The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   The worst of Mirage (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=52350)

neatoman 06-03-2015 12:00 PM

The worst of Mirage
 
So I have read through all of what IDW has reprinted of Mirage, which I think is the vast majority of what came out before the Image series and about a fourth of Tales volume 2.

So my general verdict on pre-Image Mirage and a good chunk of Tales volume 2 is that it's generally good, not amazing or the best that TMNT has to offer (in fact, even the good stories tend to be a bumpy in quality) but still decent over all. And what prevents it from being really good instead of just good is some really awkward storytelling, and there does not seem to be any shortage of Mirage stories that don't really work.

So what would you say is the worst of Mirage?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-03-2015 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1467261)
So I have read through all of what IDW has reprinted of Mirage, which I think is the vast majority of what came out before the Image series and about a fourth of Tales volume 2.

So my general verdict on pre-Image Mirage and a good chunk of Tales volume 2 is that it's generally good, not amazing or the best that TMNT has to offer (in fact, even the good stories tend to be a bumpy in quality) but still decent over all. And what prevents it from being really good instead of just good is some really awkward storytelling, and there does not seem to be any shortage of Mirage stories that don't really work.

So what would you say is the worst of Mirage?

The "Guest Era" of Volume 1. It spans from around Issue #22 (1989) to Issue #45 (1992) and is just the worst mess of inane random crap.

Now there ARE some good stories mixed in there, like "Sons of the Silent Age", the "River" trilogy, and even an interesting alternate-reality take, the "Souls Winter" trilogy. But the rest is pretty much garbage.

Tales Volume 2 is runner-up, because it breaks down to about 33% Awesome stories, 33% Okay stories, and 33% Terrible stories. And it also has about six to ten different story arcs that never got finished and totally deserved completion. (We feel your pain, Tristan Jones.)

CyberCubed 06-03-2015 12:20 PM

Besides some of the guest issues in Volume 1, and the overall mediocrity of Volume 4, I'd say the following:

- The crossovers. Both the Flaming Carrot and Savage Dragon mini's were pretty bland.

- Bodycount was really only enjoyable to see Raph killing people with guns, the story was nonsencial.

- Issue 15 that introduces the Justice Force...never cared for it

bjaxx87 06-03-2015 12:29 PM

I'm reading according to the timeline and reached the end of volume 2 without skipping a single story. I think so far Tales Vol. 2 #19, #22 and #26 were those that I really, really disliked.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-03-2015 12:34 PM

C.O.W.Boys of Moo Mesa. Can't stand that we had THREE issues of that instead of a conclusion to the Mistress, the Three Mystics, or the Gang War storylines.

WTF Mirage... WTF

CyberCubed 06-03-2015 12:42 PM

I enjoyed the vast majority of Tales Volume 2, it did have 70 issues overall so there were tons of great issues there. Even the less interesting ones weren't exactly awful, they were just there.

In fact I'd say Tales Volume 2 had the most consistent quality of any Mirage volume. And that's because Volume 1 was dragged down by guest issues, Volume 2 was too short, Tales V. 1 was only 7 issues, and Volume 4 was mediocre.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-03-2015 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1467288)
I enjoyed the vast majority of Tales Volume 2, it did have 70 issues overall so there were tons of great issues there. Even the less interesting ones weren't exactly awful, they were just there.

In fact I'd say Tales Volume 2 had the most consistent quality of any Mirage volume. And that's because Volume 1 was dragged down by guest issues, Volume 2 was too short, Tales V. 1 was only 7 issues, and Volume 4 was mediocre.

How can you say that, Cubed?

Tales Volume 1: 7 issues
Volume 2: 13 issues
Tales Volume 2: 70 issues

The quality is more consistent in either Tales Volume 1 or Mirage Volume 2 simply due to the fact that they both present a smaller sample pool. The consistency across 70 issues of anything Mirage is gonna be completely whack, as opposed to the consistency of IDW's ~70 in-continuity TMNT issues so far.

Numbers and math, man... numbers and math.

CyberCubed 06-03-2015 12:57 PM

70 issues with at least 50 of them being good or above average is certainly more enjoyment than a small run.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-03-2015 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1467292)
70 issues with at least 50 of them being good or above average is certainly more enjoyment than a small run.

I think most people would credit Tales Volume 2 with no more than half of the stories being good or great. Would be interesting to see numbers on that... maybe a poll?

Whereas I think most people would agree that at least four out of seven issues of Tales Volume 1 are good or great (Cousin Sid, I Monster, Leatherhead, Savanti Romero)...

Cryomancer 06-03-2015 01:09 PM

April as a drawing is pretty whatever, but the time travel cockroach stuff is just....why.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-03-2015 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cryomancer (Post 1467307)
April as a drawing is pretty whatever, but the time travel cockroach stuff is just....why.

Why? Because experimental drugs, man. :tlol:

CyberCubed 06-03-2015 04:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1467303)
I think most people would credit Tales Volume 2 with no more than half of the stories being good or great. Would be interesting to see numbers on that... maybe a poll?

Whereas I think most people would agree that at least four out of seven issues of Tales Volume 1 are good or great (Cousin Sid, I Monster, Leatherhead, Savanti Romero)...

I liked the entire original Tales run. Granted the Complete Carnage issue was nothing special, but it was still decent.

Jephael 06-03-2015 04:37 PM

I can't really say I hated any issue of the Mirage comics, though I will say I was not looking forward to the re-write of Vol. 1 #8. I understand why they wanted to do it, but at the same time I enjoyed that issue as it originally was, Cerebus and all.

Cryomancer 06-03-2015 05:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jephael (Post 1467435)
I can't really say I hated any issue of the Mirage comics, though I will say I was not looking forward to the re-write of Vol. 1 #8. I understand why they wanted to do it, but at the same time I enjoyed that issue as it originally was, Cerebus and all.

The rewrite doesn't really contradict the original, they go together fairly well.

Powder 06-03-2015 09:48 PM

I like Vol. 4 & certain portions of the guest era least of all (Like the Hedden & Mcweeney stuff). That being said, I still enjoy it all on some level, but they have less re-reading value to me.

Leo656 06-03-2015 09:59 PM

Everything about April's "Secret Origin". That was some of the biggest bullsh*t I ever forced myself to re-read. The moment you've realized Peter Laird had become George Lucas, and that pretty much anybody could handle his creation better than him by that point.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-03-2015 10:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1467588)
Everything about April's "Secret Origin". That was some of the biggest bullsh*t I ever forced myself to re-read. The moment you've realized Peter Laird had become George Lucas, and that pretty much anybody could handle his creation better than him by that point.

Gospel truth, my man...

ctt4lfecw 06-04-2015 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1467588)
Everything about April's "Secret Origin". That was some of the biggest bullsh*t I ever forced myself to re-read. The moment you've realized Peter Laird had become George Lucas, and that pretty much anybody could handle his creation better than him by that point.

So much this.

DK2 06-05-2015 02:10 AM

Definitely the creator filler run in Vol. 1. It had no end of being almost shameful with few acceptions. It really shouldn't have happened at all. I don't get why anyone can bicker about Tales Vol 1. Its so much apart of their Turtles' Northampton time. Really the stories in there are no better than the short stories. Tales Vol. 2 was probably the most best in terms of narrative and where there could've been/were some arcs. Something TMNT Vol. 1 never could do until RTY and CAW arcs. TMNT Vol. 2 was OK. Some were not so good to being good. The one bad one I recall was the early issues where it was about the worms from RTY post Shredder death. I found it hard to accept that they were still out there after RTY's ending. Should've not told that story. Even Tales V2 #70 at least filled a gap in RTY. TMNT Vol. 4 was OK to good. Vol. 3 may have been the most engaging because of the action and pacing. Something that was the most saddest part on V2 and V4. They were paced at such a slow rate, Vol. 4 in particular. But the April "revealed origin" issue was really shocking. But I also remember it being the most emotional issue I've read of TMNT. Coming from April's mind and thoughts of the revelation, her voice got to me. I'm not too negative about Mirage s worst I guess.

Xav 06-05-2015 02:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1467588)
Everything about April's "Secret Origin". That was some of the biggest bullsh*t I ever forced myself to re-read. The moment you've realized Peter Laird had become George Lucas, and that pretty much anybody could handle his creation better than him by that point.

Even Michael Bay?

neatoman 06-05-2015 03:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xav (Post 1468052)
Even Michael Bay?

Or Haim Saban?

Panda_Kahn_fan 06-05-2015 10:58 AM

Personal taste aside, the stories, plots and characters I despised was;

-April O' Neal the magic drawing, who mates and produces offspring as a roach. (Gee, thanks Renet!)

-Shredder Shark. Would've rather had Armaggon than this bad joke of a character.

-The time-travelling ball of snot with eye stalks that turned out to be a little girl when time got changed. What the-!?

-So we can't have animal mutants or characters from the OT, but we CAN have; wierd fish creature, turtle monster and it's egg, an athro Punisher knock-off that paddles people instead of killing them, dinosaurs ladies breeding with Mikey, and- I really don't need to go on!

At least the image run, with it's severd limbs and cyborgs, was entertaining in it's absurdity.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1468150)
Personal taste aside, the stories, plots and characters I despised was;

-April O' Neal the magic drawing, who mates and produces offspring as a roach. (Gee, thanks Renet!)

-Shredder Shark. Would've rather had Armaggon than this bad joke of a character.

-The time-travelling ball of snot with eye stalks that turned out to be a little girl when time got changed. What the-!?

-So we can't have animal mutants or characters from the OT, but we CAN have; wierd fish creature, turtle monster and it's egg, an athro Punisher knock-off that paddles people instead of killing them, dinosaurs ladies breeding with Mikey, and- I really don't need to go on!

At least the image run, with it's severd limbs and cyborgs, was entertaining in it's absurdity.

I liked Seri and Mikey getting it on... really wish Volume 4 had a proper conclusion so we could see where that storyline went.

But yeah, everything else you mentioned is absurdly bad. Like, drug-trip bad.

CyberCubed 06-05-2015 12:45 PM

Well Mirage had no real rogues gallery. Every major villain they met either died after one or two appearances or became an ally:

- Shredder dies in the first issue. His clones die by RTNY.

- Karai becomes an ally during City at War which is her first appearance.

- Baxter only really appears twice, once during #2 and we don't see him again till Volume 2. After that he's pretty much gone besides one brief panel in Volume 4 where he's only shown again to kill him off.

- Rat King dies in his first appearance, becomes a ghost after that.

- Leatherhead becomes an ally in his first appearance.

- Utroms become allies in their first story arc

- The Triceratons appear a few times at least


I think the only real recurring villain was Savanti Romero who reappeared in a lot of Renet issues.

Leo656 06-05-2015 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xav (Post 1468052)
Even Michael Bay?

Much as I'm loathe to admit it, the movie did make money. More people have seen that movie than will EVER read Vol. 4, or ALL of Mirage, for that matter.

And yes, much as it pains me to admit it, literally EVERY THING in that awful movie, was better than "April is a drawing". And also that cockroach bullsh*t. Christ.

Kinda sucks that the guy most fans refer to as "THE Creator" of TMNT (since Kev mostly checked out a long time ago) is the guy responsible for making the worst idea of all "canon". But then I've always thought he was kind of a hack. I mean nothing personal, I'm glad for him and Kev creating the Turtles, but I really don't think they're all that creative or talented. I mean you look and see, when they're on their own, the kind of sh*t they produce. It's like they hit a creative peak one night when they were doing bong hits and doodling, that became TMNT #1, and they've never come close to that since.

But that's ok. Neither Seigel nor Shuster was very good, either.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 08:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1468339)
Much as I'm loathe to admit it, the movie did make money. More people have seen that movie than will EVER read Vol. 4, or ALL of Mirage, for that matter.

And yes, much as it pains me to admit it, literally EVERY THING in that awful movie, was better than "April is a drawing". And also that cockroach bullsh*t. Christ.

Kinda sucks that the guy most fans refer to as "THE Creator" of TMNT (since Kev mostly checked out a long time ago) is the guy responsible for making the worst idea of all "canon". But then I've always thought he was kind of a hack. I mean nothing personal, I'm glad for him and Kev creating the Turtles, but I really don't think they're all that creative or talented. I mean you look and see, when they're on their own, the kind of sh*t they produce. It's like they hit a creative peak one night when they were doing bong hits and doodling, that became TMNT #1, and they've never come close to that since.

But that's ok. Neither Seigel not Shuster was very good, either.

I totally agree with you. Together they had some sort of weird mental creative balancing act that canceled out each other's crap and produced amazing stuff like the original #1-12 issues, Return to New York, and City at War. But by themselves, they're pretty terrible.

I'll say it again: Peter Laird and Kevin Eastman are the Firestorm of comic writers. Apart, they are nothing. Together, they can do great things.

Xav 06-05-2015 09:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1468150)
-April O' Neal the magic drawing, who mates and produces offspring as a roach. (Gee, thanks Renet!)

I know April was a drawing but when did she become a roach?
Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1468195)
- Baxter only really appears twice, once during #2 and we don't see him again till Volume 2. After that he's pretty much gone besides one brief panel in Volume 4 where he's only shown again to kill him off.

Stockman also appeared in Donatello: The Brain Thief.

Leo656 06-05-2015 09:33 PM

It was some kind of time-travel loophole; April had to inhabit the body of a roach while in the past, so she would be inconsequential and not accidentally disrupt anything that could affect the future/present.

The book makes it quite clear that, while a roach, April mates with another roach and (I'm pretty sure, but it's been a while since I read it) produced offspring. Pretty gross, pretty stupid.

I've seen a ton of dumb retcons and "secret origins" in my day, but this is still one of the dumbest things I've EVER read in any comic. Just f*ckin' brutal. I never really got back into Vol. 4 after that. I still read it, but I was detached; I'd never liked it much to start, and it just got worse, and after that mess, I had to force myself to read each new issue. I was honestly glad when they cancelled it; it really wasn't worth the inflated cover price, I was only buying it out of brand loyalty, and I always hated myself after reading it. I felt double-guilty because the comic store I went to only ordered it for me, not one other person was buying it, and I wasn't even really into it.

Tales was really good, though. Tales should've been the main book, and Vol. 4 just shouldn't have happened.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1468371)
It was some kind of time-travel loophole; April had to inhabit the body of a roach while in the past, so she would be inconsequential and not accidentally disrupt anything that could affect the future/present.

The book makes it quite clear that, while a roach, April mates with another roach and (I'm pretty sure, but it's been a while since I read it) produced offspring. Pretty gross, pretty stupid.

I've never actually read the issue in question myself, only ever heard of it and its events from fellow fans.

But WHAT. THE. F*** was Laird thinking?

Drugs, kids... Not even once! :teek:

Leo656 06-05-2015 09:45 PM

To be fair, it comes in handy sometimes. Like whenever someone mentions how "gross" it would be for April to F*** one of the Turtles, it's fun to point out, "She's done worse, AND it's canon!" :lol:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 09:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1468377)
To be fair, it comes in handy sometimes. Like whenever someone mentions how "gross" it would be for April to F*** one of the Turtles, it's fun to point out, "She's done worse, AND it's canon!" :lol:

Laird frowns upon turtle on turtle action (re: Venus de Milo) and yet he gives us April O'Neil roach on roach action?

The hypocrisy is too much. FAR too much. (that and the really REALLY bad taste.)

Redeemer 06-05-2015 10:21 PM

I have only read the ultimate collection stuff and all issues up to 20 or so. I really don't remember one bad story.
I think Mirage actually has the best stories. The original Leonardo Micro is my all time favorite TMNT story across any media.

Mind you have not read the Archie series or Tales, but all the current IDW issues.

LeotheLateBloomer 06-05-2015 11:08 PM

I heard about this issue (April mating with a roach) but I thought it was just a hoax someone made up. What issue was this?

Duke Nukem 06-05-2015 11:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1468382)
Laird frowns upon turtle on turtle action (re: Venus de Milo) and yet he gives us April O'Neil roach on roach action?

The hypocrisy is too much. FAR too much. (that and the really REALLY bad taste.)

I think Laird disapproves of turtles mating because part of what makes the TMNT who they are is that there are no female turtles for them and no possibility of such (outside of TNM), so their only option is inter-species mating.

I agree with E&L each being not too good without the other. I have no problem with April being a drawing. Probably the worst of Mirage's TMNT for me would be Mark Martin's #22 and especially #23, and the Spaced Out trilogy. I'm sure there's a few others I've forgotten, but most of it is at least okay.

neatoman 06-06-2015 06:34 AM

April as a roach mating with another roach? Sounds stupid but also kind of interesting, when IDW gets to it I'll probably try to figure out the purpose of that.

I always wondered though, was the origin story for April in the Nick show at all inspired by the magic drawing revelation?

LeotheLateBloomer 06-06-2015 10:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1468150)
So we can't have animal mutants or characters from the OT

People keep bringing this up and I keep asking, how often do you see canon-immigrants occur in a comic book? The only exception I can think of is Harley Quinn and Barbara Gordon (the latter being a joint idea).

CyberCubed 06-07-2015 12:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeotheLateBloomer (Post 1468843)
People keep bringing this up and I keep asking, how often do you see canon-immigrants occur in a comic book? The only exception I can think of is Harley Quinn and Barbara Gordon (the latter being a joint idea).

Hun appeared in Mirage after debuting in the 4kids cartoon. He's in a few issues of Tales.

Technogeek29 06-07-2015 12:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeotheLateBloomer (Post 1468414)
I heard about this issue (April mating with a roach) but I thought it was just a hoax someone made up. What issue was this?

It exist I found the issue in my local comic store. Lucky for me it was only 1.00 a lot of volume 4 I found there and some of volume 3.

Panda_Kahn_fan 06-07-2015 01:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeotheLateBloomer (Post 1468843)
People keep bringing this up and I keep asking, how often do you see canon-immigrants occur in a comic book? The only exception I can think of is Harley Quinn and Barbara Gordon (the latter being a joint idea).

Actually, some of the most important characters and concepts in comics are 'cannon immigrants'. Jimmy Olsen, Perry White, The daily planet, and Kryptonite all first appeared in the superman radio show before migrating back to the comics. Lex Luthor's henchwoman mercy was adapted, and Mr. Freeze's backstory was a cannon immigration.

And the cockroach mating thing was in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Vol. 4 #22, along with the drawing B.S... There is nothing, in the history of TMNT that can justify this little bunch of &%$! to me!

ProphetofGanja 06-07-2015 02:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsksOhMy (Post 1468172)
I liked Seri and Mikey getting it on... really wish Volume 4 had a proper conclusion so we could see where that storyline went.

But yeah, everything else you mentioned is absurdly bad. Like, drug-trip bad.

As someone who's had a lot of drug trips, I resent that

You guys are making the Mirage run sound so bad, I don't know if I'll ever get around to reading it


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:45 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.