The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Canon Immigrant (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=50798)

LeotheLateBloomer 01-15-2015 01:01 PM

Canon Immigrant
 
I finally read a few of the IDW comics but I have yet to have a full opinion of what I think of them. I see that the new series incorporates elements from a few incarnations such as the different colored headbands, Rocksteady and Bebop, Hun, etc. How do you guys feel about this series incorporating elements from different variations? I honestly don't know how I feel about it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 01-15-2015 01:14 PM

It's my favorite canon of TMNT so far, beating out the original Mirage/Image and 2003 cartoon. So much of Mirage was wasted on non-canon guest issues (Volume 1) or on storylines that were dropped or went nowhere (looking at YOU, Tales Volume 2). But there have been ~75 main issues (including the micro-series and spinoffs), and EVERY SINGLE issue continues the main story. Everything matters.

Daunting if you're entering the series fresh, but I find it both promising and fulfilling. And its homages to previous iterations are wonderful, too. (Still waiting to see Raphael in an eyepatch... and Leatherhead. Can't wait for the big croc.)

snake 01-15-2015 01:45 PM

I love it. Mixing incarnations is fun to read.

Panda_Kahn_fan 01-15-2015 02:39 PM

Personally, I love it! There are so many different wells of TMNT lore to draw material from, no one truly superior to the other. So many stories and characters to draw on. Kind of like how Harley Quinn made her way into the DC universe, or Mister Freeze's animated origin became his origin in the source material. These lines that divide characters and storylines from different sources into 'true' characters and 'not true' characters only exist in fan's minds.

Usagi Miyamoto 01-15-2015 02:42 PM

IMO it leads to a really rich, enjoyable universe. Even Mirage ended up incorporating elements from the series that it inspired(the use of Hun for instance).

IDW has me anticipating how they'll either bring back old characters or incorporate new, fresh characters. It also puts characters from the weakest parts of the franchise, Archie and OT, into newer and brighter lights.

tilallr1 01-16-2015 07:23 AM

I feel the mixing is being done really well and thus the story is really fun to follow.

IMHO, so far, this is the best TMNT story done thus far.

Mutant Ninja Anole 01-16-2015 09:05 AM

It's been done very well IMHO.

Toitlefan 01-16-2015 09:50 AM

Just start reading from the beginning, pick up the micro-series and you will be hooked in no time. IDW has done a fantastic job incorporating almost every character and plot line. If you are a long time TMNT fan there will be at least a couple things that will make you shriek like a little girl with excitement. :tlol:

CyberCubed 01-16-2015 02:20 PM

Mixing elements of Mirage, with the original cartoon and 4kids cartoon was a great idea. IDW takes the best elements of each series and works wonders with them.

And now with the Mutanimals and Null they're also starting to adapt Archie stuff which is fantastic.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 01-16-2015 04:22 PM

I'm just waiting for Bishop and Leatherhead! And maaaaybe someday a revamped Pimiko. THAT would be great.

neatoman 01-16-2015 05:23 PM

I don't have any special feelings about it at all, no really I expected that too much for me to be surprised, because I knew it's impossible not to do that these days.

I knew Bebop, Rocksteady and Krang were going to be in there because they're too popular not to be. I knew the classic Mirage characters like Renet and Fugitoid would eventually show up because comic book writers love to bring back things from older runs. I was maybe a little surprised to see Angel and Hun return (at least in the way they did) but I did expect 4kids characters to come back since that series is generally well liked. I knew some older characters would be put in simply because the writers like them. I can see some Nick characters popping up later.

TMNT is only 31 years old right now and while that might still seem old, it's still settling in to what will eventually be the definitive canon with it's characters and status quo.
I'm predicting the set of characters that'll be the most essential/established characters for the franchise to (as of now) be:
  1. The Turtles
  2. Splinter
  3. April
  4. Casey
  5. Shredder
  6. Karai
  7. Krang
  8. Baxter Stockman
  9. Hun
  10. The Fugitoid
  11. Renet
  12. Bebop
  13. Rocksteady
  14. Rat King
  15. Slash
  16. Leatherhead
These are part of an unoffical, updating list of what will become "The" TMNT charcters eventually, but it's still not set in stone what the most essential TMNT characters are, we'll have to wait a few decades and see.

Usagi Miyamoto 01-16-2015 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1407551)
I'm just waiting for Bishop and Leatherhead! And maaaaybe someday a revamped Pimiko. THAT would be great.

Leatherhead and Bishop are the highest on my list too, though I think both should be expected sooner rather than later given story trends. This Karai is sort of in the Pimiko role again, but if there was a way to bring her in that didn't feel like a duplication of Karai I'd be on board.

Speaking on the Image side of things the Komodo brothers would make a pretty cool addition to the crime world - maybe connect them to the Ghostboys or another minor gang to flesh things out, then bring Leatherhead out around the time of the King Komodo mutation to mimic the Image plotline.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 01-16-2015 07:42 PM

I'm confident we'll meet Leatherhead in the Mighty Mutanimals mini-series. As for Bishop, I haven't seen any hints that he's coming, but he is such a major and grounded antagonist that I am very hopeful he'll become a major player in the next 50 issues, after Krang and Shredder are dealt solid blows.

As for Pimiko, I agree that they'd have to come up with a new backstory for her as Karai is already the Shredder's heir (literally and figuratively). But she has such a great love/hate chemistry with Raph, and I am DYING to see Raphael follow a path similar to the Image series (taking over part of the Foot Clan).

And I would LOVE to see King Komodo. That guy was pretty beast.

Bry 01-16-2015 10:57 PM

It's its main strength, really - the way it's able to take elements from so many very different versions of the property and combine it all into a cohesive whole is super impressive. It's one of those things that could be a total mess in the wrong hands, and Waltz and company make it look effortless.

I mean... Mirage is still my personal "best". But this series is up there.

Gunstar_Red 01-17-2015 06:13 PM

As others said, I really dig the mixing of different versions and overall easier to follow story (for me). I wish they approached a couple of subjects tactfully, but one of the fun things about this version is trying to guess what is going to happen next even though you may have a vague idea. It's shaping up to be my favorite comic version, though not my favorite incarnation.

MsMarvelDuckie 01-17-2015 08:11 PM

It's my neck-and-neck favorite with the 2K3 toon, for me. The fact that it uses so many of my favorite OT toon elements doesn't hurt, either.

neatoman 01-18-2015 04:05 AM

I will though, I am happy that it is it's own thing taking elements from other versions. It seems like it would have been so easy just to take the FW cartoon and make it a more mture version of that, but it isn't and I'm grateful for that.

GeneralTragg 01-18-2015 10:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1407032)
Still waiting to see Raphael in an eyepatch...

He's wearing one briefly in Turtles in Time issue 3....

2K3 01-24-2015 04:32 PM

My Hopes for future characters
 
One thing I have really loved about the IDW series is it's ability take characters from all over "Turtle-Verse" and make them work in this take. I have taken time to make a list of characters from the Mirage, 80s, Adventures, 2K3 and Nick series that I'd love to see appear in IDW:

Mirage
Leatherhead (OBVIOUSLY)
Klunk (or Ice Cream Kitty, whichever, Mikey needs a cat)
General Blanque (but make him human, not alien; never liked the idea of Aliens that look EXACTLY like a human)
King of Thieves (I want to have it that one of the villains from the Mikey Micro becomes this villain)
Savanti Romero (Add him to the roster of Kitsune and Rat King)
Triceraton Prime Leader Zandramon and Cmdr. Mozar (I just love the Triceratons)

80s Series
Channel 6 Crew Irma Langstein, Vernon Fenwick and Burne Thompson (make them cameos in news reports)

Adventures
Wingnut (I just loved that bat, just didn't like Screwloose)
Maligna (I like to think there are more threats in Dimension X than just Krang)

2K3
Agent Bishop (One of my favourite Villains of 2K3)
Mr. Touch and Mr. Go (A guilty pleasure of mine, I'd give them to that crime boss; Antonio)
Mortu (I like to think not all of the Utroms in this series are BAD)

Nick
Tiger Claw (Favourite new villain in Nick, I'd love to see him join the ranks of the Foot Clan)

ProphetofGanja 01-26-2015 11:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2K3 (Post 1410894)
One thing I have really loved about the IDW series is it's ability take characters from all over "Turtle-Verse" and make them work in this take. I have taken time to make a list of characters from the Mirage, 80s, Adventures, 2K3 and Nick series that I'd love to see appear in IDW:

Mirage
Leatherhead (OBVIOUSLY)
Klunk (or Ice Cream Kitty, whichever, Mikey needs a cat)
General Blanque (but make him human, not alien; never liked the idea of Aliens that look EXACTLY like a human)
King of Thieves (I want to have it that one of the villains from the Mikey Micro becomes this villain)
Savanti Romero (Add him to the roster of Kitsune and Rat King)
Triceraton Prime Leader Zandramon and Cmdr. Mozar (I just love the Triceratons)

80s Series
Channel 6 Crew Irma Langstein, Vernon Fenwick and Burne Thompson (make them cameos in news reports)

Adventures
Wingnut (I just loved that bat, just didn't like Screwloose)
Maligna (I like to think there are more threats in Dimension X than just Krang)

2K3
Agent Bishop (One of my favourite Villains of 2K3)
Mr. Touch and Mr. Go (A guilty pleasure of mine, I'd give them to that crime boss; Antonio)
Mortu (I like to think not all of the Utroms in this series are BAD)

Nick
Tiger Claw (Favourite new villain in Nick, I'd love to see him join the ranks of the Foot Clan)


Ok so may I ask who the hell this Savanti Romero guy is? I'm not familiar with him but I've heard his name in passing quite a few times and I've gathered that he was a significant enemy of the Turtles. His name makes me think he's an Italian mafia boss, but apparently he's like a demon or something? Can anyone enlighten me?

ChosenOne 01-26-2015 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProphetofGanja (Post 1411822)
Ok so may I ask who the hell this Savanti Romero guy is? I'm not familiar with him but I've heard his name in passing quite a few times and I've gathered that he was a significant enemy of the Turtles. His name makes me think he's an Italian mafia boss, but apparently he's like a demon or something? Can anyone enlighten me?

From what little I know of the character, he's the Baron Mordo to Renet's Doctor Strange, ie, her and her mentor Lord Simultaneous' rival who usually engages in time travel shenanigans with Renet and the Turtles.

Joey Kamikaze 01-26-2015 11:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProphetofGanja (Post 1411822)
Ok so may I ask who the hell this Savanti Romero guy is? I'm not familiar with him but I've heard his name in passing quite a few times and I've gathered that he was a significant enemy of the Turtles. His name makes me think he's an Italian mafia boss, but apparently he's like a demon or something? Can anyone enlighten me?

IIRC he's Lord Simultaneous' old apprentice who tried to overthrow him back before LS was training Renet. He was the recurring villain of early Renet stories.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.