes to prose reading (I seriously never touch genre). They're so ingrained in into the formation of those mediums there's a pleasure in the iconography, whether it's being completely played into or subverted. I really like Final Crisis. I believe I had to have a Wiki handy for portions, but I'd just read all four of the Fourth World omnibuses before picking it up, which helped immensely. Those Superman Beyond issues are the bee's knees. The bee's knees, you guys. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Also, I added some stuff replying to Tazi to that earlier post, since people said more stuff since then. |
I stopped buying comics around 2003. The prices were getting out of control, especially when it only takes me 5 minutes to read most of them
I bought myself a large tablet and now obtain my comics through a couple of websites. Id never buy another comic again. Reading on a tablet is fantastic. |
Digital comics are a no-go for me. I can't get over reading a comic on an electric device. I downloaded IDW's app for the sample issues (issue 1 was free as was the Don micro), and while its competently uploaded....I just can't read a comic on a phone or ipad or whatever.
It's just wrong. I need to feel the paper in my hands. |
Quote:
|
100% agreed.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:56 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.