The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Character designs that don't match (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=51222)

neatoman 02-21-2015 03:21 AM

Character designs that don't match
 
So does it bother anyone else that IDW's artists can use designs that don't really match each others? As an example:

Here's Bates' Rocksteady.


And here's Santolouco's Rocksteady.


Note that Bates' Rocksteady has red eyes, fangs and tattoos. Santolouco's Rocksteady has yellow eyes, a differently shaped skull, no fangs sticking out and no tattoo's. It's a bit distracting that characters can look very different depending on who is drawing them.

Now keep in mind, I'm not saying all the artists should draw in the same style, that would be absurd and somewhat limiting, I'm talking about the details of the designs. The artists does do a fairly decent job of keeping the human designs consistant between them, look at Karai for example:

Mainly the problem comes with the mutant characters where the details can be all over the place.

Creativemind 02-21-2015 04:19 AM

Yeah, I really don't like when they do that drastic of a change.

Joey Kamikaze 02-21-2015 04:28 AM

It doesn't bug me. *shrug*

Refractive Reflections 02-21-2015 05:54 AM

Don't forget the Turtles' designs especially... from cutesy and childish looking, to lean and athletic, to massively muscular too. Their body structures/frames need at least some consistency rather than being all over the place, ranging from looking like preteen boys to 30-something bodybuilders.

Tazi 02-21-2015 06:13 AM

The thing that really disturbed me was in TMNT/Ghostbusters: When they went through the portal, they had totally different gear on them. Like what the hell?
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/...0fked%20up.png
That's one thing when design changes between storylines, but for one issue it should be consistent at least!


I think what Santolouco/Smith/Campbell did in the last storyarcs is pretty cool: Now all the turtles have somewhat different gear on them fitted to their weapons, and personality, etc. I think artists should stick to that design, and that should even apply to Eastman.

oldmanwinters 02-21-2015 07:59 AM

Personally, I appreciate a diversity of artistic styles. It's one of my favorite phenomenons about comics. Sometimes the style change can be jarring (like when it happens in the course of a single issue, as in the case of TMNT Adventures #24 or the TMNT/Flaming Carrot crossover series). But sometimes it can also be used to great artistic effect, as in the case of Leo's nightmares in IDW TMNT #23.

And I really liked the art shift in the TMNT/Ghostbusters book. I think it really played up the "We're not in Kansas anymore" effect of dimensional crossing.

Tazi 02-21-2015 10:58 AM

I don't have a problem with different art direction, but changing the outfits so often is something else...
I also think that modifications that Santolouco/Campbell did were reasonable, and there's no reason to go back again. I mean you don't really see Batman these days wearing purple gloves again, or panties weared outside of his trousers. (well, except Zero Year, which takes place earlier in the timeline, so it was actually consistent)
There's no reason to add goofy beltbuckles on the turtles again, and remove their scabbards/weapon-stashes. That's not art direct, that's stupid. :ohwell:

Mew 02-21-2015 11:31 AM

My Opinion:http://thecatonmyhead.com/wp-content...207255-001.jpg
I don't care! I like to see different designs!

snake 02-21-2015 11:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MewMeow (Post 1423846)
My Opinion:http://thecatonmyhead.com/wp-content...207255-001.jpg
I don't care! I like to see different designs!

Do you even read IDW?

boywonder26 02-21-2015 12:28 PM

Personally I like the different art style's it keeps things fresh. Some of the drastic changes like one issue theyll have pads and the next they won't that's what bugs me

Mew 02-21-2015 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake (Post 1423850)
Do you even read IDW?

Yes. I've read the first few issues, but I have seen designs vary.

nimajneb 02-21-2015 01:16 PM

It really doesn't bother me.
That said, it was jarring in GB/TMNT to see them vastly different. Normally costumes are the same but you appreciate the artists different interpretations such as going between Campbell's Northampton coda and then back to NY with Santolouco

neatoman 02-21-2015 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MewMeow (Post 1423874)
Yes. I've read the first few issues, but I have seen designs vary.

So you don't at all find it distracting that, let's say, Rocksteady as drawn by Bates has tattoos while Rocksteady drawn by Santolouco does not?

Tazi 02-21-2015 02:55 PM

Or what about Alopex having one finger less in each leg/hand, since the last story arcs?

snake 02-21-2015 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MewMeow (Post 1423874)
Yes. I've read the first few issues, but I have seen designs vary.

Alright. That's good. What do you think of them so far?

nimajneb 02-21-2015 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tazi (Post 1423901)
Or what about Alopex having one finger less in each leg/hand, since the last story arcs?

I've re-read the full series more then once or twice and I've never noticed this,

Tazi 02-21-2015 03:15 PM

Compare her in SHotFC and Mutant World Order.

Coola Yagami 02-21-2015 06:15 PM

I kinda agree and it's very distracting sometimes. It's like the comic version of 'same character/different actor'. The Turtles randomly de-age from one saga to the next and they just randomly change gear without really acknowledge it. They kinda act as if they were wearing the extra gauntlets and such since issue 1.

Artist intrepetation is one thing, like pin ups and whatnot, but Bebop and Rocksteady's legs shouldn't change depending on who's drawing them. And have the characters carry on as if nothing was different.

Karai was a perfect example. She doesn't have a random Foot Tattoo on her arm that vanished from issue or issue, nor does she randomly have long shoulder length hair from one issue and then short the next.

Refractive Reflections 02-21-2015 08:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 1423964)
I kinda agree and it's very distracting sometimes. It's like the comic version of 'same character/different actor'. The Turtles randomly de-age from one saga to the next and they just randomly change gear without really acknowledge it. They kinda act as if they were wearing the extra gauntlets and such since issue 1.

Artist intrepetation is one thing, like pin ups and whatnot, but Bebop and Rocksteady's legs shouldn't change depending on who's drawing them. And have the characters carry on as if nothing was different.

Karai was a perfect example. She doesn't have a random Foot Tattoo on her arm that vanished from issue or issue, nor does she randomly have long shoulder length hair from one issue and then short the next.

With the Turtles' differing body structure and the visual element importance in comics, at times the Turtles can come across as deceptively cute and innocent (if they look childlike) or brutish beasts (if they're muscular), which can change the interpretation of how threatening/aggressive they look and, in the process, change the tone of the scene and issue as a whole.

...I mean it is up to each artist's intrepretation... but the changes can sure be abrupt though. **shrug**

Powder 02-21-2015 08:15 PM

Doesn't bother me at all. We've had this same "problem" in both Mirage & Archie, & personally, I find it one of the coolest things about TMNT comics. No two look the same.

corvus 02-21-2015 08:26 PM

Changing clothes is whatev. The only thing that kind of irked me was the tattoo.

CyberCubed 02-21-2015 08:28 PM

I still love Ben Bates Bebop/Rocksteady designs the most. They have a lot of humor and personality to them, something I don't get in the main series.

I hope Ben Bates gets to draw a Bebop/Rocksteady 4-issue miniseries or something.

Usagi Miyamoto 02-21-2015 09:22 PM

This change in what's previously established is probably what most annoys me about the ever shrinking and deaging turtles.

Creativemind 02-22-2015 12:20 AM

What I hate most is that in the current issues they try and make them look more like the Nick Turtles when there is already a comic line for those versions anyway. :tmad:

neatoman 02-22-2015 02:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1423995)
I still love Ben Bates Bebop/Rocksteady designs the most. They have a lot of humor and personality to them, something I don't get in the main series.

I hope Ben Bates gets to draw a Bebop/Rocksteady 4-issue miniseries or something.

Oh I agree, the way Bates draws them is amazing.

Mew 02-22-2015 04:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake (Post 1423903)
Alright. That's good. What do you think of them so far?

They're really good.
I need to get issue 4 now.

Huzzah 02-22-2015 05:08 PM

The benefit of reading the comics as trades, is that it's usually the same artist through those connected issues, therefore the differences are a lot less noticeable. My favorite artists on the title are definitely Campbell followed by Santolouco.

CyberCubed 02-22-2015 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1424064)
Oh I agree, the way Bates draws them is amazing.

Yeah, something like a small Bebop/Rocksteady mini-series with Ben Bates doing all the art is amazing. His Bebop and Rocksteady have so much personality and they're so fun to look at.

Icegaze 02-23-2015 04:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Usagi Miyamoto (Post 1424003)
This change in what's previously established is probably what most annoys me about the ever shrinking and deaging turtles.

Agreed. Design inconsistency really bothers me. Not art style differences.
I hope IDW artistic team is seriously looking into this thread. Many fans like myself would like a steady character design for each mutant and human. I can barely recognize Alopex nowadays. What happened there??

Sophie Campbell 02-23-2015 07:56 PM

never! we will never comply! :evilgrin:

it's really cool to see most of the artists post-Northampton using the different gear/outfits i came up with for the Turtles, though.

ProphetofGanja 02-23-2015 10:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ross Campbell (Post 1424516)
never! we will never comply! :evilgrin:

lmao Ross you too much man

neatoman 02-24-2015 04:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ross Campbell (Post 1424516)
never! we will never comply! :evilgrin:

it's really cool to see most of the artists post-Northampton using the different gear/outfits i came up with for the Turtles, though.

Just a question Ross, if you were to draw Rocksteady, would you do it with or without the tattoos?

Sophie Campbell 02-24-2015 10:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1424605)
Just a question Ross, if you were to draw Rocksteady, would you do it with or without the tattoos?

i'd draw the tattoos for sure, it adds a lot of character. Ben's Rocksteady and Bebop are the best, i think the B&R micro might be my favorite single issue so far, it's so stylish.

anyway, i see where some of you guys are coming from about the character designs being inconsistent, i admit that as a fan sometimes i don't like things like Alopex suddenly having a different number of fingers or something like that, but i mean ultimately it really doesn't matter, it's so insanely minor unless there's a story that specifically deals with Alopex's finger situations. but more than that, i think you guys aren't seeing how awesome it is that the IDW TMNT artists have that much freedom, you're not seeing it from our perspective. yeah, it's a licensed property and working within certain confines comes with the job, and there are some limitations like obviously i couldn't go in and draw Raph with four arms for no reason, but it's amazing that IDW and Nickelodeon let us add our own personal flourishes on a corporate series like this. i personally think it's an embarrassment of riches and sometimes it makes me sad that some fans don't seem to see it or feel that way. it seems like they want TMNT to be MORE corporate and more restrictive, which baffles me.

what i'm about to say is all my personal opinion based on my own experiences and feelings, so take it with a grain of salt, and obviously i'm not speaking for everyone! but if it were more restrictive with designs i don't think we'd have half the awesome artists we've gotten on this series. there are already enough notes from the powers-that-be, imagine if all us artists got style sheets or something when we signed on detailing how many fingers a character should have, nobody would want to deal with it because it would all be busywork that would never add up to anything. this isn't Marvel or DC where we're swimming in massive paychecks. people would move on. i don't think there's any other corporate comic out there right now that has as many artists working on it who just LOVE this stuff, and i think Nickelodeon and Bobby know that, and the best artwork happens when artists are allowed to have as much fun as possible, and getting guidelines about which character has however many fingers or who has this or that tattoo, it piles up and it wears you down. it starts feeling way more like work than fun, and obviously this IS work, it's a job like any other, and some artists are more than happy to work within that structure, but at the end of the day better work is produced when the editors and powers-that-be know when to step in and most importantly know when to step back.

i was hesitant to post about this, i feel like i'm always coming in here and butting in with behinds-the-scenes posts that squash discussion... i don't know if it's helpful or interesting or just annoying. XD but i really love this series and the people who work on it so sometimes i feel compelled to swoop in! i should probably stop, haha.

neatoman 02-24-2015 10:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ross Campbell (Post 1424669)
i'd draw the tattoos for sure, it adds a lot of character. Ben's Rocksteady and Bebop are the best, i think the B&R micro might be my favorite single issue so far, it's so stylish.

anyway, i see where some of you guys are coming from about the character designs being inconsistent, i admit that as a fan sometimes i don't like things like Alopex suddenly having a different number of fingers or something like that, but i mean ultimately it really doesn't matter, it's so insanely minor unless there's a story that specifically deals with Alopex's finger situations. but more than that, i think you guys aren't seeing how awesome it is that the IDW TMNT artists have that much freedom, you're not seeing it from our perspective. yeah, it's a licensed property and working within certain confines comes with the job, and there are some limitations like obviously i couldn't go in and draw Raph with four arms for no reason, but it's amazing that IDW and Nickelodeon let us add our own personal flourishes on a corporate series like this. i personally think it's an embarrassment of riches and sometimes it makes me sad that some fans don't seem to see it or feel that way. it seems like they want TMNT to be MORE corporate and more restrictive, which baffles me.

what i'm about to say is all my personal opinion based on my own experiences and feelings, so take it with a grain of salt, and obviously i'm not speaking for everyone! but if it were more restrictive with designs i don't think we'd have half the awesome artists we've gotten on this series. there are already enough notes from the powers-that-be, imagine if all us artists got style sheets or something when we signed on detailing how many fingers a character should have, nobody would want to deal with it because it would all be busywork that would never add up to anything. this isn't Marvel or DC where we're swimming in massive paychecks. people would move on. i don't think there's any other corporate comic out there right now that has as many artists working on it who just LOVE this stuff, and i think Nickelodeon and Bobby know that, and the best artwork happens when artists are allowed to have as much fun as possible, and getting guidelines about which character has however many fingers or who has this or that tattoo, it piles up and it wears you down. it starts feeling way more like work than fun, and obviously this IS work, it's a job like any other, and some artists are more than happy to work within that structure, but at the end of the day better work is produced when the editors and powers-that-be know when to step in and most importantly know when to step back.

i was hesitant to post about this, i feel like i'm always coming in here and butting in with behinds-the-scenes posts that squash discussion... i don't know if it's helpful or interesting or just annoying. XD but i really love this series and the people who work on it so sometimes i feel compelled to swoop in! i should probably stop, haha.

Well considering that I was the one to start this thread, let me just say that I did not mean any disrespect towards any of the IDW artists.

I greatly appreciate the wonderful artwork you guys have put out, a lot of you add wonderful personality to it and I'm really happy to hear that IDW is offering a lot of freedom to you when it comes to the artwork. If you weren't given enough freedom then there would have been a risk the comics would feel soulless or sloppy, I understand that. Hopefully everyone here understands artistic freedom is important.

And yes of course, none of the contradictory details in character design really matter as long as the artwork and writing are good, there's a reason the IDW series became my favourite version of TMNT. It's just a little weird that characters can look so different depending on who draws them, but yes that is insignifigant compared to the quality of the artwork itself.

Mew 02-24-2015 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1424678)
Well considering that I was the one to start this thread, let me just say that I did not mean any disrespect towards any of the IDW artists.

I greatly appreciate the wonderful artwork you guys have put out, a lot of you add wonderful personality to it and I'm really happy to hear that IDW is offering a lot of freedom to you when it comes to the artwork. If you weren't given enough freedom then there would have been a risk the comics would feel soulless or sloppy, I understand that. Hopefully everyone here understands artistic freedom is important.

And yes of course, none of the contradictory details in character design really matter as long as the artwork and writing are good, there's a reason the IDW series became my favourite version of TMNT. It's just a little weird that characters can look so different depending on who draws them, but yes that is insignifigant compared to the quality of the artwork itself.

Agreed. No disrespect. They put time and effort into their drawings, and I like the IDW artists' looks. My favorite version of the TMNT!

Mormegil 02-24-2015 11:02 AM

I think it helps a lot and i like that you put yourself out there.

I really like the art Dan Duncan did on the first issues. When i saw the Northampton art and the fact that it leans towards the Nick cartoon show i hated it at first. I figured it was corporate coming down on the comic and making it look more like the cartoon show.

But after i read your posts on the forum about the art being more your choice and having some artistic freedom, I looked back at the material and thought "maybe it isn't so bad after all."

There's nothing wrong with the cartoon show or its art. I just don't want it to bleed over and take away the feel that has already been established.

I defiantly think i judged the Northampton stuff to quickly and i really appreciate you posting on the forums and giving us the insight that you do. Getting the facts is a lot better than watching the fans widely speculate all the time.

Sophie Campbell 02-24-2015 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1424678)
Well considering that I was the one to start this thread, let me just say that I did not mean any disrespect towards any of the IDW artists.

I greatly appreciate the wonderful artwork you guys have put out, a lot of you add wonderful personality to it and I'm really happy to hear that IDW is offering a lot of freedom to you when it comes to the artwork. If you weren't given enough freedom then there would have been a risk the comics would feel soulless or sloppy, I understand that. Hopefully everyone here understands artistic freedom is important.

And yes of course, none of the contradictory details in character design really matter as long as the artwork and writing are good, there's a reason the IDW series became my favourite version of TMNT. It's just a little weird that characters can look so different depending on who draws them, but yes that is insignifigant compared to the quality of the artwork itself.

i knew you didn't mean any disrespect, i hope i didn't come off that way! it's a perfectly valid and legit critique about the character designs varying, i wasn't trying to say anyone with that concern is wrong for feeling that way. like i said even i feel that way sometimes, so i totally get it. ;) i like some variations and others i'm indifferent to, then sometimes an artist will do something that makes me go "what the hell are they doing" (i won't name names! ;D) but i think it's great that they had that freedom even if i'm not personally fond of what they do with it, as i know there are people who don't like what i did with my freedom, either. which is fine! :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mormegil (Post 1424681)
I think it helps a lot and i like that you put yourself out there.

I really like the art Dan Duncan did on the first issues. When i saw the Northampton art and the fact that it leans towards the Nick cartoon show i hated it at first. I figured it was corporate coming down on the comic and making it look more like the cartoon show.

But after i read your posts on the forum about the art being more your choice and having some artistic freedom, I looked back at the material and thought "maybe it isn't so bad after all."

There's nothing wrong with the cartoon show or its art. I just don't want it to bleed over and take away the feel that has already been established.

I defiantly think i judged the Northampton stuff to quickly and i really appreciate you posting on the forums and giving us the insight that you do. Getting the facts is a lot better than watching the fans widely speculate all the time.

thanks! i appreciate that. :) i love a lot of the character designs on the Nick show but i wasn't actively going for that look like i was saying, it was just a combination of my own sensibilities, i've been drawing the Turtles cute and soft-looking for years, and also kinda riffing on what Mateus was doing. if there had been a corporate mandate for imitating the Nick show, or forcing me to draw the Turtles in ANY specific way, period, i never would have taken the job in the first place. i'm that stubborn and that's how much i care about this stuff! anyway i'm glad you guys seem to be cool with me posting like this, i hope it doesn't seem like i'm bringing the hammer down or whatever. this is all great discussion!

Redeemer 02-24-2015 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tazi (Post 1423795)
The thing that really disturbed me was in TMNT/Ghostbusters: When they went through the portal, they had totally different gear on them. Like what the hell?
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/...0fked%20up.png
That's one thing when design changes between storylines, but for one issue it should be consistent at least!


I think what Santolouco/Smith/Campbell did in the last storyarcs is pretty cool: Now all the turtles have somewhat different gear on them fitted to their weapons, and personality, etc. I think artists should stick to that design, and that should even apply to Eastman.

Does anyone notice that Donny is holding a com from the Fred Wolf series????

Duke Nukem 02-24-2015 09:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ross Campbell (Post 1424669)
i was hesitant to post about this, i feel like i'm always coming in here and butting in with behinds-the-scenes posts that squash discussion... i don't know if it's helpful or interesting or just annoying. XD but i really love this series and the people who work on it so sometimes i feel compelled to swoop in! i should probably stop, haha.

Regardless of the effect, more information is always good from our perspective. Much of the discussion that gets squashed involves us speculating, which becomes pointless when someone directly involved is in a position to state facts instead of conjecture.

As for the topic at hand, I think it's great that the artists are given more freedom, but when most of the fanbase is clamoring for something, it's at least worth considering. I'm specifically thinking about Santolouco's turtles now looking like grade-school mutant ninja turtles, which doesn't at all jibe with the overall tone of the story, considering that the turtles are basically fighting for the fate of the entire world. While it's true that many of us fans are resistant to change for no reason at all and don't like to give new interpretations a chance, some things are just not good on their own merit. I give Santolouco credit for trying something different, but I hope that he either returns to his old style, or somehow manages to evolve from the current design into something that works better for the tone of the comic.

spookycookies 02-24-2015 11:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Duke Nukem (Post 1424867)
Regardless of the effect, more information is always good from our perspective. Much of the discussion that gets squashed involves us speculating, which becomes pointless when someone directly involved is in a position to state facts instead of conjecture.

As for the topic at hand, I think it's great that the artists are given more freedom, but when most of the fanbase is clamoring for something, it's at least worth considering. I'm specifically thinking about Santolouco's turtles now looking like grade-school mutant ninja turtles, which doesn't at all jibe with the overall tone of the story, considering that the turtles are basically fighting for the fate of the entire world. While it's true that many of us fans are resistant to change for no reason at all and don't like to give new interpretations a chance, some things are just not good on their own merit. I give Santolouco credit for trying something different, but I hope that he either returns to his old style, or somehow manages to evolve from the current design into something that works better for the tone of the comic.

The transparency of the IDW staff when it comes to this book is the cherry on the top of a great great comic. Lets face it whether you are drawing or reading this comic we all bleed the same ooze, (so to speak.) Insider answers don't always nullify reader discussion but it informs us in a way that we can refine our conversations in a way that we couldn't if the creatives were completely tightlipped.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:54 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.