![]() |
Reincarnation
So now that it's been almost four years since the new origin story was revealed, a couple of questions:
And just to answer my own questions right away: Spoiler:
|
Quote:
To me it filled in some of the problems I've always had with the turtles. For example Splinter: He was always either a rat first who learned martial arts from a book/by watching his master from his cage or he was a master martial artist exiled from Japan to present day New York. First of all (as far as him being a rat), I've been a student of various martial arts since I was able to stand and anyone who knows anything about it knows that there's a whole lot more to it than what you can learn from a single book or by watching some guy do moves. There are rituals, beliefs, meditations, and understandings that must be adopted in order to master. It's much more than just "moves", it is a mindset and almost a religion in it's own right. Things that cannot be taught, but instead are an evolution of one's self. Second of all (as far as him being an exiled ninja), it was always hard for me to believe that there was still some prominent clan of ninja trained in the ancient ways that were still operating in present day Japan. I had a hard time buying into that notion. So for me it was a win in that it took away some of those elements from previous origins that I felt were utterly stupid despite my love for the turtles. |
I'm still not a fan of the reincarnation bit, but at least the comic is good enough that it's not really a big issue.
|
I liked Splinter being the reincarnated form of Hamato Yoshi as its a nice way to mix his human and rat origins together. I like Shredder being reincarnated too, because it reminds me of 4kids Shredder where he was around for thousands of years, only this Shredder is completely human.
I wasn't too keen on the Turtles being reincarnated humans, but I don't think it really matters. As said, it was handled well so its not a big deal. |
I think it works great. It makes a lot more sense that the turtles and shredder cling to the old martial arts.
It just makes the turtles and splinter that much more close. |
Quote:
|
I PERSONALLY LOVE IT! Liked it in the beginning, like it now, wish it's be used in all future versions! It gives Splinter an actual reason to hate shredder beyond 'you killed the human who fed me'. Also, the reincarnation angle gives a better explanation than a normal rat copying ninja moves from a cage. I also like how it combines the two origins; Splinter has always been a rat, yet is also hamato yoshi at the same time!
As I said before, the rat origin, no matter how you try to coat it, has always seemed stupid to me- original mirage or no. I can't sympathize will a still un-mutated Splinter seeking revenge for his dead owner, it's just pushes my suspension of disbelief over the edge. |
At first I wasn't crazy about the idea, mainly because it was an easy out to the turtles knowing martial arts. Over time I have come to appreciate the angle they took as it makes as much sense as any origin they have done, I suppose. It has also allowed them to set up a conflict that is much bigger than the average scenario in a way that doesn't feel forced. I guess it could work for future incarnations but only if it ties in to the whole story like in the IDW series.
|
I always liked the concept of people coming back to life as animals. Perhaps all the mutants in this series happen to have the personalities of whoever they were in a previous life. It would certainly explain how they're able to behave the way they do instead of showing them start off as babies. I'd love to see Old Hob discover that he and the rest of the Mutanimals were all human once before.
|
Quote:
|
For a while I was waiting for it to be revealed as a possible fabrication, which could've been a non-melodramatic source of conflict for the Turtles -- a "What do we make of ourselves?" akin to much of Mirage.
The ship has sailed on that with the number of outside forces seeming to confirm their reincarnation. And for what it's worth, it plays well within the structure of the IDW series, where everything seems to stem back to actions on the part of a few characters in fuedal Japan (or earlier). It does introduce some questions the series isn't quite equipped to answer (the oddness of the Turtles keeping their new names and not knowing their old ones, the role of Tang Shen, etc. (also the fact that Tang Shen is a Chinese woman in feudal Japan) -- but it works well enough in this incarnation and certainly remains one of the series' more interesting elements. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
No, no revealing the reincarnation to be fake would not have been more interesting, not have been more compelling. It just takes us right back to the same old 'pet gets revenge' origin the other versions have. For the four brothers it might have been interesting, but Splinter should remain Yoshi- it better illustrates the whole 'vengeance' plot. Besides, man seeking revenge for his murdered family and lost life resonates more with people than fido seeking revenge for the guy that feeds him!
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Honestly this is the best (and least goofy) origin story for the Turtles, and I hope it becomes the defining one in the years to come. It eliminates the suspension of disbelief necessary to accept a rat becoming a ninjitsu master by watching a guy do a few moves and it gives the whole story a more personal slant. I think its definitely an improvement all-around, and I guess that most people who take issue with it are somewhat biased by nostalgia or whatever
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I think it's the best change to come out of the IDW series.
If nothing else, it's my favorite change. |
Quote:
I mean, it does. But in a kind of trite, straight-forward way. It works if you're to imbue the vengeance with a bit of credence. One of the joys of, say, the Mirage series, is that you're absolutely not clear how legitimate Splinter's vendetta is. He was a pet rat; he has no business even starting what he does with the Turtles. And that ambiguity colored a lot of their world once the series matured. The entire vengeance bit was destructive and misguided from the start. |
I choose to think of IDW's Splinter as being more upset that he didn't keep his promise to Tang Shen, rather than being upset that she died.
Mostly because I'm tired of writers killing women to give their partners something to do. |
Quote:
But on the other hand, it does give us an absolutely bloodier feud between Saki and Yoshi. Which is AWESOME. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I think the reason the turtles are easier for me to believe in is because they learned everything they know from Splinter (and various media). How to speak, social etiquette, values, morals, principles, how to walk... just basically everything that would be considered a "human" quality/characteristic and not something that a turtle instinctively does came from him. But where did he learn it? Because if you go by the rat origin then he wasn't fully mutated very long before they were and all of those things are traits he would have to develop/learn on his own before teaching them. He didn't learn how to speak/read English in his cage, or how to use a spoon or dress himself or cook. And that's why it's stupid. A rat is a voracious creature that has two main goals in life: 1. To Eat (they'll even eat their own babies) 2. To Reproduce So the first thing he would have done is ate the turtles and then rape the first person he saw. He wouldn't have helped them... That's why I've always preferred the origins where he is Hamato Yoshi as a man that's mutated into a rat-being as opposed to a stupid rat that's mutated into a humanoid creature. But the reincarnation angle takes the best of both origins and makes a much more logical origin than any before. |
Quote:
|
Um....citation? Because, I've never seen a domestic rat, which Splinter was, behave that way. In fact they're really intelligent animals, which is why we've used them in medical experimentation for years.
My issue with the Yoshi/Splinter angle is that it comes way too-close-for-my-comfort to propaganda the United States utilized during WWII, which depicted the Japanese as rodents. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
And we don't use them in medical experiments because of their intelligence. We use them because they're cheap, easy to reproduce, and biologically similar to humans. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
As far as suspension-of-disbelief, since that seems to be where discussion is headed, IDW's version is hardly free of blemishes.
I pointed these out last page, but there's a lot of holes the series won't or can't address. Tang Shen is now a Chinese woman (presumably?) in feudal Japan. She isn't re-incarnated (could possibly be explained by Kitsune playing a role in the whole thing, but that remains to be seen). We can't/don't know the Turtles' original names, when we do know Splinter's. There are quite a few ways in which the origin has to buck against what would make the most sense in order to accommodate elements readers are familiar with, and they're sometimes hard to ignore. Mirage's origin may be sillier from the get-go, but it only requires that one comic-book-ish leap, which fits in just fine with the early tone of the series and the anything-goes genre and pastiche elements that continue to mark it. The original origin is premised on one central absurdity that's within the terms of its genre and doesn't ask you to take it seriously. IDW's is still plagued by several while asking readers to take it quite seriously. It's A-OK within its series, but there's still quite a bit of trying to have its cake and eat it too. For it too feel really solid, I think we'd need it to depart even further from familiar territory. Also, I gotta call BS on the idea that IDW somehow takes care of the silliness of mutated animals suddenly being adept at being humanoid. Look at all of the Mutanimals and Foot mutants. Old Hob walks out of an alleyway making f*cking quips. |
Quote:
Tang could have been the daughter of a visiting merchant from China there under the protection of a Daimyo, or the daughter of a diplomat visiting from the Chinese imperial court- there was still SOME contact, even during the Sengoku and Edo. She didn't reincarnate because her anger didn't hold her to the reincarnation cycle like it did yoshi and the boys, and she ascended to nirvana. She's talking to her sons and husband as a bodhisattva, trying to guide them on the proper path. That's just one possibility And why do we need to know their original names? Their memories are more fragmentary than splinter's, so it's this lifetime that is who they are, and not the past one like Yoshi's. And I still despise the rat origin, for both stated and other reasons. |
Quote:
And as far as their names... Spoiler:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
different strokes for different folks, but i have to say i'm surprised at the negativity toward the Mirage/1990 movie origin. i've always loved the original origin, i find Splinter having been a rat rather than a human or reincarnated-human-in-a-rat makes him more relatable. for me, i always remember a line from the 1985 TMNT tabletop RPG book, that talks about the various ways animal characters can be mutated, and it said something like Splinter was clearly never an ordinary rat to begin with, he could be said to be a mutant before he was mutated, so to speak. i don't think the comparisons some people have made here about the dog learning football or whatever really work, partly because it's a fantasy story, but as far as the context of the TMNT world goes, Splinter is just obviously not a run of the mill rat. i always really liked that aspect.
|
I guess the plausibility of pre-mutated splinter as a rat goes up if he's not just a normal rat... but that was never officially established in most versions. Also, I personally feel that the stakes of his loss are higher if he was human- the loss of a family and your humanity vs. the loss of the guy who keeps you in a cage and feeds you. (I know there are strong bonds between cats and dogs and their owners, but I've never seen anything on a similar bond with a rat.)
|
Is humanity really that big a deal?
That's like putting human's in a higher pedestal then animals. Losing the ability to interact and socialize, sure. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:48 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.