The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Mateus Santolouco interview: Podcast in a Half-shell (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=52127)

PangolinFeets 05-14-2015 10:59 PM

Mateus Santolouco interview: Podcast in a Half-shell
 
I didn't see this get posted anywhere, but it's a really cool interview. There's a lot of neat behind-the-scene tidbits regarding City Fall and SHotFC. It shows just how much different this comic could be without Nickelodeon pulling in the reigns.

http://popcultureparlour.podbean.com...08d7bef5c1543f

spookycookies 05-15-2015 01:19 AM

Spoiler:
About the original concept for City Fall with Leo being Saki's son. I don't know if that revelation is something that would have really brought him over to the foot. I know the brain washing plot seems cliche but it worked in getting him to the Foot and then his emotional fallout and triumph in Northampton.

Wentos 05-15-2015 02:38 AM

Their description of Volume 3 is so spot-on. This is great.

Powder 05-15-2015 03:26 AM

Could barely sit through half of it, terrible interviewers. If anyone wants to put in some bullet points from what Mateus said, I'd appreciate it.

Wentos 05-15-2015 03:31 AM

I just reached the end of the interview where Mateus is talking about his future plans and I had a wave of dread wash over me as I realized his future with the book is not set in stone.

If Mateus or Cory ever leave this book, I'm just going to cry. I know that's a selfish thing to say and I don't care.

PangolinFeets 05-15-2015 11:09 AM

Here's some quick things off the top of my head I remember being mentioned:

- M.S. talking about how he never wanted to do art for TMNT, but write. He lost out to Eastman, which has been said before, but he was happy to lose to Eastman. I remember in the ninja notes interview he talked about his ideas for his pitch which included some more mature features in the turtles than what they went with.

-He didn't watch the series much as a kid, but he loved the arcade and played it until he could completely break it.

- He wrote basically the whole script for SHotFC while Burhnam just put in little touches here and there. I didn't realize how much work he put into it!

-He mentions that in the original draft for City Fall, instead of brainwashing Leo, Saki was pre-reincartnation Leo's true father. He didn't outright say how that would have happened, but said that Leo would have ended up siding with Saki because he is his real father. This ended up getting nixed by Nickelodeon, but there could have been all kinds of craziness spawning from that idea. I reaaally wish they stayed on this convo more.

- Original Leo's design for City Fall was just a black mask. *snooze*. Thanks for not having that. XD

- His favorite turtle is Mikey.

- He pays attention to online criticism and reviews and brought up some valid complaints. He couldn't believe the internet riot after 44, because super heroes don't die. Lol He mentioned that he liked the decisions of 45, because it made sense. He also mentions that he agrees that Casey Jones has been quite the pubching bag through the series, but he sees that as the writer's way of molding him into something in the future.

They didn't talk much about events following City Fall because one of the interviewers had just started reading it and they didn't want to spoil anything. =/ But it was still pretty interesting to hear some of his thoughts since I don't hear much from him.

Redeemer 05-15-2015 11:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1459102)
Could barely sit through half of it, terrible interviewers. If anyone wants to put in some bullet points from what Mateus said, I'd appreciate it.

I am with Powder the interview was rough.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 05-15-2015 12:04 PM

I'm really glad they didn't make Leo Saki's biological son... that's just a little too outta-left-field for me.

Really? Saki raped and/or seduced Tang Shen? Maybe in some other continuity, but I don't see it for IDW. Doesn't make sense or fit in the timeline.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 05-15-2015 12:14 PM

Now HERE'S how that idea works (just thought of this):

Raphael is older than Leonardo (oldest to youngest: Raph, Leo, Don, Mikey)

But Splinter has always chosen Leonardo to be the leader, not Raphael

This is a major factor in Raphael's resentment of both Splinter and Leo, his temper, his feelings of isolation and anger

Splinter has always maintained that Raphael is not ready to be the leader, until he can master his own anger within

The Shredder seeks out Raphael, isolates him, and reveals the truth: Saki is Raph's biological father, and forcibly took Shen for himself

Yoshi adopted Raphael for his own son, banished Saki from the Clan for his dishonor, and had three sons with Shen

Raphael, furious at what he sees as betrayal at the hands of Hamato Yoshi, willingly joins the Foot, wanting revenge against Leonardo and Splinter

After a couple of violent battles, Raphael is eventually brought back into the fold when the other Turtles and Splinter demonstrate true love for him, unwilling to turn their back on family... (and pointing out that Saki killed Raphael in his former life, despite his true parentage, when the young boy intervened to defend his adopted family)

Saki is forced to retreat, and Raphael slowly reconciles with his adopted brothers

Leo tries to yield his position as leader to Raphael, but Raphael willingly refuses it, saying that he realizes now that he is not ready

But Raphael still does not reconcile with his adopted father, challenging Splinter to honestly answer whether he kept Raphael from leadership because he feared that Raph would become a violent evil man like his father--or because he resented the Turtle's true parentage and what had been done to Tang Shen

PangolinFeets 05-15-2015 01:39 PM

Yea, unfortunately the interviewers didn't really seem to have an itinerary so it suffers. But they still talk about some pretty cool stuff. Like I said, I wish they talked more about the ideas Nickelodeon nixed.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1459280)
I'm really glad they didn't make Leo Saki's biological son... that's just a little too outta-left-field for me.

Really? Saki raped and/or seduced Tang Shen? Maybe in some other continuity, but I don't see it for IDW. Doesn't make sense or fit in the timeline.

I love that you said Leo being Saki's biological son was too weird for you, but then you just came up with a what-if of the same scenario but with Raph. XD

Its definitely an intriguing idea, but I like what they went with. There seems to be a good balance of dark themes without being too disturbing in this series.

neatoman 05-15-2015 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1459280)
I'm really glad they didn't make Leo Saki's biological son... that's just a little too outta-left-field for me.

Really? Saki raped and/or seduced Tang Shen? Maybe in some other continuity, but I don't see it for IDW. Doesn't make sense or fit in the timeline.

Rape didn't really enter my mind, seduction did though. Eh, I think that would have been great for Leo to be Saki's reincarnated son.

Klunk1234 05-15-2015 01:55 PM

I'm so glad that Oroku Saki is not Leo's real father. It would be a very shocking twist.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 05-15-2015 01:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PangolinFeets (Post 1459332)
Yea, unfortunately the interviewers didn't really seem to have an itinerary so it suffers. But they still talk about some pretty cool stuff. Like I said, I wish they talked more about the ideas Nickelodeon nixed.



I love that you said Leo being Saki's biological son was too weird for you, but then you just came up with a what-if of the same scenario but with Raph. XD

Its definitely an intriguing idea, but I like what they went with. There seems to be a good balance of dark themes without being too disturbing in this series.

Too outta-left-field for IDW. The series had gone too far and too long in a different direction, where going that way (Saki--> Leo) would have been a lot of hand-waving retroactive explaining. As a different continuity, it's an intriguing possibility.

I just don't see how they could easily explain Saki having fathered Leo, when we'd already seen so much of Yoshi, Shen, and Saki's history before City Fall and that particular revelation.

Now, if it had been something Mateus had proposed much earlier in the series... possibly it could have worked.

Metalhead 2.0 05-15-2015 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1459347)
Too outta-left-field for IDW. The series had gone too far and too long in a different direction, where going that way (Saki--> Leo) would have been a lot of hand-waving retroactive explaining. As a different continuity, it's an intriguing possibility.

I just don't see how they could easily explain Saki having fathered Leo, when we'd already seen so much of Yoshi, Shen, and Saki's history before City Fall and that particular revelation.

Now, if it had been something Mateus had proposed much earlier in the series... possibly it could have worked.

Yeah, it would have felt forced at that point. It's definitely jarring to ponder on though. I have mixed feelings on it, but in the end it just leaves me feeling angry for some reason. Not to mention it really kind of shatters the dynamic of the team to think that one of them is not blood brothers and is actually the spawn of the enemy. There would always be some amount of distrust and an air of caution when approaching Leo.

Now for a real bummer think of the implications (given the current situation) if Donnie were the one that was Saki's son.
Talk about aholes and omelets...

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 05-15-2015 02:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metalhead 2.0 (Post 1459353)
Yeah, it would have felt forced at that point. It's definitely jarring to ponder on though. I have mixed feelings on it, but in the end it just leaves me feeling angry for some reason. Not to mention it really kind of shatters the dynamic of the team to think that one of them is not blood brothers and is actually the spawn of the enemy. There would always be some amount of distrust and an air of caution when approaching Leo.

Now for a real bummer think of the implications (given the current situation) if Donnie were the one that was Saki's son.
Talk about aholes and omelets...

Words cannot express how hard it is for me to restrain my laughter as I sit at my desk at work. Dammit Saki! You A-HOLE!!! Can you just try vegan!?

Bobby Curnow 05-15-2015 06:00 PM

Saki as Leo's father was something we discussed around the time of Shadows of the Past, before the Splinter Micro and a good deal before Secret History. There's a couple ways it could have gone, but first idea was to make Saki Shen's first husband. Shen, with child by this time, leaves Saki when he turns too violent and ambitious. She eventually meets and marries Yoshi, who adopts her son.

Would have deepened the personal rift between Saki and Yoshi, and added some other story elements. However, it would have been a big change that might have raised more problems than interesting story elements, especially in regards to how it would color Leonardo's character for the rest of the series. We didn't think much more about it after it was nixed as a possibility (we were not set on it, just raised it as a "can we do this?" question) and quickly went down our current path...

...which was City Fall as we know it!

Powder 05-15-2015 06:06 PM

It's a VERY interesting idea, & it would be a great way to explain why Leo is so driven to do good in ways his brothers would never understand. I'm glad it didn't go that way for how it might complicate things, but yeah, that's a gnarly concept. If ever there were an alternate universe kinda thing, I'd love to see it explored.

Thanks for the cliffnotes, PF. Too bad they couldn't delve deeper with Mateus!

AquaParade 05-15-2015 06:19 PM

I really wish Nickelodeon woukd have let IDW carry out that concept. I can sometimes judge the IDW series harshly, when it disappoints me, but this truly show how tied their hands are, creative freedom wise.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 05-15-2015 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1459496)
Saki as Leo's father was something we discussed around the time of Shadows of the Past, before the Splinter Micro and a good deal before Secret History. There's a couple ways it could have gone, but first idea was to make Saki Shen's first husband. Shen, with child by this time, leaves Saki when he turns too violent and ambitious. She eventually meets and marries Yoshi, who adopts her son.

Would have deepened the personal rift between Saki and Yoshi, and added some other story elements. However, it would have been a big change that might have raised more problems than interesting story elements, especially in regards to how it would color Leonardo's character for the rest of the series. We didn't think much more about it after it was nixed as a possibility (we were not set on it, just raised it as a "can we do this?" question) and quickly went down our current path...

...which was City Fall as we know it!

That makes me much less skeptical, knowing that you guys weren't half-assing it but were considering it from the beginning.

I'll say it again: In IDW We Trust

Metalhead 2.0 05-15-2015 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1459521)
That makes me much less skeptical, knowing that you guys weren't half-assing it but were considering it from the beginning.

I'll say it again: In IDW We Trust

You know, the reincarnation thing was handled so well and felt so natural that I've just realised that (in my head) I've unknowingly retconned all previous and current versions of the turtles to include it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 05-15-2015 10:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metalhead 2.0 (Post 1459583)
You know, the reincarnation thing was handled so well and felt so natural that I've just realised that (in my head) I've unknowingly retconned all previous and current versions of the turtles to include it.

:tlol: When I only have the budget for one TMNT TPB and I have to choose between the Mirage canon and the new IDW canon, I don't even think about it... IDW every time. At some point I'll catch up and get the Collected Books for Volume 2 (Mirage), but DAMN. IDW beats everything else. It is a giant standing upon the shoulders of lesser, though amazing, giants.

Redeemer 05-15-2015 11:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1459501)
It's a VERY interesting idea, & it would be a great way to explain why Leo is so driven to do good in ways his brothers would never understand. I'm glad it didn't go that way for how it might complicate things, but yeah, that's a gnarly concept. If ever there were an alternate universe kinda thing, I'd love to see it explored.

Thanks for the cliffnotes, PF. Too bad they couldn't delve deeper with Mateus!

This would be a great way to explain his drive. Could also explain why Leo and Raph always clashed in past incarnations.

Wentos 05-15-2015 11:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby Curnow (Post 1459496)
Saki as Leo's father was something we discussed around the time of Shadows of the Past, before the Splinter Micro and a good deal before Secret History. There's a couple ways it could have gone, but first idea was to make Saki Shen's first husband. Shen, with child by this time, leaves Saki when he turns too violent and ambitious. She eventually meets and marries Yoshi, who adopts her son.

Would have deepened the personal rift between Saki and Yoshi, and added some other story elements. However, it would have been a big change that might have raised more problems than interesting story elements, especially in regards to how it would color Leonardo's character for the rest of the series. We didn't think much more about it after it was nixed as a possibility (we were not set on it, just raised it as a "can we do this?" question) and quickly went down our current path...

...which was City Fall as we know it!

Thanks for the clarification, Bobby. I'm not a fan of making the brothers unrelated by blood myself.

Though now I can't help but wonder how many story ideas have been nixed because Nickelodeon deemed them "questionable". I hate the idea that this book has its hands tied for the sake of keeping the brand kid-friendly.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 05-15-2015 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wentos (Post 1459610)
Thanks for the clarification, Bobby. I'm not a fan of making the brothers unrelated by blood myself.

Though now I can't help but wonder how many story ideas have been nixed because Nickelodeon deemed them "questionable". I hate the idea that this book has its hands tied for the sake of keeping the brand kid-friendly.

This just confirms what some of us already knew; Nickelodeon totally has IDW on a leash. :tsad:

But we're still getting damn good TMNT, in spite of those kid-friendly suits.

Redeemer 05-15-2015 11:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1459613)
This just confirms what some of us already knew; Nickelodeon totally has IDW on a leash. :tsad:

But we're still getting damn good TMNT, in spite of those kid-friendly suits.

Yeah I am really annoyed by the fact that they have a product like TMNT on a damn leash.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.