The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   If Shredder was played by Eric Sachs instead... (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=48812)

The True Shredder 08-11-2014 02:24 AM

If Shredder was played by Eric Sachs instead...
 
Honestly I wouldn't mind it. In fact I would look at movie with better eyes IF they had the True Shredder to be at the end of the movie. Maybe when Eric Sachs is defeated as Shredder than we see a glimpse of the True Shredder and says along the lines of "You failed me. Now it is time for the One True Shredder to reveal himself". End movie something of that nature. Hell I would forgive the whole movie if they decided to go with thatinstead of what they went for. Than people would at least be excited about that in the sequel. Or does it run much deeper than that? Your thoughts?

Midnight Mutant 08-11-2014 02:34 AM

I've always been down for Sacks being A Shredder, but not THE Shredder.
If he'd been inspired by Saki either from a personal encounter or from a legend of the Shredder. It's not uncommon for villains to get inspired by something artistic or diabolical.

The plan in the movie felt like a Sacks plan, not really an Oroku Saki plan, so he didn't feel like he had a need to be in this movie.

I'm even down for the history of Sacks being Saki's student and maybe Saki does his thing in Japan and Sacks does his thing in New York. That could work too, it could give a reason for Saki to need or want to come to NY.

The movie should have led up to Shredder being in the sequel and then Sacks could shine, but not have to be in another movie.

Xiewin 08-11-2014 02:35 AM

I wouldn't have mind it either, as long as it would have made the movie a whole lot better. Too bad they already butchered up the whole thing only to make Shredder an asian character.

Midnight Mutant 08-11-2014 02:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xiewin (Post 1329352)
I wouldn't have mind it either, as long as it would have made the movie a whole lot better. Too bad they already butchered up the whole thing only to make Shredder an asian character.

A backlash of the backlash.

Jester 08-11-2014 02:41 AM

I wish they'd have just used the man that was Oroku Saki and maybe used Baxter in the Sacks role. I mean, Baxter's back story in the Mirage books was a scientist who held the city hostage with his Mousers. Why not have him develop the gas and the antidote?

The True Shredder 08-11-2014 02:54 AM

Good points
 
I would have liked Baxter to fit the role instead of Eric Sachs. But I'm talking about way into production. Like too late for that. At least they could have done that. Maybe Eric Sachs being Modern Shredder who has to rely on the suit more thanmartial arts. And Orasaki can bethe True Traditional Shredder who relies on martial arts heavily and maybe just maybe they disagree on something and both turn against each other causing NYC to be a war zone between the Shredder. That would totally been awesome. Yeah I wanted the Shredder Wars to happen. Sue me. xD

Jester 08-11-2014 02:59 AM

Yeah, I guess I just wish this movie hadn't been so set on Sachs as Shredder early on. The whole change is pointless from day one, when there are in universe characters who could have done just as well.

The True Shredder 08-11-2014 03:20 AM

Agreed
 
They should have at least incorporated other in universe villains. But if they could have saved one thing from what they would originally were going to do with Sachs than at least build up some hype for the next one not just defeat the True Shredder right off the bat. It just made the ending anti climatic for the sequel like "Okay.The Shredder is defeated. Now what?" Sort of feel. Just disappointed to say the least.

Tora 08-11-2014 06:05 PM

If they went White Shredder I would have liked Sacks to have been raised in Japan and become obsessed with ancient Japanese culture. As a young boy he would become inspired by the stories of the Foot Clan and the Saki family because they once ruled over Japan. When he became older he would become very rich and one point find Shredder's ancient armor an use it as a template to build a robotic armor. The armor is so that he could take on anyone who opposed him while his infinite wealth would pay off the cop and politicians as he grows to power.

His goal is to build a powerful empire just like his idol Oroku.

SwiftNinjaFox 08-11-2014 06:45 PM

I thought it was utterly ridiculous to alter Shredder to be able to cast Bay's buddy Fichtner in the role. When it looked like they'd have Oroku Saki, I was glad, but having seen the film, I think they should have kept Sacks as Shredder only for Saki to arrive at the end reprimanding him for the dishonor he brought the Foot by turning them into terrorists with guns.

Easy lead-in to a more ninja-based turtles vs Foot.

Heck, imagine if Shredder had lost, Saki came in at the end, and sequel went more towards City at War

TurtleTitan97 08-11-2014 06:51 PM

A lot of this films' problems could have been avoided if they just kept Shredder as Oroku Saki in the first place.

Ninjinister 08-11-2014 06:55 PM

I find it weird that some people are still celebrating that we "got an Asian Shredder" when in order to get it we had to suffer a massively disjointed story. Like, yeah, if they were going to adapt, they should have started with it. But as-is the story would have been more cohesive had they stuck with Weeaboo Shredder.

So yeah, we got Shredder in the "right" ethnicity, but it's a small victory at the cost of a massive toll.

scratch 08-11-2014 06:58 PM

I strongly suspect that Sacks will slip into SHREDDER's armor in the sequel. I would not mind that. Shredder has to be wrecked after that ending. mean he WAS the Shredder. Its obvious that it was edited out and re shot because of the backlash from recasting all the Asian characters as white.

nintendo2600 08-11-2014 07:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scratch (Post 1330093)
I strongly suspect that Sacks will slip into SHREDDER's armor in the sequel. I would not mind that. Shredder has to be wrecked after that ending. mean he WAS the Shredder. Its obvious that it was edited out and re shot because of the backlash from recasting all the Asian characters as white.

Oh I think the "Super Shredder" will be what is featured in the second movie as the
Spoiler:
end having him alive with the broken mutagen really leads only in that direction.

nintendo2600 08-11-2014 07:09 PM

Really they should have just called Sachs by the name Stockman. That is how I explained it to my son and it made a lot more sense to him when I did so.

CyberCubed 08-11-2014 07:17 PM

Anyone who wanted white Shredder should hang up their TMNT fan card. Shredder needs to be an Oriental named Oroku Saki.

Ninjinister 08-11-2014 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1330135)
Anyone who wanted white Shredder should hang up their TMNT fan card. Shredder needs to be an Oriental named Oroku Saki.

Except he's also been an alien named Ch'rell. And a Turtle named Raphael. And a woman named Karai. And a living computer virus named Viral. And three mutated Foot Soldiers... and...

Someone who is an actual breathing poop stain on this franchise should not be dictating what people want to see in the series.

I mean did you even see the movie? Jamming Japanese Shredder into the film made it worse.

TheSkeletonMan939 08-11-2014 07:53 PM

Considering how poorly Oroku Saki was inserted into the movie, I think I'd have rather just kept Sacks as Shredder.

If you removed all the Oroku Saki scenes, the film is pretty much the exact same. You'd just assume Sacks is Shredder.

Xiewin 08-11-2014 08:01 PM

TMNT: Shredder Actor Tohoru Masamune Talks Fandom Expectations & Michael Bay's Involvement

http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansit...news/?a=105818

Netkeeper 08-11-2014 08:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninjinister (Post 1330150)
Except he's also been an alien named Ch'rell. And a Turtle named Raphael. And a woman named Karai. And a living computer virus named Viral. And three mutated Foot Soldiers... and...

Even when he was an Utrom, the Shredder was still Oroku Saki. And IIRC, any Shredder to come after Ch'rell was based on that one. Who was still a Japanese dude.

MajorViolence 08-11-2014 09:10 PM

While I feel that fans had every right to be upset about Shredder being whitewashed, if this was the best they could do it would have been far better to just consider that particular battle lost and go with what was best for the story. At least then it would have been a much better film in spite of that racially insensitive decision. Instead what we have is a Shredder who is (technically) Asian, but is a terrible, completely forgettable villain as a result of how poorly he was integrated into the plot.

beeshaw 08-11-2014 09:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MajorViolence (Post 1330236)
While I feel that fans had every right to be upset about Shredder being whitewashed, if this was the best they could do it would have been far better to just consider that particular battle lost and go with what was best for the story. At least then it would have been a much better film in spite of that racially insensitive decision. Instead what we have is a Shredder who is (technically) Asian, but is a terrible, completely forgettable villain as a result of how poorly he was integrated into the plot.

It was too late by the time 'we' got to them. They butchered the rest of the movie to make 'us' happy. Did it help the film at all that he was Japanese?? Nope. It hurt everything around it though. How many other scenes domino-ed onto the cutting room floor? Probably quite a few.

MajorViolence 08-11-2014 09:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beeshaw (Post 1330244)
It was too late by the time 'we' got to them. They butchered the rest of the movie to make 'us' happy. Did it help the film at all that he was Japanese?? Nope. It hurt everything around it though. How many other scenes domino-ed onto the cutting room floor? Probably quite a few.

This is all completely accurate, and it makes me think, like Bry said in a different thread, that it may have been a lot better for the long term of the franchise if the fan outrage had never happened. The Blue Door would have actually been filmed, it would have completely bombed at the box office, and it would just be remembered as a hilarious low point in the turtles' history. Instead, we're now likely to get a string of movies from filmmakers who are going to try desperately to please fans, but really have no idea what it is we truly want out of these films.

Coola Yagami 08-11-2014 09:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The True Shredder (Post 1329349)
Honestly I wouldn't mind it. In fact I would look at movie with better eyes IF they had the True Shredder to be at the end of the movie. Maybe when Eric Sachs is defeated as Shredder than we see a glimpse of the True Shredder and says along the lines of "You failed me. Now it is time for the One True Shredder to reveal himself". End movie something of that nature. Hell I would forgive the whole movie if they decided to go with thatinstead of what they went for. Than people would at least be excited about that in the sequel. Or does it run much deeper than that? Your thoughts?

No... because the this movie was just a (bigger) waste of time and they might as well have just started with the sequel. Would anyone have watched a Batman movie with some clown named the Jester, for the WHOLE movie and then have Joker at the end cameo and say 'now let's really show them how it's done'. No.

beeshaw 08-11-2014 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MajorViolence (Post 1330251)
This is all completely accurate, and it makes me think, like Bry said in a different thread, that it may have been a lot better for the long term of the franchise if the fan outrage had never happened. The Blue Door would have actually been filmed, it would have completely bombed at the box office, and it would just be remembered as a hilarious low point in the turtles' history. Instead, we're now likely to get a string of movies from filmmakers who are going to try desperately to please fans, but really have no idea what it is we truly want out of these films.

Nah. I think they made a mistep with the 'White Shredder', didn't realize that anyone cared until it was too late, TRIED to fix it and we got what we got. Hopefully the sequel is a little more even, they learned that we DO give a ****, and they figure out that if they fix a few things they can make even MORE money.

MajorViolence 08-11-2014 09:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beeshaw (Post 1330270)
Nah. I think they made a mistep with the 'White Shredder', didn't realize that anyone cared until it was too late, TRIED to fix it and we got what we got. Hopefully the sequel is a little more even, they learned that we DO give a ****, and they figure out that if they fix a few things they can make even MORE money.

That's a very optimistic viewpoint, and I wish I could say I gave them that much credit. I hope you turn out to be right.

Coola Yagami 08-11-2014 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by beeshaw (Post 1330270)
Nah. I think they made a mistep with the 'White Shredder', didn't realize that anyone cared until it was too late, TRIED to fix it and we got what we got. Hopefully the sequel is a little more even, they learned that we DO give a ****, and they figure out that if they fix a few things they can make even MORE money.

If a trilogy was planned, they're probably halfway through the script to the sequel now. That's a lot of re-writing they have to do now to coincide with the changes made to this movie.

MajorViolence 08-11-2014 09:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 1330278)
If a trilogy was planned, they're probably halfway through the script to the sequel now. That's a lot of re-writing they have to do now to coincide with the changes made to this movie.

I seriously doubt they have any actual work started, especially since they were working on this movie up to the final moments before release. They hired Fichtner to play Shredder before his role was reduced to Sacks, so we can expect Shredder to make a return, and probably Sacks as well if for no other reason than to take advantage of Fichtner's contract. But I doubt anything more than vague plot ideas for the sequel have been committed to paper at this point.

Leo656 08-12-2014 12:15 AM

Sounds like they gave the majority what they "wanted" as far as a Japanese Shredder, but completely didn't understand the why of it, and thus rendered the entire "fixing" effort a pointless, overly complicated waste.

Sighphi 08-12-2014 01:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MajorViolence (Post 1330251)
This is all completely accurate, and it makes me think, like Bry said in a different thread, that it may have been a lot better for the long term of the franchise if the fan outrage had never happened. The Blue Door would have actually been filmed, it would have completely bombed at the box office, and it would just be remembered as a hilarious low point in the turtles' history. Instead, we're now likely to get a string of movies from filmmakers who are going to try desperately to please fans, but really have no idea what it is we truly want out of these films.

Given what we got made this amount of money i dont think a more cohesive film with white shredder and space turtles would've had a different result in the BO.

It's just about asplosions for the general audience, they dont care about anything else. Nick was probably the one the flinched and demanded the changes because they just got the franchise and didnt want it being hurt for the fans that are actually keeping it alive.

Netkeeper 08-12-2014 01:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1330483)
Sounds like they gave the majority what they "wanted" as far as a Japanese Shredder, but completely didn't understand the why of it, and thus rendered the entire "fixing" effort a pointless, overly complicated waste.

This is exactly what happened, and now people are complaining because they did a bad job when they made the Shredder Japanese. It won't be better if Eric Sachs became the Shredder again, because he should never have been the Shredder to begin with.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:34 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.