The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   IDW Pet Peeves (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=52373)

Jester 06-05-2015 04:36 AM

IDW Pet Peeves
 
I tend to let issues of the TMNT build up so i can read them in chunks rather than month to month, but that may be leading me to see the cracks and seams in the book, so to speak. Things like:
1. The "equal time for each character" stuff. I get it, we have a large and varied cast, but does the book have to be so neatly divided into 3 pages or so for the Turtles, 3 for Harold and Angel, 3 to check in on the Foot, 3 for Krang, ect. Why can't we have issues that focus all on one of those groups....or even just the the majority.
2. And speaking of the sub-plots...there's a real habit it seems to do the whole parallel quote thing to tie each together when segueing into them. This can be done, as a friend said to me earlier, for great effect when handled right, but with EVERY character transition? It seems very over used.
3. And this one is probably very much just me, but I loathe Bebop and Rocksteady's nicknames....well...mainly just Bopster. Rock is fine, I guess, but it doesn't seem to work as well as the Turtles nick names. Maybe it's just my unfamiliarity with them, I dunna.

So. what are some of the things about the IDW books that bother you?

neatoman 06-05-2015 05:10 AM

Not a whole lot about the IDW series bothers me, just some minor things but I guess I can point them out anyway:
  1. It's a little weird how some of the humans don't seem to be bothered by the sudden appearence mutants, aliens, robots and demons. Maybe we'll find out the Justice Force or something used to run around and therefore all this don't seem that weird to them, but as it's presented now it seems like superhero type stuff wasn't normal in the recent past.
  2. I thought the Ghostbusters crossover was a bit pointless, I know it couldn't be written to be superimportant to the story since if the license for either franchise shifts to another publisher, then reprinting the story would a legal bitch.
  3. The whole part about the mutagen having multiple variations is a bit confusing. In the Mirage era comics, movies and 4Kids cartoon it was simple, if animals came into contact with it then they would become intelligent and humanoid, it was really simple. Here it's based in some kind of healing potion, and then messing with that can give it mutagenic properties but then you also need to use another variation to make sure the subject has normal intelligence and then there's at least yet another variation that creates hybrids, it's a bit of mess. I guess there was a need to explain why some mutants are dumber than others, why some are not just humanoid animals, how Bebop and Rocksteady could start out as human, etc, but I think if Bebop and Rocksteady started out as animals and and the rest was explained away as failed experiments I think that would have worked better. Still, better than the Fred Wolf and Nickelodeon cartoons where the mutagen just does whatever the hell a writer wants (I will never accept that a car can be mutated).
  4. The Annuals. I respect Kevin but scripting was never his strength.

nimajneb 06-05-2015 05:27 AM

I like that the Mutagen has different properties, it's science fact. Most compounds can be taken different routes but I agree it is a bit of a McGuffin.
I do hate to say this as i love all things Turtles but the Annuals, as nice as they are to look at are instantly forgetful.

mrmaczaps 06-05-2015 05:57 AM

The art on most of the series... I know I'm alone mostly on this... But give me some better looking Turtles. Most of the people look fine if still a bit more sketch than full done, well defined art... But the Turtles look hasn't been great since the first arc. The micro series were all great. Steve Lavigne does a great turtle mix of old and new.

I absolutely hate the feminine looking rounded baby turtles from the Northampton arc. The cartoon look should also stay with the cartoon. I want lean green fighting turtles. Or at least a more Laird looking turtle.

HotJuicyBurgers 06-05-2015 07:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmaczaps (Post 1468079)
The art on most of the series... I know I'm alone mostly on this... But give me some better looking Turtles. Most of the people look fine if still a bit more sketch than full done, well defined art... But the Turtles look hasn't been great since the first arc. The micro series were all great. Steve Lavigne does a great turtle mix of old and new.

I absolutely hate the feminine looking rounded baby turtles from the Northampton arc. The cartoon look should also stay with the cartoon. I want lean green fighting turtles. Or at least a more Laird looking turtle.

Which artists are you talking about? I think most of the artists we have gotten on the book have actually drawn the turtles pretty well

And who doesn't like the Bopster... Everybody loves the Bopster!

ToTheNines 06-05-2015 07:30 AM

I really like the segue dialogue. Waltz is good at it.

Can't really say I have a pet peeve, it's my favorite comic on the selves these days. Little gripes, yeah. But nothing major.

Except maybe the turtles not being allowed to kill for whatever reason. The book does some really gnarly stuff sometimes, so it makes it seem weird that the good guys aren't dishing it out too (even though I guess they did decide to kill Shredder back in 2012, real time).

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 09:17 AM

I have VERY FEW complaints.

#1. Mateus' and Campbell's artwork when drawing the Turtles. I love how these guys draw everything else, but PLEASE STOP with the preteen-looking Turtles. I want IDW to stay as far away as possible from the Nick designs. No gap tooth Donnie, no preteen Mikey.

#2. Kevin Eastman's annuals. Dude just needs to stop; he has NO ability to write an engaging story. Just contribute, Kevin, don't write.

#3. It is pretty noticeable how the comics are written for trade collection in that the first two issues of any arc are just building up to the last two. Sometimes it definitely feels like we could get to the action quicker, but the characterization and setting is always great so I can live with it.

But at the end of the day, none of these are going to stop me from buying every single issue and TPB. IDW's TMNT is my favorite iteration of the Turtles EVER.

HotJuicyBurgers 06-05-2015 09:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1468115)

#2. Kevin Eastman's annuals. Dude just needs to stop; he has NO ability to write an engaging story. Just contribute, Kevin, don't write.

As much as I love Kevin's actual art, I kind of have to agree. Without Peter there all of his stories kind of become crazy action stories without much weight.
If he does another annual I would like it if maybe someone helped him write the story.

Raptor86 06-05-2015 09:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1468061)
Not a whole lot about the IDW series bothers me, just some minor things but I guess I can point them out anyway:
[*]The whole part about the mutagen having multiple variations is a bit confusing. In the Mirage era comics, movies and 4Kids cartoon it was simple, if animals came into contact with it then they would become intelligent and humanoid, it was really simple. Here it's based in some kind of healing potion, and then messing with that can give it mutagenic properties but then you also need to use another variation to make sure the subject has normal intelligence and then there's at least yet another variation that creates hybrids, it's a bit of mess. I guess there was a need to explain why some mutants are dumber than others, why some are not just humanoid animals, how Bebop and Rocksteady could start out as human, etc, but I think if Bebop and Rocksteady started out as animals and and the rest was explained away as failed experiments I think that would have worked better. Still, better than the Fred Wolf and Nickelodeon cartoons where the mutagen just does whatever the hell a writer wants (I will never accept that a car can be mutated).

[/LIST]

It was well explained in one of the previous numbers (I do not remember one). Apparentely there are three compounds:
Alien Ooze: can cure and extend lifespan
Mutagen: well it mutates stuff. It is derived from the ooze.
Psychotropic compound: it gives intelligence and can trigger memories of a past life in mutate animals/people

mrmaczaps 06-05-2015 09:48 AM

Mateus' and Campbell's I guess... The art isn't bad, but just not really screaming Turtles... Specifically the Turtles. There other characters are fine...

Metalhead 2.0 06-05-2015 10:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1468115)
#2. Kevin Eastman's annuals. Dude just needs to stop; he has NO ability to write an engaging story. Just contribute, Kevin, don't write.

THIS. Just take Eastman out of the picture all together. What more does he actually even have to contribute at this point? His recent actions and endorsements have shown that the integrity of the property are no longer what motivates him and his interest lies more-so in padding his wallet. I have a feeling name recognition is the sole purpose of his continued involvement.

HotJuicyBurgers 06-05-2015 10:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmaczaps (Post 1468126)
Mateus' and Campbell's I guess... The art isn't bad, but just not really screaming Turtles... Specifically the Turtles. There other characters are fine...

I can see how someone wouldn't enjoy Campbell's work (I personally do like it)

But I have to disagree with you on Mateus' art. It is awesome.


neatoman 06-05-2015 10:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raptor86 (Post 1468119)
It was well explained in one of the previous numbers (I do not remember one). Apparentely there are three compounds:
Alien Ooze: can cure and extend lifespan
Mutagen: well it mutates stuff. It is derived from the ooze.
Psychotropic compound: it gives intelligence and can trigger memories of a past life in mutate animals/people

Yeah but it still seems needlessly complicated.

Wentos 06-05-2015 10:22 AM

I wish the turtles themselves would get more focus. Sometimes I feel like the IDW series forgets who its main characters are.

Very often it feels like the four turtles are just small cogs in the midst of a larger story, rather than the protagonists driving the plot forward. Characters like Splinter, April, Casey, Alopex, Harold and Fugitoid are all awesome and they totally have their place, but IMO we shouldn't be seeing them as often as we see the turtles. They're supporting characters, not main characters.

I also agree with the rest of you that Eastman needs to stay far, far away from scripting annuals.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 10:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HotJuicyBurgers (Post 1468136)
I can see how someone wouldn't enjoy Campbell's work (I personally do like it)

But I have to disagree with you on Mateus' art. It is awesome.


Yeah, Mateus can draw everyone except Michelangelo, Donatello, and Leonardo. He can do a pretty great Raph.

I still want him to change his style or leave. And I feel really bad saying that, because I love his work, but THREE of the four main characters are just appallingly childlike.

Metalhead 2.0 06-05-2015 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1468145)
Yeah, Mateus can draw everyone except Michelangelo, Donatello, and Leonardo. He can do a pretty great Raph.

I still want him to change his style or leave. And I feel really bad saying that, because I love his work, but THREE of the four main characters are just appallingly childlike.

I thought Leo looked like a complete badass during SHotFC.


plastroncafe 06-05-2015 11:07 AM

I only real peeve with the IDW books is their style of storytelling. It's far more tell, and far less show, then I generally prefer.

the breather moments where the characters can stop, regroup, and catch their breath are rare.

and this new holistic trope in genre fiction is a bit too played out for me. every single storyline, every single character, and every single motivation does not need to tie up neatly in a bow.

Panda_Kahn_fan 06-05-2015 11:29 AM

I have very few issues with IDW, but there is one thing that keeps bugging me;

-Why oh why not use exiting TMNT characters instead of throwing dozens of expys onto the pile? Ninjara instead of Alopex, Scratch instead Old Hob, Armaggon instead of Bludgeon, Jordan Perry instead of Harold Lyja, Al Falqua instead of Koya, Wingnut instead of Pigeon Pete, Tony Vivaldi instead of Anthony the random gangster, so many characters that already exist that aren't being used!

plastroncafe 06-05-2015 11:33 AM

I can't speak to the other characters, but IDW doesn't have the rights to Ninjara.

Panda_Kahn_fan 06-05-2015 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1468164)
I can't speak to the other characters, but IDW doesn't have the rights to Ninjara.

Then that's one I withdraw. My mistake! :tsad:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metalhead 2.0 (Post 1468156)

Leo did look great in SHotFC. But since then, his face and mask just look weird...

http://imgur.com/auR5Sk5
http://i.imgur.com/auR5Sk5.jpg

Metalhead 2.0 06-05-2015 12:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1468175)
Leo did look great in SHotFC. But since then, his face and mask just look weird...

http://imgur.com/auR5Sk5
http://i.imgur.com/auR5Sk5.jpg

Yeah, I don't know why he decided to deviate from the Secret History design. It was so much more intense and heroic.

It's like now Leo's the only one that wears his mask over his 'nose'. It really takes away from his character for some reason. I'm huge fan of Santolouco, but I really wish he would go back to the SHotFC designs for the turtles.

PangolinFeets 06-05-2015 12:22 PM

I'm also not a fan of the annuals.

I have no complaints on the art. I actually like them looking younger. To me, an important part of this story is to remember that they're just kids. They never seemed very teenager-y in other versions.

Someone brought up the lack of brutality before. Its a little weird that aside from Splinter breaking his leg and Donnie's recent situation, everyone seems to make it out of fights no prob....I mean, besides Casey. Even the villains. I know Nick has the team shackled on bloodlust, but I'd love to see more brutal fights with more serious consequences on both sides. Like, a super nitty gritty fight between Karai and Leo where they both get all bloody and bruised would be so awesome. More fights like the first Slash fight. :3

And yea, aside from the fact that it only comes out once a month, I have very few complaints.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metalhead 2.0 (Post 1468180)
Yeah, I don't know why he decided to deviate from the Secret History design. It was so much more intense and heroic.

It's like now Leo's the only one that wears his mask over his 'nose'. It really takes away from his character for some reason. I'm huge fan of Santolouco, but I really wish he would go back to the SHotFC designs for the turtles.

I've always assumed it took a lot longer to draw. It's much more detailed. Heck, even Donnie looks great, gap tooth and all. I can even endure Mikey in SHotFC, even though it's also not too great.

CyberCubed 06-05-2015 12:41 PM

Like most people here the complaints I have are very few and more nitpicky than anything. Most of IDW is great from the story, to the art, to the handling of the characters.

I do want to see more issues where the Turtles aren't on some "end of the world" struggle like the last 20 issues or so.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1468192)
Like most people here the complaints I have are very few and more nitpicky than anything. Most of IDW is great from the story, to the art, to the handling of the characters.

I do want to see more issues where the Turtles aren't on some "end of the world" struggle like the last 20 issues or so.

What about their noses, Cubed? Don't those bother you? :twink:

CyberCubed 06-05-2015 12:46 PM

Nah, they're fine.

As for the sheer mass of characters, I think that's why IDW does so well. They introduced so many major characters and villains and have to get to them all. But some characters are suffering, like Bludgeon the shark. I mean that shark mutant looks cool, but does he have any personality or backstory at all? He's just kinda there.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1468197)
Nah, they're fine.

As for the sheer mass of characters, I think that's why IDW does so well. They introduced so many major characters and villains and have to get to them all. But some characters are suffering, like Bludgeon the shark. I mean that shark mutant looks cool, but does he have any personality or backstory at all? He's just kinda there.

Well, in the defense of both IDW and Bludgeon (or Koya), when characters are in it for the long haul, they don't have to be fleshed out immediately. Alopex and Karai were both pretty one-note and shallow until their respective micro-issues around the time of "City Fall." Karai was just the Foot second-in-command but had about as much personality as Tatsu, and Alopex was just running around fighting.

Now they're both incredibly intriguing characters (even if I do dislike the Raph/Alopex shipping). So I feel confident that we'll be getting to know Bludgeon (and Koya) better at some point.

CyberCubed 06-05-2015 01:02 PM

Yeah, but that poses the problem of introducing too many characters too quickly, there's not enough time to get around to them all. I think the Mutanimals are going to have the same problem now with Man Ray and Sally there, because even Mondo and the Crab only have a little bit of characterisation and could use more.

But I guess with this being a monthly comic with only a certain amount of pages that cannot be helped.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 01:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1468207)
Yeah, but that poses the problem of introducing too many characters too quickly, there's not enough time to get around to them all. I think the Mutanimals are going to have the same problem now with Man Ray and Sally there, because even Mondo and the Crab only have a little bit of characterisation and could use more.

But I guess with this being a monthly comic with only a certain amount of pages that cannot be helped.

Yeah, but look how much more depth has already been given to Herman and Mondo in just four issues of "Mutanimals" since their appearances in "Attack on Technodrome" and "New Mutant Order!" Granted they're nowhere near as fleshed out as Slash or Hob, but they're definitely further along than Bludgeon or Koya. At the moment, Bludgeon and Koya have been given all of the characterization of any of the OT Playmates mutants.

But Sally and Ray will get their development, and so will Bludgeon and Koya. The characters haven't been around that long yet... we all just need to be patient.

Mormegil 06-05-2015 02:00 PM

I don't think every side character needs to be completely fleshed out. I can except that bludgeon is just a badass hammerhead and is fiercely loyal to whoever runs the foot. They're side characters. They aren't supposed to be fleshed out as much.

HotJuicyBurgers 06-05-2015 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mormegil (Post 1468239)
I don't think every side character needs to be completely fleshed out. I can except that bludgeon is just a badass hammerhead and is fiercely loyal to whoever runs the foot. They're side characters. They aren't supposed to be fleshed out as much.

First, nice avatar.

Second, It's hard not to expect a bit of backstory from a man shark hybrid, but I agree. Every single nameless foot soldier doesn't need a backstory, and it wouldn't make sense to do that.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 02:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HotJuicyBurgers (Post 1468246)
First, nice avatar.

Second, It's hard not to expect a bit of backstory from a man shark hybrid, but I agree. Every single nameless foot soldier doesn't need a backstory, and it wouldn't make sense to do that.

Also agreed. Myself, I'm perfectly happy with what I so far know about him, Koya, and Sally and Ray. I expect to get more, but I'm content.

Badass shark mutant intensely loyal to the Foot. That's all I needed for my action figures as a kid! :tlol:

mrmaczaps 06-05-2015 02:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1468175)
Leo did look great in SHotFC. But since then, his face and mask just look weird...

http://imgur.com/auR5Sk5
http://i.imgur.com/auR5Sk5.jpg

THIS!
As art, its GREAT!

Its just not TMNT to me. The art one TMNT NAA has been leaps and bounds better than this series, even ghosting the look from the toon. Its consistent.

You want rotating artists, use one shots or a new volume of Tales. Spotlight all kinds of new artists and/or new takes. Primary series, have everyone do more or less the ideal Turtle. A more serious looking OT/Mirage look.

I will collect TMNT no matter what, but get me some art like those first few issues and micros... Heck, I'd buy Tales with all these odd takes... Fat legs and arms... But they aren't scary or mean looking... Not threatening at all. As much as I hate the new BayTurtles, Raph was at least menacing. Sort of. Lol

funatic 06-05-2015 03:24 PM

If anyone has glanced at the last Mutanimals thread recently... we might be getting a little more character development for that crew. :twink:

Metalhead 2.0 06-05-2015 03:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by funatic (Post 1468269)
If anyone has glanced at the last Mutanimals thread recently... we might be getting a little more character development for that crew. :twink:

I refuse to go into the preview threads until I've read the book.

HotJuicyBurgers 06-05-2015 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metalhead 2.0 (Post 1468271)
I refuse to go into the preview threads until I've read the book.

Are you sure you don't want to hear about the future of the mutanimals?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-05-2015 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Metalhead 2.0 (Post 1468271)
I refuse to go into the preview threads until I've read the book.

Two words, my man: Ongoing. Series.

Jester 06-05-2015 05:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1468115)
#3. It is pretty noticeable how the comics are written for trade collection in that the first two issues of any arc are just building up to the last two. Sometimes it definitely feels like we could get to the action quicker, but the characterization and setting is always great so I can live with it.

I was just thinking this! My complaint that there are 3 pages here and 3 pages there is only really "undone" by the ending of an "arc" which coalesces all those threads together. Very formulaic.

ProphetofGanja 06-05-2015 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1468163)
I have very few issues with IDW, but there is one thing that keeps bugging me;

-Why oh why not use exiting TMNT characters instead of throwing dozens of expys onto the pile? Ninjara instead of Alopex, Scratch instead Old Hob, Armaggon instead of Bludgeon, Jordan Perry instead of Harold Lyja, Al Falqua instead of Koya, Wingnut instead of Pigeon Pete, Tony Vivaldi instead of Anthony the random gangster, so many characters that already exist that aren't being used!

personally I love that they're creating their own characters; I have no familiarity with characters from previous iterations of the TMNT and I don't care to have old characters introduced just for nostalgia's sake.

Quote:

Originally Posted by PangolinFeets (Post 1468188)
I'm also not a fan of the annuals.

I have no complaints on the art. I actually like them looking younger. To me, an important part of this story is to remember that they're just kids. They never seemed very teenager-y in other versions.

Someone brought up the lack of brutality before. Its a little weird that aside from Splinter breaking his leg and Donnie's recent situation, everyone seems to make it out of fights no prob....I mean, besides Casey. Even the villains. I know Nick has the team shackled on bloodlust, but I'd love to see more brutal fights with more serious consequences on both sides. Like, a super nitty gritty fight between Karai and Leo where they both get all bloody and bruised would be so awesome. More fights like the first Slash fight. :3

And yea, aside from the fact that it only comes out once a month, I have very few complaints.

ditto on the annuals


haha yeah if this comic came out twice a month I'd be in heaven


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.