The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   getting into TMNT comic (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=49596)

go_ninja84 10-03-2014 03:05 PM

getting into TMNT comic
 
i have been a fan of tmnt for 25 yrs and grew up with the old cartoon show. i watched all the 2k3, Next Mutation, all the movies, and i have always collected the toys. recently i have been wanting to get into the comics too since they were more adult oriented then the shows/movies. i started on ebay purchasing a few and this is what i came up with so far. i wanna get into it properly so am i on the right track? what are a few items that a beginning collector should look for as staples in a collection? im not really interested in resale values i really wanna read the stories and get a first hand feel of their earlier years. any advice for a beginner?:D

The Turtle Terminator 10-03-2014 03:55 PM

For collectables, try either the works of ultimate collections. Thats most of the important comics in chronological order

Joey Kamikaze 10-03-2014 04:28 PM

IDW has been reprinting the old Mirage stories since they got the rights a few years back. That's your best bet. As a quick and dirty explanation of what's out there:

You can separate the original black and white TMNT comic (volume one) into two rough camps: Eastman and Laird's issues (which are most of the canon stories from that era) and everyone else's guest issues (which vary in quality and often don't count as canon). The main canon run goes roughly from #1 to the Return to New York story that concludes in #21 plus the original Tales of the TMNT miniseries, then jumps to #45 through the end of City At War and volume one at #62. The easiest way to read the canon stories is through nabbing IDW's Ultimate Collections (original black and white) or The Works (in color) books.

After that you have volume two, which is brief. Volume three, published by Image, is no longer considered canon, so technically the next stretch of story is found in the canon (but yet incomplete) volume four issues and volume two of Tales of the TMNT. IDW has been collecting this material in trades going in order of publication so hopefully it'll all be easy to find in a few years.

If you want a more modern and easy to follow TMNT series that also skews to teens and adults, I'd also suggest picking up the ongoing IDW series. IMO it's becoming the definitive TMNT comic thanks to its tight storytelling and consistent quality as the years go on. IDW is a reboot that incorporates bits of past TMNT universes for its own spin on the mythos and it's all available in TPBs.

Andrew NDB 10-03-2014 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1358545)
IDW is a reboot that incorporates bits of past TMNT universes for its own spin on the mythos and it's all available in TPBs.

You can't call it a reboot. It's just a different universe. And "reboot" implies the old material has ceased... Volume 4 is still going, albeit at a snail's pace.

So-CoAddict 10-03-2014 07:55 PM

I started collecting TMNT cooks about 2 months ago. Some advice I would pass along would be...

- Research the various volumes and publishers and decide which of those you'd like to collect. I started wanting just Volume 1, but my collecting snowballed and I'm now hunting for any and all TMNT books (minus IDW). Problem is, I've drained my bank account. Now I need to be extra diligent.

- Pay extra attention to photos posted from buyers and always ask for additional info/pics if you're unsure. I've found people will throw in the words "unread" or "never been read" in an effort to hide the fact that the book has an internal flaw, which they obviously do not mention when selling. It sucks finding a flaw after you've made the purchase, thinking you're getting a NM book.

- Learn the variants. I stay away from IDW right now specifically because there are so many variants. Some people only collect the main books, while others only collect the variants. I honestly can't keep track of them all, so I focus my vision on completing earlier volumes and hunting for the rare books.

Other than that, have fun with it. :tgrin: There are so many great TMNT artists out there, you'll enjoy everything you get your hands on.

PS - I've got a handful of TMNT books I'm looking to offload soon. Might post them to the forums, but PM me if you're interested. ;)

snake 10-03-2014 08:04 PM

Read IDW. Its avalible currently and less expensive to track down then Mirage. Mirage is still awesome, but IDW is easier to collect.

Andrew NDB 10-04-2014 12:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake (Post 1358730)
Read IDW. Its avalible currently and less expensive to track down then Mirage. Mirage is still awesome, but IDW is easier to collect.

That's not a good enough reason to seek out IDW over Mirage. But IDW is good.

go_ninja84 10-04-2014 07:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake (Post 1358730)
Read IDW. Its avalible currently and less expensive to track down then Mirage. Mirage is still awesome, but IDW is easier to collect.

is IDW the same stories as Mirage? i mostly wanted to get the Mirage comics since they go back a ways. but if IDW has the same stories and its easier on my wallet i could settle for them but keep an eye out for Mirage gems

Tazi 10-04-2014 08:08 AM

Nah, those are completely different stories, set in a completely different universe. IDW is great btw, but if you want to read the original classic series you have two options:
1.) Getting original/repring seperate issues from amazon/ebay/etc. That can be lot a of money, but if you really want to collect the stories in their true original form that's the only way.
2.) Getting reprint hardcovers and TPBs from IDW of the Mirage series. The TMNT Ultimate Collection books are collects the Eastmen & Laird issues of Mirage volume 1, and mostly it's done pretty well. The "Classics" and "Tales of..." TPBs are collects all the other Mirage stuff, and still on-going. The downside of it is that they are recolored in an undemanding way. :tcry:
There's also "The Works" HC, it's mostly the same as Ultimate Collection, but with the same problematic recolouring. Also there's the TMNT Legends, the 1st on of that will have Michael Zulli stuff (Souls Winter, etc.), but we don't know how they plan to continue it. Btw, some of the Zulli stuff also been released in the classics.

snake 10-04-2014 08:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by go_ninja84 (Post 1359067)
is IDW the same stories as Mirage? i mostly wanted to get the Mirage comics since they go back a ways. but if IDW has the same stories and its easier on my wallet i could settle for them but keep an eye out for Mirage gems

No. But they do reprint older Mirage stories, albiet in color, its always an option. If you want the real thing, go for the ultimate collections.

go_ninja84 10-04-2014 02:39 PM

i did some more hunting and was surprised to find the first issue #1 from Mirage was 20,000 dollars. was this one in short print? i found and bought the same book but i believe it was a 2009 reprint, it says "free comic book day" on it. is this the same one just reprinted?

im also hunting on amazon too and tonight i plan on checking out my local comic stores

Mayhem 10-04-2014 03:53 PM

There are a LOT of reprints of the very first issue... something like 13-14 I believe now :lol:

The $20k copy will be a high graded slabbed version of the very first print, which may or may be actually worth that amount. What was the grade on it? The very first print run back in 1984 was 3000 copies, and both Kevin and Peter admit that they used many of those copies as advertising material, cut up and stuck to make posters and flyers. So the actual number of first prints still in existence is very much unknown.

I consider myself fortunate to have bought a copy, signed by both back in 1985, around ten years ago. Cost me just over a grand. Probably worth 3-4 times that at least if I got it graded today, but I don't really do grading.

go_ninja84 10-05-2014 07:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mayhem (Post 1359306)
There are a LOT of reprints of the very first issue... something like 13-14 I believe now :lol:

The $20k copy will be a high graded slabbed version of the very first print, which may or may be actually worth that amount. What was the grade on it? The very first print run back in 1984 was 3000 copies, and both Kevin and Peter admit that they used many of those copies as advertising material, cut up and stuck to make posters and flyers. So the actual number of first prints still in existence is very much unknown.

I consider myself fortunate to have bought a copy, signed by both back in 1985, around ten years ago. Cost me just over a grand. Probably worth 3-4 times that at least if I got it graded today, but I don't really do grading.

is the 2009 FCBD version have the same story as the original printing?

Powder 10-05-2014 08:10 AM

Considering it's a reprint, it answers the question by simply existing. Yes.

Mayhem 10-05-2014 11:10 AM

Okay, maybe not quite as many as I stated, but I think these are all the #1 printings across the years...


http://i136.photobucket.com/albums/q...ps2e9cbff1.jpg

snake 10-05-2014 11:12 AM

Even the reprints of 1 fetch a lot of money. It's not an easy book to collect.

Fearing 10-05-2014 11:55 AM

@Mayhem: ALMOST all. There's also the reprint that was a pre-order bonus at GameStop for the TMNT CG movie game (very similar to the 2009 FCBD reprint but with a TMNT logo and some other text where the FCBD logo would be) and the one that came with that Ultimate Visual History book that came out recently. Then there's also the hardcover version of that anniversary reprint/photographic reproduction book and you could maybe count the error version of the 25th anniversary colored reprint and the corrected one as two separate printings as technically they had to go back to press to correct it, but I'm sure that could be debated as there's plenty of nuances to what counts as a seperate printing that I'm probably not aware of... and there's probably another one or two I can't think of or didn't know about.

Mayhem 10-05-2014 12:11 PM

Ah yeah, forgot to pull the #1 from the UVH book into the shot there. Don't own the Gamestop reprint yet. There is a hardcover of the "sixth" printing, but I could that as part of the softcover. And yeah, I'm not counting misprints in the mix here either.

Jephael 10-05-2014 08:55 PM

If you're still fond of the original cartoon, I highly recommend reading the Archie series from the 90s.

snake 10-05-2014 09:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jephael (Post 1359979)
If you're still fond of the original cartoon, I highly recommend reading the Archie series from the 90s.

Archie is good as well. IDW is currently reprinting it in small volumes.

go_ninja84 10-06-2014 03:22 PM

thanks for all the info guys, i actually stopped off at a local Barns and Noble book store and bought a IDW comic depicting their origin. i think "Change is Constant" its an interesting read so far :)

quick question TMNT issue 1 i believe 3rd print how much should one pay for this? i saw one for 99.00 does show wear on back though but like i said before i planned on reading these books

corvus 10-06-2014 04:08 PM

The best way to catch up in my opinion is jump on at city fall then slowly work your way through the back issues. City fall lays the foundation for the current state of the comic.

Joey Kamikaze 10-06-2014 04:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by corvus (Post 1360331)
The best way to catch up in my opinion is jump on at city fall then slowly work your way through the back issues. City fall lays the foundation for the current state of the comic.

I'd more or less agree, except I'd suggest starting with Secret History of the Foot Clan and then reading City Fall if you just wanted to jump into IDW mid-stream. SHotFC reinforces the reincarnation angle, gives you insight on Shredder's agenda and explains who Kitsune is and why she's important; in a lot of ways it's a prelude to City Fall and the more recent arcs. It's also probably one of the best standalone TMNT stories in any medium IMO.

snake 10-06-2014 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by corvus (Post 1360331)
The best way to catch up in my opinion is jump on at city fall then slowly work your way through the back issues. City fall lays the foundation for the current state of the comic.

This. City fall and above is a great jump on point.

Davetello 10-06-2014 05:46 PM

The most important Mirage Volume 1 stuff is the first eleven issues or so, plus the character one-shots. Then the Return to NY arc and after that City at War. The best thing to do is to collect all of the Ultimate Collections as they will fill you in on all the important stuff from volume 1.

It would be nice if the early Mirage stuff could be offered digitally on comixology.

tfranzone 10-07-2014 09:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mayhem (Post 1359677)
Okay, maybe not quite as many as I stated, but I think these are all the #1 printings across the years...


http://i136.photobucket.com/albums/q...ps2e9cbff1.jpg


nice collection of #1's!

I'm not sure if this counts, but technically it may.. that 2009 color reprint.. theres actually 2 of those if we're counting the first printing of it that was an error with the hatching marks across pages 21/22 i believe or 20/21.. but yea, so theres techinically 2 copies of this reprint.

I just sent my error copy to CGC, i think errors like that are fun books to preserve and worth the slabbing in my opinion.



To help OP, I'd grab the Ultimate collections.

Mayhem 10-07-2014 11:11 AM

I don't count misprints in the total, because they are the same edition issue heh. But as noted, I did forget to get my UVH #1 out of the pocket for the shot, and I don't own the Gamestop version.

go_ninja84 10-11-2014 08:45 AM

well...it was a long search but i finally got the Mirage issue 1, its a 3rd print but im a happy collector

go_ninja84 10-17-2014 02:58 PM

im having a little issue here, im aware its my fault since i didnt examine the pictures but it looks like somebody removed the "third printing" area and wrote in pen over the "1985" part. is this comic book junk? is there anything i can do with this?

Powder 10-17-2014 04:27 PM

Oh boy... What did you pay for that?

go_ninja84 10-17-2014 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1366921)
Oh boy... What did you pay for that?

i paid little over 100 but i messaged the seller and he said he could exchange it for another one


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.