The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Turtles in Time #4 - Preview/Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=49348)

ChosenOne 09-12-2014 12:08 PM

Turtles in Time #4 - Preview/Discussion
 
Preview here.

Redeemer 09-12-2014 12:15 PM

Cant freaking wait!!!!!!!! I am glad to see Dan Duncan coming back for this issue!!!!!! I want it now!!!!!!

Plasticplayhouse 09-12-2014 12:38 PM

TiT has been an epic adventure. as much as i cant wait for this issue, i will be sad it is ending.

funatic 09-12-2014 12:41 PM

Spoiler:
Stockman owns Australia in the future?! (I can only assume that's what the fly insignia implies on the map in the last panel.)

ProphetofGanja 09-12-2014 01:06 PM

I'm verrrrry curious about the four bandannas hanging on the wall in the last panel

ProphetofGanja 09-12-2014 01:10 PM

Also, is that Metalhead in the corner there in the second-to-last panel?

ProphetofGanja 09-12-2014 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by funatic (Post 1348433)
Spoiler:
Stockman owns Australia in the future?! (I can only assume that's what the fly insignia implies on the map in the last panel.)

I think it's more likely that Shredder and Krang exiled him there, along with a bunch of flyborgs... making him Lord of the Flies! :lol:

Tazi 09-12-2014 01:18 PM

Letting him rule a whole continent is not really an exile tho... :P

I'm glad about Krang getting Europe. He is still a better option then our current president. :lol:


(besides, I don't think this should be in spoiler tags, after all we are talking about the preview in the topic called "preview".)

Mutant Ninja Anole 09-12-2014 01:23 PM

The world split between Shredder, Krang and Stockman? Mutants the norm, at least in Shredder's domain? I'm torn between the horror and awesome!

It's been implied in Shredder's micro, and in the Secret History of the Foot Clan arc that Shredder is essentially 'destined' to rule. It'll be interesting to see if the Turtles are going to be able to literally 'fight the future' from happening.

Maybe this is Renet's ultimate purpose in having them time jump like this, to show them the possible future if things continue to go as they are headed.

ChosenOne 09-12-2014 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProphetofGanja (Post 1348446)
Also, is that Metalhead in the corner there in the second-to-last panel?

Yes, it is!

ProphetofGanja 09-12-2014 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1348454)
Yes, it is!

All of a sudden this issue feels like its going to be the Days of Future Past of the TMNTverse

ChosenOne 09-12-2014 01:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProphetofGanja (Post 1348463)
All of a sudden this issue feels like its going to be the Days of Future Past of the TMNTverse

I hadn't thought of that yet, but I very much like the comparison. Here's hoping!

The map was totally unexpected and totally awesome. Maybe future!Baxter is also a mutant? Being so close to Krang's territory, I guess we can figure out where his loyalties ultimately lie in the coming war.

boywonder26 09-12-2014 04:34 PM

This looks incredible!!!!can not wait to read!!!!😮

neatoman 09-12-2014 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by funatic (Post 1348433)
Spoiler:
Stockman owns Australia in the future?! (I can only assume that's what the fly insignia implies on the map in the last panel.)

Huh... I thought it was just a random doodle.

Also I noticed some geographical oddities on the map:
Spain should not be connected to Africa.
Ireland is not that small and not connected to Great Britain.
Italy is really messed up here.
Madagascar is missing.
Korea seems too big and should not connect to Japan which is missing some islands and looks really distorted.
The Americas look roughly correct but Mexico looks really diminished.

Either the Foot/Utrom war has really messed something up or the artist just messed up a lot. Still, not as bad as when Lawson drew the planet for Archie, that one didn't get the Americas close and those were only continents on the panel.

Mutant Ninja Anole 09-12-2014 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1348468)
I hadn't thought of that yet, but I very much like the comparison. Here's hoping!

The map was totally unexpected and totally awesome. Maybe future!Baxter is also a mutant? Being so close to Krang's territory, I guess we can figure out where his loyalties ultimately lie in the coming war.

Presumably his own, actually. That or it's a 1984 situation, with the two weaker nations teaming up against the stronger one, until the balance shifts and then so do the alliances.

ChosenOne 09-12-2014 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mutant Ninja Anole (Post 1348601)
Presumably his own, actually. That or it's a 1984 situation, with the two weaker nations teaming up against the stronger one, until the balance shifts and then so do the alliances.

What I meant was, would he really risk carving out a piece of territory right in Krang's backyard if it weren't in some way a reward for his loyalty during the war? That's the only way I see Krang not launching an offensive against the guy who went behind his back to wipe out the Utroms.

Joey Kamikaze 09-12-2014 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProphetofGanja (Post 1348463)
All of a sudden this issue feels like its going to be the Days of Future Past of the TMNTverse

That's essentially what Future Shark Trilogy is in Archie too, and the #1 thing I'm hoping to see is a hint at future turtles.

Don't really have much else to say except "god I love this series."

qt.bangerang 09-12-2014 10:03 PM

This is going to be so epic! I really hope Baxter is a mutant fly.

Rooish 09-12-2014 10:55 PM

Looks very cool! Donnie was showing pretty poor judgement, eh?

Baxter definitely rules Australia.

Also, is there a 5th turtle in the second last panel?

Redeemer 09-12-2014 11:16 PM

I love post apocalyptic future stuff and I wish they would do a four or three issue mini series for this section alone!!!!!!

snake 09-12-2014 11:40 PM

Hyped. When does this come out?

Joey Kamikaze 09-13-2014 01:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 1348719)
Also, is there a 5th turtle in the second last panel?

99% sure it's Metalhead.

Quote:

Hyped. When does this come out?
Next Wednesday, the 17th, AFAIK.

The Big Bad 09-13-2014 05:28 AM

Something that occurs to me: in the past three issues, we've seen the turtles bring about changes that we've already seen in the present. They're not changing the future / present we know, but rather helping to bring it about. That means that, if the writers are being at all consistent with their time travel rules and there's not some sort of twist like the future seen here being actually an illusion made so the turtles will hand over the Phoenix Gate, the future shown here is this 'verse's canonical future. I don't find that encouraging.

Mutant Ninja Anole 09-13-2014 09:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1348610)
What I meant was, would he really risk carving out a piece of territory right in Krang's backyard if it weren't in some way a reward for his loyalty during the war? That's the only way I see Krang not launching an offensive against the guy who went behind his back to wipe out the Utroms.

Well Australia is pretty isolated, and Krang's got Shredder to concern himself with first. Besides, Stockman has done pretty good at getting the better of Krang so far, I wouldn't assume Krang can just overwhelm whatever Stockman has set up there without leaving himself open to Shredder.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1348857)
Something that occurs to me: in the past three issues, we've seen the turtles bring about changes that we've already seen in the present. They're not changing the future / present we know, but rather helping to bring it about. That means that, if the writers are being at all consistent with their time travel rules and there's not some sort of twist like the future seen here being actually an illusion made so the turtles will hand over the Phoenix Gate, the future shown here is this 'verse's canonical future. I don't find that encouraging.

There may be some aspects to how time travel works we don't know, and not many time travel stories are perfectly consistent. It's just too confusing when broken down.

Although honestly as bad as this future looks, it's pretty cool looking and people actually do seem to be living mostly normal lives under Shredder. I mean, as normal as it can be when everyone's a mutant animal person.

I'm actually kind of intrigued by this world. I wonder if you could have a spin off ongoing story in this setting. Or perhaps even a game set up in that world (Video game, books and dice, etc).

Rooish 09-13-2014 10:18 AM

The future looks a little better than in SAINW! I wonder if they'll meet their future selves!

Also this art barely looks like Dan Duncan's. Maybe it's because he adjusted the arm and leg wraps and gave Mikey the short bandanna and gave everyone pupils! I love it but it's not very recognizable!

The Big Bad 09-13-2014 11:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mutant Ninja Anole (Post 1348901)
There may be some aspects to how time travel works we don't know, and not many time travel stories are perfectly consistent. It's just too confusing when broken down.

A lack of consistency wouldn't normally be a problem--glob knows there's plenty of it when the other series tackle time travel--except this entire series has been all about how the turtles are unknowingly responsible for shaping their present. In order for that particular conceit to work, it needs to be understood that the places the turtles are visiting are all part of their timeline. However, if the future isn't part of the timeline, how can we trust that the other places are? How can we be sure that it is indeed the turtles actions that, in our timeline, caused the Utroms to see dinosaurs' combat potential, or convinced Saki to kill Yoshi and his family, etc.? It can be explained away, but it's a contrivance that can't help but feel artificial, and take away from whatever thematic coherence the mini can claim to have.

Cipher 09-13-2014 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Big Bad (Post 1348939)
A lack of consistency wouldn't normally be a problem--glob knows there's plenty of it when the other series tackle time travel--except this entire series has been all about how the turtles are unknowingly responsible for shaping their present. In order for that particular conceit to work, it needs to be understood that the places the turtles are visiting are all part of their timeline. However, if the future isn't part of the timeline, how can we trust that the other places are? How can we be sure that it is indeed the turtles actions that, in our timeline, caused the Utroms to see dinosaurs' combat potential, or convinced Saki to kill Yoshi and his family, etc.? It can be explained away, but it's a contrivance that can't help but feel artificial, and take away from whatever thematic coherence the mini can claim to have.

There's still an out in that they've previously altered the past to resemble the present. I.e., time travel has always had its effects manifest in the present, canonical timeline.

If that holds true it's just as easy to argue that here, in seeing the future, the ramifications of this bit of time travel will also affect things to come. I.e., time travel always has its ramifications felt; but in this instance we're seeing a future that may not be canonical, which is a new area to explore an could absolutely maintain consistency with what we know were it to be avoided.

ProphetofGanja 09-13-2014 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cipher (Post 1349022)
There's still an out in that they've previously altered the past to resemble the present. I.e., time travel has always had its effects manifest in the present, canonical timeline.

If that holds true it's just as easy to argue that here, in seeing the future, the ramifications of this bit of time travel will also affect things to come. I.e., time travel always has its ramifications felt; but in this instance we're seeing a future that may not be canonical, which is a new area to explore an could absolutely maintain consistency with what we know were it to be avoided.

I think whether or not you like the outcome of this mini-series depends on whether you believe in a multiple timelines theory of time travel or a one singular, unalterable timeline theory, where everytime you alter the timeline the effects are immediate

ProphetofGanja 09-13-2014 03:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mutant Ninja Anole (Post 1348901)
Although honestly as bad as this future looks, it's pretty cool looking and people actually do seem to be living mostly normal lives under Shredder. I mean, as normal as it can be when everyone's a mutant animal person.

I'm actually kind of intrigued by this world. I wonder if you could have a spin off ongoing story in this setting. Or perhaps even a game set up in that world (Video game, books and dice, etc).

I wouldn't want to be one of the humans on page 4, handcuffed getting walked into the back of a van.

but more stories in this future would be cool

RedRocBoy 09-15-2014 10:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 1348914)
The future looks a little better than in SAINW! I wonder if they'll meet their future selves!

Also this art barely looks like Dan Duncan's. Maybe it's because he adjusted the arm and leg wraps and gave Mikey the short bandanna and gave everyone pupils! I love it but it's not very recognizable!

Yeah. He really did switch it up. His original style was amazing but I really his new style as well.

ProphetofGanja 09-15-2014 10:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RedRocBoy (Post 1349961)
Yeah. He really did switch it up. His original style was amazing but I really his new style as well.

It really fits the dystopian future setting

I didn't even recognize it as Duncan's work until I read the credits

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 09-15-2014 11:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProphetofGanja (Post 1349079)
I think whether or not you like the outcome of this mini-series depends on whether you believe in a multiple timelines theory of time travel or a one singular, unalterable timeline theory, where everytime you alter the timeline the effects are immediate

The things they do in the past ultimately affect the present, but whether or not they go back and make decisions that create the future they've traveled to, or it ceases to be THEIR future (it still has to exist as a possible future, duh, since they went there) is yet to be seen.

Did Archie have multiple timelines? Or did the old time line just "disappear" and get replaced after it was altered?

snake 09-15-2014 01:49 PM

At least the future is better then SAINW.

Cipher 09-15-2014 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ***Doo Doo Acureds*** (Post 1349975)
Did Archie have multiple timelines? Or did the old time line just "disappear" and get replaced after it was altered?

The future timeline doesn't seem to alter after events start going haywire in "Tetracide," so I guess we can assume there are multiple (though probably similar in terms of major events like the global flooding) timelines.

And frankly I think it's made pretty clear that Armaggon, Shredder and Verminator X going back in time is what causes things to misalign in the first place, so it's pretty clear it's not dealing with a recursive model.

As long as we're at it, Mirage is purposefully coy about the subject, but seems to lean toward recursiveness. Renet and Savanti Romero seem to imply a couple of times that things could change ("Return of Savanti Romero," "Dark Shadows, etc.), but the issue of whether time-travel is recursive is dodged for a joke in "The Return of Savanti Romero" when Mike asks about it, and most of the Turtles' future stories line up perfectly with one another. At least one Renet-Savanti story (the questionably canonical "Masks") also takes a whole-sale recursive approach.

Which just makes the action-oriented Savanti-Renet stories even more tongue-in-cheek, the downer ones more poignant, and the characters as a whole even more bizarre, all of which is cool if probably unintentional.

Bry 09-15-2014 08:29 PM

Whoa! Didn't realize Dan Duncan was coming back for this. His style looks a bit different than his original run, but I really like it. Excited!

Quote:

Originally Posted by funatic (Post 1348433)
Spoiler:
Stockman owns Australia in the future?! (I can only assume that's what the fly insignia implies on the map in the last panel.)

Spoiler:
The secondary evil schemers always get Australia. :tlol:

Venom 09-16-2014 09:23 PM

Well, this turned out to be a rather dark issue.

Pretty cool to see a few future versions of folks - one unexpected, another seen before.

The mini needs one more issue as an epilogue, in my opinion, but the themes presented here are possibly some of the deepest we've seen out of IDW's TMNT thus far, and the implications some of the darkest yet.

The subtlety and hints to untold tales and things that-could-be provided a great satisfaction and harkened back to one of the greatest elements of the Mirage universe.

Forgive the vagueness of this post, you'll all see tomorrow.

Can't wait to read Speng's thoughts on this issue.

ProphetofGanja 09-16-2014 11:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venom (Post 1350662)
Well, this turned out to be a rather dark issue.

Pretty cool to see a few future versions of folks - one unexpected, another seen before.

The mini needs one more issue as an epilogue, in my opinion, but the themes presented here are possibly some of the deepest we've seen out of IDW's TMNT thus far, and the implications some of the darkest yet.

The subtlety and hints to untold tales and things that-could-be provided a great satisfaction and harkened back to one of the greatest elements of the Mirage universe.

Forgive the vagueness of this post, you'll all see tomorrow.

Can't wait to read Speng's thoughts on this issue.

I'm so jealous, you live in my state and you got to read the issue early

The Big Bad 09-17-2014 06:59 AM

(Note: I've read the issue, and these are rather incomplete, unedited thoughts; I have to leave for school and don't want to lose them. I may edit later.)

Could Renet be any more of a plot device? I was glad to see her appearing for more than a couple of panels, but she is far from memorable here.

Interesting issue. It's not as enjoyable as the first one, but it has a certain something. I really wish more time had been spent establishing the future; while the details aren't really the point of the story, I feel they deserved more space than they got. At this point, the future we see feels rather tossed together at the last minute. But like I said, the future is not the point.


If I have one complaint, it's the whole explanation they've given for the turtles' very convenient time travel, which seems like the hand-waviest of excuses, and one that I don't feel works in this particular context, where the times and locations have been anything but random.

In order for issues #1 to #3 to have any weight, they require the reader to understand that the events shown all take place on the turtles' own timeline, and that the actions they take actually impact the larger story. The turtles themselves may not know that--the larger impact of their actions tends to be shown in their absence--but the audience knows, and that's enough to grant the story some heft.

Here, however, we have something a bit different: a possible future. What's more, we have an explanation that "the universe" chose where the turtles went, because apparently lessons needed to be learned. And apparently the lesson is that this is larger than them.

Except there's no reason to think that. Now that we know that alternate futures are in play, there's no reason for the turtles to conclude that the pasts they've seen are their own. Heck, the only reason we can conclude it is because we have an idea of how the writers think, and because the story the writers wanted to tell, particularly the "we've learned that this fight begun before we were born" point requires it.

In the end, I wish this future had turned out to be the real, canonical, inevitable future. As much as I dislike the idea of the book never outgrowing the Shredder and Krang, there's a certain appeal to setting the future in stone before one has any idea how to get to it--it takes guts--and it'd be interesting to see how the writers handle it. What we actually have, however, is the worst of both worlds. Not only is it yet more evidence that the writers can't see past the Shredder, they are also rather wishy-washy about it. It feels sloppy, and wasteful. Instead of using time travel to really cut loose, the writers have approached it with the same halfheartedness they approach the regular book.

qt.bangerang 09-17-2014 10:29 AM

I was a little disappointed in this issue. It wasn't bad, it just didn't explain a lot of what had "gone wrong" and why the majority of people are now mutants. It also dosen't really explain why Renet even came into the picture in the first place, other then they needed to learn a lesson.

ChosenOne 09-17-2014 10:46 AM

Definitely a very dark capper for this adventure, but I love how it ties into the Shredder micro.

I've noticed every issue of TiT has been centered around one of the turtles:

#1 - Raph
#2 - Leo
#3 - Mikey
#4 - Don

I guess the universe really was trying to teach them something, one at a time. Did they learn it well? We'll know soon enough when the ooze hits the fan.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:11 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.