![]() |
IDW 2014 turtles design
Hi everyone,
Because I am not a fan of the IDW current turtles design, I told Bobby Curnow about it here. As I said there, I think the turtles now look more like children and therefore I by far prefer - for example - the 2012 design from the same artist, Mateus Santolouco. I created this thread to have your opinion. Am I the only one who prefers the 2012 design? Which design do you prefer? http://plannedbanter.files.wordpress...0&h=240&crop=1 2012 design http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs70/f/20...d3-d86erk8.jpg Current/2014 design |
I definitely prefer the older style. I didn't care for his first style as the unique masks really turned me off, & I don't care for the new one as their foreheads are too large & they've got very pronounced noses. What he was doing in between these two styles was his absolute best, IMO, his start on the main run, which was similar to what Cory Smith is now doing.
|
12 year old mutant ninja turtles?
|
I like Cory Smith's turtles very much. If Mateus doesn't change its turtle design, I hope Smith will work more often on the IDW ongoing.
EDIT: Quote:
|
I really can't stand Santolouco's designs these days. Partly because I don't like the Nick designs he is trying to emulate. Michelangelo and Donatello particularly look like crap and that's the be all and end all of it.
|
Quote:
I thought that was obvious enough. |
2012 is way better.:ohwell:
|
Quote:
And yes, I also think they look like kids and that bothers me :( |
They looked best around SHotFC and City Fall, no doubt.
|
Quote:
|
I think Mateus is an excellent artist. I even appreciate his changing of the turtles masks to better resemble their classic design. However, I really think the turtles faces need a change.
|
I do prefer his old look too, so perhaps he'll change his style again next year.
|
There's no need to emulate Campbell's stuff which is looking very cutesy these days. His stuff is better suited for a book more geared towards children like the New Animated Adventures.
Santolouco should just focus on drawing like Santolouco. He's still a phenomenal artist but his stuff shined the most when he wasn't emulating Campbell. |
|
I liked Duncan's stuff too, even when it got really rushed. I like when the Turtles aren't so different looking from each other.
|
I wasn't too big on Santolouco in the beginning, but I think he have improved tremedously drawing the Turtles, although their snouts are still a bit weird at times. His humans are awesome, and the other mutants are really nice.
I really don't mind the turtles looking cute, but then again, I am a huge fan of Ross' artstyle. |
I don't mind the current look, except something about Don looks extremely feminine. In the new Vengeance promo at least.
Santolouco is always on top of his game, but as far as designs go, he was probably rocking it best during early City Fall. |
Quote:
Santolouco is an amazing artist, but I prefer his earlier 2012 designs, his current 2014 designs are just too damn childish. It could be the boys upstairs forcing him to draw them younger and more like the "Nick Toon". I really hope they change the design back bc at this point I actually might drop the book. the design is just killing me. |
I definitely prefer Santolouco pre Northampton. I think Ross's designs sort of spoiled what Mateus is up to now. Hate to spin the broken record again but they lean toward the adorable side a little too much for my tastes at times. Namely the button noses and giant anime eyes.
|
I'm not crazy about Campbell's turtle designs either, at least not on this book. His chibi turtles would be fine on a book for kids but they don't fit in a book that leans teen to adult. And his influence on Santalouco is unfortunate. Now if they stuck Campbell on NAA I'd think he would fit right in.
(One thing I will give Campbell is he draws my favorite Renet thus far.) |
I love santolouco's art.his turtles are amazing.
|
Oooh i'm ***NOT*** the only one who thinks they look horrible now!
Fugly looking tween TMNT... Great for a kids book... But eesh. Anyways, I voted 2012 version. |
I actually prefer the newer designs, it serves as a reminder that the turtles are actually teens. 15 year old kids don't look like hulking muscle bound killing machines. Don't get me wrong, I loved Santolouco's old designs too but I think everyone (writers/fans/designers/etc.) need to remember that most kids don't start to look like actual adults until about 21 years old.
The turtles in his older work look 25-30 years old. That's like when they had 24 year old Tom Welling playing a "teenage" Clark Kent. Even not taking the age thing into consideration, I still prefer his later designs. |
I voted for the new design..but I honestly love both of his designs.
|
Also guys, can we please talk about Mikey's buck tooth? Please? Like why is it there? What purpose does it serve? Why do I feel like I'm the only one who thinks it's hideous and kind of damaging to his character? Do I have to start a thread or will someone validate me on here?
|
It's to kiddify him, I think, given this series follows in Nick's footsteps with the whole Mikey is the kid brother thing. I don't mind it much, but I could see why others might.
|
I can't make up my mind to vote. Everything Mateus has done so far is gold.
|
Quote:
|
Yes! I forgot to mention that I can't stand the tooth.
|
2012, of course! :nod:
This new sudden change of art style makes my head spin! :( |
2014 Design = Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
2012 Design = Quarter-Life Mutant Angst Monsters |
Quote:
Santaluoco's good, but he's never captured movement for me in that way. Not a fan of his choices with Donatello and especially Michelangelo's faces, either. It's impossible to take this Mike seriously whatsoever, which is a shame. |
Quote:
|
Santolouco is doing great job i think. Love is art. It's different, but i'm good with this.
|
I like the new stuff. It's all been good, but they're kids. They should look like kids.
|
Went along with the 2012 design. *Because it just screams Ninja Turtles. Even though they almost look more like adults than teenagers.*
2014 looks sorta chibi-ish to me. *This can be alright if they wanted to do a flashback story when the Turtles were younger.* Like how the 2014 design defuses the seriousness of the 2012 design. |
Quote:
|
I still enjoy the current although that new image in the beginning thread post looks too chibi for my taste. It's the eyes that bothers me.
I think they look great when they look like this. http://www.destroythecyb.org/wp-cont.../08/tmnt_2.jpg But if his artwork become even more chibi stylized then I would understand their plight. Quote:
|
The new style is actually what turns me off from the new IDW comics. Those designs look too cutesy. Yuck!
Has it ever been explained why the current comics are using the Nick cartoon designs? |
Quote:
Within the comic itself it's kinda like those things where the characters aren't supposed to notice that they look different. I do like how they're drawn in the Ghostbusters art style though. Have them tackle an arc or two in the main series, at least to see the belt buckles back. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:36 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.